Israel is a society in crisis

Headline in Haaretz: "IDF order will enable mass deportations from West Bank."

A new military order aimed at preventing infiltration will come into force this week, enabling the deportation of tens of thousands of Palestinians from the West Bank, or their indictment on charges carrying prison terms of up to seven years...

The new order defines anyone who enters the West Bank illegally as an infiltrator, as well as "a person who is present in the area and does not lawfully hold a permit." The order takes the original 1969 definition of infiltrator to the extreme, as the term originally applied only to those illegally staying in Israel after having passed through countries then classified as enemy states - Jordan, Egypt, Lebanon and Syria.

The order's language is both general and ambiguous, stipulating that the term infiltrator will also be applied to Palestinian residents of Jerusalem, citizens of countries with which Israel has friendly ties (such as the United States) and Israeli citizens, whether Arab or Jewish. All this depends on the judgment of Israel Defense Forces commanders in the field.

The new guidelines are expected to clamp down on protests in the West Bank.

About Philip Weiss

Philip Weiss is Founder and Co-Editor of Mondoweiss.net.
Posted in Israel/Palestine

{ 46 comments... read them below or add one }

  1. Taxi says:

    Enforcing this diabolical ‘new law’ before the wide eyes of the world can only accelerate the dismantlement of the jewish Jim Crow state currently occupying the holy lands.

    Will I weep when this happens?

    No.

    Will I dance naked in the street?

    No.

    But I will indeed feel truly sorry for the dark and criminal legacy they will leave their children to live with and suffer for many many generations to come.

    Begs my question to the misguided jewish communities out there: was zionism really worth it?

    • zamaaz says:

      Who says Israel in crisis? These oppositions are just popping up and vanishing through in the passage of time; because what will remain true are legal historical rights… this is the main reason no country no matter their global influence can never insist anything against Israel…
      All the anti-Israel interests like the British Financial Times can do is to print blatant lies…to promote Demonization & Boycotts against Israel. This is expected from people like them.

  2. ruth says:

    was zionism really worth it?

    Absolutely!

    • Danaa says:

      ruth: was the final solution worth it, if zionism was the result?

      Just asking, you know….

    • Taxi says:

      “Absolutelely!”

      You mean your children and their children’s children deserve to suffer for your crimes against humanity? You bring them into the world so they can be your sacrificial lambs?

      Honestly, I don’t believe you mean what you say, I’m sure you love your children (if you have any) more than life itself. So why not cut the crap and simply state that the jews are a strong people, that they can live with or without zionism, which is a truth you and I know very well.

      • zamaaz says:

        You now how many millions died during the rise and fall of ancient empires? Egyptians, Assyrians, Babylonians, Persians, Greeks, and Romans from about 750 BC to 70 AD including the Israelite dead themselves? In the Bible all these happened just to give Israel a prophetic lesson, and undergo national spiritual cleansing… Now where is Zionism here? How about human rights here? I appears you are not even worthy either to know about this!

      • You mean your children and their children’s children deserve to suffer for your crimes against humanity? You bring them into the world so they can be your sacrificial lambs?

        No, Taxi, zionists will not sacrifice their Isaacs on the altar; that’s what Iran’s children are for, “the unblemished ram, caught in the thicket.”

    • Shingo says:

      Was it worth it to create a Zuonist apartheid state Ruth? Is this the legacy you want to leave your children?

      link to haaretz.com

      IDF order will enable mass deportation from West Bank

    • Avi says:

      was zionism really worth it?

      Absolutely!

      Soon, and that day is approaching fast, Zionism will have been wiped out and Israel as we know it – the tyrannical, terrorist, colonial state that it is – will have changed into a state for all its citizens, with Jewish American pissants like you looking for their next project to drag themselves out of their trailer trash existence, as Israel is like a gang a juvenile delinquent would join to have a support system, however dysfunctional and criminal.

    • Citizen says:

      Absolutely? Only pros, no cons? Are you reading a comic book?

  3. Shingo says:

    “was zionism really worth it?

    Absolutely!”

    Someone else celebrating the beginning of Israel’sfinsl solution for the Arabs.

  4. Shingo says:

    “The new order defines anyone who enters the West Bank illegally as an infiltrator, as well as “a person who is present in the area and does not lawfully hold a permit”

    Thus must be the mutual humanism and Witty was referring to.

    Papers please!

    • Citizen says:

      A permit always assumes that some privilege may or may not be given. A right is not the same as a privilege. What is the criteria for distinguishing between a privileged person and an “infiltrator?”

  5. UNIX says:

    It’s the anti-zionists and anti-semites that in crisis, Israel is growing.

    Watch before your very eyes as we build up Jerusalem and expand beyond your wildest dreams in Hebron.

    Watch.

    • Chaos4700 says:

      We toppled Nazi Germany, we sure as hell can topple second-rate ethnic cleansers like you.

      • MRW says:

        Small point of order: actually, Chaos, is was General Zhukov who toppled Nazi Germany, conquered Berlin, liberated the camps, and prepared the way for the Allies. Starting with his win at Stalingrad — the bloodiest battle in world history — he eventually commanded 5 million soldiers as he buried the Axis Powers, and forced the Germans into retreat. Hollywood would have you believe otherwise, but it’s bullshit. Zhukov moved his army across a minimum of three time zones repelling the Nazis from southwestern to northern Russia westward. No American General has done on the ground what he did in the short period of time he did it, or with such ferocity, strategy, or with his soldiers fighting on vodka fumes with cardboard for socks. Our smug view of ourselves doesn’t do us any favors when we are asking the Israelis to tell the truth about the Naqba. We owe the Russians our lives in WWII; had Hitler won against Zhukov, this world would have been wildly different after 1945.

        • Chaos4700 says:

          OK, you’ve sort of got a point, though it’s not as if the Soviet Union wasn’t slaughtering Jews by the proverbial busload in their own right. And they were working with Nazi Germany until Hitler decided, in monumental stupidity, to start war on his eastern flank.

        • tree says:

          Actually, I think it was Ukrainians that the Soviet Union was slaughtering by the millions. And they weren’t working with the Nazis, they just reached a “gentlemen’s agreement” not to rush into war with each other, before either of them were ready for it.

        • RoHa says:

          Are you sure about this? We keep being told that the world did nothing about Hitler, so it’s obvious that the Soviets didn’t really make an effort.

          They just sat under a harvest moon, drinking vodka, playing the balalaika, and singing popular songs, like “Seige of Leningrad Blues”, “I left my heart in Stalingrad. (And several other bits of me as well)”, and “Get me down to Kursk on time”.

        • Mooser says:

          “They just sat under a harvest moon, drinking vodka, playing the balalaika, and singing popular songs, like “Seige of Leningrad Blues”, “I left my heart in Stalingrad. (And several other bits of me as well)”, and “Get me down to Kursk on time”.”

          Hey, that’s my schtick! Hands off! Oh well, maybe it’s for the best, as I have less and lesstime to read and comment at Mondoweiss.

        • MRW says:

          WelL…actually…Chaos, no they weren’t. Here are two good articles that are keepers. Benjamin Schwarz’s op-ed in the LA times at the time of a major anniversary of D-Day In 2000 is an important correction of history; Schwarz is so damn smart, anyway.
          link to commondreams.org

          And Sever Plocker’s article on Stalin’s Jews:
          link to ynet.co.il

        • RoHa says:

          Think of imitation as flattery, Mooser.

    • Avi says:

      Watch before your very eyes as we build up Jerusalem and expand beyond your wildest dreams in Hebron.

      You’re not building anything. You’re sitting thousands of miles away in your living room jacking off to the violence that you support and enjoy. You’re a sadist nutjob.

    • Citizen says:

      Israel is growing, so are poisonous mushrooms. Be careful in the forest when picking your next meal. Some fungii are more nutricious than others.

  6. zebra says:

    They keep coming up with new shit. And if UNIX if is any indication, there is no hope for the palestinians.

  7. This is an attempt to drive a permanent separation between Gaza and the West Bank. It is a significant move, as it imprints a revision in Israeli policy that applied the reasoning that the West Bank and Gaza were one territory.

    This is an application of the logic that they are separated and will never unify.

    The only remedy to this logic of separation of the two regions is for Hamas to reconcile with Fatah, otherwise the Israeli logic will be confirmed in action.

    Its getting late.

    • Shingo says:

      “The only remedy to this logic of separation of the two regions is for Hamas to reconcile with Fatah, otherwise the Israeli logic will be confirmed in action.”

      That’s right Witty, it’s all the fault of the Palestinians.

      It’s gettign late. Isn’t it time you broke open the champagne and celebrated. An isolated Gaza is what you always wanted.

      • It is negligence of the Palestinians, specifically of Hamas.

        If you don’t build a bridge, requiring learning bridge-building skills as prerequisite, you won’t get across the divide.

        Its the question of goal vs complaint.

        Do you desire that Palestinians actually self-govern, or just the self-convincing words of it?

        • Taxi says:

          Hamas is the result of continuing zionist expansion into Palestine coupled with the acute corruption of Fatah.

          Hamas, like Hizbollah, are ‘new-ish’ participants in the conflict – birthed by Israeli racism and greed for land.

          You could say that they are the bastard unwanted children of Isreal that Isreal is trying to fob-off onto the world.

    • Citizen says:

      The US and Israel have done all they can to keep Hamas and Fatah separate. It’s just another version of Machavellian divide and separate. Let’s hope the Palestinians see this; I think they do. The notion of “recognizing Israel’s right to exist” is a red herring designed to allow for continued settlement expansion. So sayeth Crazy Horse and Cochise.

  8. Haaretz is an important publication in the world. Dissenters, Palestinian solidarity, liberals like myself, would have no reliable source of information in Israel or Palestine if it were not for Haaretz currently.

    Today there are three important articles, that I see:

    The one Phil referred to,

    link to haaretz.com
    Study: Anti-Semitism in Europe hit new high in 2009,

    Rights group: Israel and Hamas have failed in Gaza war probes
    link to haaretz.com

    • Citizen says:

      Well yeah, Witty, anti-Muslim in Europe hit new high in 2009. And yes, Israel and
      Hamas both decline the right of each other to exist.

      Yet they both exist. The nature of this existence, the character of it, is the issue–the only issue. The guy who killed Jeff Dahmer acted on his assumption Jeff had no right to exist. He ignored the state, who said he did–and US taxpayers would provide his bed and board, etc. And so?

  9. Colin Murray says:

    A new military order aimed at preventing infiltration will come into force this week, enabling the deportation of tens of thousands of Palestinians from the West Bank, …

    Deport them where? Not that this is any surprise for regular readers, but the Geneva Conventions, to which Israel is a signatory, prohibit transfer of population out of an occupied territory. Seizing someones residency permit, by hook or crook, and declaring them not part of the occupied population is still a clear violation. It is even more of a pathetic joke when the residency permits are issued by the occupying authority, and are not based on local records. It puts Israel’s persistent destruction of Palestinian civil archives into a new light.

    Operation Destroy the Data

    This was not a whim, or crazed vengeance, by this or that unit, nor a personal vandalistic urge of a soldier whose buddies didn’t dare stop him. There was a decision made to vandalize the civic, administrative, cultural infrastructure developed by Palestinian society.

    What Israel has done

    What anti-terrorist purpose is served by destroying the building and then removing the records of the Ministry of Education, the Ramallah Municipality, the Central Bureau of Statistics, various institutes specialising in civil rights, health and economic development, hospitals, radio and television stations? Is it not clear that Sharon is bent not only on “breaking” the Palestinians, but on trying to eliminate them as a people with national institutions?

Leave a Reply