Top university presidents tour Israel and the West Bank on comp hasbara trip

ActivismIsrael/PalestineUS Politics
on 17 Comments
project interchange presidents
University chancellors and presidents on complimentary hasbara tour to Israel organized by Project Interchange. (Photo: Project Interchange/The Times of Israel)

Earlier this month a group of university presidents and chancellors traveled to Israel and the West Bank with Project Interchange, the hasbara tourism branch of the American Jewish Committee specializing in bringing movers and shakers from the U.S. to Israel. Project Interchange delegations are specialized “to bolster their global relationships and bilateral academic exchange and cooperation.” The organization has sent nearly 6,000 people on their trips, which have included “counterterrorism” training for police departments and customized programs for U.S. elected officials, and campus “student leaders.” 

Each year Project Interchange also runs a handful of programs designed specifically for minority groups, including trips advertised for “African American leaders,” “African American Clergy,” and “Latino Leaders.”  In keeping with the this trend, this year’s university leaders trip also includes the participation of the first university president from a historically black college, Beverly Tatum from Spelman College. Another notable participant was UC Davis’ Linda Kateh, who gained national attention last fall when under her tenure university police brutally pepper sprayed protesting students.

Screen shot 2012 07 16 at 1 35 54 PM
                African American Leaders on Project Interchange’s hasbara tour, 2011.                          (Photo: Project Interchange/Facebook)

It is difficult to quantify the effectiveness of advocacy tourism, but the presidents of Cornell University and the University of California both participated in Project Interchange trips before signing onto massive academic partnerships with Israeli universities. Last winter Cornell’s president David Skorton credited his Project Interchange trip for his $450 million deal with Technion University to build a collaborative New York City campus. From the Cornell Chronicle:

Cornell President David Skorton also has had Technion connections. He and Technion President Peretz Lavie developed a good relationship when Skorton led an American Jewish Committee Project Interchange tour of Israel with other university presidents in the summer of 2010. ‘Peretz and I hit if off, and then we reconnected over the NYC Tech Campus proposal.’

And president of the entire University of California system, Mark Yudof, flew to Israel on a Project Interchange trip only two weeks after assuming his position in 2008.  Since, Yudof has re-initiated a UC wide study abroad program in Israel.

Protesting the university leaders Project Interchange trip, professors with the U.S. Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel (USACBI) issued a letter condemning academic partnerships with Israel:

Dear Presidents and Chancellors,

It has come to our attention that you participated in a recent delegation of U.S. university presidents to Israel (July 1-9, 2012), the purpose of which was to bolster bilateral academic exchange and cooperation with Israeli universities, and to explore opportunities for academic and research collaboration between your universities and Israeli universities. [1]

We are writing to urge you, in the strongest possible terms, not to pursue institutional relationships between your universities and Israeli universities, and to discontinue any existing institutional relationships that might already exist. We ask you instead to honor the call for the worldwide academic and cultural boycott of Israel, initiated in 2004 by the Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel, and supported by the U.S. Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel. [2]

Four Nobel Peace Prize Laureates, Jimmy Carter, Nelson Mandela, Desmond Tutu, and Mairead Maguire have described Israel as an apartheid state [3], and this description has been supported by the Russell Tribunal [4] and the Human Sciences Research Council of South Africa. [5] Far from being the exemplar of “a richly diverse country” or representing “Martin Luther King’s ideals of equality, integration, peace, collaboration and the value of education,” Israel is founded upon discrimination, ongoing ethnic cleansing, and the segregation of access to infrastructure, resources and even education. Indeed, the racist nature of the state of Israel is so extreme that University of Miami president Donna Shalala, who participated in a delegation similar to yours, was detained, interrogated, and humiliated at Ben-Gurion International Airport, in July 2010, simply because of her Arab ethnicity. [6]

Israel’s institutions of higher education are not innocent in relation to this systematic regime of segregation and discrimination, occupation and ethnic cleansing. To give only a handful of examples, Tel Aviv University, which you visited, currently has some 55 joint projects with the Israeli military, especially in the “innovative” field of electro-optics that directly serve and supply the occupation. Hebrew University is built on and continues to expand into occupied East Jerusalem, from which Palestinians continue to be “transferred,” despite its internationally recognized status as the future capital of any independent Palestinian State. Academics in Technion and other institutions have been directly engaged in furnishing the hydrological and demographic surveys that have guided the construction of the separation wall and the illegal settlements on the West Bank. Technion has been directly involved in the development of a remote-controlled “D9″ bulldozer used by the Israeli army to demolish Palestinian houses in acts of collective punishment or ethnic cleansing. All Israeli academic institutions are involved in structural discrimination against Palestinian students. [7]

Earlier this year, a delegation of US professors went on an alternative tour, organized by USACBI, and witnessed the impact of the Israeli occupation on the Palestinian people. They wrote eloquently of their experiences, and their commitment to sever ties with Israel until it abides by international law, in a widely-circulated statement. [8]

Returning from that delegation, the eminent African American historian, Robin Kelley commented in an account of his visit there on “the efforts Israel puts into and invests in normalizing the situation there.” [9] He is correct: the gradual recognition in the media and among an increasing segment of the US and global public of the nature of the Israeli occupation of Palestine, supported by ample documentation of Israel’s egregious abuses, has dealt a serious blow to Israel’s image in the West. As a result, the Israeli government has launched a rebranding campaign (“Brand Israel”), to fix its image, with no attempt to alter the policies that have tarnished this reputation. [10] Delegations such as yours are part of this government campaign, which seeks to distract attention from its violations of international law and of the Palestinian people’s inalienable human rights, by shining a very partial light on Israel’s academic and cultural accomplishments.

Under these circumstances, the establishment of institutional links between your universities and Israeli universities would be de facto recognition and support of Apartheid and colonialism. It would be the moral equivalent of supporting South African institutions during its Apartheid era, and would place you on the wrong side of history.

We urge you to resist the temptation to collaborate with Israeli academic institutions until Israel satisfies the requirements of international law and universally recognized human rights. And we encourage you to inform yourself more fully of the nature of Israel’s discriminatory regime and occupation. The signatories of this letter write on behalf of the U.S. Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel, a representative of which would be happy to meet or talk with you to clarify our concerns. We can be reached at [email protected]

Sincerely,
Rabab Ibrahim Abdulhadi, San Francisco State University
Angela Y. Davis, University of California, Santa Cruz
Gina Dent, University of California, Santa Cruz
Nada Elia, Antioch University- Seattle
Richard Falk, University of California, Santa Barbara and Special Rapporteur on Occupied Palestine for the UN Human Rights Council
Jess Ghannam, UC San Francisco
Sherna Berger Gluck, California State University, Long Beach
Anna Guevarra, University of Illinois, Chicago
Beverly Guy-Sheftall, Spelman College
Robin D. Kelley, University of California, Los Angeles
David Klein, California State University, Northridge
David Lloyd, University of California, Davis
Frederick C. Moten, Duke University
James Petras, Bartle Professor Emeritus, Binghamton University
Edie Pistolesi, California State University, Northridge
Mona Philips, Spelman College
Archbishop Desmond Tutu, Nobel Laureate
Waziyatawin, University of Victoria

For the Advisory Board and Organizing Collective of USACBI, the United States Campaign for the Cultural and Academic Boycott of Israel

Notes:

[1] http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/news/General+News/131662/Leading-US-University-Presidents-to-Explore-Innovation-%26-Academic-Collaboration-with-Israel.html

[2] http://www.pacbi.org/etemplate.php?id=868

[3] Carter; Mandela; Tutu; Maguire

[4] http://www.russelltribunalonpalestine.com/en/sessions/south-africa/south-africa-session-%E2%80%94-full-findings/cape-town-session-summary-of-findings

[5] http://www.hsrc.ac.za/Media_Release-378.phtml

[6] http://www.miamiherald.com/2010/08/07/1765823/um-shalala-treated-as-security.html#storylink=cpy

[7] http://www.epacbi.eu/sites/default/files/Economy_of_the_occupation_23-24.pdf

[8] http://www.usacbi.org/2012/01/us-scholars-delegation-calls-for-academic-and-cultural-boycott-of-israel/

[9] http://mondoweiss.net/2012/02/a-level-of-racist-violence-i-have-never-seen-ucla-professor-robin-d-g-kelley-on-palestine-and-the-bds-movement.html

[10] http://forward.com/articles/2070/israel-aims-to-improve-its-public-image/

The list of participants included:

Chancellor Linda P.B. Katehi, University of California, Davis
President Louis Agnese, Jr., University of the Incarnate Word, San Antonio, TX
President Lawrence Biondi, Saint Louis University, St. Louis, MO
President Karen Haynes, California State University San Marcos
President Elliot Hirshman, San Diego State University
Chancellor Dorothy Leland, University of California, Merced
Chancellor Harvey Perlman, University of Nebraska-Lincoln
President Beverly Tatum, Spelman College, Atlanta, GA
Chancellor Randy Woodson, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC

About Allison Deger

Allison Deger is the Assistant Editor of Mondoweiss.net. Follow her on twitter at @allissoncd.

Other posts by .


Posted In:

17 Responses

  1. Roya
    July 16, 2012, 9:02 pm

    [Screams in frustration. Very, very loudly.]

  2. Roya
    July 16, 2012, 9:08 pm

    I breathed a sigh of relief when I saw that my university was not on this list. Then I did a quick search and learned that my Chancellor has already gone on this trip. I am going to raise hell over this at SJP next year.

    Thank you for the report.

  3. ToivoS
    July 16, 2012, 9:28 pm

    This is impressive. Front and obvious is Linda Katehi the chancilor of UC Davis who was responsible for that famous pepper spraying incident last year against the campus occupy students. She survived that scandal with support of the faculty. Maybe not as well known is that she was part of international committee that recommended local police should be allowed to intervene in University demonstrations in Greece. Linda is Greek but has lived and prospered in US academic circles for 30 years. She was appointed to this international committee that was assigned to solve student disruption problems in Greece. A little background might help — in the 1970s Greek students were at the forefront in opposing the fascist military government. They were brutally suppressed by the military. After those fascist were driven from power, the universities gained some immunity from state police jurisdiction on the campuses. Katehi was part of an international committee that was designed to reverse that rule and recommended that the Greek campuses lose their immunity from fascist state oppression. She is definitely an approved agent for international neoliberalism.

    Interesting to see Linda front and prominent in this hasbara photo.

    • David Green
      July 17, 2012, 6:51 pm

      I could tell Katehi was bad news when she was here in Urbana, but escaped just in time to avoid a scandal, in which she was likely involved, which brought down the Chancellor and President in 2009. It’s adding insult to injury for her to participate in this junket, and she’s obviously utterly clueless regarding the movement for Palestine on campus. It’s just spitting in the face of social justice movement. But look at her background–engineering heavily involved in the MIC. But of course invoking the success of women breaking the glass ceiling in scientific academia. This is what “feminism” has become in college administration. And one needs a broader argument than that which focuses on the Lobby in order to explain this, and the magnitude of this depredation.

  4. ColinWright
    July 16, 2012, 10:59 pm

    The ‘list of participants’ is actually pleasantly unimpressive. About the closest thing to a top-flight school there is UC Davis — which as I understand it, is a good choice if you’re an undergraduate, but…

    I also don’t recognize any of the ‘Black leaders.’ Maybe the trip for ‘Hispanic leaders’ completely crashed and burned.

    When one thinks about who they would have liked to have gotten, the news seems more good than bad.

    • Roya
      July 17, 2012, 2:18 pm

      Colin don’t be so quick to dismiss this. This is the 6th year they’ve run this and they’ve got everybody–even Chinese university presidents. link to projectinterchange.org

      From their website: This engaging educational visit will be PI’s sixth seminar for University Presidents. As always, programming is tailored to the interests and concerns of American university and college chancellors and presidents, encompassing discussions with Israel’s top academic and intellectual leaders. With such widespread anti-Israel sentiment on college campuses, the accomplishments and collaborations stemming from this seminar are of utmost importance as they yield a more even handed approach on Israel-related campus issues. Translation: We are here to ban freedom of speech with regards to Israel on university campuses and to quell each and every campus BDS effort.

  5. Boycott Israel on Campus
    July 16, 2012, 11:25 pm

    A good USACBI letter by good people.

    Now…

    …Each of them should lead a delegation (even if must be a delegation of one person) to their university’s student government, and demand a resolution supporting total boycott by their university against Israel.

    Palestinian life is worth that much of an effort — and it would be no effort at all. A quick walk across your own campus, a five-minute speech at your student government, long enough to be recorded and put on YouTube.

    You could change American campuses with that one hour of effort.

    • Roya
      July 17, 2012, 2:20 pm

      BIOC, it’s not that easy. Remember UC Berkeley? Their divestment campaign lost after the Student Senate president vetoed it. No doubt she’s one of those AIPAC student conference alums.

    • David Green
      July 17, 2012, 6:43 pm

      link to mondoweiss.net

      This HAS to be the year, the academic year, where a critical mass of opposition to “academic exchanges”, junkets, “Israel Studies” programs, etc. is reached on campuses. This HAS to be the year, if there is ever to be a year, where supporters of the Palestinians make bold demands on university administrators, beginning with the most blatant examples of Lobby funding of academic content.

      • Roya
        July 17, 2012, 9:44 pm

        I love what you’re saying David, but what makes you so sure that this will be the year?
        Also that was a great article you linked to. Somebody needs to come out with a book called The Israel Lobby and U.S. Academia and you look like a great contender :).

      • David Green
        July 18, 2012, 1:04 pm

        It’s true that this has been on the table for a long time, without critical mass to challenge the status quo.

        link to zcommunications.org

        It’s up to local planning and risk-taking in the context of publicity and a national strategy. No guarantees, but without assertive action, no possibility of change either.

  6. Philip Munger
    July 17, 2012, 12:30 am

    What might be a good thing to do would be to write to each of these education administrators and ask them a series of courteous questions about the trip, and if they had any positive encounters with Palestinians or Israelis who seriously question Zionist expansionist practices. And wo on.

    I wish I had the time, but possibly a reader here does.

  7. American
    July 17, 2012, 1:20 am

    The Israel firsters might have a problem…their zio banker is getting a look see.

    Sheldon Adelson is under investigation…a big, big, big investigation….by Nev gaming commission, by the Feds for allegations of bribing foreign officials…for doing business with member of organized crime. Big trouble. I mentioned on here a year ago rumors in LV he was involved with organzied crime members.

    link to pbs.org

    • Carowhat
      July 17, 2012, 4:25 am

      When you’re rich as Sheldon Adelson all criminal investigations end up petering out.

  8. ahadhaadam
    July 17, 2012, 6:43 am

    something quite ironic and perhaps symbolic of this attempt to sugarcoat Israel’s horrific past and present is the fact that the group in the second photo are standing on the ruins of the ethnically cleansed and razed Mugrabi neighborhood, whose houses were bulldozed in 1967 with their residents still inside in some cases.

  9. erty
    July 18, 2012, 9:09 am

    Fantastic news for the palestinians who are attending world class educational facilities in the west bank and israel.

  10. erty
    July 18, 2012, 9:19 am

    What a totally stupid idea.israeli universities have more to offer arab students than those in other middle eastern countries
    Israel must be encouraged to do more to educate young arabs
    Boycotting israeli institutions will not help at all

Leave a Reply