Commenter Profile

Total number of comments: 2045 (since 2010-07-22 04:45:40)

a nominal Israel supporter until the '67 War when anti-Arab racism became so blatant that there was this Eureka moment that went something like "Damn, what a fool I've been". Ever since I've been a staunch pro-Palestinian anti-Zionist.

Showing comments 2045 - 2001

  • Jeffrey Goldberg is Jewish
    • Since Zionism does not = Judaism, anti-Zionism is not anti-Jewish. That's not to say that an anti-Zionist can't also be anti-Jewish, but that anti-Zionism itself has to do with opposition to the Jewish colonization of Palestine, not to a bias against Jews. No more, that is, than opposition to formerly apartheid South Africa was a marker (which it wasn't) for anti-white sentiment.

  • New statement calls on the movement to focus on Palestine, not divisive internal conflicts
  • Open letter to Jacob Zuma: Choose Leigh-Anne Naidoo's bravery over Amb. Sisa Ngombane's racism
  • No responsibility. No morality. No comment. No boycott.
    • Although Zionists see the worldwide boycott of settlements as the equivalent of the Nazi boycott of Jewish businesses in the thirties, today's boycott is more analogous to the 1933 Jewish-led worldwide boycott of Nazi Germany, one that might have succeeded had Zionist organizations not negotiated The Transfer Agreement with the Nazis for the transfer of 50,000 Jews and $100 million of their assets to Palestine in exchange for ending the boycott. Further similarity between the '33 and today's boycott is that the ultimate goal of both was/is to prevent a genocide - of Jews in '33, of Palestinians today. Considering the fact that but for the Transfer Agreement Nazi Germany might have died in its infancy, one has to wonder, what the fate of the Palestinian people will be, should BDS be crushed on account of Zionist opposition? Zionists sure appear to be equal opportunity genociders, either as enablers as they were in '33, or as the real McCoy, as they are (incrementally, at least) in Palestine today.
      Oh that BDS succeeds!

  • 'There is no stronger disorganizing force in American Jewish life than Israel'
    • Halevi says that there's virtually no debate in Israel about the Palestinians. If so might this be because not many Israelis are willing to pay the price - ostracization, verbal or even physical abuse - that dissenters in jingoistic societies face should they be brave enough to speak out? And even if they do speak out, will they heard, what with the media in such societies closed to dissenters. In Nazi Germany, for example, how many people stood up to defend the victims of antisemitic thuggery. Same goes for white dissenters in the days of apartheid South Africa, for anti-racist as well as antiwar activists right now in America, although here, so far at least, the suppression isn't as pronounced as in the above-mentioned societies. What's the antidote to such massive suppression? Certainly not unity in pursuit of jingoistic goals but mass rebellions to transform run amok militaristic societies, particularly ones such as Israel and the U.S. with their pretensions of being exceptional, and indispensable . For American Jews what this implies is not falling for the Israel uber justice racist line, but instead standing up for justice and equality, here in America as well as everywhere else, Palestine/Israel included.

  • In full page NYT ad, liberal Zionist group calls for ethnic segregation to retain Jewish majority within Israel
    • Hmm, Zionists publicly calling for Israel to be forever majority Jewish, "better" yet, purely Jewish? Shades of the demand by some racists that upon birth so-called anchor babies not automatically be granted U.S. citizenship, lest America turn into a melanin rich majority/white minority nation. Too late, of course, unless Trump wins in November and calls for a constitutional amendment that makes such babies non-citizens. He'll have to move quickly, though, since the percentage of whites is steadily dropping. But without a white majority what'll America be like? Same as Palestine/Israel without a Jewish majority. More just, peaceful and loving.

  • In Brookings poll, most Dems say $38 billion aid package to Israel is 'way too much' while the GOP is split
    • The Green Party's Jill Stein and the Republican Party's Gary Johnson haven't been invited to participate in the forthcoming debates. One reason for shutting them out may be that both nominees might speak out forcefully against this 38 billion aid package, which, given the above poll results, very well might peal off voters from both the major party nominees, but more so from the Democratic standard bearer. If polls suggest this is happening, Trump might change his mind & oppose the aid, but on this issue the public might not let him get away with it. Clinton, however, is so tangled up with the Israel Lobby that even if she came to her senses vis-a-vis Palestine-Israel, no way would the public believe her.

  • Commemorating the Shatila massacre, 34 years ago today
    • As someone who was a volunteer with the Palestine Red Crescent Society during the 1982 U.S.-backed Israeli siege of West Beirut, this time of the year always carries me back to those tumultuous days. The booming sound of missiles being fired from offshore Israeli warships, along with the mind-numbing experience of a of car bomb exploding outside one's residence are moments that simply won't let go. Same goes for the sight of a 11 story apartment bldg that had been flattened by a new type of ordnance (the vacuum or thermobaric bomb) that Israel was testing for its efficacy. Very effective, indeed, at least for wiping out civilians, as attested to by Yusuf, a Palestinian who lived in one of the apartments that had been destroyed, the only survivor out of an extended family of 11. Lying in his hospital bed, "No one's left", was what he told me.

      But beyond and above all the nightmares of war what sticks with me the most was/is - the unshakable spirit of the Palestinian people. Another and younger Yusuf exemplifies this spirit. Having suffered extensive first and second degree burns from an Israeli bomb, he was bedridden in an AUB dormitory that had been temporarily converted into a burn unit. He was febrile and somewhat confused, but shortly after several visitors (myself included) entered his room, he somehow willed himself to stand up. The nurse (a Dutch volunteer), fearing for his safety, asked him to return to his bed.

      "What are you doing?", the nurse asked.

      "Got to get up and help my people", his reply.

      Finally the nurse coaxed him to return to his bed.

      Could this be real? A young man who probably wasn't long for this world, his last thoughts being of his people.? Yet it is this spirit that explains why the Palestinians will never give up their quest to regain their homeland.

  • Why I single out Israel
    • Does either major party presidential candidates realize that the first one to come out against this 38 billion giveaway to Israel wins in November? Especially so if she or he links her/his opposition to said giveaway to the redirection of the 38 billion dollars to life enhancing pursuits such as tuition free higher education. Come on candidates, there's a presidency to be won; besides, you have nothing to lose except the hold that Israel-firsters have on you, and good riddance!

  • Stand with Standing Rock, and say no to Dakota Access Pipeline
    • The Palestinian Youth Movement's expression of solidarity with Native Americans in their struggle against the Dakota Access Pipeline is inspirational in that it speaks to a basic truth, that until the last chain is broken none of us will be free, yet once that last chain be broken, ah then, free at last.

  • 'Peace Now' chief slams AIPAC for misrepresenting Jews -- but Peace Now is on AIPAC exec committee
    • Severing the U.S-Israel special relationship is a vital task for American anti-Zionists. Weakening AIPAC can help bring this about because fear of being labeled an anti-Semite for criticizing Israel has silenced too many supporters of Palestinian liberation. Once they realize that they're not alone in criticizing Israel, they'll consider coming out of the closet and joining the pro-Palestinian movement in pressuring Washington to end its special relationship with Israel. And as I've stated several times before on MW, once that relationship is severed, Israel's days will be numbered. As for JVP's anti-Zionism being controversial, not only does it favor ending our government's unconditional support for Israel, it's a staunch supporter of BDS. Seems to me that those two efforts alone signify a measure of commitment to Palestinian liberation.

    • Americans for Peace Now can help bring justice to Palestine more effectively by renouncing its membership in AIPAC and the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations, instead allying itself with anti-Zionist organizations such as JVP and US Campaign to End the Occupation. Surely it must see the contradiction between its membership in AIPAC and both its opposition to the occupation and its attempts to deny that AIPAC speaks for all Jews. Switch sides, Peace Now, thereby diminishing AIPAC, at the same time advancing the cause of justice for Palestine.

  • It's war between Netanyahu and the generals (and the PM may just have lost the corporal)
    • At a time when the international Palestine liberation movement is gaining momentum, up steps Israel-firster Jeffrey Goldberg, in his role as the great distractor, trying to divert our attention towards rumblings of a split inside Israeli Jewish society. Just the moment to send in Bill Clinton, he says, and never mind that Clinton failed miserably at Camp David when he was president. Perhaps Goldberg thinks that anti-Zionists, led by him into believing that Israel's about to come apart, will call off BDS; instead waiting for the white Messiah BC to work his magic? No way! BDS is but the opening salvo in the worldwide effort to isolate the Zionist settler state Israel. Its advocates won't be distracted by petty spats within the Zionist hierarchy.

  • Many leftwing Israelis are leaving the country -- 'Forward' breaks an important story
    • Here in the U.S. of A. the potentially most effective way for the pro-Palestinian/anti-Zionist movement to help transform the Middle East is by educating the public to the fact that our government's unconditional support for Israel is the main reason They* hate us. That's not to say that the multiple other wars (Afghanistan, Iraq ,Yemen, Somalia) that America has been waging in the Middle East don't contribute to said hatred, but that. at least partly, our government engages in these wars under the misguided belief that by doing so it is protecting Israel. In the short term, perhaps, but what a steep price - in material as well as human lives - the public is and will continue to pay.

      How to turn the public on Palestine and the Middle East? By emphasizing the connection between U.S. support for Israel and the anger and hatred that renders the region's youth susceptible to appeals from Jihadists that young people join them in defeating the invaders and other infidels; by reminding the public that Osama bin Laden made it quite clear that U.S. support for Israel was a key reason for 9/11, and by hammering away at the fact that the Iraq War that took more than 5000 American lives (not to mention several hundred thousand Iraqis'), was undertaken with Israel edging America on; same goes for the Syrian war.

      Underlying the effort to sever the U.S-Israel special relationship is the belief that without this support Israel's days (not its people's) will be numbered.

      *They = the Arab/Islamic world

  • Daniel Berrigan's 1973 prophecy: Israel is becoming 'the tomb of the Jewish soul'
    • If Daniel Berrigan had been chosen to be Pope, would he have accepted that honor? If not, why not, and if so, what conditions, if any, would he have attached to his acceptance?

  • Beyond the flag
    • and what good have national anthems done?
      have they protected anyone from drone strikes?
      have they helped bring about a just and peaceful world?
      Oh, but they lift one's spirit
      make us proud to be an American
      unleash tears
      make life worthwhile
      but at the same time
      render us oblivious to
      the body counts from these perpetual wars
      the never ending racism at home
      since once a chorus of "the land of the free and the home of the brave"
      casts its magic spell
      we're lost in blissful reverie
      a momentary high
      so utterly inappropriate
      ghastly, actually
      what is being inflicted upon us
      upon the world
      in our names
      by our government
      meanwhile, we're in this trance
      which is why quarterback Colin Kaepernick wouldn't stand up for our national anthem
      it's like at the line of scrimmage
      to wake us up
      to break the trance
      he's audibilizing a new play
      telling us that when America becomes the land that it claims to be
      with liberty, equality and justice for all
      then he'll stand up
      but until then he'll remain seated
      and so should we

  • Liel Leibovitz wants to excommunicate most American Jews, beginning with Beinart
    • The just person always side with the slave, never with the slave-owner. Re: Palestine/Israel the Palestinians are the slaves, since it's their land that's been forcefully taken from them by Jewish settlers, confiscating another people's land being an act of enslavement. It is for this reason that many of us American Jews are participating in the movement for justice in Palestine, a movement made up of people from a diversity of nationalities, religions and political persuasions. For us the fact that co-religionists claim to be colonizing Palestine on behalf of all Jews, compels us to participate in this liberation movement. The history of our people, of all people informs us that until the last chain is broken, none of us will be free.

  • Let's talk about Russian influence
    • Demonizing Russia is an easy proposition for the war hawks, what with most Americans born from 1917 to 1994 having been bombarded with anti-Russian/anti-Communist propaganda. Sure, with the breakup of the USSR there was some easing in said demonizing, but empire's propagandists had to be besides themselves with joy when they were told to get back to portraying Russia/Putin as evil and threatening, since to accomplish this all they need do is play an updated version of the same tune re: alleged Russian treachery that they deployed during the existence of the Soviet Union. Or so they may think, but will it work this time around?

  • The politics of Jewish ethnocentrism
    • ethnocentrism - having or based on the idea that your own group or culture is better or more important than others (source: Merriam-Webster's Learner Dictionary) -

      syllogism: some Jews are ethnocentric bigots. Jerry is a Jew. Therefore Jerry is a bigot.

      As for Liel Liebovitz's accusation that in exchange for financial rewards Gideon Levy peddles stories about Israel's crimes, here Liebovitz must be desperate , because his characterization of Levy as someone who'd sell out his people is awful close to the antisemite's stereotypical depiction of the perfidious Jew. Shylock comes to mind. Hmm, resorting to antisemitic stereotyping, what does this tell us about Liebovitz? Self-hating Jew, perhaps?

  • Palestinian anti-racist struggle against Zionism and Black anti-racist struggle against White supremacy are crucial to building a just world
    • Many if not most people who have felt the sting of discrimination, be it based on race, ethnicity, religion, sex, age or class, come to understand that until the last chain is broken none of us will be free. This explains how it is that there are Africans supporting Palestinian liberation., Palestinians supporting African liberation and Jews supporting both liberation movements as well as their own liberation, if by that one means freeing an individual from the moral dilemma that Zionism inflicts on its adherents. A dilemma that precludes the Zionist Jew from identifying with the plight of the Palestinian. - "But how can one identify with an inferior human being?" By discarding, if but for a moment, that facade of superiority and imagining instead what being a Palestinian in Gaza would be like., thereby allowing previously forbidden connections between two peoples to take shape. Once seriously undertaken, moral dilemma resolved. Simple as that!

  • Beinart calls anti-Zionists 'revolutionaries'
    • The characterization of BLMers and anti-Zionists as revolutionaries may bother Stephen Low, but if revolution has to do with turning a society upside down, seems to me that the characterization fits the reality of Palestine/Israel. But as Phil notes in his post, not all revolutions are bloody. After all, isn't the goal of of BDS that of a bloodless transformation of P/I? Where I disagree with Phil in his insistence that changing the American-Jewish mind is the most important step towards bringing about this bloodless revolution. This might be the case if there were no pressure of time. But with time running out the aim of anti-Zionist revolutionaries should be to turn the general public against our government's unconditional support for Israel. In this effort American Jews can be helpful in that our presence among the revolutionaries will tend to dispel the Zionist charge that anti-Zionism = anti-Semitism, thereby rendering the public more receptive to the specifics of how it is that America's unfaltering support for Israel has led to so much violence, death and destruction in the Middle East. Open-mindedness being the prerequisite to discovering the truth, once the public realizes that the truth re: P/I is the opposite of what they've been taught, the revolution will have begun.

  • The 'New York Times' is dead set on marginalizing Jewish anti-Zionism
    • The NYT won't cover Jewish anti=Zionism because its editors realize that once the general public learns how many Jews reject Benjamin Netanyahu's claim that he speaks for all Jews, the fear of being being called an anti-Semite or a self-hating Jew for supporting justice for Palestine will vanish - "How can I be an anti-Semite (or self--hating Jew) when so many Jews are with me in this movement for justice?" Next those who previously held back from criticizing Israel (closet anti-Zionists) for fear of being labeled anti-Semitic will be asking what Israel's role in other Middle East conflicts has been, and how much their prior silence on these issues contributed to so much death and destruction? As this begins to take place throughout our land, Israel's (not its people's) days will be numbered. Empire too will be in serious trouble - for having provided Israel with unconditional support for more than half a century. The public will want to know how this relationship came about, who & what's to blame, and there'll be demands that those responsible be put on trial. Fear of such an outcome is what keeps the NYT from reporting on the rapidly growing Jewish pro-Palestinian/anti-Israel/anti-Zionist movement. Strange their fear, because the longer the Times' editors/publishers persevere in ignoring said movement, the worse the outcome for them. But it's not too late, if only they open up and spill the beans - about, Zionism, Israel and our nation's role in the conflagrations afflicting the Middle East, not to mention the whopper the NYT's propagates about Israel's leaders speaking for all Jews.

  • Jews need to study the Torah in order to criticize Israel, Beinart says
    • What's this about reading the torah so as to root our children so deeply in our own Jewish identity that when we support justice for Palestine we cannot be excommunicated? Sounds like Peter Beinart is trying to shrink the ranks of pro-Palestinian/anti-Zionist Jews, because for many if not most Jews, nothing could be more onerous than having to discipline oneself so as to take in the gibberish of unknown authors from a bronze age culture. Get serious, Peter, cause it ain't gonna happen. Excommunication or not, Jewish supporters of the Palestinian cause will not be deterred. Nor were white anti-apartheid members of the African National Congress deterred by the enmity directed at them by other whites.

  • Jewish entitlement, and Jewish populism
    • Isn't it more accurate to say the Jewish elite's tradition of being wary of populists, rather than, as Phil puts its, the "Jewish tradition of being wary of populists", After all even during the days of Europe's shtetls, how many Jews were in positions of power, compared to those working in the fields or scraping out a living in small towns? True, until recently most Jews, non-elite as well as elite, have sided with Zionist Israel. That's still the case but the rapid growth of anti-Zionist organizations such as Jewish Voices for Peace suggests that show-down time may not be far off. What's more the Jewish elite's fear of populism is shared by the non-Jewish elite's fear of same, perhaps not on the issue if P/I but on other issues (income disparity, racism, cost of education and health care, global warming, etc etc) where the 99% (especially its youth and minorities) is challenging the 1%.

  • Israel-splaining
    • As BDS tightens the screws on Israel no surprise that the racist state responds by resorting to the old saw that the best defense is a good offense. Unfortunately for Israel the offense it chooses is that of saying we're not the racists, you BDS'ers are; racist antisemites, that is, for falsely labeling us colonizers and practitioners of apartheid, Unfortunately here, because the evidence supporting the charge that Israelis are colonizing Palestine and enforcing apartheid on its people, the Palestinians, is overwhelming. Which puts Israel in the awkward position of having to recite the specific accusations that BDS is making in order to deny them. But in doing this Israel will be making the case for its opponents. Sooner rather than later Israel will find that its strategy has stoked public interest in what's really happening re: Palestine/Israel. And once this happens, game over, farewell, goodbye, so long, apartheid state.

  • 'NY Jewish Week' speaks bluntly of 'Israel firsters' in US politics
    • As America and its allies face the blowback from the wars that Israel-firsters have promoted in Iraq, Syria and elsewhere, it should be clear by now that these I-F'ers are at least partly responsible for the mass murders in Orlando, Paris, Brussels and Ankara. For had they put the interests of America, not to mention the rest of the world, before the interests of the settler-state Israel, there'd have been no Afghanistan war, no Iraq war, no Libya war, no Syria war. And without said wars, no blowback! Just think of it, history shaped by a tiny nation of six million people (80% Jews), along with its mostly Jewish I-F'er U.S. supporters. Antisemitism? Only if nothing is done about this.

  • Shift: Two NY Jewish leaders describe checkpoints, innocent Palestinians killed, and 'good Jews' who denounce Israel
    • "We raise good Jews " - young Jews who care about people who suffer.

      They may aim to raise young Jews to be progressive on everything except Palestine (PEP), but what's happening is that their children are learning that regardless of the nationality, ethnicity or religion of the colonizer, colonization = racism. Knowledge that can transform them into being progressive on everything including Palestine (PIP). And once this awakening occurs, considering the weight of hypocrisy that's being exposed, there's no turning back.

  • Israel is at war over nature of a Jewish state, and NYT spins it as 'changing of the guard'
    • Netanyahu is but the latest Israeli PM to advance the myth about one nation between the river and the sea. Indeed, it should be evident by now that what's holding Israel back from completing its ethnic cleansing of Palestine isn't the particular makeup of its government, but concern for the effect that such a crime would have upon its special relationship with America. In other words the players may change, but the name of the game, colonialism, stays the same. And so it has been since Columbus sailed the ocean blue in 1492. Until, that is, the natives rise up and liberate themselves from their colonizers.

  • Why Miko Peled's story resonates for Palestinians
    • Given the well known corrupting influence of power, rather than chastising American Blacks for some of its leaders perhaps having failed the test of virtue (ie power), seems to me that the fundamental progressive challenge remains how to deliver power to the people such that it's so fairly distributed that no one's virtue is tested.

    • If one truly ascribes to the principle of always siding with the oppressed, never with the oppressor, ultimately PEP becomes untenable.

  • Zionism threatens to bring anti-semitism full-circle
    • 2 important points in this article

      1) Since Israel is a major cause of hatred towards Jews around the world, they should be wary of considering it to be their 'insurance policy' (ie safe haven) when the going gets tough.

      2) If all Jews become identified by an inevitable connection to Israel then Israel becomes their greatest peril."

      Specifically, said peril is that of Israel tightly packed with 16 million Jews, most of whom will have fled there consequent to Israel's having incited virulent worldwide antisemitism with its Palestinian genocide, a crime against humanity that Israel will say was done in the name of all Jews. Won't matter whether this claim is true or not, since Jews who opposed Israel's crimes as well as those who supported them will be forced - so intense will be the hatred - to run for their lives.

      But in a world bent on revenge, how safe will the so-called safe haven be?

  • 'Either Assad or we'll burn the country' - An excerpt from 'Burning Country: Syrians in Revolution and War'
    • could it be any more obvious obvious?

      for sure
      no denying it
      the tens, hundreds of thousands
      even millions
      killed, maimed, displaced
      in exchange for ridding Iraqis of demon
      saddam hussein
      syria of demon bashar assad
      "yes, it was worth it"
      says u.s diplomat madeleine albright
      speaking not for the Iraqi or the syrian people
      but for empire usa

  • Once, most Jews viewed Israel as the anti-semite's best friend
    • Once most Jews Viewed Israel as the antisemite's best friend?

      Soundly based, too, considering the fact that the Jewish-settler colonization of Palestine accounts for most of today's antsemitism

      This is so not only because history has discredited settler colonialism, but because Palestine today is a living example of the horrors that settler conquest bestows upon native peoples.

      Perhaps Israel is no worse in this regard than the many settler colonizations that took place over the past 5 centuries. Israel's "misfortune" is that its crimes are played out before billions of people, compliments of modern communication technology. Who knows what the world would look like today had the Conquistadores been faced with such instant revelations?

      Yet Israel & its supporters, rather than asking themselves "what are we doing wrong that the world's turned against us", cling to the illusion that "they hate us because we're Jewish." Yeh, and the worldwide opposition to settler colonialism in South Africa was attributable to hatred of Whites and not to the recognition by most people that colonialism = racism, and therefore must go?

      What is there about settler colonialism that riles people up? Well, it being a form of enslavement, its existence forces us to decide, on which side, the slave (ie. the Palestinian) or the slave-owner (ie. the Jewish settler). Most of us, of course, side with the slave. Why? Perhaps has something to do with the "there but for go I", or, perhaps the realization (conscious or otherwise) that none of us will be free until the last chain is broken.

      And this, not antisemitism, is why the world's against the settler state Israel. Simple and as basic as that. Nothing to do with antisemitism, which, unfortunately is something that Israel and its supporters won't dare consider. They take that up and the walls come tumbling down.

      That's not to say that there aren't at least a few anti-Semites who'll try to jump aboard justice for Palestine movements such as BDS. Except that a few rotten apples do not a mass movement spoil, especially when its members know that opposing one form of racism (settler racism) with another (antisemitism) is a recipe for disaster.

      Indeed, with the dissolution of the state of Israel (not its people), the amount of antisemitism in the world would be reduced to a size that could easily be flushed down a toilet.

  • US Jews adopted 'deferential' relationship to Israel, and tabooed dissent so as to preserve US gov't support
    • Nothing will do more to lessen whatever antisemitism still exists in America than a widening of the deep and growing fissure within the Jewish community on Israel-Palestine. By shattering the belief that there's unity among Jews on this issue, the general public will feel less inclined to keep silent out of concern that criticizing Israel might be looked upon as an act of antisemitism - "How can I be an anti-Semite when so many Jews are saying the same thing?" Indeed, the "liberating" effect of anti-Zionist Jews (and newly formed anti--Zionist organizations such as Jewish Voices for Peace)) on the public's willingness to speak out on I-P may be the most important aspect of the split within the Jewish community. And the reason this development will reduce antisemitism is that the awakening of the public on the I-P issue has the potential of ending America's unconditional support for the colonial settler state Israel, and without said support, Israel will have to get serious about justice for Palestine. Now once Palestine is free, antisemitism will be reduced to a size that can be flushed down a toilet, and then no more energy need be wasted on such nonsense as establishing a safe haven for Jews - because the earth will have become that safe haven, not only for Jews but for all people everywhere.

  • BDS or emigration: pick one
    • Once significant numbers of settlers decide to emigrate, will the outward flow turn into a stampede? That's what happened 40 years ago in Mozambique, after Africans there won their independence from Portugal, as within 2 years only a few thousand whites remained out of a pre-independence population of 450,000 mostly Portuguese settlers (Wikipedia). To date this hasn't happened in South Africa, although since 1995 when the African National Congress took power, approximately 800, 000 out of 5,200,000 whites have emigrated. It should be noted that in Mozambique the settlers were more or less kicked out, whereas in South Africa they have been encouraged to stay; suggesting, perhaps, that how fast Jewish settlers take off for other parts may depend upon how welcomed they'll be in liberated Palestine.

  • Beinart's Jewish double-bind: Support oppression or you're out of the family
    • Don't put personal morality above loyalty to family is what police association officials preach to the cop who decides to publicly disclose a fellow officer's criminal transgressions, thereby deviating from the so-called blue code of silence. And this is the mentality that Peter Beinart hopes to foster in the Jewish community? Never mind the mass murdering of Palestinians being perpetrated by Jewish settlers in Palestine, cause it's tribal loyalty that counts? And what is Beinart's perversion of personal responsibility to be called, the "Jew code of silence?"

  • Norman Finkelstein on Sanders, the first intifada, BDS, and ten years of unemployment
    • As for Israel's using BDS so as to enhance its mantra of victimhood, despite this deceit, judging by the growth in the number of individuals and organizations committing to its goals, BDS continues to expand, not to mention the increasing public awareness that the underlying cause of the Israel-Palestine conflict is Jewish settler colonialism. Slowly, yet inexorably, we shall overcome.

    • "Palestinians are a defeated people." - Norman Finkelstein

      Except Haitians too seemed to be a defeated people in 1967 when I visited them, but by the mid-eighties they had awakened to the drumbeat of a liberation movement led by Jean-Bertrand Aristide, who not long thereafter in a landslide election became their president.

      Similarly Algerians appeared to be a defeated people after "The Battle of Algiers" but a few years later they rose up and tossed out the French occupiers.

      Same goes for Palestinians. Sure, a "snapshot" taken of them right now might reveal what looks like a defeated people,
      but continuous filming could just as well reveal a revolution in the making. Suggesting that seems to be, appears to be and looks like are not equivalents of actually are.

      What does the "snapshot" miss? Only the ongoing history of people engaged in continuous liberation struggles, Haitians for over two centuries, Algerians for eight years and Palestinians for about a century.

      Come on Norman, you may feel defeated and are giving up on the struggle, but the Palestinians, although undoubtedly discouraged, rest assured that when the right moment arrives, they'll be ready.

  • Chabon calls occupation 'the most grievous injustice I have ever seen in my life' and says he is 'culpable'
    • ah, the epiphany

      where suddenly
      with such clarity
      stupid me
      why didn't I see this before

  • When 'Broad City' Went On Birthright, and taught us all a lesson about American Jews and Israel
    • birthright

      food and sustenance
      a roof over one's head
      health care
      the company of family and friends
      not being a displaced person

  • Donna Edwards's campaign unsettles the Israel lobby inside the Democratic Party
  • Another interview on Israeli TV
    • Why is the narrator astonished at the connection made in the U.S. between blacks/other minorities and Palestinians?

      Especially since the victim of racist prejudice almost reflexively tends to identify/connect with other victims of racism

      Has he personally never felt the sting of racist insults?

      Yet many people who have never been on the receiving end of racism are able to connect with victims of racism by saying to themselves, "there but for go I."

      Could it be that he has experienced racism but his capacity to identify/connect with others afflicted by this type of hatred was blunted by life in an apartheid society? After all, even in apartheid South Africa, there were a few Africans who sided with their "masters."

      Then, of course, there's always the possibility that personal gain overwhelms one's better instincts.

  • Tidbits from Reader Survey: Please Add Your Ideas To The Mix
    • 'The World The Settlers Made'

      couldn't be clearer

      "Palestinians are nothing" - Jewish settler

      therefore it's ok to wipe them out

      besides, "they're bad, we're good" - another Jewish settler

      so what's the fuss all about?

  • Sanders's leftwing base made him take on Netanyahu
    • @Kay24
      for purposes of clarification -

      mobilization on the left = unity among the various liberation movements in pursuit of liberty, justice & equality

      mobilization on the right = the joining together of hate-peddling organizations and followers who seek a fascist world

      as for the election itself, it is relevant only to the extent that it contributes towards advancing the core values and goals of the left

      which means that despite whatever progressive positions she holds on domestic issues, on account of her position on P-I as well as her track record as a war-maker, Hillary Clinton is
      neither on the left nor progressive.

      Bernie Sanders, however, should be accepted as a man of the left, not only for his positions om domestic issues, but for his recent shift to the left on I-P and other matters of war & peace. Yes, he needs to move further in this direction, but here the left can be of assistance.

      So long as Sanders stays on course us leftists have an opportunity to advance our causes, not only by supporting him in the collective struggle, but by alerting him to whatever influences blur his vision.

      But if for whatever reason Sanders decides to separate himself from the movement, the left shouldn't hesitate to say something like "so long it's been good to know you" and be ready to carry on without him - towards that just and peaceful world that we all seek.

    • The significance of this election is that it's mobilizing both right and the left, with rightists responding to appeals to their racist, xenophobic and violent tendencies, whereas leftists are drawn to visions of a just and peaceful world. Should the right prevail in November's election and the mobilization of the left collapse, goodbye life on earth (what with perpetual war + global warming = doomsday). But regardless of the outcome in November, the left must remain mobilized, being that it is the only force that can save planet earth.

    • Page: 20
  • 'Anti-Zionism = anti-semitism' is a formal logical fallacy
    • To be true to oneself the moral person must always side with the slave, never with the slave owner, even (better, especially) when the slave owner not only happens to be of the same religious persuasion as oneself, but insists, as is the case in Israel today, that s/he speaks for everyone of said persuasion. Except Israel has been built by way of the colonization by Jewish settlers of an indigenous people's (the Palestinians') homeland, with the subsequent "cleansing" of Palestinians so as to establish settler hegemony over the now stolen land. Settler colonization being a form of enslavement, no matter one's closeness to the settlers (familial, ethnic, religious or otherwise), once again, to be true to oneself as a moral person one can only side with the slave.

  • Sanders' unprecedented call for 'justice and peace' marks decline of lobby's power
    • although not receiving as much attention from the media, on the issue of the ongoing war(s) in Syria, the differences between Linton and Saunders were just as stark as their differences on Palestine/Israel, especially when Clinton said she supports a no fly zone in Syria and Sanders was against it. Additionally, both her war hawk nature and her duplicity came through in her comments on her role in the U.S./NATO war on that country. Whereas in prior debates she didn't hesitate to take credit for bringing on that war, at the Thurs. debate she ended up backing off a bit by saying it was President Obama who made the call. Perhaps her pollsters told her that the public is now disillusioned with the war in Syria war, and to put at least some of the blame on Obama.

  • Sanders slams Clinton for ignoring Palestinian needs and thinking Netanyahu is 'right all the time'
    • @echinococcus
      I agree, up to Thurs. night's debate he was in the Zionist camp, but his words suggest to me that on P/I he's separating himself from the rest of the candidates. What's so surprising about someone who early in his life demonstrated a fervent commitment to the struggle against racism here in America suddenly waking up to the reality of racist Israel? Will he persevere in this is another question, but if he does he just might awaken the electorate to the fact that on this issue they've been had.

    • If Sander's is a man of his words, certainly his track record as a politician suggests that he is, then his call for our government to be even-handed on Palestine/Israel should not be dismissed as a desperate gambit to keep his presidential campaign alive. Israel-firsters, of course. will say that his take on P-I shows that he's out of touch with Jewish-Americans, if not the general public, and that his statement last night is gonna cost him the election (not that they ever believed he had a chance). Perhaps, but assuming he continues to play the same tune re: P/I, don't be surprised if his message begins to resonate with the public. Yes, I know,
      for decades now the media has poured out so much pro-Israel propaganda that no way will his message get through, but then there's this intrinsic sense of fairness that can be demonstrated in children as young as one year. Difficult to grasp this, considering how as we age so many of us lose interest in matters that pertain to fair play and equality, with some of us even expressing bias against certain other(s). But then along comes something like a civil rights movement, somehow rekindling that childhood sense of fairness. Here questions arise as to whether the movement for justice in Palestine can capture the imagination of the American people, whether a presidential election is the appropriate vehicle for carrying this movement forward, and whether Bernie Sanders is the right person to be in the driver's seat. Give it a try, Bernie, there's a presidency to be gained, a world to be saved - by changing it!

  • Israeli journalist Derfner succinctly analyzes the anti-Semitism vs. anti-Zionism debate
    • Besides, what generates anti-Semitism today is Israel's occupation of Palestine, along with the U.S. multiple wars on Islamic nations that won't kow-tow to U.S. dictates. If only the above violations of international law were abandoned, anti-Semitism would be reduced to a size that could be flushed down a toilet. And what need (er, excuse) then for a safe haven for "endangered" world Jewry?

  • Israel demands correction from Sanders: it killed only 532 Palestinian children in summer 2014
    • Since "only" 532 Palestinian children were killed in the "haircut" that the IDF gave to Gaza almost three years ago, Sanders should apologize. After all during the past year or so didn't Israel lose a child or two somewhere to Palestinian "terrorists?" 532 to 1 or 2, isn't this an acceptable kill ratio, considering the Zionist settler's exceptional value and worthiness compared to those good for nothing Palestinians?

  • Shocker: 'NYT' forum on anti-Zionism tilts toward equating Zionism with racism
    • Zionism = racism against Palestinians
      anti-Zionism = anti-racism against Palestinians

      & since Judaism does not = Zionism
      anti-Zionism does not equal anti-Semitism

  • Zionism is finally in the news, as officials seek to conflate anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism
    • cause and effect -

      Zionism and Nazism
      same hatred
      different targets
      as believers run amok

      Gaza and the Warsaw Ghetto
      same place
      different times
      while the world stands by

  • Why is AIPAC legitimating Donald Trump's bigotry?
    • Faced with a growing BDS movement AIPAC & other Israel-first organizations may see fascism as the surest way to save Israel from the challlenge posed by anti-Zionism. So what if a charasmatic American leader has emerged, who, like certain fascist leaders of yesteryear, revs up his followers by asking them to pledge allegiance to him with their right arm extended. Also never mind that he further imitates those same leaders by designating certain groups (Muslims & Mexican undocumented 'border-crossers') as enemies of state, something that should scare the hell out of a predominately Jewish organization, given the last century's Holocaust. Toss-in a promise to 'make America great again', to be merciless in pursuit of a world in which those who resist a hegemonic USA are destroyed, while at the same time sparing Social Security and Medicare the ravages of austerity and, voila, you have an updated version of the mix of racist, xenophobic & war hawking rhetoric (along with a bone or two of populist social policies to chew on) that brought Hitler and Mussolini to power. Remember, too, that their rise to power coincided with an emergent Left, and with that period's .01% being under attack. And now we are witnessing the same phenomena in Turkey (among other places), with racism, xenophobia and warmongering wiping out an emergent Left, at the same time attacking what had been a promising, albeit fragile democracy.

      Undoubtedly AIPAC leaders know the dangers from flirting with fascism, but for them, since Israel comes first, it's a risk worth taking.

  • What brought you to be critical of Israel?
    • What brought me to be critical of Israel?

      the same thing that brought 8 yr old me to be critical of racism in Nazi Germany

      the same thing that brought teenager me to be critical of racism in America

      the same thing that led me to be critical of racism anywhere & everywhere

      the same thing that has led me to always side with the slave/oppressed/occupied, but never to side with the slave-owner/oppressor/occupier

      no matter (better, especially) when the owner/oppressor/occupier happens to be a co-national/co-religionist/co-whatever

      isn't this the mandate of everyone of the humanist persuasion?

      knowing as we do that none of us will be free until the last chain is broken

      and that only the slave can free us all

  • Netanyahu slams Abbas in wake of killing of American tourist
    • Jewish Israelis

      grab your 2nd passport
      and pack your bags
      leave your fears at the airport
      between the mediterranean
      and the the jordan
      palestine for palestinians
      from now on

  • Palestinian citizens of Israel respond to poll showing Jewish support for expelling Arabs from country
    • Where will Palestinians be expelled to? Surely not to neighboring Arab nations,already the unhappy recipients of ethnic cleansings dating back to 1947, and definitely not to the West, considering the enmity building there towards all things Arab &/or Islamic. Which leaves internal displacement with the establishment of concentration camps (the Israeli equivalent of America's Indian reservations) as the most likely outcome for the indigenous people of occupied Palestine. Will Israel get away with it? Well, at most western leaders will utter a few tut-tuts and assorted naughty- naughties, while the UNSC passes a few resolutions prohibiting the expulsion, all of which are vetoed by Israel's grand protector, the USA. So what it'll come down to is whether or not the people of the Arab/Islamic world will allow their governments to stand by and do nothing?

  • Bernie Sanders's God is a lot like John Brown's
    • Do unto others as you would have them do unto you sure seems like a sound basis for one's religious belief. What concerns me is that when it comes to Palestine/Israel Bernie Sanders reveals that he's not a true believer, because if he were, he'd be opposing not only Israel's occupation of Palestine, but its barbaric treatment of the indigenous people of that land, the Palestinians. Doesn't Sanders realize that unless he applies his credo universally, it becomes as meaningless as a person who claims he's a vegetarian except for when he eats beef. Come on Bernie, apply your belief universally or get out of the race. And since authenticity seems to be the single character trait in this presidential election that voters are fixing upon, not only is your supporting justice for the Palestinian people the right thing to do, it'll win you the election.

  • 2017 is a crucial year for the Palestine Question
    • A few remembrances from a visit to occupied Palestine near the beginning of the First Intifada -

      taking a taxi from outside the Damascus Gate to Ramallah. The old taxi reminded me of the vintage cars I'd seen a decade earlier in Havana during a visit there. One of my fellow passengers kept his head behind a newspaper for most of the ride, except for periodically peering out to glance at me. I wondered whether I was under surveillance.

      Upon arriving at Ramallah, initially receiving a cold reception from a street vender; until, that is, I asked him if he knew a certain physician whose name I'd been given as someone to visit. Instantly he turned friendlier, at least trusting enough to direct me to said physician's house.

      At a Ramallah hospital, going to meet a physician who a friend of the hotel manager where I was staying had suggested I visit. Upon informing him of this his response - something like "Why the hell did so & so do that. I've just been released from three months in prison, and now he sends me a known activist? Just what I need to get myself back in prison." Still, albeit not too happily, he answered my questions as to the medical problems his hospital was facing consequent to the Intifada.

      Another day & another vintage taxi ride, this time to Jerusalem. Noticing, upon entering the city, from his perch on the 2nd story of a building opposite the entrance, a rifle toting IDF soldier with his mounted weapon pointing in our direction. Walking down the streets radiating outwards from the Church of the Nativity one couldn't help notice the Israeli settlements built on hills overlooking the Palestinian city.

      Ordered by an Israeli policeman on a street near the Damascus Gate to get out of their car,the sight of three young Palestinian men lined up against a wall as she checked there identification papers. "Just like Africaaners asking an African for his papers," I thought. "How humiliating that has to be."

      The three co-passengers in the Israeli taxi (a relatively new Bentley this time)) that took us from Bethlehem back to the Damascus Gate. They got in the taxi a few minutes after me and, ? coincidentally. just happened to work with the Palestinian physician whose home I had been in the day before.

      Upon returning home from Gaza one afternoon I was confronted by the serious risks accepted by participants in the Intifada. Arriving again by vintage taxi outside the Damascus Gate, I noticed there seemed to have been some sort of commotion. I asked a bystander what had happened. Turned out that a Palestinian protester had been shot dead by Israeli cops.

      Changing the scene to the Dome of the Rock which I entered one Friday afternoon after performing the rituals of washing my feet and putting on fresh slippers. Palestinian entrance being restricted during Islam's holy day of the week, at that moment my guide & I were the only persons inside the Dome.It being a hot summer day, I was suffering somewhat from heat exhaustion (dizzy and weak). My guide took my hand and led me to what appeared to a section inside the building that was covered by a canvas. "Put your hands through this." Following his instructions I reached through an opening in the canvas to where my hand felt like it was in some sort of indentation in a very hard rock. "You have your hand in the footstep of Mohammed" said the guide* Immediately it felt like an electric current had passed through my hand, whereupon my head cleared and I became, if anything, hyper alert. I attributed this turnabout to the emotional shock that the words "hands in the footstep of Mohammed" had delivered me. A couple years later I told this story to a Sufi. Asked him what he thought the above experience was about, "a signal from Mohammed, perhaps?" "No, from god, he replied," claiming that the same thing had happened to him. Being an atheist and rarely delving into mysticism, I still believe that my sudden recovery from heat exhaustion was some sort of neuropsychological reaction.

      Lastly, another unusual occurrence upon departing from Palestine. Just before leaving the hotel its mgr. gave me if a dinner plate for me to deliver to a relative of his back home. While waiting in the airport lobby for boarding, a young Israeli approached and asked me if I had been asked to carry any dinner plates back home. I said yes and gave it to him. He said wait here. Shortly thereafter he returned, thanked me and gave me back the plate. What's this about, I wandered. Later, I read that such plates were sometimes used to conceal explosives.

      Enough to turn anyone paranoid, don;t you think?

      *later he recanted and said that scholars doubted this was historically correct

  • Romney echoes neocons: Trump will lead U.S. 'into the abyss'
    • So the neocons won't support Trump because he's pro-torture and doesn't support an interventionist policy guided by principles of democracy and human rights. Yeah, like they're really upset by Israel's crimes against humanity, its apartheid system of government in occupied Palestine, or the U.S.-backed Saudi war on the people of Yemen. Yet the neocons hardly mention Israel? What, are they getting cold feet about openly supporting the Zionist criminal enterprise? Sorry, neocons, no use pretending you're only interested in what's good for America. Much too late for that. After all you're widely known as hard core Israel-firsters. As Israel goes down, so will you - glub, glub, glub, glub!

  • Why I support a one state solution and still consider myself a Zionist
    • The proper name for an endeavor by which one people occupy a native people's homeland, rename it & cleanse it of its natives is settler colonialism, not self-determination. Self-determination is what Palestinians have been struggling for - that along with freedom and independence - ever since their homeland was taken over by European Jews. It's nice that the author visualizes Jewish self-determination co-existing in partnership with Palestinian self-determination, but he should realize by now that such an arrangement has to be up to the native (ie Palestinian) people. Anything less will amount to handing colonialism a lifeline.

  • As Trump takes on the neocons, Kristol likens him to Hitler
  • Why does the U.S. continue to betray a courageous, dynamic Muslim leader in the Maldives?
    • Something's missing from this article. What is there about the islands that makes them of special interest to the U.S? Does our government plan to exploit the presence of the Maldives' militant Islamic groups so as to cajole reluctant S. Pacific and Asian nations into granting it additional U.S. military bases?

  • Jeffrey Goldberg compares Iranian Jews to 'petting zoo' animals
    • Isn't it about time that the Atlantic let go of Jeffrey Goldberg, the ex-IDF (or is he still in the IDF reserves) soldier whose every article is predicated on his belief that both the U.S. and Israel are as Beacons on the Hill, with Israel, of course, by far the shiniest of the two. As for the people in these two countries, their lives, their well-being, so long as they don't oppose U.S./Israel hegemony, he couldn't care less what happens to them.

  • Palestine and the anxiety of existence
    • So far the Zionists have been committing what's been referred to as slow genocide. Lately, though, they seem to have become somewhat bolder and are accelerating the pace. Could there been a secret "Final Solution" conference, such as the Nazis had at Wannsee on January 20,1942? If so, weighing international opinion, as they always do, perhaps Israel's criminal leaders figure that, given the rampant Islamophobia now enveloping the West, they could get away with full throttle genocide. If they opt for a final solution, will history show them to have been right?

    • the stone as an act of rejection

      and since stones are most everywhere

      no wonder zionists forever drive themselves mad

  • Most US Jewish students don't see Israel as 'civilized' or a 'democracy,' Luntz tells secret anti-BDS conference
    • doomsday averted

      a way way back when Jewish Zionists took over Palestine
      &, based on bronze age myths & on the Holocaust
      claimed it for themselves;
      no reason why not, they insisted
      since for a people without a land
      nothing could be more right than a land without a people (& never mind that Palestinians have comprised the majority of Palestine's population for most of the past 2 millennia)
      besides we speak not just for ourselves but for Jews everywhere
      so you owe us, lantsmen
      your money
      your influence
      your unquestioning support
      which the Zionists {Jewish nationalists} got,
      at least initially and for several decades thereafter,
      except, that is, for a few holdouts who refused to forsake the time
      honored Jewish tradition of always being on the side of the oppressed, never on the side of the oppressor,
      and as the oppression of Palestinians by Zionists intensified,
      more and more people, Jews included, took note of the crimes against Palestinians that were being committed in the name of world Jewry.
      but refusing to be complicit in these crimes, increasing numbers of Jews took to voicing the words "Not in Our Name."
      soon this message represented the sentiment of a majority of Jews, especially, but not limited to its youth,
      after which, Israel's days were numbered, as this turnabout coincided with a mass uprising (the ultimate Intifada) of the Palestinian people.
      and that's how the long sought justice for Palestine was attained. Once this happened it didn't take long for justice and peace to envelop the world

  • Videos: Proof of Sanders's lifelong anti-racist activism breaks on eve of Nevada Caucus
    • Publicly engaging in an anti-racist rally when he was 20 years old? That's mighty significant! Did any of the other candidates (either party) ever stand up in public against racial discrimination?

  • 'New Yorker' glosses my reality (when it renders 'Death to Arabs' chant as 'I hate all Arabs')
    • Expect Israel to set up one of its Palestinian ghettos as a model integrated community, much like Theresienstadt, the Nazi concentration camp that the Nazis presented to outsiders (and on film) as a model Jewish settlement. Undoubtedly David Remnick would publish an article about it in the New Yorker under the title "Israel, a model integrated Society."

  • Resisting anti-Semitism does not contradict resisting the Israeli state
    • since Jewish Zionists crimes against the Palestinian people is what incites antisemitism worldwide, it follows that Jewish Zionists (and their non-Jewish supporters) are the real antisemites. Indeed, were there justice for Palestine, antisemitism would be reduced to a size that could be flushed down a toilet.

  • 'Other ways of being Jewish are available' -- a poetic response to expressions of hatred on Facebook
    • back to the basics

      as the reality of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict becomes ever more clear

      the split between racist and humanist Jews can only widen

      racist Jew on the side of the Jewish settlers

      humanist Jew on the side of the Palestinians

      which side is to prevail depending upon whether the love that underlies humanism

      can overcome the hatred so intrinsic to racism

  • The irreconcilable differences of liberal Zionism
  • Sanders should declare a foreign policy of working with Iran in a 'post-hegemonic' world -- Pampinella
  • Bernie Sanders' spirituality is resonating with young religious 'None's
    • Organizations such as Jewish Voice for Peace and Jews Say No should challenge Sanders on his stance vis a vis Justice for Palestine, same as they took on the NYT on its coverage of the same issue. Best they do this creatively too, as the response to their faux NYT has been simply amazing.

    • Well said, Phil. Another criticism from the left is that Sanders isn't a real socialist, that he's leading his followers towards just another populist dead-end, etc etc. Except a movement for Medicare for all, free college tuition, busting-up big banks, making corporations and billionaires pay their fair share of taxes, getting serious about global warming, just might puts a stopper on what's been a forty year slide towards neolib-style fascism. Add to this Sanders track record of having voted against the Iraq War (yeh, I know, he later supported annual Iraq War appropriations, as well as voting to attack Libya), along with his speaking out repeatedly against our getting into these permanent wars, and, well, doesn't this represent the beginnings of a significant leftward shift? True, Sanders hasn't budged significantly on Palestine/Israel, but based upon how responsive he was a few months ago when confronted by members of Black Lives Matter, who's to say that us anti-Zionists can't convince him to lean towards justice for Palestine. Assuming, of course, that he's serious about the presidency.

      But why not just wait for the Sanders bubble to burst (as per the Jesse Jackson campaigns of the eighties), whereupon a bonafide leftist resistance will emerge and lead us to that just and peaceful world that so many of us crave? Because once moving forward our sustaining progress will be easier, and because time's running out, what with perpetual war + global warming = doomsday.

  • 'I cannot support Israel as long as Netanyahu is in office'-- many American Jews are saying
    • Elderly Jewish Zionists aren't going to change. At best most are dual-loyalists. With millennials and subsequent generations, Zionism's hold on America becomes progressively weaker. It is up to our youth, then, to educate Americans on the racist nature of Israel and for an end to the special relationship. Members of anti-Zionist/pro-Palestinian organizations such as Jewish Voices for Peace know this. Their membership is growing. Their effort merits the support of anti-Zionists of all religious persuasions.

  • Cultural Zionism good, political Zionism bad
    • Once a native people have taken back their homeland, is there even one instance where the former colonizers and newly liberated natives live together in one harmonious society based on equality with liberty and justice for all? More often than not what happens is the former settlers, rather than accept being "downgraded" to no more than one among equals, opt to return to their (or their forebears land of origin. Since over half of Jewish Israelis carry two passports, once Palestine is liberated what'll probably happen is that a goodly number of them will bid adieu to Palestine and move to wherever their second Passport takes them. And based on recent experiences elsewhere in which the natives fought and won back their homelands (Vietnam Algeria, Mozambique), expect most of the Zionist colonizers to pack up and leave ASAP.

  • Did Obama blunder in Haiti because he has to pay so much attention to Israel?
    • The U.S. has been interfering in the internal affairs of Haiti for at least two centuries now. Initially said interference had to do with slaveowner fear that a successful revolution in Haiti might inspire African slaves in America to seek their own freedom. More recently what drives U.S. interventions is the fear of the emergence of the "good example", a nation that takes a path that's outside of what's "permissible" (ie independent of the neoliberal hegemon). That's why the U.S. made sure that Jean-Bertrand Aristide was toppled (twice) in the nineties, and why puppet governments have been the norm ever since. Has to do with the revolutionary spirit of the Haitian people. After more than two centuries of collective struggle, Haitians sense almost instinctively when it's time to and how to rise up and take back their nation. They epitomize the maxim that a people united can never be defeated*. So saying that President Obama's inattentiveness to Haiti is the cause of the rebellion now sweeping this island nation is like saying the Iraq War was a consequence of George W. Bush's stupidity, since both the rebellion and the war are consistent with the U.S. drive for world domination, something that, to date, has been more or less independent of who happens to be in the White House and what sort of blunders he supposedly made.

      *some will insist that the failure of Haiti's ongoing struggle disproves this maxim. But said failure is attributable to outside (U.S. or U.S.-led) interventions, and I have no doubt that the Haitian spirit will eventually prevail.

  • Jewish organizations look to co-opt 'intersectionality' in the fight against BDS
    • By equating BDS with antisemitism Zionist organizations expect to deter anti-racist movements from making alliances with BDS activists? Except it's not Jews per se but Zionist Jews (specifically) and the Zionist entity (Israel) which occupies the homeland (Palestine) of the Palestinian people that BDS is opposing. And even though Israeli leaders claim that they speak for all Jews, the presence of Jews in BDS, either directly or via membership in BDS allied Jewish organizations such as JVP &JSP, exposes this claim to be false. Another Zionist falsehood is their accusation that pro-Palestinian/anti-Zionist Jews are self-haters. The mistake here is that of equating Zionism (Jewish nationalism) with being Jewish. Nothing could be farther from the truth, at least for Jews like myself who express our faith through always siding with the oppressed, never with the oppressor, even (better, especially) when the oppressor happens to be a co-religionist, as in the Israeli occupation of Palestine. As for BDS's alleged antisemitism, the movement's leaders have repeatedly disavowed antisemitism. Once again, what they oppose, same as a growing number of Jews, is the Israeli settler colonization of another people's homeland. Simple as that!

  • 'Little Jewboy' moment highlights coming divorce between US Jews and Israel
    • Undoubtedly for some if not most who oppose the Zionist regime the reason for their doing so has to do with our common humanity, but for others there's enough antisemitism building up in them that they're committing antisemitic acts (including violence), such that police have been assigned to guard synagogues in France, Spain & other European nations. Israeli leaders, of course, are ecstatic over this. For some time now they've been appealing to French Jews to "come home." They must figure that six hundred thousand French Jews (a significant percentage of whom are "chosen" (ie Ashkanazi) might stave off the much feared but inevitable demographic turnabout (whereby Palestinians outnumber Jews) for a year or so. Such indifference to actual Jewish suffering has a long history, with the infamous statement by David Ben Gurion at a meeting of "left" Zionists telling it as it was and still is - "If I knew it would be possible to save all the children in Germany by bringing them over to England and only half of them by transporting them to Eratz Israel, then I opt for the second alternative."

    • At a time when Zionist Israel's violence against Palestinians is stoking Antisemitism throughout the world, Jews who speak out against Israel are self-haters? Pure nonsense, since it is the Israeli perpetrators of said violence (along with their Jewish supporters elsewhere) who are the self-haters. After all it is their actions that endanger world Jewry, not the words or deeds of Jews who oppose them and Israel. Indeed, always being on the side of the oppressed, even (better, especially) when the oppressor happens to be Jewish, for many of us, goes to the essence of what it is to be a Jew.

  • As the calendar turns to 2016, there is not much hope for the future in Gaza
    • once again -

      Gaza and the Warsaw Ghetto
      same place
      different times
      while the world stands by

      Zionism and Nazism
      same deadly hatred
      different target
      while the world stands by
      in control

  • Small victories
    • By example your effort in Seattle shows what steadfastness, being well prepared and remaining cool under fire can accomplish. Congratulations.

  • Sick of Zionism’s stranglehold on Jewish culture? There is an alternative.
  • Goodbye to all that (my Jewish-WASP shtik)
    • Seems to me that Phil adheres to Mahatma Gandhi's adage about being that which you wish to see in the world. And if I'm reading him correctly that world would be one of liberty, justice and equality, with everyone considered to be of equal importance in the total scheme of things as well as the day to day.

  • Israeli ambassador flings Nazi label at Israeli leaders, after latest authoritarian step
  • Infected by atrocity
    • corr.
      .....between those who side with the slave/oppressed/occupied.....

    • "On the one hand the problem is that, as in all religions and nationalities, Jewish life and Judaism is divided between those who want justice and those who celebrate atrocities,"

      The closely related divide in America (and much of the western world) is between those who want justice and equality for all and those who want the status quo or worse. In other words, between those who side with the slave/oppressed/occupier and those who side with the slave-owner/oppressor/occupier.

  • Video: O little invasion of Bethlehem
    • cause and effect

      Zionism and Nazism
      same deadly hate
      different targets
      while the world stands by
      run amok

      Gaza and the Warsaw Ghetto
      same place
      different times
      while the world stands by

    • Putting all Palestinians in occupied Palestine into high rise prisons in Gaza would fit the definition of genocide, as defined by the 1948 Convention on the Definition and Prevention of the Crime of Genocide, Article II of the Convention defines genocide as:

      ...any of the following acts committed with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:
      (a) Killing members of the group;
      (b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
      (c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;
      (d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
      (e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.

      Surely Israel's Incarcerating the Palestinians of Occupied Palestine in high rise buildings would meet the requirements of (c) and Israel's ongoing violence against Palestinians fits those of both (a) and (b).

    • Nothing this side of extermination is going to deter Palestinian resistance. Bethlehem during the first Intifada was nothing like this. I was there at the time and was horrified to find IDF marksmen glaring down at me from their perch on the 2nd floor of a building overlooking the main entrance to the city. Almost peaceful, one might say, in comparison to what's taking place there today. Seems that the more desperate the occupiers become, the more vicious their behavior towards Palestinians. What's holding them back from their "final solution" is uncertainty as to whether or not they'd get away with it. If they were sure they could, I doubt they'd hesitate.

  • Jewish settlers carry out another 'price tag' attack on sleeping Palestinian family
    • Those that Naftali Bennett calls "terror suspects" are merely the fringe that turns Israel into an ever more extremist entity, while, at the same time, allowing Israelis to congratulate themselves for not being like "those terrorists". It's a way they can have their cake (albeit poisoned) and eat it too.

  • Jewish Voice for Peace members say they seek 'transformation' not 'destruction' in Israel/Palestine
    • The U.S. government labels as terrorist anyone who supports terrorist organizations such as ISIS, so why shouldn't anyone supporting the terrorist state Israel also be labeled a terrorist?

  • Palestinians took over in the afternoon, at the Haaretz NIF conference
    • re: Shavit's"...In exchange for {Israel's} keeping us Jewish, American Jews must support Israel in the U.S." -

      What keeps us Jewish is always being on the side of the slave, never on the side of the slave-owner

      Since Israel occupies the Palestinian homeland (occupying another people's homeland being a form of enslavement), our opposition to Israel/support of justice for Palestine is consistent with what makes us Jewish.

  • Terrorism is an understandable response to west's wars in Middle East, realist and left writers say
    • If our nation had boots on the ground our government wouldn't get away with its perpetual wars, since when it comes to souring the public on U.S. military adventures there's nothing so effective as the sight of loved ones coming home in body bags. But how do we turn the public against wars in which there are no (or very few) body bags? Seems to me that the most direct way is for us peacemakers to make the connection between Islamic terrorist paybacks, such as what took place recently in Paris, Beirut & S.B., and the terrorist actions of the U.S. war-making apparatus. Yes, warmongers will say that such comparisons justify Islamic terrorism, but their accusations can be countered by our pointing out that, assuming our goal is to put an end to terrorism (rather than merely seeking retaliation and vengeance), this can be accomplished only by an understanding of what drives Islamic terrorists to violence. But it's not as if they haven't gone public with their explanations - The U.S.-led West's interventions in Afghanistan, Iraq, Somalia, Yemen & Libya, along with the Zionist occupation of Palestine. So if our government is serious about ending Islamic terrorism, it'll (1) call off what the Arab/Islamic world perceives to be terrorism, Western style; namely, the above military interventions, and (2) end its unconditional support of the Zionist occupiers. Right now mass mobilization and action is the only possible way to force our government even to consider such a striking turnabout in its ME policies. Surely a monumental task, but one that we must undertake, if life on earth is to survive.

  • Trump at the rightwing Jewish conference
    • Three decades ago I received a death threat after speaking out publicly against the Israeli occupation of Palestine. More recently on the same subject The Guardian newspaper has placed my comments on pre-moderation. Ah yes, intimidation and censorship. Proof, that is. that the more things change, the more they stay the same.

  • The way for Americans to take on the Islamic state is to end support for Jewish nationalism
    • Ending support for Jewish nationalism (Zionism) translates into putting an end to the U.S.-Israel special relationship, whereupon there'll be this mass exodus of Israelis to Western countries, such that Israel will be so weakened it'll be forced to negotiate with a popularly elected Palestinian leadership. A just and peaceful settlement is sure to follow. And the key to cutting off American support for Israel is educating the public to the fact that said support is the main reason "they" (the Arab/Islamic world) hate us. Yes, our military involvements elsewhere in the region (Iraq, Syria, Afghanistan, Libya, Yemen) has something to do with said hatred, but even those actions can be attributed (at least in part) to our government's blindness about Israel and its aggressive behavior towards its neighbors. What's needed, then, is an ongoing campaign to sever the US-Israel special relationship, a movement whose slogan might be something like, "Defeat IS/ End US support for Israel."

  • Seachange in public opinion: 'I am tired of Israel using US-made rockets to bomb Palestinians so that ultra-conservatives can steal their land'
    • Once again,

      One is either on the side of the slave or the slave-owner

      Palestinians are slaves by dint of their homeland, Palestine, being occupied by European Jews

      Occupying another people's land is to enslave them

      And since none of us will be free until the last chain is broken

      on whose side am I, are you, are we?

  • Only way to save Israel is for US to get out of peace process -- Friedman of Peace Now
    • "The only thing that can save Israel is the U.S. getting out of the peace process"?

      three thoughts:

      1) Why save Israel (the state, not its people)?

      2) There is only a fake peace process.

      3) Once America's unconditional support for Israel ends - "look, there goes the so-called Jewish & democratic state."

  • 'The Palestinian body finally achieves the approving gaze of the settler'
    • The sight of settlers so casually observing (one settler even photographing) the dead body of the Palestinian teenager Farouq Abdul Qader Sedr contrasts sharply with the scene that would have taken place, had it been an Israeli instead of a Palestinian who'd been killed. Then a photograph, had one been taken, would have revealed visibly anguished Israelis mourning the loss of one of their own. Such indifference to the murder of an oppressed other is characteristic of societies in which a self-designated "superior" people takes control of, demonizes and dehumanizes what they consider to be an "inferior" people. Invariably this occurs in colonial situations, whereby an outside power (European in most cases) invades and conquers an indigenous people, as took place in what became known as the Americas, and has been going on for over a century in Palestine. Here the colonizers happen to be European Jews, with the Palestinians its indigenous people. Resistance by the indigenous people is the inevitable consequence of settler colonization, with liberation its ultimate outcome.

  • 'Most-read' article at Washington Post calls Israel 'savage, unrepairable society'
    • Israel and Nazi Germany

      same supremacist credo
      same intolerance of dissent
      different dehumanized others
      while the world stands by

  • Two establishment Jews (Harvard and Microsoft) endorse boycott of Israel and 'single state' in Washington Post
    • In addition to expressing their love for Israel by coming out publicly for BDS, the two professors might consider challenging the WH and Congress to terminate their support for the Zionist state - military, economic and diplomatic - thereby proving that they too love Israel.

  • Chaos in Jerusalem is a warning of things to come
    • History repeating itself?

      Kristallnacht: Nov. 9-10, 1938- Mobs of German non-Jews and Nazi Stormtroopers go on a mad spree in the cities of Germany and Austria, attacking and killing hundreds of Jews, burning their businesses and synagogues

      Bloody October 2015 - Mobs of Jews patrol Jerusalem and Israeli cities calling out "Death to Arabs" and killing upwards of 40 Palestinians.

      the big lie of the 1930's - Chancellor Adolf Hitler blames Jews for Germany's defeat in WW I

      today's big lie - Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu blames a long dead Grand Mufti of Jerusalem for the Holocaust

  • Latest Palestinian teens shot dead are 16, 17, and 18
    • from the Ghetto in America to Jerusalem in Palestine

      the occupier brutalizes the occupied

      and he mows them down


      mows them down

      so keep fightin back

      righteous ones

      ain't got nothin to lose

      nothin at all

      by standing up tall

  • Most of the mourning I've done as a Zionist turned anti-Zionist has been alone
    • Liz Rose,

      your turning from Zionist to anti-Zionist

      calls for rejoicing, not mourning

      what's more

      the whole world rejoices with you

      count on it

  • Just what Palestine needs: more religion-addled American Jews with big guns and selfie sticks
  • Jerusalem at a breaking point
    • is this the Zionist equivalent of Kristallnacht?

      those two horrific days in November'38 when mobs of SA paramilitary forces and civilians roamed the streets in search of Jews

      what's now considered to have been the beginning of Nazi Germany's Final Solution

      only this time it's mobs of Jewish soldiers and civilians out in the streets searching for Palestinians

      the beginning of Zionist Israel's Final Solution? -

      a turnabout of sorts

      whereby participating in the colonization of a native people's land somehow transmogrifies the former victim into the victimizer

  • 'Third intifada was launched,' Palestinian law student posted before carrying out fatal attack in Jerusalem
  • How can a 'New York Times' reader possibly know what is truly happening in Israel/Palestine?
    • Gaza and the Warsaw Ghetto
      same place
      different time
      while the world stands by

      Zionism and Naziism
      same deadly hatred
      different target
      while the world stands by

  • Israeli embassy's attack on Rosengarten just made her stronger
    • an accurate Israel-Nazi Germany comparison -

      Gaza and the Warsaw Ghetto

      same place
      different time
      while the world stands by

  • Remi Kanazi will be a poet for as long as the western media is on coffee break
    • solidarity

      since none of us will be free

      until that last chain is broken

      doesn't it all boil down to

      each of us having to decide

      on which side


      or slave-owner


      or oppressor


      or occupier

      and that only the slave/oppressed/occupied within each of us

      (the there but for go I)

      can free us all?

  • Department of Projectile Vomiting
    • With AIPAC et al discrediting themselves on account of their Israel-firstness being exposed, there's more space not only for us to further reduce their influence, but to advance the cause of justice for Palestine. Simply stated, as they go down, we go up. Assuming, of course, that we take advantage of this opening.

    • For his contributions to improve government policy, social welfare, or political understanding, the American Enterprise Institute is honoring the still at large war criminal Benjamin Netanyahu? Who will the AEI honor next, the also still at large war criminal George W Bush, for having eliminated Iraq's nonexistent WMD and {not} bringing democracy to that nation? And just think, he accomplished all this at the bargain price of 5000+ American lives, not to mention the half-million Iraqi lives wasted.

  • Everyone's kicking AIPAC now that it's down
    • On account of its blatant Israel-firstness AIPAC et al are suffering a loss of credibility. Deservedly so, considering their role in much of the violence and turmoil that afflict the Middle East., But what this take-down of AIPAC means vis-a-vis the attainment of justice for Palestine depends upon how effectively those of us in this struggle take advantage of the space that the decline of Israel-firsters affords us. Space in the marketplace of information, that is, with which we can reach the public re: the righteousness of the struggle of the Palestinian people for freedom and independence. Simply put, as AIPAC et al go down, we go up.

  • Bernie Sanders is 'radical' on economic policy but a pussycat for Israel
    • Once again, Bernie Sanders must be challenged by anti-Zionist activists on the issue of Israel/Palestine, if for no other reason than to make I/P a campaign issue. Somehow we have to convince the public that peace in the Middle East begins with justice for Palestine, that without said peace we face a continuation of all the multiple permanent wars in the region, wars that are so costly they'll leave little to nothing for President Sander's to fulfill his promises re: economic justice. Our challenging Sanders will enable us not only to raise the I/P issue, but to motivate the public into joining us activists in pressuring Sanders to get with it.

    • Bernie Sanders has to be challenged at his rallies by a delegation of pro-Palestinian/anti-Zionist activists demanding that he reconsider his position on the I-P conflict, as well as his embrace of Wahhabi Saudi Arabia as the foremost U.S. ally in the Middle East. Will this tactic move Sanders, as it did when Black Lives Matter confronted him? Probably not, but until representatives from, say, Jewish Voices for Peace challenge him at his rallies, how will we know for sure?

  • 'NYT' and 'NYRB' publish important pieces on Jewish terrorism
  • Long Island synagogue marks High Holidays with thanks to Israeli soldiers in Gaza war
    • Froggy,

      Yes, of course, praying for a foreign army. Need some help on that one. A relationship between two nations (er, one nation and an entity) that's analogous to the U.S.-Israel axis? Any thoughts? I did consider substituting the Vatican for any German religious body but not sure a Long Island synagogue-Vatican comparison is appropriate.

    • piotr,

      so in your opinion it all boils down to the Zionist side being the good side, the Palestinian side, the bad side? Nice that it's that simple. But you omitted one important person, Grand Mufti Amin al-Husayni of Jerusalem. Don't you remember, he met with Adolf Hitler? Did you leave him out because you thought we might counter with the names of Zionist officials who collaborated with the Nazis? Rudolf Kastner, for one, the representative in Hungary of the Jewish Agency who cut a deal with the Nazis that allowed over a thousand wealthy Zionist Jews (including he and his family, of course) to depart for Palestine; the quid pro quo being Kastner's giving the Nazis a list of names and addresses of Jews to be deported. Consequently nearly 450,000 Jews were deported. With Zionist "friends" such as Kastner, it's not surprising that so few Jews escaped the gas chambers.

    • I don't know if any German religious body ever gave thanks to Hitler's Waffen-SS troops for having quashed the Warsaw Ghetto uprising, but if such an occurrence did take place, it would be the WW II equivalent of the Long Island Synagogue's marking the High Holidays with thanks to the Israeli soldiers in the Gaza war.

  • 'New Yorker' says anti-Zionism is 'firmly rooted' in British left, and it's anti-Semitic
    • Lane envisions Labor MPs as being opposed to Jeremy Corbyn's leftist proposals. Initially maybe, but watch them move to the left as the popular support that gave Corbyn his victory puts pressure on Labor MPs to rally behind their new leader. And despite Lane's belief that proposals for public ownership of railroads and dismantling Britain's Trident missiles belong to a prior era, opinion polls indicate that such proposals still resonate with the public. Having participated a half-century ago in one of Britain's Aldermaston Marches, I can attest to the strength and fervor of the antinuclear movement there, today just as much as yesterday, based on the Scottish National Party's call for ridding itself of the Trident.

  • Iran Deal's liberation: Judaism is not Zionism
    • Today Judaism and Zionism are no longer united in the American Jewish mind. Well enough, but it's just as important that non-Jewish Americans also recognize that this is so. As for the the Iran deal being liberatory for Jews, this may be true in the sense that false beliefs are as shackles on the mind, but for the Jew (all peoples, actually), the attainment of justice for the Palestinian people will be the ultimate moment of truth. So while it's quite natural that we acknowledge to ourselves the importance of this victory over Zionism, not to forget that this much anticipated victory lies just ahead. Onward together!

  • Video: Israel's celebrated Labour Party 'is the mother and father of racism', says member of Knesset
    • Israel is a settler colonial entity

      without exception settler colonial entities are racist

      therefore all of its institutions are racist

      the labor party is an Israeli institution

      no surprise that it is & has always been racist

  • 'NYT' openly counts Jewish politicians, and Obama and Clinton both reach out to Netanyahu
    • As if he's having misgivings about his role in securing the nuclear accord, President Obama has vowed to preserve Israel's qualitative military edge?

      Oh no you don't, Mr. President.

      Why not?

      Because the peace movement that helped you convince forty-two Senators to support the accord won't let you get away with giving Israel the tools & wherewithal to go it alone against Iran.

      How will we accomplish this?


  • Don't trade a war on Palestinians for a war on Iran -- Berman
    • How to prevent Israel from once again attacking Gaza?

      We pressure Congress to end the special relationship.

      Once isolated Israel won't dare attack any nation.

      What about AIPAC and the rest of the Israel-firsters?

      We treat them like the losers that they are.


  • 'NYT' misrepresents Iran's prediction about 'Zionist regime' to mean 'Israel'
    • Timeline for Dissolution of Zionist Regime

      2015 - Iran nuclear accord

      2016 - anti-Zionist movement pressures political candidates on special relationship, thereby influencing November election

      2017 - New President feels pressure from anti-Z'ers

      2018 - BDS seriously impacts Israeli economy

      2019 - exodus of Jewish-Israelis accelerates

      2020 - Israeli government agrees to no pre-conditions peace conference with Palestinians

      2021 - Dissolution of Zionist regime

  • AIPAC is going out with a whimper not a bang
    • Former AIPAC boss Dine:
      "We have to heal the wounds inflicted by the clashes over the Iran deal as soon as possible.The future of the U.S., the Middle East and Israel depend on it."

      Doesn't this tell us that the Israel Lobby is on the ropes. Our task? To keep pummeling away until they go down for the count*. And just because AIPAC was able to recover from the 1982 AWACS debacle doesn't mean they can recover from this one. For one, there was no organized Jewish anti-Zionist movement then, there is now. Secondly, no BDS. Thirdly, we can do this!

      *please forgive the sports metaphor

    • Furthermore, given this victory over Israel-firsters along with their prominence in the neocon cabal, what will the imminent dissolution of Israel (the entity, not its people), portend for the global so-called order?

    • One crucial victory for us peacemakers over the Israel Lobby, but continued progress depends upon our ability to keep Israel-firsters on the defensive.

  • Why do Jewish legislators carry more weight on Iran Deal?
    • They may carry more weight because AIPAC and other Israel-firster organizations/individuals are trying to pin the label "anti-Semite" on members of Congress who support the nuclear accord (for Jewish members the pejorative used is "self-hating Jew" Despite these attacks by Israel-firsters, most Jews in Congress have come out in favor of the accord. And based on opinion polls, the position of Jewish legislators on this issue closely mirrors that of Jewish-Americans. What will the general public make of all this michigas? Will they think "Best we stay out because it's strictly a Jewish affair", or, recognizing that what's at stake here, war or peace, effects every American, will it pay close attention to what's being said and decide for themselves, on which side, that of the Israel-firsters or that of those who put America's interests before that of any other country. As for the accusation that Jews who support this nuclear accord are self-haters, contrariwise, considering the fact that it is Israel's mistreatment of Palestinians that is responsible for most of today's antisemitism (google spikes in antisemitism after Israeli attacks on Gaza), it is Israel (claiming, as it does, that it speaks and acts on behalf of world Jewry) and its supporters who are the real anti-Semites, for it is their violent deeds that incite this backlash. After all, isn't it antisemitic to commit acts of violence that themselves lead to antisemitic responses? That's not to excuse such responses, but to attack another people when it's almost certain that there'll be a price to pay? Let Israel cease and desist in its aggression against the people of Palestine and antisemitism would be reduced to a size that could be flushed down the toilet. The nuclear accord represents a step in this direction, since it will give peace a chance.

  • The Israel lobby is alive and well-- and split
    • @Stephen Shenfield

      Not ward off accusations of antisemitism, but render them resistant to such taunts. Has to do with the spirit and power of solidarity.

    • the struggle is for the minds of all Americans, not Jewish-Americans only. Too many Americans avoid entering the fray because of fear that they'll be labeled antisemitic. And this is where Jewish-Americans can best serve the cause of justice for Palestine - by expressing such a profound and unwavering commitment to justice for Palestine that those Americans, who, up to now, have been holding back for fear of being called antisemitic, will feel free to step forward, each saying something like "label me antisemitic if you choose, but clearly I'm not, being that, in this struggle on behalf of human rights, I'm part of a diverse coalition that has many Jews in its ranks?"

  • Debacle for the Israel lobby: Booker jilts Boteach, and Netanyahu sinks AIPAC
    • Now that the myth about the invincibility of the Israel lobby has been shattered, how long before the special relationship between Israel and the U.S. is no more? A year? Five years? And with the U.S. no longer Israel's guardian angel, will Jewish Israelis begin to doubt Israel's long term viability? How widespread does such doubt have to be before those Israelis who have dual citizenship play it safe and take off for some other land? No problem, though, because there'll be plenty of Palestinians eager and ready to exercise their right of return, thereby taking the place of Israelis who opt to live elsewhere. Gradually, then, the peaceful dissolution of Israel. In its place, Palestine rising, the homeland of people of various religions and ethnicities, living together peacefully based on equality and justice for all.

  • Obama and the Zionists
    • Michel Siegal of the Jewish Federations told President Barack Obama that "Jews get unsettled and anxious whenever there's "daylight" between the American government and Israel? Some Jews, perhaps, but fewer and fewer now, based on recent polls as well as on the rapid growth of anti- Zionist organizations such as Jewish Voices for Peace. Surely President Obama knows this, what with Jewish supporters of the Iran nuclear agreement going all out to bring their position on said accord before Congress and the White House. Perhaps he was too polite to remind his Israel-firster visitors that, despite their claim, they don't speak for all Jews. Too bad there was no one in the oval office to speak for the growing number of us Jews who are grateful for all this "daylight" and eagerly look forward to the day when the special relationship between the the U.S. and Israel will be a thing of the past.

  • Jewish community is Humpty Dumpty-- it won't come back together again, and shouldn't
  • 'NYT' and Chris Matthews are frank about Jewish role in Iran Deal debate
    • No matter their religion, color, ethnicity or sexual orientation, our elected representatives in Congress must concern themselves with the merit of this nuclear agreement vis-a-vis its importance to the U.S. of A.. Those whose primary concern is heeding Prime Minister Netanyhahu's call for the accord to be rejected are Israel-firsters. As such they should be impeached by their fellow congresspersons/senators &/or primaried out of office, whichever comes first.

  • Videos: 'Vanity Fair' story about anti-Semitic pogrom in Paris is falling apart
    • Marie Brenner wonders whether French Jews should leave their country.

      Earlier this year Israeli Prime Minister called not only upon French Jews but all European Jews to immigrate to Israel.

      Not surprising since by its own admission Israel faces a "demographic problem",

      which might be alleviated, temporarily, at least, by the the quick fix that the mass exodus of 600,000 French Jews would provide.

      Dirty tricks, such as those carried out last year in Paris by the French version of the Jewish Defense League, are tactics previously used by Zionists in their efforts to stampede Jews into emigrating to Israel (google Lavon Affair).

      Why is Vanity Fair allowing its pages to be used to propagandize for Jewish immigration to Israel?

  • President Obama wants us to argue about the special relationship
    • way way back during the presidency of Barack Obama

      when only a nuclear deal stood in the way of a war against Iran

      a deal that the Israel-firsters

      were desperately seeking to prevent

      no matter to them the possibility of WW III

      after all

      wouldn't be there children coming home in body bags

      only it turned out

      inspired as they were by peacemakers of all racial, political and religious persuasions

      that at the last moment the public woke up

      with the sanity of the people united quickly prevailing over the madness of Israel-firsters

      soon thereafter the special relationship between the U.S. and Israel ended

      that there be no war no more, nowhere, never again

      with special thanks to mondoweiss

    • petition signed

    • these Israel-firsters are scared

      and well they should be

      knowing as they must that their putting the interests of Israel before those of the U.S. is a risky business

      especially, should they succeed in turning Congress against the Iran deal

      and by so doing

      once again the public is to be confronted with the spectacle of body bags coming home from the Middle East

      each containing what remains of a life


      in another war that could (should) have been averted

    • Zionism is a form of settler colonialism

      all forms of colonialism are racist

      Judaism is not racist

      therefore Zionism is not the same as Judaism

      what is it then?

      a 19th century racist credo that's out to hijack Judaism

    • Zionists fear that "opening up the argument will crack the American support system"

      as when Humpty Dumpty had his big fall, only in this instance it'll be -

      all the Israel lobbyists and all the dual loyalists couldn't put the special relationship together again

  • It's not bigoted to call out the Israel lobby over Iran Deal

Showing comments 2045 - 2001