News

Story of forced searches of travelers’ emails goes viral

TFHI
The latest entry in the “Texts from Hillary” meme.

I was shocked this morning when I began my usual google search for news from Israel. The very first story as I scrolled down to “news” was an AP article titled “Israel airport asks traveller to open email to inspection” which began, “JERUSALEM—When Sandra Tamari arrived at Israel’s international airport…”
 

I practically jumped off the mattress! It was published by an outfit from CTVWinnipeg. Upon further search I realized this article by Josef Federman and Diaa Hadid had saturated the mainstream media. And it picks up the deportation, first reported on our site, of Najwa Doughman and Sasha al-Sarabi.

The Boston Globe, Seattle Times and many other outlets have published this important story, in which Federman and Hadid informed readers of the context:

Israel has become increasingly strict following a series of run-ins with international activists in recent years, highlighted by a deadly clash two years ago between Israeli naval commandos and a flotilla trying to break Israel’s naval blockade of the Gaza Strip. Both sides accused the other of provoking the violence in which nine Turkish activists were killed.

Since then, Israel has prevented international activists from arriving on similar flotillas as well as a pair of “fly-ins” by pro-Palestinian activists. Israeli officials acknowledge they used social media accounts, such as Facebook and Twitter, to identify activists ahead of time and prevent them from boarding flights to Israel.

Emanuel Gross, a law professor at Haifa University, said such a practice would seem to be illegal in Israel.

“In Israel, you need a search warrant to go into somebody’s computer,” he said. “I’m skeptical that the security guards asked a judge first for a warrant and I’m skeptical that a judge would give it.”

Gawker also picked up the story, with the great headline, “US Tourists with ‘Arab Names’ Forced to Undergo Invasive Email Searches at Israeli Airport.” Tablet is on it too.

And we were thrilled to read Sami Kishawi at Sixteen Minutes to Palestine going over the top for us in saying that we are helping to democratize the discourse.

Let’s be clear, the byline on this scoop was Najwa Doughman and Sasha Al-Sarabi. This is about all of us working together in so many ways to change the discourse. It’s citizen journalism, people telling their stories in their own voices. Stories arrive in our inboxes or land in our twitter feeds because we all know if we do not speak up, who will speak for us? Here’s Kishawi:

At this year’s Google Zeitgeist conference, former Al Jazeera producer and current Huffington Post columnist Ahmed Shihab-Eldin spoke about citizen journalism and its growing effect on mainstream media. He drew attention to the emergence of independent blogs as a crucial medium for reportage, one that expands the depth of today’s journalism and “democratizes” the discourse. …

It is important to note that had Tamari, Doughman, or Al-Sarabi remained silent about their grueling experiences under interrogation, Mondoweiss wouldn’t have had any stories to run. And had Mondoweiss not helped push the narratives to a wider public, the Associated Press wouldn’t have had a story to put on the wire.

Let this encourage everyone to share their stories—good or bad—because, for now at least, this might be the only efficient way to publicly document injustice.

(my bold)

Sometimes the personal humiliation becomes too much to bear so how can we put it on the internet and share what is most fragile to us? Especially knowing for the rest of our lives we will remain exposed. But it is precisely those experiences, of Doughman breaking into tears, and the hopelessness of Tamari’s realization our embassy would do nothing to assist her, that reaches the commonality of all of us because ultimately, we share more in common than not.

For years we have relied on reporters such as Amira Hass– who covered this report today in Haaretz ”Israel airport security demands access to tourists’ private email accounts”–and in turn Hass has relied on people on the ground who experience and witness. Journalists may have more training, but they don’t have a corner on the truth, or on human expression, or independence of thought. If we keep speaking, they will hear us because we are not the sound of one hand clapping. We are millions clapping and shouting and demanding justice.

A huge shout out to Josef Federman and Diaa Hadid for hearing the voices of Tamari, Doughman and Al-Sarabi. A huge shout out to everyone who tweets and shares and won’t shut up. And to activists on the ground doing the yeoman’s work, everyday you change our hearts. If it were not for the real people documenting atrocities, who would believe us?

So thank you everyone for giving me faith we can change the world. Hillary and Barack, can you hear us?

109 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

It is never late to learn, Annie. It helps to reduce stress levels and hype.
“Fourth Amendment permits warrantless searches of the contents of laptop computers and other electronic storage devices”

https://help.cbp.gov/app/answers/detail/a_id/176/~/cbp-search-authority

http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/homesec/RL31826.pdf
Cheerio!

Thank Pat Buchanan too. If he hadn’t quoted Phil *at length* two weeks ago on antiwar.com and The American Conservative, you wouldn’t have had clearly mainstream voices go “Oh-Oh.”

No matter what you think of Pat Buchanan, he is clearly one you don’t want identifying you as a pea under his mattress. The man can write his way out of a paper bag, and he can incite paleo-conservatives to near-riot. His writing is FAR more measured than his speech, and is taken seriously by the center-right and far-right for that reason.

Buchanan did MW a serious favor. I havent checked the Alexa stats but I suspect they will show that.

I think there is an increasing global appetite for stories that paint Israel as it is, its warts in high definition beyond the range of hasbara makeup. Going over that media cliff thinking the world still supports it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_d8ROhH3_vs

Mark Toner was asked again about Ms. Tamari at yesterday’s State Department press briefing, but he gave a most unsatisfactory answer:

QUESTION: Can we stay on this for just one second? Did you – was there ever an answer to my question last week about this American woman who – from St. Louis who was deported and was told by the – or allegedly told by the embassy they couldn’t help her because she was not Jewish?

MR. TONER: Right. I did do some research. I thought that somebody had gotten back to you on that. If they haven’t we will get in touch with you. We’re somewhat limited by your old friend, the Privacy Act waiver and the fact that we don’t have one for this individual. But my understanding is —

QUESTION: (Inaudible) managed to put out a press release about this.

MR. TONER: Yes. As you know, these individuals can do that, but unless they’ve signed a Privacy Act waiver, we’re limited in what we can say about that particular case. I do believe that she was, as you said, stopped at the airport. She did speak to consular officials who offered her appropriate support, but beyond that, I can’t comment.

Hopefully he’ll be asked about Doughman and Al-Sarabi.

RE: “Israel airport asks traveller to open email to inspection” ~ AP article

MY COMMENT: If it looks like a duck fascism, swims like a duck fascism, and quacks like a duck fascism, then it probably is a duck fascism.

Duck test – http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duck_test