More evidence of the crisis inside American Jewish life triggered by the Gaza massacre. Earlier episodes: Israel has rabies, by Lawrence Wechsler. Israel has no idea how much it’s alienated world opinion, by Ayelet Waldman.
Art Spiegelman has posted a cartoon on Facebook that he did for The Nation that neatly captures what others have called the Israeli national psychosis. The author of the Holocaust cartoon Maus writes that Gaza at last loosened his tongue:
I’ve spent a lifetime trying to NOT think about Israel—deciding it has nothin more to do with me, a diasporist, than the rest of the World’s Bad News on Parade. Israel is like some badly battered child with PTSD who has grown up to batter others.
But… here’s a collage I did for last week’s Nation magazine.
(Maybe Spiegelman should have hat-tipped Blumenthal?)
Roger Cohen had a column at the Times yesterday, A War of Choice in Gaza, that was sharply critical of Israel for launching the Gaza onslaught and challenged the asserted basis for it. Cohen says the American media have never really looked into these bogus claims:
Much mystery continues to shroud its genesis, the abduction on June 12 of three Israeli youths near Hebron and their murder, now attributed to a local Palestinian clan including Hamas operatives who acted without the knowledge or direction of the Hamas leadership. (There has been no major investigative piece in the American press on the incident, a troubling omission.)
But enough detail has emerged to make clear that Netanyahu leapt on “unequivocal proof” of Hamas responsibility (still unproduced) for political ends. The prime minister’s aim was to discredit Mahmoud Abbas, the president of the Palestinian Authority, for reconciling with Hamas; vindicate the collapse of the peace talks Secretary of State John Kerry had pursued; stir up Israeli rage over the fate of the teenagers; sweep through the West Bank arresting hundreds of suspected Hamas members, including 58 released under the terms of an earlier deal with Hamas; and consolidate divide-and-rule…
For more than two weeks after the abduction, persuasive evidence that the teenagers were dead was kept from the Israeli public. A hugely emotional return-our-boys campaign was pursued while the recording of a phone call from one of those boys to the police in the immediate aftermath of the kidnapping was not divulged. In it, shots and cries of pain could be heard.As Shlomi Eldar wrote, “It was a murder in real time, horrifying and monstrous.” After it, “Those who heard the emergency call recording knew that the best one could hope for was to bring the boys to their final resting places.”
The effect of this concealment, whatever its justification, was to whip up an Israeli frenzy. This was the context in which a Palestinian teenager was killed by Israeli extremists. It was also the context of the drift to war: air campaign, Hamas rockets and tunnel raids, Israeli ground invasion. Drift is the operative word. Israel’s purpose was shifting. At different moments it included “zero rockets,” demilitarizing Gaza and destroying the tunnels. “Lacking clear aims, Israel was dragged, by its own actions, into a confrontation it did not seek and did not control,” [Assaf] Sharon writes [at The New York Review of Books].
Certainly many on the left have challenged the Israeli claims, but it ought to be on the front pages.
Noam Chomsky– who has a new book, Masters of Mankind, coming out next week — has of course been critical of Israel for a long time, doesn’t need a Gaza crisis. He expresses the same cynicism as Cohen about Israel’s pretext for warmongering in a piece up at TomDispatch.com:
As usual, a pretext was needed to move on to the next escalation. Such an occasion arose when three Israeli boys from the settler community in the West Bank were brutally murdered. The Israeli government evidently quickly realized that they were dead, but pretended otherwise, which provided the opportunity to launch a “rescue operation” — actually a rampage primarily targeting Hamas. The Netanyahu government has claimed from the start that it knew Hamas was responsible, but has made no effort to present evidence.
One of Israel’s leading authorities on Hamas, Shlomi Eldar, reported almost at once that the killers very likely came from a dissident clan in Hebron that has long been a thorn in the side of the Hamas leadership. He added, “I’m sure they didn’t get any green light from the leadership of Hamas, they just thought it was the right time to act.”
The Israeli police have since been searching for and arresting members of the clan, still claiming, without evidence, that they are “Hamas terrorists.” On September 2nd, Haaretz reported that, after very intensive interrogations, the Israeli security services concluded the abduction of the teenagers “was carried out by an independent cell” with no known direct links to Hamas.
The 18-day rampage by the Israeli Defense Forces succeeded in undermining the feared unity government. According to Israeli military sources, its soldiers arrested 419 Palestinians, including 335 affiliated with Hamas, and killed six, while searching thousands of locations and confiscating $350,000. Israel also conducted dozens of attacks in Gaza, killing five Hamas members on July 7th.
Yes, when will the Times do a big investigation of these Weapons of Mass Destruction, chapter 2.
Tragic that Richard “This is not an entirely trivial matter since government officials should not lie to grand juries, but neither should they be called to account for practicing the dark art of politics. As with sex or real estate, it is often best to keep the lights off” Cohen and Roger Cohen have no relationship.
(wiki quote)
Thanks for this.
The mere fact that the Israelis knew those 3 unfortunate kids were killed the next day, and yet pretended to go on searching them, while destroying Palestinian homes and arresting hundreds, by itself is an act of deception and brutality.
“Cohen says the American media have never really looked into these bogus claims”
The media have never really looked, no, and they never will.
Israel who controls what the US media says, knows fully well, that whatever they claim, most false, will end up being the story forever, and that no one in the media, will investigate or retract earlier false claims. Israel is empowered in the US media. Their narrative becomes the facts in the US. Sad.
And we’ll be frum, frum, frum til Daddy takes the Torah away.
So what do Cohen and Chomsky have to say about this, then? it seems that the exploitation of the murders is more complex than they describe it.
Hey the pictures alone are worth the click. There’s one that looks like it came out of a NFL elevator video!