Commenter Profile

Total number of comments: 2286 (since 2010-11-23 16:57:18)

Potsherd2

Showing comments 300 - 201
Page:

  • Secular Herzl sought to use 'mystic elements' to bind Jews to a place they had no living connection to
    • See, Mooser, Israel has now totally solved this problem, proving that in the right environment, Jews can be ignorant thugs as well as any other peoples.

    • You don't think so? When every day you have to choose between Jewish supremacy and the violations of human rights committed by the Israel state?

    • Which card would you choose, hophmi - your Jewish card or your human card?

    • eee, if you'd taken that logic course you'd be able to recognize your own self-contradictions.

      If American Jews are predominately conservative and reform, while Israelis are not, how can they be one people, given that Jewishness is defined by religion.

    • Michael W - I don't believe we can save the Palestinians. It's too late, it has already gone too far. I'm convinced that it's futile to try to change Israeli ways. They are rapidly changing for the worse. By every indication, the evil there is growing daily, and they reject any attempts at intervention.

      You can only save people who want to be saved. Israel doesn't want to be saved. The sane and the moral among the population will not suffer destruction. They will leave it to the fanatics. The fanatics will recreate the state in their own hideous image, telling themselves they are following the word of god.

      What the rest of us need to do is ensure that they don't drag the rest of the world down with them.

    • eee is right in a way. The future of Palestine is in the hands of Israeli Jews. The rest of us should recognize this, stand back and let the fanatics complete the process of their own self-destruction.

      Our cause should be the protection of other peoples from their violence during the disintegration.

    • Actually, eee, it is the establishment of Israel that is dividing the Jewish people. There are Israelis and there are Jews, and the two groups are pulling apart like a split ice floe in the ocean. The more racist Israel becomes, the more Jews elsewhere will draw back in revulsion.

      Eventually they will come to realize the nature of the catastrophe - that monsters have taken over the ancient holy center of Judaism, dividing them from it even more t han they were ever divided by Ottoman rule.

  • Groundswell
    • There are too many comments to read them all, but I hope someone pointed out the bias in the article: aimed at stopping rocket attacks and weapons smuggling.

  • Guerrilla ad campaign in SFO
  • Brooklyn-Jenin: Why didn’t the judges prevent the demolition in Lod?
    • I would like to see the members of the US Congress come home from a session of attacking peace and justice to find their own homes in rubble, their own children crying, their own pets shot.

      It's easy to maintain indifference from a position of impunity.

  • What slapdash H.R. 1765 reveals about the lobby and public awareness
    • Faced with the alternative between a just state and a Jewish state, there is only one choice. Let those who want a Jewish state take on the burden of making it just.

    • Convenient, isn't it!

      The idiots in the Israeli press took this to mean the resolution was passed unanimously.

    • This is excellent. This is what J Street should have been and failed to be. You have my support.

  • quick sermon on irreligion
    • It wasn't the Jews who were thrown to the lions in the Colosseum, hophmi, it was the Christians. Christians are so in love with their own persecution that they invented martyrology.

      If history proves anything, it's that there is no religion that won't persecute any others as soon as they attain a position of power over them. Israel today is a perfect example.

  • Palestinian farmer watches settlers burn 19 of his sheep, killing 12
  • Bronner exaggerates Palestinian violence
    • After Turkey sent help to Israel it was assumed that there would finally be reconciliation, with an apology and compensation paid to the victims. But Israeli propaganda did its work too well. There was a vast outcry protesting the idea of apologizing to "terrorists" and nothing more has been heard of the idea.

      Another nail in the coffin.

    • Bronner doesn't think the "brief raids" by armed troops counts as "violence." Israel is never violent. Israel only defends itself.

  • Imagine the Brookings Institution having a forum on the Future of the South in 1964 and inviting no black people
    • I have one word for you: Saban.

      Mearsheimer and Walt then mention the Saban Center and the Brooking Institution as an example[8] :

      Take the Brookings Institution. For many years, its senior expert on the Middle East was William B. Quandt, a former National Security Council official with a well-deserved reputation for even-handedness. Today, Brookings’s coverage is conducted through the Saban Center for Middle East Studies, which is financed by Haim Saban, an Israeli-American businessman and ardent Zionist. The centre’s director is the ubiquitous Martin Indyk. What was once a non-partisan policy institute is now part of the pro-Israel chorus."[

  • 50 years ago in the U.S., Jews were incensed by real estate 'covenants' against Jewish purchases
    • There's a name for this phenomenon: "I've Got Mine, Jack."

      Jewish commitment to rights has always been tied to Jewish persecution. With persecution only now a fading memory, interest in universal rights also fades, replaced by commitment to privilege and exclusivity.

  • State Department says it has 'raised' Abu Rahmah case with Israelis...
  • Mr President, answer Matthew Lee of the AP: 'Why is it beneath the United States to come out and say something about this practitioner of nonviolence?'
    • Holstun, it's perfectly clear that "Moscowitz" is not meant to refer to ALL Jews but those right-wing billionaires who fund West Bank settlements and do as much to subvert the Israeli government as the do the government of the US.

    • The US government, every branch of it, simply is incapable of shame.

      Congress just amply demonstrated this fact by passing the latest AIPAC resolution against a Palestinian state. The State Dept has no shame. The presidency has no shame. They are owned 100% by monied interests and don't really care that anyone knows this, because they know there is nothing that we can do.

      You can slap the word HYPOCRISY across their faces, and they don't even know what it means.

  • Jeffrey Goldberg likens BDS movement to Nazi Germany policies
    • I see no evidence that the blog administrators here are feeling any need for responsiveness when it comes to their moderation policy.

      It definitely dampens one's eagerness to offer support.

    • Zionism will lynch Jews who manifest disloyalty, like Richard Goldstone.

      "Hath not Goldstone Jewish eyes?"

    • Maybe the Palestinians will finally be allowed to run their own tech companies and the workers can be employed there. Just like Palestinian construction workers can finally be employed building Palestinian homes instead of Jewish settlements.

      That would be a lot better, wouldn't it, hophmi?

    • hophmi, your tactics are transparent. If you were really concerned about human rights violations in Saudi and Yemen, you'd hie yourself over to the Bash Arabs site and complain there. But no, your purpose is merely deflection.

      I hope that the next time muggers attack you and break your nose, the judge dismisses the case against them on the grounds that some other muggers cracked open another guy's head.

    • That's just hophmi, grasping at antisemitic straws cause it's all he got

    • If we could figure out how to use that profile thing, we could check.

    • eee, it's about that Logic class . . .

    • What is Cisco doing to tear down the wall?

      This is just another capitalist ploy to get cheap labor from a captive population of serfs. It's the Likud plan to turn the WB into a maqiladora behind prison walls.

    • Dialog works quite well. The committment to dialog to the exclusion of action effectively keeps progress from being made.

    • The religion of the Israelis has nothing to do with this call for a boycott. It has everything to do with Israeli actions.

      hophmi is only trying the tired old ploy of identifying the BDS movement with antisemitism.

    • As do I. But Goldberg isn't likely to approve some other method more effective in undermining the Israeli state, which the Isreali state is doing quite well by itself anyway, without outside help.

    • Goldberg needs to be reminded of the very effective Jewish boycott campaign against Nazi Germany. That is by far the closer precedent.

      And yes, it was an attempt to undermine the Nazi German state. Who has a problem with that?

  • Say it ain't so: Zakaria, Huffington and Tom Friedman go to bat for center that is desecrating Muslim cemetery in Jerusalem
    • Or maybe a Polish Museum of Tolerance?

    • For too many people, the name "Simon Wiesenthal" means a saint, any project bearing his name can do no wrong, and any criticism of him amounts to sacrilege.

      Of course, the center takes full advantage of this.

  • At Brooklyn College, the dialogue problem
    • jon s - the contradiction is not between "Jewish" and "democratic" but between "Jewish state" and "democratic state."

      And individual can be both Jewish and committed to democracy, but a state that defines itself as privileging one ethnic or religious group is by definition discriminating against any others.

      Sweden is Swedish not because it privileges ethnic Swedes but because it declares that any citizen of Sweden is thereby Swedish. It extends Swedishness to all members of the state. Israel does the opposite when it explicitly refuses to become "a state of all its citizens" and discriminates between Jews and non-Jews. No democratic state can do this.

      As for the historic ties of Jews to Palestine, Zionism has overlooked the fact that the Palestinians are the true descendants of the ancient Judeans, those who remained in the homeland while others scattered across the world. Their history in this land is of far longer duration than the Israelite kingdoms ever were, and it lasted until they were evicted by Zionist Europeans, playing the role of Babylon and Rome.

    • The Palestinians single out Israel because they are Israel's victims. It is the Palestinians who have called for the boycott, and people who value justice have answered their call.

      What other human-rights victims have been calling for a boycott of their oppressors? Who has spurned such a call?

      The work of the boycott of Israel can be seen in this: today, whenever performers travel to Israel, voices are raised to call Shame.

    • Steps so small that by the time you reach your destination, it has long since been blown away by malice, indifference and time.

      Which is the intention of those with the hobbles.

    • eee, you asked for options to dialog. That means, something else besides dialog.

    • How about - when the IDF comes to campus, join the Palestinian group in protest.

    • Where are the Palestinian lands in Brooklyn?

      Perhaps the Palestinian student groups might be more receptive to invitations from Jewish groups to join them in actions, rather than futile dialogue.

  • E tu Canberra?
    • So now eee is claiming to read minds! The word "disarmed" is nowhere in Phil's post.

      Israel should lead by example by signing the NPT and adhering to NPT resolutions instead of claiming exceptionalism.

  • Hasbara at UN
    • What hypocrisy! Israel is one of the chief suppliers of arms to non-Muslim African states, arming the conflicts.

      NAIROBI, Kenya, April 30 (UPI) -- Kenya, which faces being dragged into the war in neighboring Somalia, is seeking to buy arms from Israel in hopes of securing the support of the Jewish state's military expertise in countering the jihadist threat.

      That fits in neatly with Israel's own efforts to boost military sales in strife-torn Africa, particularly among the energy-rich states such as Nigeria and Angola.

      Connecticut-based Forecast International, which provides market intelligence on the defense and aerospace sectors, noted in a December analysis that these days Africa "is host to a dynamic arms market polarized by broad economic disparities and myriad security challenges.

      "Burgeoning energy economies have fueled significant market growth in recent years but a new wave of economic challenges threatens to slow this expansion," Forecast International said.

      Still, Forecast International said that the northern tier of African states, particularly Algeria, have eclipsed South Africa as "the region's most active and thus most lucrative, arms market."

      African states spent around $18 billion on defense in 2008, a 7.7 percent increase over 2007, the consultancy said.

      However, the North African states, overwhelmingly Muslim and opposed to Israel, are, of course, not open to the Jewish state. It is focusing largely on the sub-Saharan states like Angola and Nigeria, the region's leading oil producers, as customers for its high-tech defense industry.

      In September, Israel's hawkish Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman toured nine African states accompanied by a large entourage of arms dealers and defense industry executives from companies such as the flagship Israel Aerospace Industries, Israel Military Industries, Elbit Systems, Israel Shipyards and others.

      There was also a delegation from Sibat, the Defense Ministry department that oversees Israel arms sales and military assistance and Israel's intelligence community, including the Mossad, the foreign intelligence service that has long operated in Africa.

      No arms deals were signed during the tour, which included Ethiopia, Kenya, Nigeria, Ghana and Uganda. But Israeli Foreign Ministry officials estimated Africa's business potential at $1 billion. They noted some countries, such as Nigeria, were considered important markets for Israeli arms.

      The Kenyans have given no public indication of what kind of weapons systems they want from Israel but they are likely to include counterinsurgency systems and unmanned aerial vehicles for border surveillance.

      Israeli drones have been sold to Angola, the Ivory Coast and other countries to protect oil installations and other facilities.

      link to upi.com

      Naturally, they frame this activity as "fighting jihadism" just as, 50 years ago, the US excuse for promoting worldwide armed conflict was "fighting communism."

  • State Department hails 'civil society activists' around the world but refuses to say anything for imprisoned Abdallah Abu Rahmah
    • I'll probably prod Amnesty again about his case, which is about the most effective thing I can think of. Not our worthless government, for sure.

  • Editable comments | Site Improvements
    • So put it BELOW the Recent Comments, then.

    • OK, but it should certainly be somewhere on the home page, maybe just above the Recent Comments, where it is on every other page but the FP. It makes no sense to have Recent Comments take precedence over Recent Posts.

      In fact, you can't scan the recent articles so easily from the FP, as a less recent article is usually parked at the top and articles are not placed there in order of posted time. I have often missed a new article entirely, as it was way down the page, and it's quite frustrating.

    • Yes! That's better.

      Now, how about the Recent Posts list? This should really be at the top of the right sidebar on the home page, but it's not there at all from the home.

    • hophmi, if people were singling out someone's posts for criticism based on ideological preference, you would be one of the most likely targets. But no, you and your fellow Zionist tools are tolerated here and perfectly free to illustrate the vileness of your beliefs and the weakness of your reasoning as much as you wish.

    • It worked better when it was on the right side.

    • One site improvement would be for the Recent Posts list to be viewable on the home page.

    • Most sites like this have links that will add the html code for the user, thus eliminating many errors.

  • House vote against Palestinian statehood actually showed that Israel lobby is losing its grip
    • According to your explanation, if suspending the rules requires a 2/3 vote to pass the resolution, and there was no roll call vote, there was no 2/3 vote. Does this not mean that the resolution didn't pass?

  • Miami Jewish Federation smear-video says that Jimmy Carter and Walt and Mearsheimer want Israel 'wiped off the map'
    • I would LOVE to see Israel's war criminals in the dock at the Hague!

      Right next to their good buddy Darth Cheney!

  • Talks foundered because-- U.S. does not know what Palestinians want!
  • Sourani, in 1999: 'We should wait on no one to claim what is rightfully ours'
    • That's the entire idea.

      If you look at the procedings you see that most issues are dealt with by suspending the rules.

    • Here, at least, we can see the cosponsor roll of shame:

      Rep Ackerman, Gary L. [NY-5] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Alexander, Rodney [LA-5] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Berkley, Shelley [NV-1] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Bilirakis, Gus M. [FL-9] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Blackburn, Marsha [TN-7] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Buchanan, Vern [FL-13] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Burton, Dan [IN-5] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Campbell, John [CA-48] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Capito, Shelley Moore [WV-2] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Costa, Jim [CA-20] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Crowley, Joseph [NY-7] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Culberson, John Abney [TX-7] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Deutch, Theodore E. [FL-19] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Engel, Eliot L. [NY-17] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Foxx, Virginia [NC-5] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Garrett, Scott [NJ-5] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Granger, Kay [TX-12] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Green, Gene [TX-29] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Hensarling, Jeb [TX-5] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Israel, Steve [NY-2] - 12/15/2010
      Rep King, Peter T. [NY-3] - 12/15/2010
      Rep King, Steve [IA-5] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Klein, Ron [FL-22] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Lamborn, Doug [CO-5] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Lance, Leonard [NJ-7] - 12/15/2010
      Rep LoBiondo, Frank A. [NJ-2] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Lowey, Nita M. [NY-18] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Mack, Connie [FL-14] - 12/15/2010
      Rep McClintock, Tom [CA-4] - 12/15/2010
      Rep McCotter, Thaddeus G. [MI-11] - 12/15/2010
      Rep McMahon, Michael E. [NY-13] - 12/15/2010
      Rep McMorris Rodgers, Cathy [WA-5] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Murphy, Tim [PA-18] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Nadler, Jerrold [NY-8] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Pence, Mike [IN-6] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Poe, Ted [TX-2] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Quigley, Mike [IL-5] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Roe, David P. [TN-1] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Rogers, Mike D. [AL-3] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Ros-Lehtinen, Ileana [FL-18] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Roskam, Peter J. [IL-6] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Rothman, Steven R. [NJ-9] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Scalise, Steve [LA-1] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Schakowsky, Janice D. [IL-9] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Schauer, Mark H. [MI-7] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Schiff, Adam B. [CA-29] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Schmidt, Jean [OH-2] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Sherman, Brad [CA-27] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Sires, Albio [NJ-13] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Tiberi, Patrick J. [OH-12] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Waxman, Henry A. [CA-30] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Weiner, Anthony D. [NY-9] - 12/15/2010
      Rep Wolf, Frank R. [VA-10] - 12/15/2010

    • The stinking cowards wouldn't even do a roll call to record their votes for their constituents and posterity to condemn.

  • The Guardian calls it: The peace process is dead, but some don't want the party to end
    • US letters of assurance to Israel are entirely irrelevant to Palestinian rights and should certainly be taken into no account at all.

    • The division among the Palestinians is the successful consequence of USraeli machinations, beginning with the overthrow of the elected Palestinian parliament. The Palestinians threw out the corrupt quisling party Fatah, but USrael reimposed it on them by force. The Palestinian armed forces supposedly "loyal to Abbas" are in fact US-paid mercenaries who have no real loyalties to any Palestinian party.

    • And nothing but a lump of coal under the Presidential tree.

  • When in Rome, do as the Israelis do
    • And perhaps other people have their good reasons to be cautious of Israelis in tennis togs. When a country goes around the world assassinating right and left, it is no wonder it makes enemies.

      So now honest hotel workers have to suffer because international criminals choose to patronise their place of employment.

    • Wrong again, Jonah. Jews can enter SA and even live there under some circumstances. Of course no one ever considered the Saudis to be great advocates of human rights.

      But not even the Saudis would make such a demand in the US, thus demonstrating how much more bigoted Israelis are.

    • Maybe they should start. How do they otherwise know that Jewish employees aren't working for the Mossad as assassins?

    • The next time a Saudi delegation comes to town and demands that no Jewish employees be allowed on its floor, eee will of course understand how there is no prejudice involved.

    • If hotels are subjected to lawsuits for this kind of discrimination, they will become reluctant to take Israeli guests. Pariah state, closer every day.

  • Secret House resolution says No to Palestinian statehood
  • Why I was willing to risk arrest at the AIPAC annual dinner
    • You make one vital point, that African-Americans largely don't understand how their elected representatives are supporting a racist, Jim Crow state. They urgently need to know what AIPAC is and how it is corrupting the representatives they send to Congress. If there is any solidarity among people of color, it should begin here.

  • 'My name is Israel and I've been sleeping with a neofascist fundamentalist' 'Hi Israel!'
    • If hophmi can't grasp why Jews might feel consternation at the thought of an alliance with Nazis, he's even thicker than I thought.

    • I just saw the photo of that flag and would love for it to be displayed on the front pages of news outlets in every US city. I think a LOT of people would find it as offensive as you do.

      "Dual loyalty?" Who, us?

  • Slater: What's really wrong with the Goldstone Report
    • eee, when you began your philosophical studies, you should have started with Logic 101. Your deficiency is painfully evident. Statements have implications.

      First, when you say that "Jews in Israel are certainly willing to fight," what this implies is that they are willing to kill. It is not your own dead body that you envision, but the dead bodies of the Arabs you are prepared to kill in order to prevent "a one state solution."

      Now what is this "one state solution" you find so appalling that you are willing to sacrifice lives to oppose? It is the idea of a democratic state with equal rights for all, regardless of ethnic background. And what is so appalling about such a state? That non-Jews will have rights equal to Jews and that Jews will not constitute a democratic majority. In short, that it will destroy Jewish supremacy.

      It really only remains to inquire how many lives you are willing to spend in order to uphold Jewish supremacy, for it is clear from your own statements that this is indeed what you are committed to.

      I suggest that in addition to logic, you might consider a course in elementary ethics and leave epistemology for the upperclassmen who are prepared for such advanced study.

    • The US wasn't entitled to attack Afghanistan.

      But eee is actually correct, there is no middle ground here. Israel is a criminal state waging aggressive war on a population it is mandated to protect as occupying power. The only party with a right to self-defense are the Gazans.

    • An excellent reminder, thanks.

  • Fear and loathing in Long Island
  • Abunimah: Let's stick by 'Dayton Agreement' principles for Palestinian refugees
    • First time I've seen that photo of the desecrated flag. This used to be illegal.

      I'd like to get a better picture of it to use when Zionists carp about "dual loyalty" charges.

  • Schnabel says 'Miral' was delayed because 'the world' isn't ready for its message
    • Comment reported for threadjacking, not that this ever does any good around here.

    • This is a damn shame, and it's obvious that the usual pressure was applied. The film was promoted on the cover of VOGUE, for god's sake!

  • International pressure mounts on Netanyahu
    • BYahoo's coalition is also fracturing along the predictable internal stress lines. He can't postpone all the votes on all the issues indefinitely. At some point, he'll have to take stands on these issues, and then it all comes tumbling.

  • A long Palestinian struggle has ended Partition, maybe?
  • Palestinians in Israel would prefer one secular democratic state (but who's asking them?)
    • If Israel really wanted to negotiate in good faith it could have started by dealing with the actual government elected by the Palestinians instead of overthrowing it by force. But first it has to withdraw from the occupied territories for there to be a state to negotiate with.

    • I wonder how many native Australians would have been displaced to make that happen? "White Australia" is just as white if it includes Jews.

    • Halacha says different, eee. You obviously don't know what you're talking about, as I always suspected.

      Rabbis have ruled that kids brought up orthodox from the moment of the bris, with a Jewish father and a mother who converted, aren't Jewish because the mother's conversion wasn't orthodox enough.

    • Merkel is a sucker, and German reparations to Israel are a con game. Most of that money doesn't make it to the actual victims.

    • The Arab governments had no reason to expel their Jewish citizens until the Zionists drove the Palestinians across their borders, so they were indeed to blame.

      If your family wants to sue for the return of its Tunisian property, justice would support them.

      As for your kibbutz, it may or may not have purchased its land legally in 1939, but most kibbutzim took advantage of the Naqba to steal the property of their Arab neighbors in 1948.

      If your kibbutz can be shown to have legal title to its property, then justice would require Palestine to honor this claim and allow the title to stand.

    • "The Jews" had the option of not founding the state of Israel, and it was the only just option.

    • eee, lacking the virtue of consistency, says that Phil's kids can't be Jews because they don't have a Jewish mother, even if they are brought up to practice the Jewish religion.

      But Albright, with her Jewish mother, can't be Jew either, because she doesn't practice the Jewish religion.

    • I vote for the vile racist explanation, myself.

    • eee, I don't expect you to be able to grasp the distinction, but the children of thieves are not culpable, they are victims of their parents' crimes when the stolen property is reclaimed for its rightful owners.

      When you see your children crying because they have been evicted from the home they thought was their own, you can have the consolation that it was the fault of their parents.

    • Michael W - so withdraw already.

    • It's terrible for the children, who are certainly innocent, regardless of the guilt of their parents. But this is what people should consider when they decide to steal from others, that the payback may not end with themselves.

    • Annie, one reason given by Madoff for his suicide was the impending clawback suit against his children.

      You forget that, just like Palestinian land in the hands of Israeli Jews, Mark Madoff and his children are in possession of money stolen from other people, often their life savings, without which they are destitute. The clawback suits are the legal attempt to get back just a fraction of the stolen sums to restore them to the persons defrauded. This is justice.

      Would you rather have pensioners living on catfood because you're too softhearted to take stolen property from the heirs of the thieves? No one is proposing to indict the grandchildren or charge them with crimes. But thieves don't get to keep the money they stole, and they don't get to pass it on to their heirs.

      Let's keep straight in our minds who the real victims are.

Showing comments 300 - 201
Page:

Comments are closed.