Commenter Profile

Total number of comments: 1576 (since 2011-07-30 17:54:17)

born part Arab part Scots/Irish, worked in training ulema for the european environment/ journalist broadcaster for many years working mainly for bbc. From a faction of euro-islam much favored by the establishment, writer etc nothing really of interest may as well move along.

Showing comments 1576 - 1501

  • Thousands gather to mourn Palestinian teen shot dead during clashes
  • 'Constructed crisis for political ends': anti-Semitism claims are prime weapon for UK Israel lobby, Al Jazeera shows
    • "As if accusing members in your own party of being Nazis is acceptable discourse. Foster said he “could have easily referred to Mao and the Red Guard or Saddam Hussein and the Revolutionary Guard” when discussing Momentum. But he didn’t: He chose Nazis."

      In England it is imperative to slur correctly, but more interestingly

      The Zionist lobbyists are using the 'soft-power' aspect of a counterinsurgency approach rather than attempting to debate their opponents within the confines of legitimate democratic political intercourse.

      while people are concerned about anti-semitism the UK is embracing her Muslim community with something called CONTEST (see link) which is comprised of 4 limbs

      "Pursue, Prevent, Protect and Prepare" (?)

      the soft power bit is the current Zionist approach to their fellow non-Muslim citizens, but there is always the kinetic option, the Muslims are getting that already see at link, and see if you think this below fits the scenario you describe

      "Soft-power’ is used to mean non-violent action that seeks to influence a social agent and make them change their behaviour. In a counterinsurgency and counter-terrorism context, the use of soft-power would typically involve the use of financial reward and inducements, developing a rapport with people/populations in order to develop intelligence, and the crafting and dissemination of propaganda or ‘strategic communication’.

      What is worth emphasising is that even though soft-power may be non-violent, it can still be highly coercive and therefore, in practice, create the same outcome or effect as an act of violence. Exactly how both forms of power are combined in order to fulfil state objectives, discipline groups, and socially control populations can be better understood by drawing on Antonio Gramsci’s (1971) seminal work on hegemony. Such a framework is especially helpful in theoretically understanding the false dichotomy between coercion and consent, and ultimately, Prevent and Pursue."

  • The immaculate conception of Louis Brandeis
    • "Also note some Palestinian family names like Masri, Hourani, Hijazi, etc"

      Masri like Moses?

      Hourani like Job?

      Hijazi are you suggesting that the Khalidis, who could be Hijazi if Ibni Walid hadn't been such a superstar, are not Palestinian?

      over to you Ameriki

    • "“gamal” this time Phil Weiss has gone too far"

      yes didn't mean to be rude i just thought North's "pretty fly for a white guy" accolade to Brandies was funny well he does have three parentheses to feed and as an Arab i'm probably moderately prejudiced at the very least, i could go radical any second and what is it with Weiss and failing to fall away, the guy has stamina.

    • "He would stride across the American political landscape today like a colossus"

      while possibly true I think it says more about the "American political landscape" than much else,

      from the excert below "This land, treeless a generation ago, supposed to be sterile and hopelessly arid, has been shown to have been treeless and sterile because of man's misrule."

      "of man's misrule." who they?

      sure sounds like a Yankee colossus

      "Zionism seeks to establish in Palestine, for such Jews as choose to go and remain there, and for their descendants, a legally secured home, where they may live together and lead a Jewish life, where they may expect ultimately to constitute a majority of the population, and may look forward to what we should call home rule."

      "they expect ultimately to constitute a majority" anodyne words utterly devoid of any redeeming quality.

      From the Jewish Problem and How to Solve it.

      "Nature and man presented obstacles in Palestine which appeared almost insuperable; and the colonists were in fact ill-equipped for their task, save in their spirit of devotion and self-sacrifice. The land, harassed by centuries of misrule, was treeless and apparently sterile; and it was infested with malaria. The Government offered them no security, either as to life or property. The colonists themselves were not only unfamiliar with the character of the country, but were ignorant of the farmer's life which they proposed to lead; for the Jews of Russia and Roumania had been generally denied the opportunity of owning or working land. Furthermore, these colonists were not inured to the physical hardships to which the life of a pioneer is necessarily subjected. To these hardships and to malaria many succumbed. Those who survived were long confronted with failure. But at last success came. Within a generation these Jewish Pilgrim Fathers, and those who followed them, have succeeded in establishing these two fundamental propositions:

      First: That Palestine is fit for the modern Jew.

      Second: That the modern Jew is fit for Palestine.

      Over forty self-governing Jewish colonies attest to this remarkable achievement.

      This land, treeless a generation ago, supposed to be sterile and hopelessly arid, has been shown to have been treeless and sterile because of man's misrule. It has been shown to be capable of becoming again a land “flowing with milk and honey.” Oranges and grapes, olives and almonds, wheat and other cereals are now growing there in profusion."

  • Statement: Palestinian students in UK demand resignation of National Union of Students VP following Al Jazeera investigation
  • It turns out Jews are as stupid as everyone else
    • " least Jewish Jews"

      yes man now you rocking,
      bring the band on down behind you,

      what is the least Jewishness one can have? I may have had a build up, may need to purge for progress' sake

      ( i not sure about the commas, no disrespect i'm comalexic, how do apostrophes work, are they not vowels?)

  • On eve of Paris talks PA support for two-state solution not shared among Palestinians
  • Kal Penn's primetime shoutout to Palestinian refugees is gift that keeps on giving
  • Origins of a golden shower
  • Against Israel, Hamas and Fatah
    • "at least not explicitly, f-Israel,"

      he is explicit on FB "fuck Israel first" he says, getting the order right.

      "we all have to be resigned to Israel" buck up old man, no one in the region is resigned to anything, can you imagine being 29 in Gaza? my oldest girl was born '88 like Majed, for Arabs the "Fuck List" is extensive...don't get me started, but i think Muhammad Asad below has a point too, once you are factionalised, which is they hated and why they killed Arafat after neutering him, frustration is the atmosphere everywhere in the Arab world, fuck America is well up on my list.

      and he is right with many of the "Islamic" factions the "Islam" is embarrassing, the nationalists are not nationalist, the secularists are not secular and the Islamic parties are tedious. it tries the patience of the saints.

  • How I got over the Milk-and-Honey-and-Chosen-People place
    • "Is there a prayer to thank God for not making me a Jew?"

      yes in Islam we have one but it goes even further, as afghans are wont to.

      Not Christian or Jew or
      Muslim, not Hindu,
      Buddhist, Sufi, or Zen.
      Not any religion

      or cultural system. I am
      not from the east
      or the west, not
      out of the ocean or up

      from the ground, not
      natural or ethereal, not
      composed of elements at all.
      I do not exist,

      am not an entity in this
      world or the next,
      did not descend from
      Adam and Eve or any

      origin story. My place is
      the placeless, a trace
      of the traceless.
      Neither body or soul.

      I belong to the beloved,
      have seen the two
      worlds as one and
      that one
      call to and know,

      first, last, outer, inner,
      only that breath breathing

      human being.

      sufi mystic - jelaluddin rumi - 13th century

    • ", most of the time."

      thats how to use a comma, that was class sir. skip that because it isn't Judaism you have the instinct.

      yes they have their things but you just going to do what you want like a Jewish toaster, when hopeton lewis made a track uroy put it on his system and dubbed out the tracks and said his thing over it, toasting, i have always thought Israel would do well to hear this track in relation to their relationship with the US " don't kill the goose that lay the golden egg" yes "Tom drunk but Tom na fool.... then you have to beg" "you cheated and you lied" and you are wrong adds roy.

      well if you not the pandit you are at least the Jewish American U roy (there is no higher praise) the caterpillar crack below would win a prize in any other forum,

  • The Palestinian state never had a chance: a review of Toufic Haddad's 'Palestine Ltd: Neoliberalism and Nationalism in the Occupied Territory'
    • two things

      anyone who actually knows the history knows that while these regions were nominally part of this or that meta-political formation large areas of Palestine and the whole levant and Egypt were in fact self governing for extended periods, read a book,


      are there actually people who comment about Arabs who have never listened to enta omri, i don't believe it, but i have heard it sometimes happens, it may spiritually circumcise you a little Arab little Jew, also it has a kind of implacable womaness that is too much.,

  • Mostly-Jewish golf club is roiled by a prospective member's stance on Israel-- Obama's
  • US watched ISIS rise in Syria and hoped to 'manage' it -- Kerry on leaked tape
    • "i don’t think it’s true that the opposition is comprised of mainly jihadis. i think it’s true the fighting force of the opposition is dominated by jihadist and for this reason assad has even more support by syrians than he would have if that were not the case. but i think there are a lot of syrians with legitimate complaints against assad. i think there are ordinary secular syrians, ordinary religious syrians of every stripe who have concerns about assad. but i’ve always felt the jihadists completely dominated the (fighting) forces opposing assad."

      thats very astute and one might add those of a revolutionary leftist perspective also have plenty of legitimate complaints about the Syrian ba'ath, in the end the national security outlook crippled them and the inter-Arab catastrophe of the last half of the 20th century, they became timid if steadfast, for all his courage Assad is a mediocre leader, in comparison to the Kings or Western stooge Sissis however he is the messiah.

  • The truck attack that killed four Israeli soldiers in Jerusalem was not 'terrorism'
    • "But there’s a problem, is there not"

      yes, kind of, 3 that i can think of

      1. dul kalu il dunya ghaba wa wal0u ilfatil

      2. bahgit il irhab balina kam sana amerika wa israil wakhdiniha fatawina

      but mostly

      Ya amm arabi imta nawin tadharaku

      here shaaban expostulates, with all necessary translation, its common knowledge in my manor after all

  • There is no such thing as 'Progressive Except Palestine'
    • "Dear Self-Proclaimed "Progressives": as Apologists for the Neocon-Neoliberal Empire, You Are as Evil as the Empire You've Enabled"

      Charles Hugh Smith

      "Sorry, pal, you're evil. Self-righteous indignation counts for nothing in the strict accounting of real progressivism."

      "Dear Self-Proclaimed "Progressive": I love you, man, but it has become necessary to intervene in your self-destruction. Your ideological blinders and apologies for the Establishment's Neocon-Neoliberal Empire are not just destroying your credibility, they're destroying the nation and everywhere the Empire intervenes.

      While you squandered your political capital defending zero-cost causes like "safe spaces on college campuses," the Empire was busy killing, maiming and making refugees of women and children in Syria. President Obama and his Neocon crew (former Secretary Hillary Clinton included) aren't fools; they rely on drones and proxy armies to do their dirty work.

      Neoliberalism is the Establishment's core ideology, and by supporting Bill Clinton and Barack Obama, you furthered, defended and rationalized the Empire's neoliberal expansion and exploitation. Neoliberalism's Big Lie is transforming everything into a market makes everyone richer."

  • Israeli diplomat schemed to 'take down' UK's Deputy Foreign Secretary because he slammed settlements
    • "the juvenile Zionist Jared Kushner as his senior Advisor in foreign affairs."

      This young man is his son-in-law? thats odd

      and to be fair a warm sandwich could formulate and implement American "foreign policy", it's simple and brutal and will lead to catastrophe for all of us.

      Who is the president hardly matters any more, America has mounted the world and is fomenting war everywhere, its going to be spectacularly bad, it already is. I am genuinely surprised how the destruction of the Arab world and the wars all over Africa have been so easily normalised in American, what, political awareness, discourse or whatever, its all so 18th brumaire with an added heart of darkness/darkness at noon/ladder of bones aspect, these have become interesting times, there is no social basis for resistance in the "west" may be the Africans and Arabs will save you.

  • 'Progressive' Defenders of the Racial State: Reflections on the Modern Language Association BDS vote
  • The mainstreaming of Palestinian genocide
    • "You’ve never heard of My Lai?" the whole Phoenix program was a massive crime, Empire is such a messy business.

      Air Commander Lionel Charlton resigned his commission in 1923 because of the British policy of "intimidation by bomb" as used in Mesopotamia, Palestine, Somalia, Egypt and India later extended to Aden. A few Pilots were indeed prosecuted for atrocities which were indistinguishable from scores of other celebrated actions as in below...

      "Once deployed in Iraq the RAF proceeded to bomb civilians and tribal insurgents alike. A Kurdish survivor of these attacks later recalled, "They were bombing here in the Kaniya Khoran ... Sometimes they raided three times a day."[6] Wing Commander Lewis, of the 30th RAF Squadron remembered: "one would get a signal that a certain Kurdish village had to be bombed."

      Arthur Harris, the man who would later oversee the destruction of German cities during WW II, also saw action in Iraq and participated in the bombing of civilians as a wing commander. He wrote of this experience, "The Arab and Kurd now know what real bombing means in casualties and damage. Within forty-five minutes a full-size village can be practically wiped out and a third of its inhabitants killed or injured."[7] Similarly, J.A. Chamier, another British wing commander, wrote, "The attack with bombs and machine guns must be relentless and unremitting and carried on continuously by day and night, on houses, inhabitants, crops and cattle."[8] By March 1922 the Air Ministry had proven its tactics so effective that it was given control over security in Mesopotamia. For the next decade RAF planes would bomb numerous tribes that continued to defy British rule.

      Britain Wrecks International Arms Control Negotiations to Ban Bombing of Civilians
      Due to Its Desire to Use Bombing against Its Imperial Subjects

      Serous efforts were made in international arms control negotiations to ban the bombing of cities and civilians. However, Great Britain rebuffed any attempt to restrict its use of bombers against civilians in territories under its control. For example, during disarmament talks in March 1933, Great Britain had submitted the so-called MacDonald Plan, Article 34 of which agreed in principle to a limitation on aerial bombardment "with the exception of police actions in certain distant locations." Two years later, in May 1935, Lord Londonderry then defended Britain's refusal to agree to a prohibition on using aerial bombardment against civilians that had been proposed at the Geneva Disarmament Conference:

      "I hammered home to my colleagues and also to the entire nation the vital position that the Royal Air Force occupies in our defensive plans. At this time of general outcry for disarmament I had the greatest difficulty even maintaining the need for bombers on the frontiers of the Middle East and in India, where it was only thanks to the air force that we were able to keep these areas in check."

      Trenchard's concept of "Air Control" had thus become entrenched as formal government policy and Britain would never give up its right to use aerial bombardment against peoples within its empire."

  • New poll shows sharp partisan divide on UN settlements resolution, and between Jews and African-Americans
    • forgive me

      "You surely don’t believe this tosh about Russian hacking?"

      loh and behold (google better not let me down, so many slavs around)


      "A russian word describing a naive and extremely trusting person, subject to various frauds and fails"

      - Look, mate! A guy in the street sold me this Rollex for 100$!
      - what a loh you are! that's a Chinese fake!

    • "You should be so lucky.

      Putin is, if not the most, certainly one of the most respected national leaders in the world"

      god sake man it's "I should be so lucky",

      i would welcome Putin we have a zombei (sic) Kenny, first name Enda but he won't, in Ireland the greatest person was countess Markievicz, why not Put'n as the Americans have it, i respect you too much to link to Kylie, let Oz retain its dignity.

  • In 'breathtaking' UN vote, Obama changed his policy on Israeli settlements, making them a war crime -- Finkelstein
  • Hamas celebrates 29th anniversary amid local and international challenges
  • Terrorism: How the Israeli state was won
    • "work out for Custer?"

      like the Jews emphasise hubris gets you every time, have you noticed how the msm is trying to provoke race war, everything gone helter-skelter, in Europe its refugees raping white women and groping Aryan thighs, Isis Islam encroaching everywhere, if you think Arabs are naive like Native Americans, take a deep breath we fight over millennia, our papers are in order too, whats wrong with Americans? you in a Margherita haze?

    • Dear Mr. Suarez

      972 mag had a Hillel Cohen piece that i thought was interesting for a number of reasons about 1929 in Palestine.

  • Scenes from Gaza on the last day of 2016
    • "What incensed him the most was the blatant jokes of the ones that passed it all off as a jest, pretending to understand everything and in reality not knowing their own minds"

      nothing changed then Leo, still chewing nutty gizzards and urine scented kidneys?

  • Israeli hysteria over UN vote is solidifying country's new status, as a rogue state
    • "there was no going lower"

      no there's always lower my sweet innocent friend, the pit is bottomless, i have the t-shirt.

    • 'Echin, on Phil Weiss:'

      Yes myself i would be cautious when thinking that if Mr. Weiss is expressing views more in harmony with my view that he could be said to be making "progress" unless he craves the state of injurious hooligan like my humble self, someones got to do it delinquency will have it's say.

      Remember its a Weiss Weiss world and only getting Weisser,

      to my mind Philip Weiss has always shown the courage to call it as he sees it and god bless him for that, i think his site stands alone, do you all know the words to auld land syne, let me compose myself and i'll do the bass others the descant, i think the Arabic part is in Weiss Arabic because i don't get a word (be misunderstood..does no one read deeply, its not pearls before swine but they are peanuts at least (fuck off) take my hand and with your pink martini

      but genuinely respect Mr. Weiss, you have certainly earned mine.

  • Scenes from a neoconservative meltdown
    • "Israel is indeed NOT an ally.”

      " “Atlantaiconoclast” if you can post comments here, you can post comments at any on-line forum."

      Mooser you know we weep at the Zionist oppression under which the US labours, its seems to me that Trump allows for the possibility of both classical Anti-Semitism in the sacred capitalist homeland coupled with vigorous Zionism, that will teach you "libtard" anti-zionist Jews,

      "is no ally" just look at Saudi thats a consummated alliance,

      last week it occurred to me that i can go on alt-right or was it breitbart, i learned that yezidis are probs Celtic, there were photos blondes and green eyed girls, Arabs are orcs and Jews have made white people want to dance with their hips and take drugs and have sex with black people,
      are you not a little contrite, we expect a "mullet" go faster stripes and an overwrought tearful rendition of "amazing grace" fucksake try to fit in of which may i multicultural you

      my father was a shadhliyyite, pretty lame really but in the oral lineage the following is recorded,

      during a lecture in Alazhar the sheikh Shadhili was listening to the Sh al Azhar explaining the moral superiority of the Muslims, how noble and restrained our dignity how perfect our conduct, when the august dandy Shad stood up and produced his member and urinated all over his prayer matt, he assiduously cleared himself of urine arranged himself and resumed his seat, there was stunned silence he said, free simple trans, "we don't look so good now do we"

  • It is time to recognize the US-Palestinian conflict
    • not only is there a Palestinian US conflict a weakness in analysis in the west is the inability to locate the Palestinian US conflict within the overall Arab US conflict,

      the US has established Fort Laramie (Israel) Fort Phil Kearney (Baghdad) Fort Apache (Kabul) etc and now is behaving as if the Red Mans Law (International Law) is dead and US rule will be extended to west Asia by the US military, resistance to this is inevitable not caused by hatred, anger, backwardness or religion currently the US is fighting itself and as a by product burning down the Arab house, the situation now in the Arab world is becoming finally pre-revolutionary solely as a result of the insane violence and injustice of US aggression and that of their proxy monarchies

      it might be time to consider

      "There Are No Terrorists? Counterterrorism = Supporting Terrorism? Western Governments Are Supporting Terrorist Organizations Which They are Allegedly Combating"

      "The Western media in chorus is accusing the Syrian government and its allies including Russia and Iran of “crimes against humanity” for having liberated Aleppo from the clutch of Al Qaeda terrorists. “Putin and Assad could face justice for war crimes in Syria” according to the Washington Post.

      In the media coverage of Aleppo, the Al Qaeda affiliated terrorists are casually described as opposition “rebels” waging a “revolution” against the government of Bashar al Assad, who is portrayed as a “dictator”.

      The media propaganda campaign has gone into high gear. The words “Al Qaeda”, “Al Nusra” or “terrorists” are simply not mentioned in recent media reports. It never happened. “Opposition rebels” committed to democracy have been crushed by the Russians, according to “authoritative” media sources.

      According to reports, there were no terrorists in Aleppo. The “rebels” are now being portrayed as the victims of Russian aggression. These are the same terrorists who are the object of Obama’s alleged “counterterrorism” campaign, which is largely intent upon protecting the terrorists.

      Lies by Omission

      There is no mention of the fact that East Aleppo has been occupied by Al Qaeda affilated entities (which are on the EU and US State Department “terror lists”) and that these terrorists –which are now portrayed as “freedom fighters’– have committed countless atrocities against civilians. And these atrocities are now casually being blamed on the Syrian, Russian and Iranian forces which liberated Aleppo.

      For four years East Aleppo has been occupied by Al Qaeda, which had established a regime of terror and destruction. The media has portrayed the terrorists as “the moderate” opposition.

      Syria: A US-NATO Sponsored Terrorist Insurrection Initiated in March 2011

      The evidence amply confirms that Washington has supported the terrorists from the very outset. The influx of Salafist mercenaries commenced in the Southern city of Daraa on the border with Jordan in mid-March 2011.

      Moreover, in an August 2011 report, Israeli intelligence news (Debka) confirmed that NATO and the Turkish High Command were involved in recruiting Mujahideen mercenaries throughout “the Middle East and the Muslim world”, while providing the rebels with an vast array of weapons:

      “NATO strategists are thinking more in terms of pouring large quantities of anti-tank and anti-air rockets, mortars and heavy machine guns into the protest centers… ” (Debka) .

      The terrorists are the foot-soldiers of the Western military alliance. Al Qaeda is a creation of the CIA. The Islamic State (ISIS-Daesh) was originally an Al Qaeda affiliated entity (Al Qaeda in Iraq) created by US intelligence with the support of Britain’s MI6, Israel’s Mossad, Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) and Saudi Arabia’s General Intelligence Presidency (GIP)."

  • In Photos: Gaza protest commemorates second intifada
    • understand when you see resistance what an astonishing achievement you are witnessing, in sustained resistance

      "A Dialectical Pedagogy of Revolt: Gramsci, Vygotsky, and the Egyptian Revolution"

      By Brecht De Smet

      "In A Dialectical Pedagogy of Revolt Brecht De Smet integrates the political thought of Antonio Gramsci with the cultural psychology of Lev Vygotsky into an original perspective on revolutionary subjectivity that is deployed to understand the Egyptian “Tahrir” Revolution."

      it may also help with the Arab induced depression from which some of your writers are suffering

      if you take a brief look at page... well why not read on from at least chpt 26 on P.335, there is a great deal here that a "supporter" of Palestine might learn if they were open to it, the lessons may even apply where ever you may be.

  • Forced existence
  • Hell just froze over: the New York Times runs an article saying Zionism is racist
    • thanks for the trefa banquet, i should really post this to the art of resistance post but

      look what happens when people meet up in a sinai inn with no respect for boundaries

      gumar badawi

      Today's song is by an Sudanese artist named Jamal Porto, who lived at an Egyptian inn in the Sinai called RAS. At RAS, musicians have gathered for over twenty years to meet and play, and the family that owns the inn built a recording studio. In 2005, they sent out a call to musicians from all over the world, and forty artists from ten nations responded. They played and recorded music, which resulted in a CD called The RAS Project: A Musical Journey in Sinai. This song, Gamar Badawi, is from that album and is also on the 2008 Putumayo compilation Acoustic Arabia, and is a song of longing for a beloved back in Sudan."

      "Gomar Badawi (feat. Asia Medani, Avi Agababa, Boaz Nikritin, Itamar Gross, Gamal Porto, Ofer Meir Ankori, Ramadan Abel Karim, Udi Ben Kna'an & Yaron Pe'er)" by The Ras Project ( • )

    • "Mooser, the issue I am interested in is what we are allowed to say"

      "Are we allowed to say any religion is silly and repugnant?"

      if you believe that i would say you are duty bound to say so and explain why, religion as politics is a disaster today, religion as social policy is unworkable today, people who attempt to foist religion as identity or community today had better clearly understand that it can work as a mechanism for liberation only if it is both barrierless and free of concern for observance the emigrant Muslim community has been crippled by an idiotic obsession with observance, traditionalism, ie drinking non-praying expert professionals and academics were scorned as representatives etc in favour of barelwi grocers who barely spoke English and were educated to a 5th grade level,

      i broke my heart trying to organize a rational approach to our evolving communities issues, only to be asked if all the lunch was halal ( the food of Jews and Christians is halal to a muslim so long as there is no alcohol or pork, the halal industry is a scam) wtf!

      i used to argue with shks and their bloody boiler plate crap about rites etc separating believers from nonbelievers and used to patiently explain that shit has now changed today we are either one with everybody or we are worthless nahnuummat everyone, anybody really think a culture involves rotely playing out irrelevant remnants that in no way addresses current realities, we only have now fuck the ways of the past, if god and muhammad don't want to text me the answer better i "check out the real situation" and act accordingly, sadaqaallahalazeem.

    • "I recall that he has also confessed to being a murderer of Palestinian civilians"

      Hamas were not to blame?

      "He should turn himself in and stand trial for his crimes"

      go Hapless Be'er Sheva, only your malice exceeds your ineptness

  • Historical evidence does not support Zionist claims re the Western Wall
    • "It’s probably best for persons who, like like ourselves, are posting polemical arguments on a political site to be circumspect about offering advice on attachment"
      you couldn't be more wrong, if you are going to quote the Buddhas or Bodhisattvas remember they allow no excuse for attachment , with the Tibetan so you can confirm.

      i teach this practise, "Circumspect" this is Vajrayana it's blatant "circumspect"? let me tell you directly if you find attachment, this is not therapy, cut it with Manjushris' flaming wisdom sword,

      If you are attached to this life, you are not a true spiritual practitioner.
      If you are attached to samsara, you do not have renunciation.
      If you are attached to your own self-interest, you have no bodhichitta.
      If there is grasping, you do not have the View.”
      ༈ ཚེ་འདི་ལ་ཞེན་ན་ཆོས་པ་མིན།

    • "Eventually it starts performing miracles."

      i think you are embellishing it a bit, this is one of Sogyal Rinpoches', he of the illustrious Lakar family, favourite little homilies, the tooth develops those little (miraculous) pearls indicating an authentic relic,

      the point of the story is the spiritually efficacy of devotion not theft

      The Israeli state has plundered vast property from the many awqaf in Palestine

      devotion to theft and oppression is unlikely to produce much spiritually useful energy quite the contrary oh but i see you made Palestinians disappear, like an old dog skeleton clever boy,

      "I still sympathize with the many Jews who feel a strong attachment to it."

      perhaps box it and wrap it and put it under their tree, it is Christmas and they have been good,

      also when quoting a Rinpoche probably best not to express sympathy with "attachment", you may have to reread "The Tibetan Book of living and Dying" where you can enjoy this and many other picaresques little tales

  • Challenging an ideology means rupturing with community and family
    • "I think that Jewish values are in fact responsible for Israel and not the opposite."

      while I am not sure what this means "values" is vague, might i be permitted a little dissent,

      " don’t think Judaism is a nice religion or a religion that fundamentally critiques or opposes settler-colonialism"

      "nice religion': not being erudite like yourself permit to speak my "values" simply and directly, it is the purpose of all religion to bust and utterly destroy the ego, that precious sense of self cherishing seperateness which makes life misery, and thus no religion cool as they all are is nice, i rely on my own reading it being the only one that i get.

      "that fundamentally critiques or opposes settler-colonialism" "

      well thats a huge assumption that relies on a spiritually illiterate, simplistic and materialistic reading of Judaism, it may be that many Jews now talk in this way so what, that does not delimit it's scope, while i labour within the vortex of my own limbic nebula and am even a tribal man however life (and Judaism inter alia) has taught me enough that i am unerring in my actions not having an ego to torment me as gentle as it is possible to be with out utterly disappearing, as the Jews recommend. It is the combination of Judaism and modern materialism that leads to

      "One of the foundational myths in the Torah is about the conquest of Canaan under Joshua, a brutal settler-colonialism story from beginning to end"

      I read it i don't see any of that, thats just the story, Animal Farm is not about animals or farming, but then i know how to read scripture and if i want to be bad i don't need gods or anyone's support, religiously speaking you have a duty to be yourself and take the consequences.

      "It’s never been questioned or critiqued as such to the best of my knowledge"

      I don't see Jews around me stealing any more than anyone else, I know an Israeli girl who married an Irish farmer out by Ardgroom who had to sign a prenup that removed all his land from his estate in the event that he pre-deceases her, she has conquered no land in the adjacent townlands.

      You know the very way you talk about a good or bad culture, religion etc the way you seem to be implying, in your other writings here, that those of us who share this array with you are just less evolved versions of yourself, that are but encultured dupes with an attenuated breadth of awareness this is the single most widespread and destructive aspect of modern progressive western ideology currently burning my world on the basis of humanitarianism and things good

      Zionism is not Judaism but seems to be eating it you wait till the sicarii play the ikwan, my view is people don't know how to read scripture and so what, well i am no materialist and crap you can grab in the donya is less than worthless anyway despite the Walmart propaganda, I start from there

      and as a result i have very positive feelings for Judaism nice or otherwise, i think someone should try it but you have to carry the self as it is to this encounter, no mean task for polite idealistic westerners, embrace inhibition, Solomon sings about it in Judaism.

      i have something that might help ( i am a ghetto boy and so have vast amplification but you may not get all the goodness out of this i play it till my 8ft thick walls shake in conformity to Banu Isra'il's mores)

      i am serious All My Life meet Judaism, in essence, you have instincts? then hear, what else is there, as has been said you have eyes but won't look you have ears then hear.

      Solomon still sings through Sheba's sons,

  • Starving Yemeni children, bloated US weaponsmakers
    • "The Yemen crisis should also serve as a prime moment for the U.S. government to reconsider its alliance with the Saudi regime"

      yeah sure no argument with that i might add:

      "Arab guerrillas who ambushed and killed two British soldiers were reported to be in the village of Danaba, a border hamlet of mud and stone huts. Danaba was warned by leaflet that it would be bombed. Promised the R.A.F. officer commanding the operation: "The fearsome sight will frighten the Arabs . . . a terrific explosion will echo up the hills. The tribesmen will be somewhere watching the show."

      On Feb. 11 four Shackleton bombers dropped 93 500-lb. bombs on Danaba, and Venom fighter pilots followed up, pouring 72 rockets into the village; for best effect the operation was spaced over six hours.

      An earlier action was mentioned in the Daily Telegraph:

      Nearly two hours before today's bombing R.A.F. aircraft dropped leaflets on the village of Ruqaba, which is within Aden territory, warning the inhabitants to leave...Before the village was destroyed an R.A.F. reconnaissance aircraft flew over the area to observe the exodus before the bombing began."

      time to cut the UK loose too

      i mean Mad Mitch, this didn't start a few months ago, Arab nationalism was defeated in Yemen in '67, lets hope the Saudis go the same way

  • 'We betrayed the legacy of the Holocaust': Professor Yair Auron pushes Israel to confront complicity with Bosnian genocide
    • “I’m first a human being. But I’m a Jew. As part of a victim group, we have even more of a responsibility to try to avoid present and future killings. But we are doing the opposite,”

      and it's ongoing in South Sudan, where Israel is joined by the US, Qatar and Saudi in betraying themselves and the rest of us.

      And as regards atrocity i wonder might Americans consider getting their government to ratify the ICC and cancel the US' 38 bi-lateral agreements to avoid its regimen and until then to be silent about their opponents war crimes as it is the US/EU which has bankrupted the ICC morally that is...

      "Africa, Russia, United States Imperialism and the Bankruptcy of the International Criminal Court


      Imperialists War Crimes Should be Investigated and Prosecuted

      Just over the last decade-and-a-half, the U.S., Britain, France and other imperialist states have committed horrendous war crimes in Afghanistan, Iraq, Haiti, Libya, Syria, Yemen, Sudan and other geo-political regions. These crimes are related to the intervention and occupations of nation-states based on false pretenses designed to eliminate independent governments and the seizure of their resources.

      As a direct result of these massive bombings, invasions, occupations and partitions, tens of millions of people have been displaced, impoverished and disenfranchised. Millions have died in combined military actions against Afghanistan, Iraq, Haiti, Libya, Syria and other countries.

      The plight of the Palestinian people, subjected to nearly 70 years of Israeli occupation, has worsened while the imperialist governments have increased their funding, arming and diplomatic support for Tel Aviv. Gaza, popularly referred to as the largest open-air prison in the world, remains under de facto Israeli occupation along with other areas of Palestine and the Golan Heights in Syria.

      At some point these crimes must be legally addressed along with the development of the Atlantic Slave Trade, colonialism, neo-colonialism and the denial of full participation in the UN and other international bodies by the imperialist governments. The abolition of the effectiveness of the ICC should pave the way for a broader discussion on the creation of a genuine world body to pursue war crimes and the violations of the fundamental human rights of the majority of the world’s population."

  • Jared Kushner's family foundations gave $325,000 to Israeli army support group
    • "i wonder why people use them."

      i am so stupid i thought i was missing something now i get it, nothing happens, he is a very very "Bold" boy.

  • Israel advocates worry Trump's pick for State has anti-Israel bias
    • hey Harry the al binaa editor gives an Arab (Lebanese) view on Trump, English subs.

      he was accused of celebrating Trump's victory

      "Trump's election represents the victory of the resistance in Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, Palestine and Yemen as well as the sumud of Iran and Russia."

  • Jewish brawl on CNN signals breakup of the pro-Israel monolith in the Trump era
    • "And I generalise to all ideologically based charges"

      Roha resurgent.

      It starts with generalisation but it leads to essentialisation and the inevitable "offence".

      America post racial to ante bellum in a heart beat, what portfolios will the Kardashians be getting in the Trumphouse,

      America "you're fired"

  • 'Love thy neighbor as thyself' -- Really?
    • "But they are not good exemplars of morality."

      no worries it all gets cleaned up in the Quran, why even Adam is a Prophet and Eve is blameless,

      David a Prophet who worshiped in a congregation including the mountains and birds and iron was made pliable for him so he could weave coats of mail.

      its in the sura that follows the stars and bars sura (alahzab) Saba (Sheba)

      And We softened all harshness in him, inspiring "Do good deeds sumptuously, don't stint and contemplate the source of their constant up welling and I see all that you do

      as to Solomon

      We made a fountain of molten copper to flow at his request made the spirits subservient to him

      however there is the lovely phrase starting Dawuda shukranw-wa grateful for bounty rather than arrogant about your, no doubt, amazing qualities, its the spiritual way,

      in essence the sura says don't labour under shameful servitude to egotistical monomania, like Sheba's crew did till she bucked up on God and his mate Sulayman and his ifrits, bloody Yemenis.

    • "Who?" are you not the Jewish American pandit?

      "made a Jew joke" ah Jewjokitsu is lethal.

      "at his expense"

      everybody bawling

  • I hereby chuck my right to Jewish national self-determination
    • "And that’s no bud libel, either."

      obscure reeference?

    • " “Does a cow have Buddha nature?” and attained Enlightenment"

      As you well know the question was "when will the grass become enlightened" its all Japanese and I refer you to the short shrift the questioner famously received.

      "Does a cow"

      the main Mahayana text, elementary text, on tathagatagarba, sugatagarhba, Buddha Nature is the Uttara Tantra (Shastra): (i accurately reproduce the punctuation in my English texts those are Maitreya's commas, it is a primitive translation)

      It is uncreated because its nature
      is without beginning, middle, or end
      It is said to be spontaneity
      since it is peace, holder of the Dharmakaya

      It's realization is not due to any external cause since
      it has to be realized through ones pure apperceptive cognition
      it is knowledge since it is realization of these three
      it is great compassionate love because it shows the way

      it is ability becuase it removes
      suffering and defilement (klesa)by jnana (direct perception as "knowledge")and compassion
      through these first three there is value for oneself
      and through the latter three is value for others"

      since it is not possible to know others status the Cow could well be a Buddha, give it a beer and rub down just in case, think of the merit.

  • Arab Bedouins expelled for second time to make way for new Jewish community
    • I know not even double figures and already the complaints. Arabs ain't what they used to be, sometimes we build our houses as demolished structures to maximize the space.

      after all kharab and arab they must be related

    • "Arab is a Hebrew signifier that means “vermin” "

      oh well god seems very suspicious of them their only mention in his book is quite tart:

      "alarabu ashadu kufran wa nifakan" (9.97) alarabu means bedu, according to Razi and others, he says the leaders in unbelief and hypocrisy....we never get a break..did he say the same in Hebrew? liable to ignore his limits ( ajdaru allayalamu hududa) and stingy fi sabeelilah, shit he has a point you know we are no better than we should be.

      i aint sure about not Arab what do you mean, i am banu awf-metwali worst of the worst and we do live in Cairo now many of us in Nasr city in poor conditions and medinat almandubin (which appears on no map because the task was delegated, thats a bit forced but still i crack myself up)

    • no one is from Cairo

    • bedouin love to tease and as the lady writes below Americans should learn Arabic before visiting Egypt to appreciate the wind up and perhaps retort, even the tea maker can't suppress a laugh, looks like coffee that is bedouin tea so rich in tannin it can make you sick and we learn English for you.

      Andree Chedid the Lebanese poet wrote

      "Imagine branches

      Ceasing to be perches"

      and Adonis "my future is a desert.....

      The cities break up

      the world becomes a rising dust cloud

      Only love

      knows how to marry this place."

      I have come across Ms Gadzo before she seems quite unflappable.

      anyway your native guide taking the proverbial a la bedu

  • More than half of US aid 'to entire world' goes to Israel and it ignores our warnings on settlements -- Kerry
    • " As to those who have taken to worshiping the calf condemnation will overtake them and ignominy in the life of this world.............but as to those who repent their Sustainer's is full of forgiveness a dispenser of blessing"

      "the faculty of discernment" near the end.

  • Despite Israeli restrictions, surfers in Gaza hope to join global competition
    • ana mizaagi giddan (correct in both Arabics) others may disagree even so i would say "Ya walad" the intonation connotes either contempt or approbation, but then i have been in a comma for 30 years.

  • 'He won because of race' -- Netanyahu's upset anticipated Trump's
  • 'Tis the season, to boycott!
    • "We’ll put on the day
      And we’ll talk in present tenses”

      thats brilliant you old incense owl

    • "After all, how unrealistic is it for people to love the people who invaded them killed them and took their land?"

      may i

      "After all, how unrealistic is it for people to accept the people who are invading them killing them and taking their land?"

      may i stand behind you i shouldn't like to be passively aggressed by llap.

  • Israelis 'neutralize' 48-year-old at Qalandiya checkpoint-- 240th Palestinian to be killed in wave of unrest
  • 'We have to channel fear into organizing': Muslim-Americans prepare for Trump's 'Muslim registry'
    • those of an scholastic bent might enjoy

      “Ambiguous State of Being”: Identity
      Construction in Contemporary ArabAmerican
      (post-9/11) Poetry"

      by Radwan

      "Corbey and Leerssen
      (1991) argue that the construction of this Othering (for example, as expressed in the literary productions of the Arab-American community even before 9/11), ―can be detected at the root of much injustice and suffering‖ (xvii). Such an approach intends to highlight how American racial structures (or hierarchies), with their multiple socio-historical connotations, influence Arab-American group studies and the development of an Arab-American critical analysis.

      According to Leerssen (2007b), the image of the ―Arab‖ in the European imagination:

      was never sharply distinguished from the Islamic religion (which is centered on the Arabian holy places of Mecca and Medina, and whose holy book, the Qur‘an, is in the Arabic language). Most characteristics attributed to Arabs therefore are part of the more general discourse of European […] Orientalism.(94)
      European Orientalist discourse has made its way into American representations of Arabs, Islam and the East in general. However, in America, Orientalism has been thoroughly racialized, ―something that was central to the early Arab immigrant experience since the late-19th century, when race had cultural, political, and legal implications"

  • Zionists embrace of Trump and Bannon is no surprise
    • "Do you identify as white?" silsila you are killing me but

      "You've done enough. Have you no sense of decency, sir, at long last? Have you left no sense of decency?"

  • General under consideration by Trump for Defense has slammed Israel for impending 'apartheid'
  • I'm not worried about anti-Semitism
    • "First they came for the Muslims …"

      they'll have to go through Greenblatt first

    • well

      “There is no reason why a well thought-out story should resemble real life; life strives with all its might to resemble a well thought-out story.”

      that does it for me and TBK.

  • When Sanders changed political reality. And hasbara culture slapped him down.
  • Saving the daughters of Israel from the annihilation of intermarriage

Showing comments 1576 - 1501