Salaita speaks out and warns of a ‘Palestinian exception’ to the first amendment and academic freedom

US Politics
on 13 Comments

At a press conference yesterday afternoon, Professor Steven Salaita spoke publicly for the first time since the termination of his employment. Nearly one year ago, Professor Steven Salaita accepted an offer from the interim Dean of the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences to join the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign as a professor with lifetime tenure. However, a number of wealthy donors pressured the UIUC board of trustees and chancellor to rescind Professor Salaita’s offer of employment, citing the professor’s controversial tweets about the most recent Israeli attack on Gaza. In early August of 2014, two weeks before Professor Salaita was scheduled to begin teaching courses, UIUC Chancellor Phyllis Wise sent Professor Salaita a letter informing him that his offer of employment had been terminated. A large public outcry ensued, with over 5000 scholars boycotting the University of Illinois until Professor Salaita is reinstated.

Yesterdays’s press conference drew a sizeable crowd, with hundreds of people spilling out from the event hall and into the lobby. Speakers included a representative from the Graduate Employees’ Organization, student organizers, American Indian Studies’ director Robert Warrior, head of the English department Michael Rothberg, Professor Salaita’s legal representative, Maria LaHood from the Center for Constitutional Rights and Professor Steven Salaita himself.

An image created by the Support Salaita campaign. (Image: Facebook)

An image created by the Support Salaita campaign. (Image: Facebook)

LaHood headed off the press conference by emphasizing that Dr. Salaita’s case raised profoundly important questions about academic freedom and the first amendment. She lauded the academic boycott and the now eleven UIUC departments that have voted “no confidence” in Chancellor Wise. According to LaHood, what is happening to Professor Salaita is but one example of a common tactic used to silence critiques of Israel: to brand support for Palestinian rights and personhood as uncivil. “What is actually uncivil,” LaHood insisted, “is the killing of more than 500 children, and the terminating of a tenured professor because he dared to speak out.” LaHood, along with all other speakers at today’s press conference, called upon the Board of Trustees and Chancellor Wise to uphold the principles of academic freedom and to reinstate Professor Salaita.

Dr. Salaita’s focused and powerful address emphasized one clear message: the reaffirmation of his “commitment to teaching and to a position with the American Indian Studies program at UIUC.” Salaita and his lawyers repeatedly insisted that their goal was not to pursue legal recourse against the university, but for the Chancellor and the Board of Trustees to reinstate his position. However, it was clear that he and his legal team are prepared to pursue legal avenues to force his reinstatement if necessary.

Dr. Salaita explained the profound impact the university’s decision had on his personal and professional life. His family, he explained, now has no income or health insurance and great damage has been done to his reputation. Beyond the personal cost he has paid, Dr. Salaita deplored what he sees as the risk of creating a  “Palestinian exception” to the first amendment and academic freedom. Salaita stressed the quality of his teaching record, insisting that he has always been a collegial and dedicated educator, and that he remains more dedicated than ever to challenging prevailing orthodoxies. “This is, as we say in my profession, a teaching moment,” Salaita said.

Asked by a member of the press whether he supported the over 5000 scholars who have pledged to boycott the university until his reinstatement, Dr. Salaita paused. After a few moments of careful thought, Salaita responded with a confident, “I do.” Boycott, he explained, is another form of speech and political expression and is within our right as Americans and as students and faculty.

Dr. Salaita’s appearance was met with a great deal of enthusiasm. Chanting, cheering and applause frequently interrupted his address and those of the other speakers. One member of the press asked Salaita why he would want to return to the UIUC despite all of the controversy and hardship. Salaita replied, “ The answer is in this room.” Calling today’s press conference “one of the proudest moments of [his] life,” Salaita extended his thanks to all of his supporters at UIUC and beyond.

Dr. Salaita, his legal team, and the student and faculty organizers remain committed Professor Salaita’s reinstatement. All are hopeful that Thursday’s meeting of the Board of Trustees will bring good news.

Salaita addresses a press conference. (Photo: Samantha Brotman)

Salaita addresses a press conference. (Photo: Samantha Brotman)

About Samantha Brotman

Samantha Brotman is a Visiting Lecturer & Arabic Specialist at the UIUC's Intensive English Institute. She also works as a project coordinator with The Arab Studies Institute. She is an alumna of University of Oregon and of Georgetown University's MA in Arab Studies, where she researched Christian and Jewish Zionism. She drafted the Jewish Community Letter in Support of Professor Salaita in September 2014. Samantha has also helped to establish a chapter of Jewish Voice for Peace in Champaign, IL.

Other posts by .


Posted In:

13 Responses

  1. seafoid
    September 10, 2014, 10:44 am

    Salaita has a teaching moment here alright and he could use it to draw attention to the thousands of people whose careers have been destroyed by Zionism.

    “It was a technique which the Zionists were to employ throughout their struggle. The technique of promoting damaging personal attacks on those who stood in their way rather than trying to counter their arguments.”
    “Such non conformists were subtly made aware that their jobs might be at risk, their books unpublishable, their preferment out of the question, their public reputations vulnerable if they did not renounce the heresy of anti Zionism ”
    Publish it not, Mayhew and Adams, 1975

    • Mooser
      September 10, 2014, 11:30 am

      “It was a technique which the Zionists were to employ throughout their struggle. The technique of promoting damaging personal attacks on those who stood in their way rather than trying to counter their arguments.”

      And that isn’t, by a long shot, the only correspondence between Zionism and Scientology! But yes, Zionism has a “Fair Game” policy. I’m glad you brought that up, Seafoid, it is an interesting comparison. Why, a person could say that Zionism is a Jewish Scientology.

      • seafoid
        September 10, 2014, 1:36 pm

        And the lobby in DC is Zionism’s magic underwear.
        But it’s very soiled now.

  2. seafoid
    September 10, 2014, 1:38 pm

    “Steven Salaita talks about his termination”. Could some PR hack not come up with formulation to bring anti abortion activists on board? A coalition of the willing against the bots. Flush them out into the light, their ultimate nightmare.

  3. DICKERSON3870
    September 10, 2014, 2:13 pm

    RE: “Speakers included . . . Professor Salaita’s legal representative, Maria LaHood from the Center for Constitutional Rights . . . it was clear that he and his legal team are prepared to pursue legal avenues to force his reinstatement if necessary.” ~ Samantha Brotman

    MY COMMENT: I made a donation via PayPal a couple of weeks ago at SupportStevenSalaita.com, but it no longer has a donation button as they transition to a better fundraising platform. – link to supportstevensalaita.com

    MEANWHILE:
    Palestine Solidarity Legal Support (PSLS) engages in coordinated and strategic legal advocacy to protect and advance the constitutional rights of Palestinian human rights activists across the U.S. PSLS is an initiative built in partnership with the Center for Constitutional Rights, and in collaboration with the National Lawyers Guild and other groups. We aim to build the power of activists to withstand the concerted assault on free speech and continue advocating for Palestinian human rights.
    ● MORE ABOUT PSLS – link to palestinelegalsupport.org

    Help us protect the right to stand for justice!

    Because you support us, we can support Palestinian rights advocates in the US!
    Your donation builds the power of activists to withstand the concerted assault on free speech.

    PSLS is a fiscally sponsored project of the Tides Center, a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization.

    TO DONATE ONLINE USING CREDIT/DEBIT CARDS OR PAYPAL – link to donatenow.networkforgood.org

    To send a check, please make it out to “Tides Center – Palestine Solidarity Legal Support” and mail to: Palestine Solidarity Legal Support – 637 S. Dearborn, 3rd Floor – Chicago, IL 60605.

  4. unverified__5ilf90kd
    September 10, 2014, 5:30 pm

    Seafoid, you are right, thousands of innocents have been sacrificed in the past. As a Prof at several medical schools I saw this in action over 50 years in the trenches. Any criticism of Israel or Jewry was not open to discussion and the punishment was banishment. At last the truth is being revealed to the public (I hope) in this example made of poor Salaita and it will force a lot of Zionist to think about their irrational behavior.

  5. ritzl
    September 10, 2014, 6:07 pm

    On the “civility == death” graphic, when you catch your kids are playing in a busy street, do you say “Please don’t play in the street.” and wait for a reaction, or are you going to perhaps use another tone to get their attention?

    Does “Get your little asses out of the street, NOW!” mean you hate them? Don’t think so.

    • michelle
      September 11, 2014, 11:42 am

      .
      +1
      exactly
      .
      it isn’t the words or actions as much as the motive and intent
      .
      G-d Bless
      .

  6. Exchequer
    September 11, 2014, 3:44 am

    It’s not just at colleges. It’s also in business, government, the arts, indeed any field of endeavor. Dissent must be silenced; it cannot ever be countenanced.

  7. tree
    September 11, 2014, 2:12 pm

    The UICU Board of Trustees just turned down Salaita’s appointment. Vote was 8-1, with the lone dissenter being James Montgomery, a prominent black attorney in Chicago. He was the one who had earlier expressed reservations about the way WIse handled the matter.

    link to youtube.com

  8. James Canning
    September 14, 2014, 3:58 pm

    I continue to think it is not in the best interests of Israel, for free speech in the US regarding Palestine (and Israel’s treatment of the Palestinians) to be suppressed. Which in fact is what is happening.

    • Mooser
      September 15, 2014, 1:22 pm

      “I continue to think it is not in the best interests of Israel, for free speech in the US regarding Palestine (and Israel’s treatment of the Palestinians) to be suppressed.”

      So you are saying the Israelis, the Zionists, don’t know what they’re doing? Have you founded and expanded any Jewish States lately, Canning? When you have some experience in the process, you can criticize the way Zionism handles itself.
      Why on earth would Israel do anything not in its own self-interest?

  9. broadside
    September 15, 2014, 10:27 am

    Erred by calling it Palestinian exception. Should have called it Israel exception.

Leave a Reply