Is Shimon Peres the Israeli Minister of Propaganda?

Gideon Levy thinks so:

Peres also hasn't forgotten the shopworn, hollow old slogans about Israel's yearning for peace, slogans for which one might still find dubious buyers only occasionally in America.

Israel yearns for "peace with all peoples, with all Arab states .... No more war, no more destruction, no more hatred," he recited, as is his wont, at the conference of the right-wing Jewish propaganda lobby, AIPAC. Peres feels at home there, of course.

With its arms outstretched for peace, Israel opened two criminal wars in two years, and Peres didn't utter a peep. With arms outstretched for peace, Israel continues to build settlements in the territories, and the president hasn't said a word. No more destruction? What about the terrible destruction Israel wreaked in vain on Gaza? Not a sound from Peres. No more hatred? What exactly was Israel sowing in Gaza? Peres keeps mum.

Similar to Levy's point above, I was struck during Peres's speech to AIPAC how cookie cutter it was. It could have been the same speech he gave 15 years ago (you can read and watch it here). The audience was appreciative, but I couldn't see it holding much sway with the Obama administration or other government leaders. Times seem to have passed Peres by. Levy also points out another inevitable task Peres has taken on - selling the Netanyahu/Lieberman government to the world. Or as he puts it, "slapping the kosher stamp of approval on what the world sees as an abomination."

Noam Sheizaf makes a similar point on in his Promised Land blog in the post, "I don’t listen to Peres, and you shouldn’t either." There he accuses Peres, and the Israeli government in general, of doing something that Israel often attacks others for doing - "speaking in two languages. The first one is aimed to please the world . . . the second one – reserved for internal use only – deals with the things we really plan to do."

About Adam Horowitz

Adam Horowitz is Co-Editor of Mondoweiss.net.
Posted in Israel Lobby, Israel/Palestine, Israeli Government

{ 14 comments... read them below or add one }

  1. LeaNder says:

    I can't listen to Peres any more. I in fact wonder what made people celebrate his speech at Davos.

    One thing that distinctively remains on my mind is the young women approaching him and whispering in his ear when he is about to address the audience in Davos after Erdogan's speech.

    That surely was the most interesting part of it.

    Who was that?

    The old man has started off and then immediately has to overcome a gorgeous female whispering in his ear in front of all the cameras that his hair looks like he's an 86 year old geezer who's just got out of bed (much affectionate laughter from Erdo, Ban and Moussa at this mo).

    Whereupon the old geezer then stumbles, mumbles and loses his glasses for five minutes (eliciting further affectionate body language from E. B & M) before working up to a towering, impassioned, flawlessly rhetorical defense of Israel mostly addressed personally to Erdo – transfixing the Israel skeptic Davos audience and inspiring them to give the old jew Peres more applause than Erdo, Moussa and Ban got between them. Gawd, Sorkin couldn't have written the scene better. In fact Peres outclassed Clint Eastwood in Gran Torino. Easily.

  2. August West says:

    Shimon Peres also is a Holocaust Denier. He denied the Armenian Holocaust when he said "What happened to the Armenians was a tragedy, not a genocide." Peres has ZERO moral authority. Jews, more than any other people, have no right to to deny the Armenian Holocaust. By doing so, Peres has legitimized denial of the tragedy that was not a genocide of the Jews. He's worse than Ahmadinejad.

    And Israel has no right to complain about Shoah-denial as long as Peres hold public office. None. Nada. Zero. Zilch.

  3. RE:"Is Shimon Peres the Israeli Minister of Propaganda?"

    MY COMMENT: I once respected Peres, but now he strikes me as the type of person that I would like to keep my distance from. That change really accelerated when he came to the U.S. following the Lebanon '06 war to do a PR tour. His rationalizations really 'turned my stomach'. He now seems coated with a very slimy, malodorous oil.

  4. US Congress says:

    There's no business like Shoah business, like no business I know…

  5. Ed says:

    Shimon Peres is like the archetype we've seen in countless movies of the kindly old gent who seems so proper and austere on the surface, conservative, well-dressed and gentlemanly, but something happens and his real identity as a Nazi in hiding is disclosed, at which point his old venomous side comes spilling out. How many primp and proper Jewish Zionists are living like that, only openly and proudly Jewish nationalist socialist, in America? Kind of scary, really.

  6. Dick says:

    Peres is right. Israel yearns for peace. It is the terms that need defining.

  7. MRW says:

    Peres was on Morning Joe during AIPAC spewing out the worn lines. The silence from the anchors was painful. They pitched softballs to get through the timeslot. I saw a flicker in Peres' eyes that they weren't buying. Peres' eyes went cold and contemptuous, his true nature, and what he really thinks of American goys anyway.

  8. Abe Fucus says:

    That reminds me, how is Agriprocessors, Inc going out there in Postville Iowa? Do we have the old kosher packing process back up and running, so everyone can see the light to the world in all its glory? Before the raid, looked to me like a perfect metaphor for internal Israel and domestic USA. Hope we have a green light again. After all, we are better than Hee-Haw reruns. Plus, we have a longer history.

  9. Richard Witty says:

    Israel entered two asserted criminal wars in response to two criminal initiations and conflrmations of war.

  10. Jacobwolfen says:

    Asserted? How so?

  11. Richard Witty says:

    Crimes are determined in courts, not by rumors or assertions.

  12. Shirin says:

    What the hell does that even mean?!

  13. Shirin says:

    Some crimes are obvious on their face.

Leave a Reply