Commenter Profile

Total number of comments: 3275 (since 2010-05-21 23:21:46)

I am a lawyer with several degrees in Classics (Greek and Latin).

Showing comments 300 - 201
Page:

  • Religion doesn't matter any more,
    • It would be interesting to know how much of a role ethnic solidarity played in Elena Kagan's woeful affirmative action record: only one non-white appointed to a tenure or tenure-track position at Harvard Law School during her deanship (and that an Asian woman who happened to be married to another member of the Harvard faculty).

  • To defuse one-staters, liberal Zionist must justify 'wrongs' of '48
    • Patton's Third Army occupied Thuringia and Saxony in April of 1945. I believe this included Dresden. The Americans did not evacuate these two provinces until some 100 days later, after the Potsdam Conference, in accordance with previous agreements with the Soviets.

  • Roll over Ben-Gurion-- Michael Oren says the special relationship is over
    • The Israelis could still have something better than a Bernadotte deal, a one-state solution that guarantees rights to them, if only they would start negotiating in good faith.

      They seem to have no intention of doing so.

  • 'NYT' reporter who grooved on Jewish terrorism made Chomsky out to be 'self-hating' nut
    • It certainly is possible to have a certain sympathy for Irgun, the Communists, and their sympathizers of yore. What is not possible is not to have the same sympathy for Hamas and its sympathizers, unless one is operating purely on the basis of prejudice.

  • US tax dollars at work in Egypt
  • Internet is undermining the authority & status of academics and journalists before our eyes
    • There is an excellent history of the last years of the DNVP, Hermann Beck's The Fateful Alliance: German Conservatives and Nazis in 1933: the Machtergreifung in a New Light. Unfortunately, the book is quite expensive.

    • Duesterberg's DNVP (German Nationalist) supporters no doubt felt more comfortable voting for Hitler than for either of his remaining opponents, even Hindenburg. The DNVP ended up as Hitler's coalition partners when Hitler's coalition government came to power in January 1933. The leader of the DNVP, Hugenberg, got a major ministry in that coalition government. (Only Hugenberg and a lot of other non-Nazis soon lost all power, and the DNVP itself was dissolved within months of the coalition coming to power.)

      I doubt if Duesterberg himself, the co-head of the Stahlhelm conservative veterans association, approved of the Nazis coming to power. As someone with Jewish ancestry, he was not only denied any role in the coalition government, but he was quickly forced to resign his leadership position in the Stahlhelm. Although arrested during the Night of the Long Knives (aka R&oeml;hm Purge), Duesterberg did manage to survive the Third Reich, dying in 1950.

      Another major figure in the DNVP, Ernst Oberfohren, the leader of the DNVP fraction in the Reichstag, was not so lucky. He was known to be uneasy about his party's alliance with the Nazis, and eventually became critical of party leader Hugenberg's support of this alliance. A couple of days after the Reichstag voted to approve Hitler's Enabling Act in late March 1933, Oberfohren was forced to resign his leadership position and his Reichstag seat altogether, because Göring's eavesdropping agency, the Forschungsamt, was already eavesdropping on prominent people, and so became aware that Oberfohren was criticizing Hugenberg to other members of the DNVP, which resulted in police raids on Oberfohren's offices that led to his resignation. By the beginning of June, for whatever reason, Oberfohren was found dead, in a rather suspicious case of alleged suicide.

      The DNVP is important for any allegations that Hitler ever got a majority, because in the last semi-free elections in Germany, in March 1933, the coalition only got a majority if one includes the DNVP junior partners in the coalition. The Nazis got 43.9% of the vote, the DNVP got 8.0%.

      Once the Nazi dictatorship was fully installed, further elections and referenda did not even have the semblance of being free. In the Reichstag election of Nov. 1933, the sole slate allowed, the Nazi one, got 92.2% of the vote. In the simultaneous referendum on Germany's withdrawal from the League of Nations, 93.4% voted Yes. Further referenda had even more lopsided results. Odd in a way, because by that point a clear majority of the German people undoubtedly had come to support the Nazi government.

  • Israel seizes oxygen tanks bound for Palestinian hospitals
    • Amy Teibel was the AP reporter responsible for that story.

    • New AP story on Gilad Shalit's family setting out on march to Jerusalem to pressure Israeli government to make deal that results in release of Shalit, Captured soldier's family marching to Jerusalem, continues lie that blockade of Gaza was a result of Shalit's capture:

      Israel began restricting the movement of goods into and out of Gaza after Schalit was captured, hoping to pressure Hamas to release him, and later imposed an all-out blockade after Hamas overran the territory a year later.

  • I have a friend who calls Uncle Sam Uncle Sucker
    • Jeffrey Goldberg alleges that Israelis' unwillingness to be made suckers again explains Netanyahu's policies: Netanyahu's Dilemma:

      Now, of course, the peace process, such as it is, hinges in part on an Israeli willingness to withdraw from the West Bank, including the hills of the West Bank that overlook Tel Aviv, the airport, and the entire thickly-populated central region of the country. This withdrawal will not be happening anytime soon, because there is a high degree of certainty among Israelis that a withdrawal from the West Bank hills would be followed not by peaceful reconciliation, but, again, by rockets. No Israeli wants to be a freier, a sucker, and right now the Israelis feel like suckers. Twice in ten years they've withdrawn from territory, and twice they've been hit by rockets. They are not doing this again, not until the politics of the Palestinians -- and the politics of Iran -- change dramatically.

      If they really believe this, and are not just saying that they do, they are victims of their own propaganda.

      Talk about being a sucker.

  • The failed peace process is on display in Silwan
    • Ynet News reports that the UN General Assebly will take up the Israeli attack on the Freedom Flotilla while Netanyahu is visiting the U.S. in July. UN General Assembly to discuss Gaza flotilla raid:

      The UN General Assembly is slated to discuss last month's Israeli raid on the Gaza-bound flotilla, during which nine Turkish citizens were killed. Ynet has learned that Malaysia has initiated, with the support of Arab states, a discussion that is slated to take place at the General Assembly in New York during Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's visit to Washington.

      Netanyahu is scheduled to meet with US President Barack Obama at the White House on July 6. (Yitzhak Benhorin, Washington)

    • Der Spiegel reports that Netanyahu's government rejected a German-arranged prisoner exchange that would have resulted in the release of Gilad Shalit: Israels Fehler: Streit um Niebels Gaza-Reise [Israel's Mistake: Niebel's Disputed Visit to Gaza]:

      Das deutsch-israelische Verhältnis steckt in einer Krise. Schuld ist die Arroganz der Regierung von Ministerpräsident Benjamin Netanjahu. Über seinen Sicherheitsberater ließ er Merkel ausrichten, sie dürfe bei Netanjahus Besuch in Berlin öffentlich nichts zur Siedlungspolitik sagen. Er stellte ein kritisches Telefonat öffentlich als positiven Plausch dar. Er lehnte einen Gefangenenaustausch ab, den der deutsche Bundesnachrichtendienst organisiert hatte, um den entführten israelischen Soldaten Gilad Schalit nach Hause zu bringen. Letzteres nennt der israelische Handelsminister Benjamin Ben-Elieser gegenüber dem SPIEGEL "einen Fehler".

      [My translation: Israeli-German relations are in a state of crisis. The arrogance of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government is what is responsible for this. He instructed Merkel through his security adviser not to say anything officially about the settlement policy during Netanyahu's visit to Berlin. He portrayed a critical telephone call as positive approval. He refused a prisoner exchange that had been arranged by the German Bundesnachrichtendienst intelligence agency that would have brought home the kidnapped Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit. Israeli Trade Minister Benjamin Ben-Elieser described this last to Der Spiegel as "a mistake".]

      If this is true, it makes it pretty clear that Israel is not blockading Gaza in order to get Shalit released. Rather, it is making sure he is not released so that it can continue to use his being held as an excuse to continue the blockade.

  • Israel lobby group FLAME says black Ethiopian Jews are 'backward'
    • The Ethiopians I have known here in the U.S. (and there are a lot of them in the D.C. area) have struck me as perfectly intelligent, certainly with IQ's way above 70-80.

    • Where did the Asians fit in? Did they put them in one of the other categories (Coloureds, presumably)?

    • Amharic, the official language of Ethiopia, is a Semitic language. As is Ge'ez, the classical language of Ethiopia. As is Arabic.

  • Where Kindness Is A Crime
    • Hanging Judge Jeffreys was the villain in Captain Blood. He sentenced Dr. Peter Blood to transportation and penal servitude in the West Indies for rendering medical assistance to the rebels in Monmouth's Rebellion.

      This Supreme Court would approve of what Judge Jeffreys did.

  • The brand is tanking, in the East River
    • Ynet News is reporting that the UN General Assembly will take up the issue of the attack on the Freedom Flotilla while Netanyahu is in the U.S. in early July: UN General Assembly to discuss Gaza flotilla raid:

      The UN General Assembly is slated to discuss last month's Israeli raid on the Gaza-bound flotilla, during which nine Turkish citizens were killed. Ynet has learned that Malaysia has initiated, with the support of Arab states, a discussion that is slated to take place at the General Assembly in New York during Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's visit to Washington.

      Netanyahu is scheduled to meet with US President Barack Obama at the White House on July 6. (Yitzhak Benhorin, Washington)

    • Recent Der Spiegel article blames Netanyahu for nixing the prisoner exchange: Israels Fehler: Streit um Niebels Gaza-Reise [Israel's Mistake: Niebel's Disputed Visit to Gaza]:

      Er lehnte einen Gefangenenaustausch ab, den der deutsche Bundesnachrichtendienst organisiert hatte, um den entführten israelischen Soldaten Gilad Schalit nach Hause zu bringen. Letzteres nennt der israelische Handelsminister Benjamin Ben-Elieser gegenüber dem SPIEGEL "einen Fehler".

      [My translation: He [Netanyahu] rejected a prisoner exchange arranged by the German Bundesnachrichtendienst intelligence agency that would have resulted in the kidnapped Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit going home. Israeli Trade Minister Benjamin Ben-Elieser described this last to Der Spiegel as "a mistake".]

  • Third war is urged on Obama
  • cycle of abuse
    • No harm in saying more than once something that happens to be true.

    • I remember how the classical archaeologist Elisabeth Alföldi-Rosenbaum expressed to me the opinion that there was a lot about what Israel was doing that was like what the Nazis had done. Since she had survived the Third Reich, she probably knew what she was talking about.

      She told me this while I was working at the Instituted for Advanced Study in Princeton. So it was at some time during the 1980's.

    • Funny, then, how it's the Ulster Protestants who have been demonstrative in their support of Israel, whereas Irish Catholics have supported the Palestinian cause. Ireland, Ulster and the Flotilla Inquiry:

      As Ben Smith pointed out earlier today on Politico’s Web site, Ulster Protestants like Mr. Trimble have been generally more sympathetic to Israel than their Catholic neighbors:

      The Irish Republican Army made common anticolonialist cause with the Palestinian Liberation Organization, with the P.L.O. allegedly providing arms and training for the I.R.A. as early as the 1970s. And so, logically, [Northern] Irish Protestant leaders allied themselves with the Israelis.

      Maybe the two sides in Ireland know more than you do?

    • I don't think blacks in this country object to comparisons between Jim Crow and the treatment of the Palestinians by the Israelis. I know that I, as an Irish-American, have absolutely no objection to comparisons between that treatment and how my people, the Irish, were the victims of colonial settler policies. As a matter of fact, I believe most Irish Catholics, far from having any objections to such comparisons, sympathize with the Palestinians precisely because they see parallels.

    • I am currently reading the just-released third volume of Hart's Zionism: The Real Enemy of the Jews. The first chapters deal precisely with the '67 war and the attack on the USS Liberty.

  • 'New York Review of Books' is thinking outside the box, again, on one-state
    • Absolute equality and brutal apartheid aren't necessarily the only possible one-state solutions. You could have constitutional guarantees for both nationalities in a binational state (if necessary, guaranteed by international guarantors as part of the settlement).

      For example, I continue to think of John C. Calhoun's idea of a concurrent majority. You could have a legislative house for each of the two nationalities, with approval by both houses necessary for any legislation. You could have two executives, a la the two consuls in Rome, each of whom could veto any action by the other.

      De Klerk tried to negotiate for constitutional guarantees for the whites in South Africa in the last years of white rule. He eventually had to settle just for straight equality, it is said because Mandela was enraged when he found out that de Klerk's government was secretly behind the Third Force violence in the last years of white rule. But who knows what could have been achieved if the negotiations had happened a few years earlier?

    • One of the threads of thought running through the new third volume of Alan Hart's Zionism: The Real Enemy of the Jews is how already, in the 1980's and 1990's, such settlements as the Israelis already had then in the Occupied Territories made it extremely difficult for Israeli leaders to make peace with the Palestinians, because of the threat of an Israeli civil war. By now, the threat of civil war is far worse.

      A two-state solution is by now almost certainly absolutely impossible politically for Israeli leaders.

      Maybe a de Gaulle could do it, but where is a de Gaulle?

  • Helen Thomas (and the long, anticolonial walk to freedom)
    • Shlomo Sand committed that sin in his book

      Thomas is a foot soldier in a Roman-inspired war against the Jewish people and commits a sin that is “the first cousin of Holocaust denial”: denying that Jews are a nation. Also, she seeks to deny Jews “the truth of their history” (whatever that means).

      And his book was praised in reviews by the likes of Tony Judt and Max Hastings, and won a big prize in France.

  • Did the State Dept cave to pressure in denying flotilla activist entry to U.S.?
    • Interesting blog commentary on the CSIS charge: Charlie Smith: CBC helps CSIS change the lead story from the Air India bombing to foreign espionage:

      The Canadian media are in an uproar over comments on CBC by Richard Fadden, the director of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service.

      Fadden told interviewer Peter "Bilderberger" Mansbridge that CSIS is aware of municipal and provincial politicians who have come under the influence of foreign governments.

      This will send reporters on a chase to find out which municipal politicians have accepted free trips to China.

      Mansbridge didn't ask Fadden about MPs who've accepted free trips to Israel, Taiwan, and other countries.

      Some cynics might wonder if Mansbridge himself was acting on behalf of a foreign government when he conducted a softball interview with Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu in late May.

      Lower-level CSIS and RCMP officials have raised the spectre of Chinese espionage in the past, most notably in the Project Sidewinder investigation, which was derailed by their superiors.

      What I find curious about the whole affair is the timing.

      CSIS chose to make this revelation and CBC chose to broadcast it the day before the 25th anniversary of the bombing of Air India Flight 182 off the coast of Ireland. The attack killed 329 passengers and crew.

      CSIS's shameful conduct in the period before and after the bombing was thoroughly chronicled in retired Supreme Court of Justice John Major's recently released report following a lengthy inquiry.

      The 25th anniversary of the bombing will generate a great deal of media attention, as it should.

      But somehow, CSIS has managed to change the lead story on newscasts across the country by making an unsubstantiated claim that puts a cloud over many politicians.

      As a result, CSIS will come under less scrutiny from the media over its contribution to the largest mass murder in Canadian history.

      During the 1980s, a great many security experts, politicians, and media commentators were questioning the competence of CSIS.

      Journalist and author Richard Cleroux would tell tales of how RCMP and CSIS officers would refuse to share the same elevator.

      Years later, the Globe and Mail carried a shocking report explaining how CSIS burned surveillance tapes from the Air India investigation on top of a building on West Broadway in Vancouver.

      It's clear that since those sorry days, the security service has become far more adept in one important area: media relations. The proof was on display in Fadden's interview with Mansbridge.

    • Toronto Sun: PM never warned about CSIS allegations:

      OTTAWA — The head of Canada’s spy agency said he never warned the prime minister about allegations he made on CBC that foreign spies were infiltrating municipal and provincial politics.

      In a rare interview with CBC’s The National, Richard Fadden, the director of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service, said CSIS was worried foreign states such as the Chinese were recruiting public servants early in their careers and, that in some cases, provincial politicians had developed “quite an attachment to foreign countries.”

      “All of a sudden, decisions aren't taken on the basis of the public good but on the basis of another country's preoccupations," he said.

      Fadden told Peter Mansbridge, in an interview taped Monday, that CSIS was “in the process of discussing” with the Privy Council Office, the prime minister’s department, how they were going to inform the provinces implicated.

    • Jews are only 1.1% of the population of Canada. What does this reflect, the power of the Bronfmans?

    • The Supreme Court's decision earlier this week approved classifying the PKK Kurdish rebels in Turkey as a terrorist group and of crimininalizing merely associating with them. If -- as seems likely -- Israel is now coordinating attacks with the PKK, what are the legal implications for Israel?

  • Gack!
  • Guardian piece: obsession with Israel has rational basis, but is dangerous
    • Israel threatens world peace like no other country (with the possible exception of the United States). Seems to me that's sufficient reason to focus on it.

  • Lawrence Wright: 'most ideal outcome of entire flotilla episode' would be.... release of Gilad Shalit!
    • Der Spiegel reports that Netanyahu’s government rejected a German-arranged prisoner exchange that would have resulted in the release of Gilad Shalit: Israels Fehler: Streit um Niebels Gaza-Reise [Israel's Mistake: Niebel's Disputed Visit to Gaza]:

      Das deutsch-israelische Verhältnis steckt in einer Krise. Schuld ist die Arroganz der Regierung von Ministerpräsident Benjamin Netanjahu. Über seinen Sicherheitsberater ließ er Merkel ausrichten, sie dürfe bei Netanjahus Besuch in Berlin öffentlich nichts zur Siedlungspolitik sagen. Er stellte ein kritisches Telefonat öffentlich als positiven Plausch dar. Er lehnte einen Gefangenenaustausch ab, den der deutsche Bundesnachrichtendienst organisiert hatte, um den entführten israelischen Soldaten Gilad Schalit nach Hause zu bringen. Letzteres nennt der israelische Handelsminister Benjamin Ben-Elieser gegenüber dem SPIEGEL “einen Fehler”.

      [My translation: Israeli-German relations are in a state of crisis. The arrogance of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government is what is responsible for this. He instructed Merkel through his security adviser not to say anything officially about the settlement policy during Netanyahu's visit to Berlin. He portrayed a critical telephone call as positive approval. He refused a prisoner exchange that had been arranged by the German Bundesnachrichtendienst intelligence agency that would have brought home the kidnapped Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit. Israeli Trade Minister Benjamin Ben-Elieser described this last to Der Spiegel as "a mistake".]

      If this is true, it makes it pretty clear that Israel is not blockading Gaza in order to get Shalit released. Rather, it is making sure he is not released so that it can continue to use his being held as an excuse to continue the blockade.

  • Speaking of Berman,
  • Israeli ad looks for help sabotaging upcoming flotilla
    • How can I comment on the report you cite, when I have no idea what the Americans in that convoy were doing, and I also have no idea who attacked them? I do notice in that report the allegation that the CIA was in the convoy.

      And I am reminded that the U.S. State Dept.'s largest security contractor is Blackwater, or whatever that firm is currently called:

      Two former employees of Blackwater Worldwide have accused the private security contractor of defrauding the government for years through phony billing, including charging taxpayers for alcohol-filled parties, spa trips and a prostitute.

      In court records unsealed this week, a husband and wife who worked for Blackwater said they have firsthand knowledge of the company falsifying invoices, double-billing federal agencies and improperly charging the government for personal expenses. They said they witnessed "systematic" fraud in the company's security contracts with the State Department in Iraq and Afghanistan, and with the Department of Homeland Security and the Federal Emergency Management Agency in Louisiana after Hurricane Katrina.

      Blackwater is the State Department's largest security contractor, and a State Department spokesman said Thursday that his agency and the Justice Department reviewed the allegations in 2008, when the lawsuit was filed under seal in federal court in Virginia. The spokesman, P.J. Crowley, could not determine what came of the review.

      When whatever happened in Gaza in Oct. 2003 happened, Blackwater was already providing security to our diplomats in Iraq. Looks, from the Wikipedia entry on Blackwater Security Consulting, like it was also already providing security for our diplomats in Israel:

      Blackwater Security Consulting (BSC) was formed in 2001, and based in Moyock, North Carolina. BSC is one of the private security firms employed during the Iraq War to guard officials and installations, train Iraq's new Army and Police, and provide other support for Coalition Forces.[18]

      Its primary public contract is from the U.S. State Department under the Bureau of Diplomatic Security's Worldwide Personal Protective Services (WPPS) and WPPS II umbrella contracts, along with DynCorp International and Triple Canopy, Inc. for protective services in Iraq, Afghanistan, Bosnia, and Israel.[39][40] Blackwater's responsibilities include the United States embassy in Iraq.[41]

    • The Wikileaks entry on Furkan Doğan continues this morning to have the notice we heard about yesterday that the article may be deleted:

      This article may not meet the general notability guideline. Please help to establish notability by adding reliable, secondary sources about the topic. If notability cannot be established, the article is likely to be merged, redirected, or deleted. (June 2010).

      The article also says that Doğan "had dual American and Turkish citizenship", citing to a New York Times article. Haven't we learned (from an interview with Doğan's father that was posted on Daily Kos) that Doğan only had U.S. citizenship?

  • 'Renowned philosopher' says Jews invented democracy (OK, but what about hummus?)
    • It was the Phoenicians who were the sailors, not the Hebrews.

      Of course, both peoples spoke what were essentially different dialects of the same language, and used basically the same alphabet.

      But the Phoenicians were definitely not monotheists.

    • Lévy studied at the Lycée Louis-le-Grand in Paris, and then at the École Normale Supérieure, from which he graduated with a degree in philosophy. Surely he knows better.

    • The Greeks might have something to say about this.

      Was there even a word for anything like "democracy" in Biblical Hebrew?

  • The settlers' one-state argument, or ploy
    • Let's hope future flotillas take care not to coordinate what they're doing with Hamas, since today's Supreme Court decision makes it clear that independent action not coordinated with the terrorist group in question is not prohibited by the statute.

      On the other hand, the PKK Kurdish rebels are one of the two allegedly terrorist organizations directly involved in today's case (the other being the Tamil Tigers.) I wonder what implications that will have for current Israeli (and U.S. military/intel?) coordination of activities with the PKK.

  • Liberal Zionists excommunicate anti-Zionists
    • The plutocrats in this country avoid any change inimical to their interest by controlling both parties that have any chance of being elected. The "left" party, the Democrats, are just there to provide the illusion of choice.

      Maybe J Street was set up for similar reasons?

  • Update from Oakland: Victory!
    • Meanwhile, Congress goes the other way. Pro-Israel letter unites Senate Democrats, Republicans:

      85 senators -- including both the majority and minority leaders -- signed an AIPAC-endorsed letter expressing unconditional support for both Israel's botched raid on an aid flotilla that killed nine and the ongoing siege of Gaza that compelled the activists to organize the flotilla in the first place.

      We fully support Israel’s right to self-defense. In response to thousands of rocket attacks on Israel from Hamas terrorists in Gaza, Israel took steps to prevent items which could be used to support these attacks from reaching Gaza. Israel’s naval blockade, which is legal under international law, allows Israel to keep dangerous goods from entering Gaza by sea. The intent of the measures is to protect Israel, while allowing humanitarian aid into Gaza.

      It would be interesting to know who the 15 were who did not sign.

  • Movements take years to build... to Freedom Summer
    • Westerwelle is openly gay. He may have a natural sympathy for the underdog, the way Jews used to have (and some of them still do).

    • What look like very important developments on the German front:

      Although it is difficult to see other changes in the political climate concerning the international community’s regard for the Israeli government from the vantage point of reading or watching U.S. media these past three weeks, the climate in Europe has changed markedly. Yesterday, the Israelis refused to grant permission to a German cabinet member to visit Gaza to see what needs to be done to restore sewage treatment facilities to the besieged enclave:

      German Development Aid Minister Dirk Niebel was denied entry into the Gaza Strip during his current visit to Israel, German officials said Saturday evening.

      A ministry spokesman said talks had continued to the last moment with Israeli officials over Niebel’s aim to visit the Palestinian areas.

      Niebel, who arrived in Israel earlier Saturday, had hoped to visit a sewage treatment plant being financed with German development aid.

      Speaking on the second German TV network ZDF program"heute" (today) Saturday evening, Niebel expressed his anger about being denied entry.

      "I would have wished for a clear political signal would be sent for an opening and for transparency," said Niebel, of Germany’s liberal Free Democratic Party (FDP).

      "Sometimes the Israeli government does not make it easy for its friends to explain why it behaves the way it does," he added.

      Niebel said that Israel’s latest announcement on easing the Gaza blockade was "not sufficient" and that Israel must "now deliver" on its pledge.

      Beyond that, the government in Jerusalem should be "clear about how Israel, within an international context, wants to cooperate with
      its friends in the future as well," the German minister said.

      Earlier Saturday, the daily Sueddeutsche Zeitung reported that the German parliament is to issue a cross-party demand that Israel allow humanitarian aid to reach the Gaza Strip by sea.

      As if to underline Niebel’s statements about Israeli "transparency," in another development between the Israeli and German governments, the Germans have refused to acquiesce to an Israeli demand that they not extradite Mossad operative Uri Brodsky from Poland to Germany, for Brodsky’s role in illegally acquiring German passports for use by the Mossad Dubai hit team last January. So much for the Israelis being able to keep their fingerprints off of that keystone cops episode, eh?

      The German government has said it will not intervene to stop an investigation into a suspected Mossad spy linked to the assassination of a Hamas official in Dubai, despite pressure from Israel, a German newspaper reported on Saturday.

      A German official told Der Spiegel his ministry was united in the belief that any investigation into Uri Brodsky should be "dealt with according to purely judicial considerations".

      Brodsky, who was wanted by German authorities, was arrested on June 4 at an airport in the Polish capital Warsaw, provoking strong protests from Israeli diplomats. He is suspected of helping to procure a German passport for the killers of Mahmoud al-Mabhouh, assassinated in a Dubai hotel room on January 19.

      But despite Israel’s demands, Germany will not invoke a law citing "overwhelming public interest" to halt the investigation into Brodsky’s role in the killing.

      The German government has asked Poland to extradite Brodsky for trial in Germany, something Israel had sought to prevent.

    • The report I read said "Israeli-occupied", rather than "Israeli-controlled," and I was very puzzled indeed how anyone would consider the port of Gaza Israeli-occupied. But is it even Israeli-controlled?

  • Friedman: Middle Easterners are scheming, except Israel
    • Thomas was a Marshall Scholar, and got an M.Phil. in Middle Eastern Studies from the University of Oxford. At least in his youth, he was no dummy.

    • A reading of Paul McGeough's Kill Khalid: The Failed Mossad Assassination of Khalid Mishal and the Rise of Hamas leaves one with the strong suspicion that Israel launched the failed attempt to assassinate Khalid Mishal in 1997 in order to leave a different leader that Israel preferred in control of Hamas.

    • Sounds like Friedman is one of those trying to bring about a military coup in Turkey to remove Erdogan's government.

      Pity for these schemers that Israel's joining forces with the PKK has made any such venture even less possible than it was before.

      And Friedman has the nerve to suggest that, whereas Erdogan and his government are not democratic, a coup government would be democratic.

    • So Friedman would have us believe that it was just a coincidence that, two hours before the Israelis attacked the Freedom Flotilla, the PKK attacked the Turkish naval base at Iskenderun near the Syrian border, which just happened to be the base from which any Turkish naval assistance to the flotilla would have come? What's more, he would have us believe it was so clearly just a coincidence that to believe anything else is insane?

  • Our western privilege is the legacy of historical violence
    • A lot of people were excited by the events leading to World War One in July-August 1914 as well.

    • The Lebanese aid ship for Gaza "Miriam" is due to set sail from Tripoli in Lebanon next week, with 50 Christian and Muslim Lebanese women on board with medical supplies. The Israeli media are doing their best to tie the ship in with Hizbullah, like they tried to tie the Freedom Flotilla in with Hamas.

    • Without Bose's Indian National Army, which fought with the Japanese against the British, and without the mutinies in the Indian navy and army that were precipitated by the attempt to try the veterans of the Indian National Army for treason right after the end of World War Two, I doubt if the British would have quit India quite as soon as they did.

      Nonviolence was accompanied by violence, and the stark threat of further violence if nonviolence was not allowed to win.

  • Why is this happening in a church basement?
    • I couldn't connect to the Maan article on the Lebanese relief ship "Miriam" due to leave for Gaza next week that Google says is there.

    • New report in Forward: link to forward.com">Push To Sanction Backers of Gaza Flotilla Gains Steam in U.S.: Jewish Leaders, Lawmakers Seek ‘Terrorist’ Status for Turkish Group:

      Washington — Jewish groups, working with congressional leaders, are pressing to designate one of the main organizers of the humanitarian flotilla that sought to break Israel’s blockade of Gaza as a terrorist group.

      With a boost from Senate leaders, the Jewish groups are lobbying the administration to sanction Insani Yardım Vakfı, the nonprofit sponsor of the ship Mavi Marmara. Nine Turkish passengers, including one dual-nationality American, were killed on the Gaza-bound Turkish vessel when Israeli commandos seized control of it in international waters, leading to a clash between the commandos and some of the passengers.

      Many questions about what happened on board the ship remain in dispute, and calls for an international investigation have led Israel to sponsor a panel with two international observers that will examine some aspects of the affair, though not what happened on the boat.

      But meanwhile, New York-area Congress members and the Jewish Community Relations Council of Greater New York are also urging the administration to deny visas to passengers on the Mavi Marmara who have been invited to speak in the United States about what they experienced.

      “The people who were on that flotilla should not be allowed to come to the United States and spill their propaganda and hatred and terrorist rhetoric,” said Rep. Eliot Engel, a New York Democrat. Rep. Jerrold Nadler added: “It is the responsibility of our government to ensure that terrorists, and those who support terrorist activities, not be allowed to enter the United States.”

      "Those who support terrorist activities" could be interpreted to cover a lot of people.

      Was the Attorney General's List of Subversive Organizations, from the McCarthy era, ever struck down?

  • Bill Bennett & his neocon sidekick say reelecting Obama means the end of Israel
    • Sasha Polakow-Suransky's book The Unspoken Alliance says that Israeli strategists thought in the mid-1980's that apartheid still had about 20 years to go in South Africa.

  • Howler
  • Israel eases the siege in English, leaves it in place in Hebrew
  • 'J Street' leader suggests that Israel's behavior threatens security of Jews in U.S.
  • Pinkwashing
    • This Gaza Flotilla Anthem was written by Tommy Sands in conversation with Nobel Laureate Mairead Corrigan-Maguire before the Gaza bound boat the
      Rachel Corrie left for Gaza. The words show the peaceful intent of the Mission. An mp3 of the track is available on request.

      Peace on the Shores of Gaza

      We are sailing away with hope in our soul
      We are sailing to say You are not alone
      Sailing today Salaam Shalom (Two neighbours wishing for the same Salaam and Shalom)
      For Peace on the shores of Gaza

      We bear no weaponry of war, no gun nor mortar
      We bear no hatred in our hearts for any living creature
      But when this human family pains no matter where the nation
      Can we not give some comfort then and keep communication

      Memories of bitter days gone by, pain too sad to mention (Holocaust)
      And as the wire rises higher the more good neighbours question (both neighbours)
      Who is gaining from this war in dark deliberation (Yes who on all sides?)
      And watch poor people live in fear (Israelis) or die in desperation (Palestinians)

      We come with nothing much to give but words of caring
      We come knowing when we leave it's we who are learning
      From a spirit that survives the tides of cruel devastation
      Can rise again and sow the seeds of peace and celebration (both sides)

      For further information, mp3 of ‘Shores of Gaza’ or to speak with Tommy, contact Pat Tynan

      pattynan@btinternet.com

  • The 'Mavi Marmara' and the 'Rachel Corrie' (and non-violent resistance)
    • With the rapid decline of the power of the U.S., the room is open for regional alliances that do not involve outside powers.

      The kind of attacks on infrastructure you suggest is what the ANC concentrated on in its later years. Combined with its international attacks on the legitimacy of apartheid South Africa, and Mandela's convincing white South African leaders that he did not represent an existential threat to them, that sort of attacks led to ultimate victory.

    • Subhas Chandra Bose, one of the leaders of the Congress Party, and the founder of the Indian National Army that fought on the Japanese side against Britain in World War Two, showed where India might go if the British did not quit India. Because Indian popular opinion was so sympathetic to the captured soldiers of the Indian Army, and because there were mutinies of the ratings in the Royal Indian Navy and of the other ranks in the British Indian Army, Britain was forced, after the war, to abandon the idea of executing or deporting those captured soldiers. They were released.

      If Britian had not quit India, there was every prospect of violence.

  • Chomsky in Lebanon
    • I do not consider a "footnote" that resulted in millions of deaths (and may yet result in many millions more) to be a mere "tiny footnote".

    • A statement yesterday by the Israeli government indicates it regards Lebanon as an "enemy state."

    • If the same forces that killed JFK are still in power in the U.S. and are the forces that continue to drive us into wars, then the way he died should matter to you.

      I have two recent works to recommend on the JFK assassination that in my opinion prove he was killed by the U.S. national security state: James Douglass's JFK and the Unspeakable: Why He Died and Why It Matters, and Douglas Horne's five-volume Inside the Assassination Records Review Board: The U.S. Government's Final Attempt to Reconcile the Conflicting Medical Evidence in the Assassination of JFK. However, the fact that the U.S. national security state was primarily responsible for the assassination does not exclude the possibility of there having been accomplices.

    • Or he may be afraid to allow thoughts to wander towards what he suspects the truth is about that assassination.

    • A month before the attack on the flotilla (which just happened to occur at about the same time as the PKK Kurdish rebel attack on the Turkish naval base at Iskenderun,) there were reports in the press that the Turks had moved into the Iskenderun area antiaircraft batteries that were intended to prevent Israeli air attacks on Syria and Iran.

      I suspect that those batteries will present a great obstacle to future Israeli aggression to the north. What the Israelis have managed to accomplish in recent military escapades, they were able to do because of air supremacy.

  • Brits say 13 'Bloody Sunday' victims were innocent, 28 years later (flotilla echo)
    • Air travel has gotten to be such a torment, they really ought to bring back the ocean liners.

  • Lobby stomped journalist over Armenian genocide
    • The third volume of Richard Evans's history of the Third Reich, The Third Reich at War engages in some very convoluted and implausible reasoning to reach the conclusion that what the Third Reich did to the Gypsies was somehow not true genocide. (If memory serves, his reasoning is that, because the Nazis killed even half-Gypsies, whereas they allowed half-Jews to live, that somehow meant that what they did to the Gypsies was not genocide. It didn't make any sense to me at all.)

    • Lemkin's definition as codified in the convention is very broad indeed. When will Israel's treatment of the Palestinians cross over into the territory covered by that definition of "genocide"? Or has it done so already?

      And once it does become genocide, or if it is already genocide, what does that mean other states are obliged under that convention to do with respect to Israel?

  • Transatlantic Jewish coalition set to break the siege of Gaza
    • One of the flotilla's ships (the Gazze) was carrying the Turkish flag, one was carrying the U.S. flag, two were carrying the Greek flag.

      Plenty of NATO involvement.

  • 'Global citizens must respond where governments have failed'
    • It was a unanimous decision by the court. (Opinion of the Court written by retiring Justice Stevens.)

  • After killing Ziad al-Jilani, Israel now seeks to question his American widow (where is Congress?)
    • It's already been 43 years since the attack on the USS Liberty.

    • Does the U.S. State Department consider East Jerusalem part of the West Bank? If it does not, that security advisory would not apply to it.

  • One possible framework for a single state in Israel/Palestine
  • Blockade of 'Mavi Marmara' continues, stateside
    • That Ha'aretz article seems to indicate Israel now considers Lebanon an "enemy state":

      Attempts by the Iranians and Lebanese to break Israel's blockade of Gaza would be seen not just as a provocation and a breach of law, but as a "hostile" act because the ships and their cargo are from enemy states, said Foreign Ministry spokesman Yigal Palmor.

      "They are under a different status," he said, referring to the earlier aid flotilla forcefully intercepted on May 31, which had carried aid and activists mainly from European states including Turkey, Greece and Ireland.

      "They are coming from an enemy state and it means that of course the treatment is different, because legally they are different," Palmor said of the Iranian and Lebanese ships.

    • Also W.E.B. DuBois, until the whole practice of denying passports to political dissidents was struck down by the Warren Court in Kent v. Dulles, 357 U.S. 116 (1958) ("Kent" being Rockwell Kent.)

    • Why is Israel so supremely important to the corporatists? Are they able to do things there and through that country that otherwise they cannot do?

    • Turns out Furkan Dogan was only 18 years old (Turkish states ages as one greater than we do: Dogan was in his 19th year, hence 19.)

    • Speaking of the 1950's, the list of terrorist organizations increasingly looks like the Attorney General's list of subversive organizations back in the McCarthyite time. Totally political.

  • When will 'NYT' get around to printing Emily Henochowicz's name?
  • Israeli investigation on flotilla will be biased (and Netanyahu leaked the results already)
    • "Transparency" has become a favorite word of the Obama administration, and of Hillary Clinton in particular. Where did that word come from? I don't recall hearing it at all when I was growing up.

  • Who knew that the Israeli blockade is 'economic warfare'?
    • I was able to get an Irish passport because I could show the Irish embassy the baptismal certificate of one of my parents. Actually, to get an Irish passport, it's enough to document that one of your parents or gransparents was born on Ireland (for this purpose, including Northern Ireland). Actually, both my parents and all four of my grandparents were born on the island of Ireland (although, at the time they were born, it was part of the territory of the then-existing United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland,) but one parent was enough.

    • At an interdepartmental meeting during the Bush I administration, Attorney General Barr said at one point, "F*** international law!", as I was told by someone who was at the meeting.

      So the attitude has been there for quite some time. But at that time they had not yet gone public with it.

    • The Germans justified their barbaric behavior in their war on the Eastern Front against Soviet Russia by saying it was a new kind of war, a Weltanschauungskrieg.

    • The EU's offer, which Israel has already rejected, to inspect shipments in Cyprus before letting them through ought to be a sufficent answer to any problems about weapons.

    • Sounds like Arnaiz-Villena has been exonerated. From his Wikipedia entry:

      Jews and Palestinians

      Arnaiz-Villena's research was internationally reported following the publication of a paper on the genetic history of Jews and Palestinians, in the journal Human Immunology. This became controversial because of its assertions about the origins of the Palestine/Israeli conflict. Following strong criticism, it was withdrawn from the journal and deleted from the scientific archive. Also, academics who had already received a copy of the journal were urged to "physically remove" the pages with the article, in a move that had no precedent in research publishing.[4] The comments about Arab-Israeli conflicts were described as "extreme political writing", which included claims that Palestinians lived in "concentration camps". Arnaiz-Villena was removed from the journal's editorial board. The decision was met with opposition from several academics. Andrew Goffey, a Senior Lecturer at Middlesex University, England, observing that "it was conceded that the article had not been removed on the basis of its scientific evidence," failed to find anything offensive in the paper. Several scientists wrote to the publishers to support Arnaiz-Villena and to protest about their heavy-handedness. One of them said: "If Arnaiz-Villena had found evidence that Jewish people were genetically very special, instead of ordinary, you can be sure no one would have objected to the phrases he used in his article. This is a very sad business."[5]

      ...

      Suspension, accusations and counter-accusations

      In 2002, Arnaiz-Villena was suspended without pay from the Hospital Doce de Octubre, after being charged with embezzlement of funds. He was accused of "purchase of products not used in his department's health care activities; purchase of hospital products used in health care activities but in quantities much greater than needed; falsification of statistical data apparently to justify purchases; humiliating treatment of department staff; delay in health care activities; and transfer of department products to the university."[38] Though suspended from the hospital he continued his work at the University. One year later he was reinstated to the hospital because "his basic and Constitutional Human Rights had been broken" according to a three body Court.[39] All accusations were declared invalid (2003). On November 2003 the Court of the Contentious-Administrative n. 8 of Madrid condemned him to 33 months of suspension from work without pay, for one very serious offence and three serious [40] Another three-body Court judgment again declared invalid all the accusations.[41] Arnaiz-Villena was in practice never punished because he belongs only to University staff (Full Professor) and not to the Hospital one. The Public Prosecutor in an unusual thirteen type-written sheets concluded the accusations were not proved and that some of Arnaiz-Villena collaborators were pressured to declare against him. Lastly, The Royal College of Physicians of Madrid carried out an extensive investigation at Arnaiz-Villena's request and concluded that none of the accusations were soundly based.[42]

      Let us remember that in 2002 Arnaz's right-wing government was in power in Spain.

    • The Newsweek article says the DNA does not support the Khazar descent theory, but that's only a peripheral part of Sand's case. The basis of his case is that current Jews have a lot of blood in them that is not from the ancient Hebrews, and the study discussed in the article says the DNA does support Sand's view that an awful lot of non-Jewish people in the Greco-Roman world were converted to Judaism, so that European Jews significantly diverge in DNA from Middle Eastern Jews.

      There's also this:

      The Druze, Bedouins, and Palestinians were closest to the Iranian, Iraqi, and Syrian Jews.

      So the DNA of Palestinians is apparently very much like that of Middle Eastern Jews.

  • Fair and balanced, the inquiry commission is
    • Ulster Unionists have a natural affinity for Zionist colonialism, as the National Party supporters of apartheid in South Africa did, as documented in the recent book The Unspoken Alliance.

  • A conversation about the Warsaw Ghetto
    • The PA did initially oppose the UN taking up the Goldstone Report (allegedly, according to some reports, because the Israelis coerced him by threatening to reveal how he had supported Operation Cast Lead). The PA was quickly forced by Palestinian popular opinion to reverse its position on the Goldstone Report.

    • The National in Dubai is reporting that Ha'aretz is reporting that unnamed European officials have told the paper that they were briefed by White House officials that Abbas, on his recent visit to Washington, asked Obama to keep the blockade of Gaza in place, but the PA denounces the report as Israeli propaganda: Did Abbas ask for siege of Gaza to be kept in place?:

      RAMALLAH // As Israel promises to ease its blockade on Gaza, intra-Palestinian rivalry again came to the fore on Sunday with a report in an Israeli daily that the Fatah leader, Mahmoud Abbas, had asked the US to ensure that there be no end to the maritime blockade on Gaza lest such a move boost Hamas, Fatah’s Islamist rivals.

      Mr Abbas is supposed to have made the comments during his meeting with Barack Obama, the US president, last week.

      The Haaretz newspaper report, however, only cited unnamed European officials who had reportedly been briefed by White House officials, and Palestinian officials around Mr Abbas were quick to label the article part of an Israeli “disinformation” campaign.

      How's that for convoluted reporting? Circles within circles.

      Meanwhile, here's what I find in Ha'aretz: Hamas rejects Abbas insistence on supervising Gaza aid: Abbas calls PA 'legitimate government' of Gaza, while Hamas says: Abbas doesn't exist here.:

      President Mahmoud Abbas has said any new system for supplying the Gaza Strip must involve his West Bank-based government - a position rejected by the Hamas Islamists who govern the territory.

      Not quite the same thing as asking Washington to keep the blockade in place. But close.

    • Ah, but to what extent is it Hamas that is firing those rockets?

    • "In harm's way" is no neologism, unless you consider John Paul Jones recent:

      "I wish to have no connection with any ship that does not sail fast, for I intend to go in harm's way."

      And this retired lieutenant commander can testify that that saying is a favorite one in the U.S. Navy.

  • Let's get the facts straight on Hamas
  • The moral authority of non-violence
    • It's an oversimplification to say that, all through the history of Nazi Germany, the law was simply what Adolf Hitler said. In late 1933, most of the defendants in the Reichstag Fire trial were acquitted by the Reichsgericht. Reichstag Fire Trial. As a matter of fact, it was Hitler's fury at this result that led to his establishing the Volksgerichtshof, the People's Court that condemned the White Rose protesters.

      But, even though gradually the German legal system was more and more Nazified over time, Hitler continued to be dissatisfied by German courts' decisions. The last time the Reichstag met, on April 26, 1942, it was to pass a law that gave Hitler total power to overrule court decisions.

  • Christian Zionists were the sine qua non of the creation of Israel
    • I've read allegations that Lyndon Johnson was raised as a Christian Zionist. I'd have to be convinced, however, that there was anything he wasn't a total cynic about.

Showing comments 300 - 201
Page:

Comments are closed.