We often report about house demolitions, but it is something else to see one up close. Two days ago in Palestine I saw “the cruelest demolition” in the tiny village of Sadat a Thaale in the southern West Bank.
Last Wednesday morning, the Israeli civil administration came into the village, which is situated between two sprawling Israeli settlements, and used heavy equipment to destroy three structures: a house that was home to eight people, a cistern, and a large sheep shed. The authorities did not even empty the shed of sheep when they crushed the roof. Farmer Jamil Awad told international visitors that five sheep were killed, including one lamb.
You can see the destruction, and the dead lamb, in the video I shot above. You can see the cistern too, broken and fouled.
About 1 minute into the video, I call over Ezra Nawi, the famous Israeli activist who was arrested last week when he protested this demolition. In the wind-whipped interview, he says that this was the “cruelest demolition” he has ever witnessed– because the authorities wanted to destroy animals.
The likely reason for the demolition– the true object of the Israeli civil administration’s wrath– is an ambitious solar project that gives the 100 villagers of Sadat a Thaale minimal electrical power. In the last year, the German government working with an Israeli/Palestinian group called Community Energy and Technology in the Middle East (Comet-ME) to erect a bank of solar panels and a battery house, at a cost of about $80,000.
But in the last two months, the Israeli government has issued stop work orders on the solar panels in Sadat a Thaale and five other villages. The obstruction could turn into an international incident.
Elad Orian at disputed solar panels in Sadat a Thaale
“Area C is the most important political issue in Palestine at the moment,” Elad Orian of Comet told me. “It’s becoming clear from both the Palestinian Authority side and the European Union that they do not accept Israeli policies any more [against Palestinian building in the West Bank]. This issue is at the forefront of international politics.”
Akiva Eldar reports that the German government is making the solar panels an issue:
A German Foreign Ministry spokesperson said the German government is aware of the stoppage order for the solar energy systems in Tha’lah, and is in close contact with the Israeli government in order to find an amicable solution. The German press sees Israel’s behavior as a rude gesture to the European Union, which dared publish a report critical of Israel’s discriminatory policy toward 150,000 Palestinians in Area C, who have survived the harassment of the authorities and the fury of the settlers.
The solar project is one of 16 that Comet has undertaken with a political goal: to keep Palestinian villages on the map. The projects are being built without permission from the Israelis, who may have discovered their presence from satellite imagery.
Sadat a Thaale can be found on British survey maps of the last century, Orian said. But in recent years, two large settlements, Ma’on and Carmel, have taken over the nearby hills and prevented the villagers from grazing sheep on the land.
Near the end of the video, you can see Ezra Nawi gesturing at the village lands that were taken over by the neighboring settlements, and see a shepherd leading sheep on village lands.
Jamil Awad repeatedly thanked international visitors for coming to observe the destruction. While Orian, explaining his own commitment to the “strong” villagers, said, “The work we do is based on our understanding that, to put it in high terms, the oppressor is as enslaved as the oppressed. I don’t want to live in a place where racism is institutionalized. I want to create a different reality.”
Here are excerpts of that interview with Nawi:
Q. How does this make you feel?
A. Great. [ironic] I have never seen such a cruel demolition. I’ve been to many many… When somebody kill animals, he come to such a level…
He [an official who participated in the destruction] was smiling… I met him outside… I said, your face show that you have endless orgasm, so satisfied…
Q. This makes me think something is very wrong with Zionism.
A. I think Zionist is … very racist, very very racist. People don’t know the real face of Zionism from the 20s, the 30s.
Q. Is this the real face?
It’s one of the faces.
I have to say, I find the idea of two jewish guys discussing the “faces of zionism” while standing on the recently created ruins of yet another Palestinian family’s homestead pretty distasteful. The only “face” of zionism that exists is the one showing utter contempt for the rest of humanity. The Israeli Flag should have on it a Big Middle Finger.
Zionism reaches a new low, as if that is possible. Vile, cruel, moronic behaviour. Nice message to send to the world about your values. Regev, what is your feeble, whining excuse this time?
You can see the Demolitions and their consequence at:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x1OMfMf1CgI
Phil, for God’s sake, what are you doing in Palestine! I am appalled you would go there to do interviews right on the heels of speaking at the BDS conference. I mean — Phil, these people are crazy, armed and dangerous, and they have your number. Think Woody Allen with a Uzi.
We already have enough American martyrs to the cause of Greater Israel, Phil. And it is so not necessary for you to expose yourself like this. This whole thing has turned a corner, finally. The US military high command is getting active on this issue, there won’t be any US military support for an attack on Iran — see news for Gen. Martin Demsey — it’s not ‘political’, it’s not from Obama, it’s the military looking after both itself and the country.
It was the Army that finally brought down McCarthy, and there’s a lot of resonance between the two issues — both McCarthyism and Israelism is very, very bad for the nation. This is an American Problem. Not a Jewish Problem. So try to think of it like that — Phil, sometimes I think that you do not really behave according to your own philosophy. These are not “Jews” you are dealing with. They are “Israelis”. A foreign nation. And they do not love you and they will not be careful of your being. So get the f*ck out of Palestine, ok?
Phil – thanks for this video. Yet another tragedy.
A tech tip for the future, from my years in broadcasting – Though I haven’t been there, I know that Palestine is a windy place because of the many videos I have seen with wind noise a problem for the audio. The solution is to use a muff (usually made of foam plastic) on the microphone. If a camcorder is being used that doesn’t have a mic that sticks out from the body of the camera, an inexpensive external mic can be purchased at a place like Radio Shack (if the camcorder allows one to be plugged in) and a muff placed on it. This will also get rid of the explosive popping sounds made when people speak very close to the mic and hit it with their breath.