Rabbi Yoffie offers racism first, so as to have his warning heeded by Israel

on 11 Comments

Must Rabbi Yoffie first offer racism to be taken seriously in Israel– and then offer ignorance?

In Haaretz, the rabbi wisely warns: “Israel’s leaders’ defiance of reality is the real danger.” The racism:

Extremism of a particularly vicious variety is a Palestinian disease for which a cure has yet to be found.
The ignorance (“never object to a reprimand from an Israeli colleague”?):
“American rabbis should never object to a reprimand from an Israeli colleague, particularly one who has helped us to think about Israel in new and important ways. But I urge Rabbi Gordis to remember that if he is concerned about confronting reality, there are realities that he is not addressing.”

The Yoffie piece is evidence of my assertion that a divorce is coming between US and Israeli Jewry. Yoffie sees it too:

Far from being wild-eyed liberals, most American Jews have sensible, pragmatic views on Israel and the likelihood of peace, but they are confused and incredulous at the myopia of Israel’s political leaders – a dismay that far eclipses the ‘faults’ of U.S. Jewish leaders as identified by Daniel Gordis.

    Leave a Reply