News

Millions disenfranchised in Israeli vote due solely to ethnicity and geography

Who Votes
(Click on the image below to view it larger.)

Gary Spedding comments on yesterday’s Israeli elections in his post “No ‘Democracy in Action’ for the Disenfranchised“:

I thought to highlight the overriding flaw found in the idea of Israel having an airtight democracy. This is demonstrable simply by discussing just who does get a vote in Israel’s democracy, highlighting the fact that one in every 4.5 people living under Israeli rule does not have the right to vote.

Indeed whilst their Israeli neighbors living in the illegal settlements, constructed on snatched Palestinian land, were casting their votes in locally available ballot boxes, the completely disenfranchised Palestinians living under Israeli rule in the Occupied Territories were not even able to utilize the privilege of voting because as Liel Maghen learned and expertly articulated; the right to vote is not a basic right in Israel, but a privilege dependent on geography and ethnicity.

Yousef Munayyer makes a similar, if more blunt, point in his post sharing the official election results from the occupied territories:

With 100% of Ballots Counted, here’s how the following localities voted –

Ramallah (pop 400000 )
Total Ballots Cast: 0*

Nablus (pop 150000 ):
Total Ballots Cast: 0*

Al-Khalil (pop 250000 )
Total Ballots Cast: 0*

Qalqilya (pop 50000 )
Total Ballots Cast: 0*

Bethlehem (pop 30000)
Total Ballots Cast: 0*

Tulkarem (pop 70000)
Total Ballots Cast: 0*

Jericho (pop 20000)
Total Ballots Cast: 0*

Jenin (pop 50000)
Total Ballots Cast: 0*

Gaza (pop 1.7 million)
Total Ballots Cast: 0*

265 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

And what if everyone could vote? It remains totally useless in a “Jewish state”.

I’m not sure if this line of thought is productive. If you’re saying that the Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza should have the right to vote, aren’t you saying that the West Bank and Gaza are not in fact occupied but should be considered legitimately part of Israel, thus implicitly condoning the military conquest in 1967?

Adam Horowitz.
This is really Amazing…….. As a joke it might amuse someone.
Since when do those who live in Ramallah Have an Israeli Citizenship ????

When did Israel declare on the Annexation of the west bank or Gaza.
Israel Left Gaza, Gaza has it’s own voted government…….
Let me tell you another thing…….. Israelis that hold an Israeli Passport, cannot vote if they are out side of Israel…….
You just made it clear, why a ONE state is not an issue at all.
I wonder how far you can go…….

1. How would you write this story when the Palestinian Authority has an election? Should Israelis demand the right to elect the Palestinian leadership?
2. Palestinian residents of Jerusalem have had the right to Israeli citizenship for many years, allowing them to vote if they so choose. (Yes, it is complicated…) But in general, the national consensus was to NOT exercise that right. Are you suggesting that this is a strategic mistake, and Palestinian residents should hurry up and get citizenship so they can vote?

The right to vote everywhere is a privilege based on ethnicity and geography. I can’t vote in Spanish, French or British elections because I don’t meet the ethnic or geographical criteria. So what?