Peter Kaplan leaves ‘the Observer’

My dear friend Peter Kaplan is leaving the New York Observer (2 years after I did). A few quick thoughts:
--An era ends. Print/newspapers/the legacy of William Shawn and Harold Ross, that arc of literary sophistication and great New York news values that Kaplan personifies, is coming to a cultural finis. That part's obvious. It assumes a different garb now; and Kaplan will be there.
--Kaplan's a genius for a few reasons. He is the most intuitive person I know in the business. He never bothered with the fussy superficialties of a story, he always got to heart of a story, to its emotional breathing agonized soul. I often felt he was disappointed in my work because his Storytelling standards are so high. This was evident in college when I wrote a long tedious piece all about cancer research and he did the cartoon to accompany the story, and the cartoon was better than the story. It showed a scientist with a beaker announcing he had discovered the cure to cancer and he was going to sell it to people for $10 a person! Savage.
--He is a great editor in that he tried to help me, and countless others, become writers. He always said, "Where's Weiss in it?" He meant a story was a dead thing unless a writer was engaged emotionally by the material. He was the first editor to really explain this to me and push me to figure out what I thought. (That said, he was made uncomfortable by my distaste for Zionism, which made him an unsuitable editor to me in that way; he's pro-Zionist, oldfashioned that way, prehistoric.)
--He named this site. When I tried to name my column at the Observer, "An American in New York," he said, No Phil you're a Jew. He was right. When I tried to name this site, The Needle, he said, that sounds like you have a needledick, no way. Outside the Tribe made him scowl. Lacking in poetry. He said that the power of naming separated the great producers. With a great name, it was like God/Ziegfeld up in the sky in his armchair tapping the ash off his cigar as he thought up the right name for someone. Maybe Monica Lewinsky produced that insight? I forget. Kaplan loves cigars and this was the best thing that happened to this site, early on, getting that name. It said, the world of Weiss, the fact that I have no connection to reality, the fact that I am a B movie.
--His psychological insights are deadly. He gets people in an instant. Streetsmart, close to the ground, and rambling the house late at night to grab a turkey leg from the fridge and a cigar.
--The most maddening man on the planet. The most charming, the most quotable--and the most maddening. I'll tell you some other time.
--It was time for him to go. I can't wait to see what he will do next.

About Philip Weiss

Philip Weiss is Founder and Co-Editor of Mondoweiss.net.
Posted in American Jewish Community, Beyondoweiss

{ 3 comments... read them below or add one }

  1. GI Joe says:

    He reminds me of Adolf Hitler. Or do you think Hitler was a wall painter who ate carpets?

  2. Phoebe Hoban says:

    Hey Phil,

    Couldn't agree with you more. Peter is the real deal, and his loss is significant. It is indeed another sign of hte end of the era of newspapers. RIP

    Phoebe Hoban

Leave a Reply