Pekar’s posthumous title is ‘Not the Israel My Parents Promised Me’

Israel/PalestineUS Politics
on 5 Comments

This is exciting. Guernica Magazine is excerpting a new cartoon book from the late artist Harvey Pekar, called Not the Israel My Parents Promised Me, based on interviews with the writer J.T. Waldman. It’s exciting to think that this is one of the last projects this American Jew of restless conscience was working on before his death two years ago. (Though it is framed as a dialogue, and last year I was fearful of what sad punch Waldman was bringing to the party.)

Pekar is most famous for American Splendor, an autobiographical series; and Wikipedia says his father was from Poland and a Talmudic scholar. Like Tony Judt clearing the decks on his own Zionist attachments, it was important for Pekar to get right with religious nationalism before he went. Great pictures are at the link above. The intro:

Harvey Pekar entered the world as a Zionist. As a young child in Cleveland, his mother, father, and Hebrew school teachers planted an ideal image of the Jewish state that eventually turned sour in Pekar’s mind. Just before the publicly enigmatic comic book artist and writer died two years ago, he documented a daylong conversation with illustrator JT Waldman about the history of the Jewish people, his beliefs versus his parents’, and the debilitating mixture of land, rights, religion, and death in Palestine. In this excerpt from the forthcoming graphic memoir Not the Israel My Parents Promised Me, which Pekar’s partner Joyce Brabner finished and epilogued after his death, Pekar and Waldman wrestle with fairness, justice, and solutions, ranging from the two-state option to sending Jews to the moon.

The book is coming out this month from Farrar, Straus, the same publisher that gave us The Israel Lobby. This is the way the tide is running now, friends. There’s no stopping it. Commentary has a long attack on anti-Zionists, called Attacking Israel Online. Does anyone really care? No; Jews are opening their eyes to this new chapter of our history.

About Philip Weiss

Philip Weiss is Founder and Co-Editor of

Other posts by .

Posted In:

5 Responses

  1. Les
    July 3, 2012, 12:32 pm

    Perhaps some on this blog will share how, and how difficult it was, for them, to turn away from Zionism and to come to oppose it. I suspect few had the dramatic conversion of Saul of Tarsus.

  2. Sumud
    July 3, 2012, 1:50 pm

    Commentary has a long attack on anti-Zionists, called Attacking Israel Online. Does anyone really care? No; Jews are opening their eyes to this new chapter of our history.

    Ben Cohen spilt an awful lot of words for what is essentially a hit piece cum zionist pity party.

    So much stale hasbara…

  3. DICKERSON3870
    July 3, 2012, 3:59 pm

    REALLY GOOD STUFF! When he starts talking about the inanity of the settlements in Figure 5 (of the 7) at Guernica Magazine, remember that when Israel began the settlements they called them “security settlements”.

    • West Bank Political and Security Settlements

    • Israeli Settlements
    Jan 19, 2003 – Settlements make up less than 2 percent of the West Bank. … agreements, coined the term “security settlements” to describe those communities … –

    • facts west bank settlements occupation illegal jewish settlers
    israel facts and settlements west bank palestine facts the truth on israel and … military analysts still hold the view that the “security” settlements are vital for. . . –

  4. seafoid
    July 3, 2012, 4:23 pm

    Harvey Pekar was a real Mentsch. There was a wonderful interview with him in the Cleveland magazine “The Funny Times” a few months after his death. People who think independently are not cut out to be Zionist material.

  5. optimax
    July 3, 2012, 5:58 pm

    I’m glad to see Harvey Pekar recognized as an important artist here. His American Slendor explored how the mundane acts of living added up to make pinnacles of awareness–not an easy task in these days of super heroes and magical realism. His perception was deep. His early graphic novels were drawn by R. Crumb.

Leave a Reply