I’m down with the orientalists on the shoes

Angry Arab makes fun of western reporters who say that throwing shoes at someone is a sign of disrespect in Arab culture, as if it isn't here, too. Gabriel at JSF makes fun of what he says will be a refrain in the press: showing the soles of the feet is a sign of contempt in Arab culture.

Well, I'm with the western reporters and orientalists. This episode will forever mark the Bush presidency because of its peculiar symbolism: avenging the most horrific violence with a symbolic sign of utter contempt. It will be the way the Iraq war is signified in war documentaries. (Just as Bush's father's vomiting in Japan marked his presidency, and Jimmy Carter's cardigan sweater.) You can't remove the shoeness from it. It wasn't a blackberry or a microphone, it was shoes.

And as an American who has spent time in the third world, I say, don't try to remove all differences in culture from these different experiences. People don't take their shoes off when they go into American houses, they do in the Third World. Feet have a different significance in the third world, in my humble experience. The first foreign country I visited, Samoa, in 1978, it was the second of three rules I was told, by a Peace Corps volunteer: don't show the soles of your feet to anyone. (And don't walk past an older person, but stop and let him pass; and don't walk and eat at the same time–rules I never learned in the U.S.) Third world cities have more s**t and sewage in the streets. So let us celebrate the shoeness of the incident: The baseness of George Bush is revealed in that moment, and also, the delicacy of other cultures.

About Philip Weiss

Philip Weiss is Founder and Co-Editor of Mondoweiss.net.
Posted in Iraq, US Politics

{ 6 comments... read them below or add one }

  1. Colin Murray says:

    I laughed when I first heard about it. I couldn't design a more appropriate send-off for President Bush. I hope Mr. Al-Zaidi is freed soon. In a world where psychopaths from every faction are chomping at the bit to murder, torture, rape, and steal, it's delightful to see humor used as such an effective weapon. Until my dying day, when I think of George W. Bush, in my mind's eye I'll see him deftly ducking the first shoe with that vacuous look on his face. LOL

  2. Amos says:

    Gosh Phil, your eally MUST be a super sophisticate! People take off their shoes when they enter houses IN THE THIRD WORLD! Wow, I sure am glad to know the hundred plus countries that make up the nations you so describe are all the same in this way!!!

  3. Colin Murray says:

    Another shoe-oriented post from Jesus' General:

    Our Leader didn't abandon the flag during the shoe onslaught

    http://patriotboy.blogspot.com/

    It's funny, check it out. :)

  4. anon says:

    I agree with Colin Murray. It was a perfect poetic period to the Shrub's eight year sentence. Or better, exclamation point.

  5. John Lewis-Dickerson says:

    *****************************************
    Please sign this petition to demand the immediate release of Mr. Al-Zeidi-
    link to ipetitions.com

    PS. I do have a bit of a problem with Mr. Al-Zeidi's having called Bush a dog. It was terribly unfair to canines!

  6. Zionists also have a sort of internal Jewish orientalism. See Conundrum of Jewish Arab Identity.

Leave a Reply