Commenter Profile

Total number of comments: 1976 (since 2010-06-24 23:41:16)

Showing comments 1976 - 1901

  • Resolution 242 does not mean what you may think it means
    • @ talknic

      funny on the 1948 illegal borders your no different than the most murderous zionist terrorist. the 48 borders have no legal validity despite your sense of entitlement to them. Israel was not a secession from palestine as you oh so dubiously want it to be. it was a violent foreign conquest. just because the US and countless other states violated international law to recognize Israel doesn't magically make Israel's terrorist war of conquest in 48 legal. in fact the United States recognizition is unconsititional. the montevideo convention preculdes the regonition of gains through force and coercion. all of Israel was gained that way. Despite your pretense to belief in the law you have the same sense of zionist entitlement belief in conquest makes right. either go all the way in defending the law or just quit pretending you care about it at all. this half way stuff just makes you look like an intellectual coward.

  • Anti-Semitism is considered a serious moral failing. But no one calls out anti-Palestinian bigotry
    • The biggest problem with the anti semitism claims is if you are accused of it you are automatically deemed guilty no defense is allowed thats it doesn't matter how baseless it is your forever tainted. your anti palestinian no body really cares.

  • Saying Israel has no right to exist as a Jewish state is not anti-Semitic
    • are you trying to claim jews can only exist as war criminals? how antisemitic of you

    • well yeah most people tend to try and fight off invading armies. funny how that one works out.

  • Advice to British leftwingers on kicking racism out of their anti-Israel rhetoric
    • of course you like it. in the end he is another zionist jew trying to suppress criticism of Israel. only 3 is a valid concern. for the second colionalist endevors and self determination are mutual exclusive. as for the first whine about all you want there are rather strong signifigant parrals between certain nazi actions and Israeli policies. while there is no comparison between treatment of jews by nazis and Israeli's treatments of the palestinians. how ever some rather strong comparisons between nazi policies in poland in regards to the polish and Israeli treatment of palestinians do exist. and saying they shouldn't be mention is trying to suppress criticism. should these claims be handled with the upmost care yes but to wholesale they shouldn't be made is wrong

  • Sy Hersh's 'forbidden statement': Sanders's liberation from NY Jewish money could change US foreign policy
    • many because people like you force feed them lies. if one side is always portrayed as innocent and one as always evil who do think people are going to side with? you keep repeating that like there has been some sort of nuetral info stream and they just choose to support israel. there has been a distorted information given to ensure that. you ignore that because your dishonest.

  • Woman and child killed in Iraq as US adopts Israeli 'knocker' bombs and leaflet drops
    • Call me stupid or nuts but i'd rather have my house not get blowed up. i know crazy thought

    • Thats a load of crap. you want to minimize civilian casualaties its real easy. DON"T SHOOT AT THEM

    • its illegal when israel does it. its illegal when the us does it. no matter how you want to slice it you can't fire ordinace at civilians legally

  • BDS has arrived
    • Am i the only person who caught the fact that the guy is fundementaly claiming that being jewish and being for human rights are mutual exclusive?

  • The Jewish-Israeli navel-gazers
    • perhaps if you want to be taken seriously you shouldn't use made up names for places. its the west bank. judea and samaria are names given to it by terrorists

  • Academics both 'pleased and concerned' with Salaita settlement with University of Illinois
    • says the person belonging to a coddled minority that cries like babies if anyone says anything they don't like. says the person who demands special privileges based on his faith. your a real piece of work. thankfully in the next you will get that which you have earned.

  • Why do Palestinians burn Jewish holy sites?: The fraught history of Joseph’s Tomb
    • there is no such thing as a jewish nationality. it was a fraudlent creation in the late 1800's as a means to aquire land. to be jewish is to be a part of the religion. even israel which pushes the lie of a jewish nation relies on religion to determine who is a jew.

  • Israel gets to use violence. Palestinians don't. That's the rule
  • Israeli society is crumbling under the weight of occupation
  • East Jerusalem is closed for Palestinians, but settlers march unimpeded
  • Which nation spends more on its military: Iran or Israel?
    • @daBakr
      seriously? i mean i'm used to right wingers being delusional. you flat out claimed Iranian and hizbullah support was to blame in the refugees. perhaps instead of accusing me of not reading you could not lie about what you said. i won't hold my breath. so you accuse me of not reading and than dishonestly try and claim my point for your self. no you don't get to pretend you didn't claim Iran and hizbullah were supporting the side responsbile for the refugees ISIS and Assad.

    • Obama want to act. it was your fellow aholes the republicans in congress that refused to give him the authroization to act. please don't lie

    • @dabakr

      the palestinians have come to the table with reasonable compromises. its your precious war criminals that are incapable of compromise reasonable or other wise. so long Israel demands humilation and the giving up basic human rights the conflict will continue

    • um Iran and Hezzbollah are fighting against ISIS. nice job there way to get your facts straight

  • How Israel legitimizes vigilante terror
    • bendict the moment the picked up weapons and opened fire they lost their protections and became combatants. and not all of that 78 were docters or nurses.

      benedict its standard practice to leave docs unarmed.

    • so were supposed to believe you a pathological liar and terror supporter rather than people whose honesty has never been called into question?

  • Long Island synagogue marks High Holidays with thanks to Israeli soldiers in Gaza war
  • Dreamspace in Jerusalem
    • god how paternalistic. so she is immature because she rejects militerism and hate in favor of well more mature ideas. i'd say you and yours are the ones with immature ideas.

  • Israeli gov't used my image for propaganda purposes without my consent
  • 'NYT' misrepresents Iran's prediction about 'Zionist regime' to mean 'Israel'
    • that tired old lie? no jordan is not the palestinian state. only serverely uneducated people make that claim. well those and supporters of western imperialism. jordan is the state for jordinians. palestine is the state for palestinians which zionists jews stole through warfare and terrorism.

  • Scenes from a Sanders presidency
    • thank you for proving my point. you and the other people pushing him as pure evil on this are no different the zionists. you think this is the only thing that matters. guess what i'm an american i think israel shouldn't exist at all and i'm going to vote for bernie sanders. i loath his stance on Israel but i'm sorry but to through away the only candidate who actual looks like he wants to address the real problems america has domestically i'll bite the bullet. because i'm not willing to starve to death for the low chance someone else might have of stopping genocidal aholes.

    • i find this problematic. this is just the reverse of the coin of zionists jews rants against the europe of the 30's and 40's. this single issueism. yes there are reasons to be displeased with bernie sanders on foriegn policy but the notion that american should reject him for the crimes he wishes to commit against the palestinians while ignoring the good he could do for the american people. this strikes me as similiar to the zionist jews who feel european peoples should have commited national suicide to save the jews.

  • The Iran deal: a triumph of irrationality
    • we need more men like him he was legend. he was also a decent person. i'm glad to say i met him.

  • How long will I have to convince liberals that Palestinians matter?
    • the left has never really been anti cop. I'm sorry but expecting the cops to do there jobs properly and not abuse people is not anti cop. its anti a-hole abuser. if you'll not back during the 60's the cops abused a crap ton of people than too

  • Why the Charleston massacre isn't terrorism, and Palestinian resistance always will be
    • some times violence is the answer. it should be avoided whenever possible and always be the last resort. but when an oppressor doesn't listen and kills those who peacefully speak out i would say it is time for the sword to leave its sheath. being peaceful is a laudable thing but pacifism for the sake of pacifism is just stupid.

  • BDS will keep Israeli tanks from moving and F15 from flying, Oren says
    • no being responsible or acountable for anything is against zionism. its always somebody elses fault jews are perfect superman who should rule over everyone.

    • its easy to win with a rigged deck. israel would lose any fair fight mainly because it doesn't know how to win with out in overall advantage. mainly because its always had that advantage. shoddly trained and heavily reliant on superier tech. look at the flight logs of Israel pilots. next to nothing compared to actual top notch countries. its all about patting them selves on the back for killing people with no effective means of fighting back.

  • Munayyer and Beinart's historic debate on the solution to the conflict
    • i really wish you wouldn't use the term self determination to refer to israel. its creation and existence have nothing to do with the concept of a right to self determination which is the right of the people of a territory to decide there own political status. Israel was created through naked conquest by people from outside the territory.. there is not a single solitary inch that was gained through naked conquest. to claim or imply other wise is misrepresenting what happened and only rewards criminals for there crimes.

      again Israel creation is literally the exact opposite of self determination.

  • Dutch government issues travel warning about 'violent Jewish colonists'
  • 'This land is ours. All of it is ours': Meet the Netanyahu cabinet members focused on fighting BDS & annexing the West Bank
    • neggy i don't need to zionist attacks on arabs (and the british i might add) were common before the war of zionist conquest started. that benny morris said arabs started is meaningless. the guy was a zionist. he was going to make the jewish terrorists look as good as possible. and haganah started attacking arab communities in 46. and i say the zionists started because had they be willing to live in peace instead of demanding territory they had no right to and planning on waging a war to do it the conflict would never happen. your a typical zionist deviod of any sense of responsibility or accountability for your sides actions.

    • @neggy no it was the zionists who started the war.

      your just defending thugs who use war to steal.

      the palestinians should get all of their country back and Israel should go bye bye like the terrorist state it is.

  • Israel will imprison soldier, 19, for publicly criticizing the occupation
  • International calls rise for FIFA to suspend Israel
  • An open letter to Pamela Geller
    • no thats what she is claiming to defend her bigotry. she however makes it a point to attack muslims for being muslims. she was behind much of the lies and hate behind the attacks against park 51. she is a borderline sociopath who feeds on hate.

  • Two videos to challenge my liberal Zionist friends
    • @dabakr

      there is no bias its a simple fact i understand why it scares you. of course it not your "truth" but at the end of the day what you support is criminal that you lack the decency to stand up to it is not my problem. and truth isn't a funny concept. the truth is simply the facts something zionist have yet to come to terms with.

      I never said the difference was large but there is a difference and it does make a difference in how we approach them. you need the palestinians to mindless creatures of hate so you can defend your beliefs but the reality is there the innocent victims of your hate.

    • there is a difference though which you fail to understand. the palestinians hate is a product of what others did to him. the Israelis is a product of what he is done to others. he learned to hate so he could harm innocents.

    • a single ember can burn an entire forest. and whitewashing somethat happened as oppossed to a more factual telling is suppressing it.

  • Night of horror at Ben Gurion airport for two French music students
    • its naive to expect to be treated with basic human decency? maybe in in israel but in the civilized world it is not.

  • 'Celebration of ethnic cleansing is intolerable': Baltimore JVP crashes 'Israeli Independence Day' party
    • well yeah thats usualy what happens when invade a country they defend themselves. I'm sorry but Israel's victims are not responsible for Israel's crimes Israel and its supporters are.

  • Accusations of anti-Semitism roil Stanford campus as student coalition denies discrimination charges
    • but as you so conviently ignore it is appropriate to ask questions based on peoples membership in groups that oppose what the group is seeking. if jewish orgs wouldn't try and supress ideas they didn't like these questions would be needed. the fact remains given jews student groups behavior the ability to unbiased on anything regarding israel is suspect

  • Terrorism and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict: An argument
    • palestine 48 tibet 51. also you could argue the palestinians were under occupation under british rule considering how the UK suppressed the palestinians and favored zionist interests against the palestinians.

  • Understanding the Jewish National Home
    • @hophmi 2 things your inflating your numbers again and even if we accept them which i don't given your track record that still a far cry short of the hundreds of thousands you claimed. so considering your rampant dishonesty don't tell others top stop it. you got caught lying is it really that important to you to keep digging a deeper hole.

    • still sticking to your misrepresentation of history i see. anything to protect zionist crimes and strip palestinians of their humanity. again you claimed it happened in association with the holocaust it didn't plain and simple hop you lied about history yet again

    • oh quit being cranky that you called out on your disorting of history. and again so the palestinians should have been willing to accept jewish dominion over them simply because of bad things happening to jews your obtuse and showing the naked bigotry of zionism. the palestinians aren't required to accept people into their country who are hostile to them. holocaust or no.

    • um your chronology is off the knowledge of the nazi deathcamps didn't happen until late in 41 and the genoicide your refering to as the holocaust didn't start until than either. so your complaining about them not being able to see the future.

    • really if they wanted to live in peace why did they start so many wars? its the zionists who were never willing to live in peace. and jews to allied with the nazis. both for the exact same reason they were at war with the british. this is common through out history. the french scots guard for example.

    • evidence of a jewish state in palestine only goes back to around 1000bc where do you get your extra millenium from?

    • @ hophmi

      no hophmi they don't. words do not take precedent over actions. their actions show them to be racists. the only bias here is yours trying to whitewash zionism's criminal history.

    • @ hophmi
      Or simply, the Carlsbad resolution suggests that Zionists have always vied for peace, and it is their Arab neighbors who have been unwilling to make peace with them. - See more at: link to

      of course your going to argue pretty words actually mean they wanted to live in peace. sorry hop but wanting to go to a foriegn land with the intent to seek dominion over it is not a desire for peace. the zionist than and now only care about peace so long as it serves their wants.

  • Just like the Nazis, Iran 'plans to exterminate six million Jews' -- Netanyahu
    • @debakr

      what ships to strike in the mediterranean. once you remove the litoral subs from irans inventory they only have 1 more sub than Israel and while they do have more frigates which in theory could be used to project a blue water presence to use them in the med would be suicide. NATO could easily intercept with 1-3 carriers plus destroyers from the countries in the area. yeah the 9 frigates Iran could send would do squat. Iran has a brown water navy just like Israel differences they aren't trying to add to there blue water abilities like Israel is.

    • so basiclly true real self determination rather than the fake zionist one

  • Video: Max Blumenthal on the ways Zionism exploits anti-Semitism
    • @hophmi
      "Oh no? How many times has Ward Connerly or John McWhorter spoken to a mainstream African-American organization, or a campus Black Students Union, in the past decade? -"
      um last time i checked charles barkley hasn't been expelled from the black community and he disagree with with several mainstream black views. and it should be noted that both people you mentioned are asscioted with libertarian think tanks. so you know being linked to groups actively defend the right to discriminate might be the issue not their anti affirmitive action stances.

      "Another vote for an extreme antisemite. Seems we have a lot of Atzmon fans here at Mondoweiss"
      your only proving my point. he is against zionism so therefore he must hate jews. your showing my entire argument that as a zionist jew you will not even entertain the notion that a jew can be anti-zionist. for some one who whines about how nobody wants to have a real dialouge you sure refusing to have a dialougue

    • that is disingenious. black people aren't expelled from the black community for being anti affrimitive action. jews however are expelled from the community at large if they aren't zionist. most jews are zionists do to the implicent threat if they have a differing opinion. your own hatred of gilad atzmon is case in point.

  • Philosophy prof who likened Palestinians to 'rabid pit bull' ignites protest on CT campus
    • @ yonah

      i'm not denying it yonah. but unlike you i'm willing to take the time to understand. as i stated one there was zero overt call for harm and was clearly coming from a place of anger. ie the guy in anger and grief making a statement beyond what he would state normally is the one your attack the guy who literally called for the commiting of a war crime dispassionately coming from a place normality is the guy your defending. honesty is the best policy. you should try it. instead of lying about Saliata debacle to defend a criminal.

    • bullshit. your boy Passin committed a crime by inciting for the commition of a war crime genocide. Salaita did know such thing. and at no point actually called for harming Israelis and jews. the two aren't comparable. one( saliata) was someone who was expressing his anger at his people being illegally harmed and never adovocating harm to anyone. which you condemned. the other (passin) called for the genocide of another people with zero provocation and was merely expressing his own blind hate and bigotry.

    • @jeffb
      thats a load of crap. there is not one single instances of salaita calling for genocide like pessin did. you lying jeff plan and simple. salaita was inciting or trafficking toward genocide. typical of you though to attack someone who is against warcrimes and defending someone who is

    • so in your mind Salaita calling Israel warcrimes and terrorism and the people like you who defend them is the same thing as this jewish professor calling for genocide against the palestinians? my bad you think speaking out against Israel's crimes is bad but calling for genocide of your victims is ok in your book

      Salaita wasn't trafficking in hate. most of the jewish orgs you support however do. what Salaitawas trafficking is accountability some you yourself as a zionist wouldn't understand.

    • what a suprise your condoning calling for genocide. maybe this why every decent hates zionists their just a bunch a criminals.

    • advocating the commiting of crimes is an illegal act one someone can be fired for. i'm sorry but anyone who calls for genocide like he did needs to be fired post haste

  • Emails show Missouri museum canceled 'Ferguson to Palestine' event under pressure from Jewish group
    • lol since when has anything a zionist group ever been principled. supporting war crimes terrorism and the supression of these facts from getting out is not principled

  • Sheldon Adelson is not the problem
    • there is what people will accept and than there is what the laws actually says. the 67 lines are Israel's legal borders. talknic believes Israel's conquering inside the partian lines is legal i don't. but for anyone with even a passing understanding of international law will tell you nothing out side those borders is legally Israel's under international law.

  • Selective voting in the land of Greater Israel
    • while i agree a jewish sense of entitlement in zionism is a major roadblock i think it can happen. not soon it would take decades of work and the Israelis would more than likely choose to kill everybody than cede dominion i believe there is a small but real chance that it could be achieved.

    • its my firm belief that the only way long term peace will happen is one palestinian state on all of historic palestine for everyone who wants to be an equal citizen of the territory.

  • We may not have Netanyahu to kick around anymore
    • they had to be pressured into all of those moves. none of them were done because of a sincere desire for peace. Israel won't make real concessions because the Israeli electorate is to divorced from reality to demand them. again hop saying your going to steal less is not a concession. something like offering economic aid would be a real concession and show the palestinians that finally after 70 years they have a partner in peace and that their willing to give up there conquering ways

  • 'NYT' reports 'surge of hostile sentiment against Jews' nationwide -- on what basis?
    • maybe people wouldn't ask for evidence if it weren't for the mulitude of times jews have been caught fabricating or misrepresenting things as anti semitism. and at the same time those groups don't have a history of labeling anything critical toward them as automatically bigoted.

    • because despite what you and yours claim its not all that pervasive. blind hate is very rare. anti semitism is only pervasive if you include legit criticism of Israel in it which i'm willing to bet most recorded incidients are. zionist college groups have trained colligiante jews to be hypersensitive to criticism of Israel and treat as a personal attack on them and hence they label it anti semitic when its not.

  • Why Iran is not and has never been Israel’s #1 enemy
    • look if a muslim country was going to give nukes to terrorists pakistan would have done already. a nuclear Iran isn't a threat to Israel it just ceases to be a country Israel can threaten which in their eyes is the same thing.

  • Rightwing rabbi seeks to pit Power against Rice on Iran ahead of AIPAC speeches
    • @dabakr hate to break it to you but as voters a shift of jews to the republican party would be meaningless in the demographic changes. the republican party is dead as a national party and dying in most parts of the US. the republicans ability to gerrymander themselves into office is going to end and than you'l start seeing republicans losing in the house in droves. remember based on total vote counts the democratic representatives and senators got millions more votes

Showing comments 1976 - 1901