News

Why are two Republican congressmen doing a walkabout on the Temple Mount?

McKinley and Johnson at the Temple Mount. Photo Ed Wittenberg, from the Jewish Tribune
Congressmen McKinley (l) and Johnson (center) at the Temple Mount in February. To Johnson’s left is Chaim Richman of the Temple Institute. From the Jewish Tribune

As Kate noted here the other day, Ma’an reported that two Republican congressmen toured the Temple Mount in February along with rightwing Israel Jews who covet the site.

Two members of the US Congress joined right-wing Jews who toured the al-Aqsa Mosque compound escorted by Israeli police officers in February, a Jerusalem-based Fatah official said.

Dimitri Daliani told Ma’an on Thursday that Republicans Bill Johnson of Ohio and David McKinley of Virginia entered the compound with the “extremist” Chaim Richman, director of the rightist Temple Institute.

Daliani said the “congressmen’s participation in such criminal incursions into the al-Aqsa Mosque without being questioned by their own government indicates collusion with settler gangs whose aim is to hurt the al-Aqsa Mosque.”

The Temple Institute promotes Jewish prophecies of “the reestablishment of the Holy Temple in Jerusalem.”

Johnson later commented in the Jewish Tribune, on “how little real religious freedom and liberty the people of Israel have over the very land that they are supposed to be the owners of.”

“The Jewish people own the property, but they don’t control the property.”…

“I personally think they’ve given up enough,” he said. “They’ve been squeezed out of their land; the holy sites are being controlled by outsiders.

Both men are from business backgrounds and swing districts. Johnson, a Protestant and former computer scientist, captured his Ohio district from a Democrat in 2010 and beat him again in 2012– 53-47 percent. McKinley, a former engineer and an Episcopalian once divorced, also won his seat in 2010, after Democrats held it for 40 years. He won re-election handily in 2012.

Colin Wright, a former commenter on this site, saw the story and adds:

Two Congressmen recently went the extra mile and joined an Israeli walkabout on the Temple Mount.

Their vital statistics are suggestive.  Both are Republicans, both are from districts that would appear to be stuffed with evangelicals, and both recently beat out Democratic incumbents.  They are vulnerable to being unseated.  Bill Johnson, in particular, barely held onto his seat against a challenge from the apparently discontented former
tenant.

These are exactly the types that need to prove they love Israel the bestest — and they are both from districts with evangelicals.

I mention this, because during my tenure at Mondoweiss, when I tried to point out just how important the evangelical demographic is, some element of the counterargument seemed to contain a weird element of Jewish egotism.  Jews had to be the pivotal element.

Well, I don’t think they are.  I think the backbone of support for Israel in this country is evangelical.  Worse, while many or even most Jews support Israel, what they broadly seem to want is a ‘nice’ Israel — one that is democratic, doesn’t shoot children, etc.

The evangelicals are different.  For a variety of reasons, the worse Israel behaves, the better it is fulfilling their needs.  So if Jews are the original reason we have an Israel, one of the reasons it can be an Israel that behaves so badly are evangelicals.  I think that if American support for Israel hinged solely on Jews, it might well still be there — but it would find itself forced to be a much better-behaved Israel.

36 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

The Temple Institute promotes Jewish prophecies of “the reestablishment of the Holy Temple in Jerusalem.”

They contained the instructions about the first partition of Palestine, “And the stranger that cometh nigh shall be put to death. (Numbers 1:51)” The inscriptions contained in the “stones of warning” in the partition wall of the Temple enclosure were described by Josephus in §5 of Antiquities Of The Jews, Book XV, Chapter XI: “this was encompassed by a stone wall for a partition, with an inscription, which forbade any foreigner to go in under pain of death.”. The actual examples discovered by archaeologists so far do not contain any exceptions for US Congressional sightseers.

“I mention this, because during my tenure at Mondoweiss, when I tried to point out just how important the evangelical demographic is, some element of the counterargument seemed to contain a weird element of Jewish egotism. Jews had to be the pivotal element.”

If AIPAC and the Jewish Zionist billionaires and and millionaires who expect reciprocity for their campaign contributions were to stop giving, US support for Israel would collapse in a hurry. Christian Evangelicals don’t have the clout. They’ve spent 40 years trying to overturn Roe v. Wade, put the nativity scene back in our elementary
schoolsl, etc.. and they’ve failed. Evangelicals are powerful but they’re a distant second to the Jewish institutional power behind US support for Israel. When was the last time an American President, half of congress and most Presidential hopefuls attended The National Prayer Breakfast for Israel? Have we ever seen an Evangelical leader convene a “primary” like the one we just saw in Las Vegas?

One might wonder whose interests these congressmen think they represent? Because it certainly doesn’t look like the voters if Ohio and Virginia, but rather right wing extremists in Israel, whose money they gladly accept. In many other countries they call this sort of behaviour corruption.It’s certainly not democracy as we knew it.

RE: “The Temple Institute promotes Jewish prophecies of ‘the reestablishment of the Holy Temple in Jerusalem’. Johnson later commented in the Jewish Tribune, on ‘how little real religious freedom and liberty the people of Israel have over the very land that they are supposed to be the owners of’.” ~ Phil Weiss and Colin Wright

MY COMMENT: These people might well be crazy, but they also mean business. All Hail the Queen “perfect red heifer”!*

* SEE: “Pastor Strangelove”, by Sarah Posner, American Prospect, 05/21/06

[EXCERPTS] . . . Besides his million-dollar compensation package, [John] Hagee has a portfolio of other ventures, including a cattle ranch in south Texas that may have religious significance. Many evangelicals believe that the arrival of a “perfect red heifer” will signal the end times. In the Old Testament, burning a red heifer and sprinkling its ashes is described as a purification ritual for priests entering the temple. Ultra-orthodox Jews believe that the birth of a modern perfect red heifer will herald the arrival of the messiah, leading to a confrontation with Muslims over the Temple Mount, where Jews believe the Temple will be rebuilt. Some evangelicals likewise regard the red heifer as a harbinger of the ultimate showdown at the Temple Mount, which they believe will be the site of the Second Coming. And they believe that time is near.
To many other observers, the advent of the red heifer threatens to provoke a violent struggle for control of the Temple Mount, with worldwide repercussions. In the late 1990s, a group of unidentified Texas ranchers reportedly bred a perfect red heifer, which generated excitement in evangelical circles until the animal sprouted some black hairs.
Six years ago, the John C. Hagee Royalty Trust paid more than $5.5 million for a 7,600-acre ranch in Brackettville, Texas, where cattle are raised in a venture with the Texas Israel Agricultural Research Foundation, a nonprofit outfit operated by the pastor. . . Earl [David Earl, Hagee’s lobbyist] said that Hagee wants to share information to improve the production of livestock, particularly cattle, with an Israeli research project, but otherwise claimed to be unsure of the particulars. Dr. Scott Farhart, an obstetrician and trustee of the John C. Hagee Royalty Trust (and an elder at Hagee’s church), did not respond to a request for comment, nor did the director of the ranch. . .

ENTIRE ARTICLE – http://prospect.org/article/pastor-strangelove