Commenter Profile

Total number of comments: 3267 (since 2015-02-22 04:31:38)

No particular traits

Showing comments 3267 - 3201

  • The immaculate conception of Louis Brandeis
    • Weiss contributes a detail to the opening sentence of Alison Weir's authoritative book, "In 1912 prominent Jewish American attorney Louis Brandeis, who was to go on to become a Supreme Court Justice, became a Zionist." The footnote to that sentence mentions the role of De Haan and refers to the Grose article in "Moment", also mentioning the origins of that publication.

      I suppose a mention of Weir's work and the general importance of "Against our Better Judgment" would have been relevant --after all, the huge damage inflicted worldwide by the US Zionist cabal is the main point, while the sincerity or not of fake tribal belonging feelings among the conspirators remains rather academical.

  • It turns out Jews are as stupid as everyone else
    • Eva,

      Thanks for this nice reminder on a propaganda classic --

      But "Catalan" is really too impaired to do that right.

      Ash underlines why:

      The case for Israel is made of four propositions that should always be presented in the correct escalating order.


      Meaning that you can't just jump directly to Point 4 without observing the progression from 1 to 2 to 3 to 4. Otherwise one risks coming across as being exactly what one appears to be, i.e. a babbling fool.

    • Reb Feldman,

      I am speechless: such an amount of shiny polish that is even more howlingly racist than the racist turd at its core that the polish was supposed to cover.

      That's a feat, especially coming from a sunday-school thinker deep enough to afford calling Marx a POS. I hope you won't forget to grace posterity with the collected edition of your thoughts.

    • Catalan,

      Your stuff has been catching the eyes of readers here for something like a year or so.
      My question: what is your point? If there is one and you won't tell yet, when can we expect to read about it?

    • Interesting contradictions? No contradiction, as the rabidly racist theory of "Jewish" predictably falls into place here, too, with not only godless Einstein but officially x-generations-removed, opium-of-the-people Marx. Can any political movement be more ludicrously, not to mention unconsciously, racist than this non-political affiliation?

  • On eve of Paris talks PA support for two-state solution not shared among Palestinians
  • To be successful the French Peace Initiative must be based on international law and human rights
    • Ossinev,

      there has effectively been an Apartheid system in Israel and Palestine since 1948. It has however been wrapped up/disguised/figleafed from the outside world through Zionist Hasbara and the ongoing Israeli charade of seeking peace and two states

      Correct. That's why the single most urgent objective should be making clear the one-state reality and destroying all the fictions, including both that of a "justified" partition and that of a separate Palestinian state (the latter was useful when represented by an exiled resistance --no longer so.) Instead of supporting them.

      As for the ongoing genocide, stable census figures are not an argument; the material hurdles are being met by adapting the pace and methods of the extermination to the conditions on the terrain --the Ottoman forced marches were just as effective as the camps and ovens, and Zionist creativity is getting rave reviews in the US.

    • Inbound,

      "The least the Conference could have done" doesn't seem to have been among its preset objectives. In fact, look at both the recent UNSC resolution and this conference: the main objective is to give a new lease on life to the 50-year-old myth of a bilateral "Process" of discussing among unequals about what the protocol of future hypothetical talks may possibly consist of. Both UNSC res and Conference are strictly about "bilateral talks", nothing else.

      After the Oslo disaster that placed all resistance under direct Zionist control, the only thing that the West must do now is to renew the illusion of bilateral talks every once in a while, to keep its public opinion going. Some comedy to convince the boobies that the non-existent talks must be wrested off an inflexible Zionist government helps establish it as a bona fide measure.

    • Ossinev,

      Excellent description of the "Process" of the ongoing annihilation of the owners of Palestine.
      What I just don't see is why the Zionists should not have the "final solution" option. It is already being implemented and I never came across a compelling argument in this regard.

      Also, re your future tense for Apartheid and "One state solution here we come": Excuse me? It is and it has been a single Apartheid state, at any rate a full-fledged one since 1967 -- no need to get into the nitty-gritty of the earlier situation. The laughable virtual Palestinian statehood is pure fiction anyway.

      So I suppose that what I am discussing is the statement about the Apartheid single state being "a matter of time". We are at a more advanced stage and the ongoing genocide leaves no time.

  • Why Israel wants us to say 'terror'
    • Not "always", Citizen. It seems that the wholesale tarring of one's any and all opponents with the "terrorist" brush really took off with the Nazi occupation propaganda and was continued almost seamlessly by their ideological twins the Zionist bandits --the latter mindlessly parroted by the West.

    • What were they doing on other people's land?
      Your profile says: "fierce supporter of Palestinians rights since 1967" --does that include the most basic right of resisting any occupier by any means available, including armed struggle?

    • Mooser,

      It takes two to expel.
      Especially when the party of the other part is convinced he's holding an ass' jawbone or the temple columns.

  • Jared Kushner fired me over Israel ten years ago
  • The truck attack that killed four Israeli soldiers in Jerusalem was not 'terrorism'
    • John 66,

      So what is still unclear in the right of invaded and occupied peoples to use all available means to resist occupation?

  • Israel-Palestine conflict could 'explode' under Donald Trump, Israel supporter warns
    • Yes, Mooser. When a guy gets a very lofty Nobel prize instead of being hanged in Nuremberg as promised by Justice Jackson, it means he's squeaky clean, in conformity with international law and a role model for all. After all, as you say, if you aren't caught how can you get convicted?

  • There is no such thing as 'Progressive Except Palestine'
    • Sibiriak,

      Logic commands to first check the definitions you are using.

    • Oh sure, you can control and censor the thinking and categories of other people who wouldn't dream to follow you.

    • Eljay, if one uses definitions made up by reactionaries and counterrevolutionaries, of course the result will be meaningless mush.

      As Nevel so aptly observed, PEP necessarily means full-fledged support to US Imperialism. Nuff said.

  • Remembering Revolutionary Yiddishland
    • Damasco,

      Sophistry. Are you suggesting that these sharp people were too stupid, even as internationalist socialists (key element!), even in times preceding the Zionist mass folly, to see that they had nothing in common with any non-Yiddish-speaking populations? Just because the word used happens to be the same?

      The piece you quote (Glatstein?) can only be (and explicitly is) from a religious person trying to blackmail tribal nationalists. In fact, it is specifically from a poem on the... Spanish (=Sefardí) Marranos, totally unconnected culturally to anything Jiddisch/Eskenazi. An explicit exercise in spurious Jewish nationalism, the diametrical contrary of the socialist internationalism of the Bundists we were discussing.

      Can you commit a worse anachronism?

    • Thank you for the excellent review, Ajl. Isn't it an anachronism, though, to call irreligious, revolutionary Bundists, openly connected by their Yiddish language and peculiar culture, "Jewish" instead of what they called themselves --Yiddish? They never saw themselves as anything but culturally Ashkenaze people, with a marked ethnic characteristics that had not much to do with a given religion and nothing to do with any cloud-cuckoo "Jewishness".

  • MLA votes against BDS, tables resolution blaming PA and Hamas for restrictions on Palestinian academic freedom (Updated)
    • Nada,
      Thank you for the reminder about MLA's past attitude.

      One remark, though:

      this JPost article says the sponsors of the anti-BDS resolution were assisted by “Jewish organizations.” Certainly not any Jewish organizations, but Zionist ones.

      The overwhelming majority of Jewish organizations are Zionist. Stark statistical fact.

  • Getting away with murder: the Elor Azarya 'manslaughter' case
  • The mainstreaming of Palestinian genocide
    • Read the definition on the International Convention on Genocide.
      Written by Raphael Lemkin himself.
      Also, show me what chance of escape there is.

    • Ms Rosengarten,

      How can you leave Trump, Obama, the Clintons or any US politician at all out of this?
      The US is not separate from this "degenerate society with fascists at the helm". The US directly provides money, arms, diplomatic support and thousands of soldiers. It is not an accomplice but a principal. Also, fascists here are not a minority at the helm.

      since 1948 the Zionist dream of a Jewish State died in a twisted ideology of perverse racism and hate

      The Zionist dream of a Jewish State is a twisted ideology of perverse racism and hate, from way before 1948.

  • Booker slams UN resolution as 'anti-Israel,' while Saban says it's anti-American
    • Misterioso,

      So all US admins until now were flea-free? Are you sure you have correctly identified which side is the varmint carrier?
      In fact, the Yahoo had no choice as to the dog: that bed was vacated by the Anointed Harpy, pending some Act of God.

  • New poll shows sharp partisan divide on UN settlements resolution, and between Jews and African-Americans
    • RoHa,

      Of course that tosh about Russian hacking is now the official state doctrine of the US of A, including all its elected, selected and unelected organs. Just came back from my compulsory Two-Minute Hate to find most of my favorite Web sites adorned by tasteful little posts about Emmanuel Goldberg, including this page.

  • Will the Azaria verdict shield Israel from the International Criminal Court?
    • "Inaction"? If direct participation by gifting unlimited arms, ammunition, support equipment, bottomless monetary help, full diplomatic coverage and export of thousands of military and settlement personnel, not to mention a series of wars of aggression waged according to a specific public request, is "inaction" or in any way "indirect". Non-stop since the 1960s.
      They don't look about the same, they are the same.

  • After Israeli soldier is convicted of manslaughter, Times and Post portray case as isolated incident
    • Mooser,

      Not only the invasion and occupation of Palestine, but also the dispossession and genocide of its owners are definitely above any inner-Zionist dispute. A Weimar comparison never applied to the Zionist entity.

    • Weimar? It sounds past that by years. Already the bunker in Berchtesgaden.

    • Rob,

      there is no hope whatsoever for Israelis to understand their crimes

      If that ain't the first truth to write under the gate, to be read by anyone dreaming of any concessions by Zionists. Not "Israelis", all Zionists everywhere. They have stopped raising their poor kids in the normal world, for the last 2-3 generations now.

  • In 'breathtaking' UN vote, Obama changed his policy on Israeli settlements, making them a war crime -- Finkelstein
    • I know what our War Party and regime change artists are trying to call it, Mooser.

      The rest of the world calls it putsch, military takeover, coup d'État, banana republic Pronunciamento, Color Revolution, Maidan, "We Came, We Saw, He Died", etc. Especially when conducted by the chief criminals against humanity of the century and before the accused in the show trial had any opportunity to commit any high crime and/or misdemeanor.

    • RoHa,

      All the signs say it's not going to be a Lone Crazed Assassin.
      What is to be expected is a People's Tribunal, already empanelled with Everybody That Counts and His Brother, which will read the official sentence for Conduct Unbecoming prior to forming a square to the roll of drums. We have already reached the peak, ever, of bipartisan unanimity and national unity since these here Colonies rebelled. The triumph of order, decorum and war over the Rabble.

    • Just,

      “Why should we care about the birthplace of major criminal against peace, war criminal, and Butcher of Gaza Obama?”

      Last time I looked, President Obama is not PM nor King of Israel. Check your outrage at the door, please~ it is not helping the Palestinian people.

      Never said he is PM or King of the Zionist entity. Doesn't have to. The US Gpvernment is infinitely more powerful in deciding whatever happens in Palestine than any organization in Palestine.

      As for what helps the Palestinian people, there is precious little empirical evidence one way or the other. Plain logic suggests that supporting its mortal enemies is not likely to help, either.

      Speak and write to your representatives in Congress, the Senate, and your city council.

      That may be a good recommendation for the naive who still believe fairy tales about American Democracy and similar nonsense. Anyway, it mostly doesn't hurt, so I occasionally waste a good stamp.

      Good luck with Trump, though. I’m not entirely sure that he can or will be able to read anything other than twitter.

      Good luck for what? No one expects him to be any different than Obama and Co. or Bush with regard to Palestine, specifically.
      He has not committed --yet-- any of the multiple, heinous crimes against peace and war crimes of the Obama-Clinton administration --the ones for which the Nazi government was hanged in Nuremberg. He may start doing so in a few days. Until then, the sitting criminals against humanity are the main danger and the main enemy of the Palestinian resistance, and they are pushing for more war and mayhem with all the combined energy of the Demolicans, Repucrats and the (real) government.

    • Kay,

      Why should we care about the birthplace of major criminal against peace, war criminal, and Butcher of Gaza Obama?

    • Keith,

      Thanks for observing the "pinning" by Trump. If calculated as more than a single gesture, hugely promising.

    • Thank you, Mr Weiss. NF changed my perspective --the theory of a childish, spiteful, thin-skinned Obama taking a last-minute revenge without thinking too much is not implausible and the Kerry speechifying seem to document that the act was voluntary but its consequences uncalculated --especially re the the new GCC mafia under Zionist deputy leadership.

  • John Kerry picked the wrong timeline for the Jewish state
    • Mooser,

      I have to apologize for the careless use of US colloquial "you" as an undefined pronoun --instead of the clearer "one". Of course you, Mooser, weren't meant.

Showing comments 3267 - 3201