Some Israeli Kids Refuse to Serve the Occupation. Why Don’t We Know About Them?

on 8 Comments

Last week Dan Fleshler said that the Israeli soldier at the checkpoint is also a victim of the occupation, and earlier today I posted a video in which an Israeli soldier cries out in pain at the actions of settlers whom he knows by name and whom he is not stopping. It's true that Israelis also are victimized by the occupation, but some brave ones actually have walked away from the whole criminal activity.

David Bloom has directed me to the statement this week from Shministim, yes I know it sounds like a Marx Brothers movie, the organization of Israeli kids who refuse to go into the military. These kids have no trouble throwing around the a-word, apartheid. They talk about Israeli oppression and the radicalization of the Palestinians.

Their words inspire. I'll get to them in a second. But only one question must be asked here: Who in the United States is supporting these beautiful kids who don't want to wreck their lives or the lives of Arabs? Who is coming forward? I'm sure there are some, on the fringes. But these kids should be front and center in American Jewish life. Jewish organizations here ought to celebrate these kids–or forfeit their souls, how about.


We object to the means of “defense” of the Israeli society (checkpoints, the extrajudicial killings, apartheid roads for Jews only, the closures, etc.) which serve the policy of holding onto territory, annexing even more occupied lands to the state of Israel and violating the rights of the Palestinian population in an aggressive manner.These actions, both as band-aids on a bleeding wound and as providers of a temporary, limited solution which over time, result in a worsening of the conflict…
We protest the theft and vandalizing of Palestinian lands for an expansion of the settlements, all done in the name of defending Israel. Additionally, we object to the transformation of Palestinian villages and towns into closed ghettos due to the Separation Wall and the checkpoints, in which no conditions for making a basic living exist…
further protest the humiliating and contemptuous attitude taken by the military
toward Palestinian residents of the West Bank.

8 Responses

  1. Michael Weis
    September 22, 2008, 10:01 pm

    I have a friend in the IDF. She loves being part of the "occupation" force. She got the best score on the sharp shooting test in basic training. She gets to wear a uniform. Carry a gun. She loved it so much she agreed to take the officer's course and serve another 9 months.

    Oh yea, I forgot to mention what's her role in the "occupation". She works at a boarding school for kids from troubled homes.

  2. liberal white boy
    September 22, 2008, 10:17 pm

    "an Israeli soldier cries out in pain at the actions of settlers whom he knows by name and whom he is not stopping"

    I'm touched but I think someone should probably kick his cry baby war criminal ass right into the sea. In this way we can stop his horrible pain and make life less difficult for the Palestinians at the same time. Everyone is happy. Two birds with one boot in the ass.

  3. Madrid
    September 22, 2008, 10:18 pm

    Yeah sure– the IDF is in the occupied territories doing charity work. The IDF is comprised of Peace Corp volunteers, who just happen to have an affinity for lugging around fully loaded AK 47's and pointing them at children's heads.

  4. Paul Malfara
    September 22, 2008, 11:42 pm

    Michael Weis (No relation to Phil),

    Please continue pointing out that you are not related to Phil. You don't even deserve to clean out his septic tank, although it seems that the smell emanating from your comments belong in a cesspool.

    Utter Bullshit!!
    Hasbara fink!!


  5. Richard Witty
    September 23, 2008, 3:56 am

    No matter how much genuine concern you currently bear or would come to bear for the welfare and experience of the Palestinians, you are now permanently on the shit list of the "left".

  6. Richard Witty
    September 23, 2008, 4:39 am

    I like the principles articulated in the Shministin letter.

    Distinguishing between defense and oppression.

    An important distinction.

    A different distinction than the "activist" left and left/right address.

  7. LeaNder
    September 23, 2008, 10:47 am

    Michael Weis (No relation to Phil),

    How could he be related with a differently spelled name?

  8. Michael Weis
    September 23, 2008, 1:09 pm

    People usually misspell my name. So sometimes it goes either way, one or two s.

Leave a Reply