Trending Topics:

Nightmares in Jalazone: Families deal with trauma following Israeli torture

on 7 Comments

It is very tempting to take the side of the perpetrator. All the perpetrator asks is that the bystander do nothing. He appeals to the universal desire to see, hear, and speak no evil. The victim, on the contrary, asks the bystander to share the burden of pain.

– Judith Lewis Herman, M.D. “Trauma and Recovery”

To understand psychiatric home visits in Palestine necessitates forgoing Western assumptions about patient confidentiality, privacy, and timeliness. Though individual patients often refer themselves to treatment centers after a release from prison, the difficulty of traveling to and from major cities requires therapists to make home visits. Families then participate in the session as a group, thereby coming to better understand their family member’s situation and relieving some of their own symptoms as well. Throughout Palestine, families are regularly made to feel that their own house is unsafe and outside of their control. Violence may overtake a peaceful setting without warning, and to resist an arrest would be to invite danger on the rest of the relatives. A study conducted by the Ramallah Treatment and Rehabilitation Center for Victims of Torture (TRC) examining arrests as trauma-inducing events explains that, “92% of arrests [surveyed] happened at home, and most of [them] happened…in the time periods of deep sleep after midnight. This had caused severe emotional and psychological damages to the families, and doubled the impact of emotional suffering and immediate trauma” (“The Impact of Detention on Palestinian Detainees’ Families in Israeli Prisons,” 2011).

Two weeks ago, I was incredibly fortunate to visit and accompany staff from the TRC on home visits to patients. Founded by Dr. Mahmud Sehwail*, the TRC is a leading organization in the fields of psychology and research on torture survivors in the West Bank. Their work largely focuses on ex-detainees, and how to heal and re-acclimate them to society. Guided by Dr. Rania, an experienced and thoughtful social worker, we were briefed us on the patients’ history and symptoms en route to Jalazone refugee camp.

To my great surprise, the family in the camp was happy to host two Americans along with their regular therapist to talk about the violence they’d gone through, and we were greeted with tea and kisses. Dr. Rania explained the importance of this type of visit: patients have control over their environment and they tell their stories when they feel ready. Serving tea and making small talk is a simple way to prepare oneself for the discussion and reliving of traumatizing events.

The Jalazone refugee camp hangs on the outskirts of Ramallah. Serviced poorly by the UNRWA, Jalazone comprises mainly of families from central Palestinian villages that were ethnically cleansed in 1948. Home to over 11,000 people on 253 dunams, or about 25 square kilometers, space is extremely tight in Jalazone. The entire camp gives the sensation of being squeezed. Houses are built an arm’s length apart; in the building we visited, a two-floor apartment contained nine children and at least five adults.

Twenty-five-year-old Ayman was late to the session, even though he was the official patient. After some gentle prompting and with much chiming in from his parents, he narrated his experience: A few months prior, he had been arrested by IDF soldiers on a nighttime raid, beaten all over his body, and kidnapped to an Israeli prison along with the rest of the men in his family. He had recently been released, and was now unable to sleep, relax, or eat regularly for a pervasive fear of the soldiers showing up to raid his house and re-arrest him. He had taken to staying at home most of the day, dozing whenever sleep overtook him. Now, he haltingly articulated his nightmares, which sounded like exact replayings of what had happened a few months ago: being arrested for an unknown crime, attacked by soldiers, and held in a faraway prison, over and over again.

Ayman chainsmoked throughout our meeting and ran a hand through his hair every few minutes. Waves of stress emanated off his hunched body. He could not seem to stop looking toward the doors and windows, and I began to envision his phantom soldiers crashing into the room.

Judith Herman writes:

Traumatized people relive the event as though it were continually recurring in the present. It is as if time stops at the moment of trauma…[it] becomes encoded in an abnormal form of memory, which breaks spontaneously into consciousness, both as flashbacks during waking states and as nightmares during sleep…trauma arrests the course of normal development by its repetitive intrusion into the survivor’s life (36).

If Ayman were living in another political situation, he might be able to disentangle the rest of his life from the nighttime arrest, and work through the event in a space where he could be certain of his safety. However, being Palestinian in a refugee camp whose population is subject to frequent raids, beatings, and arrests, amidst a larger context of occupation and colonization of his ancestral homeland, healing from the arrest will be difficult. Being re-arrested without charge is not at all unusual, and is the single worst thing that can happen to someone already traumatized by his first arrest. Dr. Rania repeatedly informed us that the only way to heal from trauma is to remove the patient from a traumatic environment, but “in Palestine, we cannot do this.” Here, survivors must process their trauma, fear, and anxiety under the possibility that it could all happen again at any moment.

Though trauma is common in Palestine—Dr. Sehwail estimated about 25% of TRC patients are diagnosed with PTSD—seeking mental healthcare carries a stigma throughout the world, and even here, under such horrific conditions, the fear of being considered “crazy” persists. Ayman’s parents described with some anxiety their son’s ongoing terror, which had temporarily destroyed both his effort to seek employment, and their effort to get him married. Dr. Rania was careful to emphasize that what had happened to Ayman was not normal, and his brain was reacting normally to what should never have occurred. Fear lives on in his body, rendering his ordinary tasks and daily rituals nearly insurmountable challenges. Ayman told his whole story barely above a mumble, eyes fixed on the shattered glass of the front door.

His parents talked for much of the meeting. His father described to us a few years he’d spent working at a Puerto Rican restaurant in New Jersey. His worn-out English contained laughed Spanish, and he tried to chuckle through the impossibility of ever managing to secure a travel visa again, let alone leave the camp. Meanwhile, his mother explained to Dr. Rania her new policy on visitors to their home, designed to deter or at least stall aggressive soldiers: “I answer the door. He [Ayman] stays where he is. I go, no one else.” Their talk was disjointed, alternately cheerful and grave, jumping from topic to topic without transition. I tried to keep up, translate, and process each new subject as best I could. Later, on the bus back to Ramallah, Dr. Rania would tell us: “You can see, the whole family is traumatized. They don’t understand this, but they are.”

Ayman and his parents are lucky—treatment is available for them. Regular meetings with TRC staff will help them develop strategies for managing their pain, fear, and anxiety. Yet even with good counseling, his security and wellbeing will never be guaranteed, particularly in the dilapidated infrastructure of the refugee camp. He is one of thousands of young people having gone through the Israeli prison system, which is designed to weaken Palestinians and suppress their resistance to the Israeli occupation. It is 2015, and there are now several generations of trauma within Palestine, layered and complex and most going without treatment. What will be the next nightmare?

*All other names in this article have been changed.

Works Cited:

  1. Herman, Judith Lewis. Trauma and Recovery. New York, NY: Basic, 1992. Print.
  2. OCHA. Jalazone Refugee Camp Profile. N.p., n.d. Web
  3. Sohwail, Mahmud, Khader Rasras, and Wisam Sohwail. The Impact of Detention on Palestinian Detainees’ Families in Israeli Prisons “Secondary Victims of Torture, Pain and Suffering”. Rep. N.p.: Treatment and Rehabilitation Center for Victims of Torture, n.d. Print.
Lauren Jappe

Lauren Jappe has been involved in Palestine activism for several years. She graduated from Brandeis University with a B.A. in Islamic & Middle Eastern Studies and Women's & Gender Studies. She recently returned from a delegation to the West Bank co-sponsored by Interfaith Peace-Builders and the Boston-based Health and Human Rights Project, a sister organization of Jewish Voice for Peace-Boston. She tweets and retweets @ljappe1 and is based in Boston.

Other posts by .

Posted In:

7 Responses

  1. annie on December 2, 2015, 9:07 pm

    it’s chilling imagining living like this — forever.

    • Popsiq on December 6, 2015, 8:22 am

      Apparently many don’t. Therapeutic suicide stabbing seems to be an alternative to on-going mental anguish.

  2. Marnie on December 3, 2015, 12:16 am

    It’s so horrible. When your home isn’t safe enough, then what? This particular patient is a man and I hope soon he’ll be at the point he is able to experience the benefit of his therapy and maybe every moment of his life won’t be full of the flashbacks and fear he’s experiencing. I can’t imagine how difficult it is for him and his family. They’re all with PTSD, some are a bit more functional, some less.

    War crimes on top of war crimes. There is seemingly no end to this evil called the state of Israel.

  3. pabelmont on December 3, 2015, 8:39 am

    And to consider that nothing was described here other than the events of the arrest, beating, and removal — and possibility of repeat. Nothing about other torture in prison.

    Hideous. But, as American politicians are fond of saying, “Israel has a right to defend itself” as if that right is an umbrella wide enough to cover this sort of thing and all the other sorts of things Israel does, for, surely, one must see, it is all, all, defense.

    • Popsiq on December 6, 2015, 8:27 am

      Well Nazi Germany had a right to defend itself, too. Had it played by the rules there would have been no need for a Nuremburg.

      Invading another country for a slight real or imagined ( a charge leveled against Germany) doesn’t seem to be war crime any more. Apparently lining people up and killing them, as Israel takes great pains NOT to do, is the bell whether of evil.

      Decent war fighters would only do something like this ‘by accident’ or on grounds of humanitarianism, or in the heat of combat.

  4. xanadou on December 4, 2015, 5:59 pm

    Mondoweiss, could you please add Tumblr to your share sites?

    Hasbara will not let me anymore to copy and paste links to any of your articles I try post to my Tumblr blog. They (hasbara) have made my own life into a hellish nightmare on many fronts, but I am not giving up. My family had to endure much worse saving Jews from the Warsaw Ghetto during WW2. It is in their name, the dead and the few survivors, that I carry on with the family’s tradition and freely chosen obligation to give succour to the persecuted in the most exercisable manner available. Even as, to my horror, the Jews of yesteryear have been replaced by the Palestinians.

    Yes, I make sure that a clear attribution and link to the reposted article are given.

  5. gingershot on December 5, 2015, 10:48 pm

    Thank you for this article

    As posted previously, this is coming to be known as ‘Complex Trauma’, and this is a critical part in turning psychological America against Israeli DELIBERATE PSYOPS traumatization of generations. This just one of the crimes against humanity – including the human mind –

    Deliberate, conscious, emotional torture and traumatization for Zionist benefit.

    This is part of Dore Gold/Sharon’s/Weiss’s ‘formaldehyde’

    This is Bradley Burston’s ‘Israel’s Culture of the Feelgood Bully’ (aka, the sadist) on Israeli sadomasochism

    This is Alice Miller’s ‘Drama of the Gifted Child’ write large for Palestinian CHILDREN and for psychological America

    Exactly like ‘Aggressive War’ in the Nuremberg Tribunal, Apartheid and the Aggressive Wars of Apartheid contains within itself this evil of ‘Complex Trauma’

    International Military Tribunal at Nuremberg:
    “essentially an evil thing…to initiate a war of aggression…is not only an international crime; it is the supreme international crime, differing only from other war crimes in that it contains within itself the accumulated evil of the whole.

    Complex post-traumatic stress disorder

    Complex post-traumatic stress disorder (C-PTSD), also known as Developmental Trauma Disorder (DTD)[1] or complex trauma,[2] is a proposed diagnostic term for a set of symptoms resulting from prolonged stress of a social and/or interpersonal nature, especially in the context of interpersonal dependence. Subjects displaying traits associated with C-PTSD include victims of chronic maltreatment by caregivers, as well as hostages, prisoners of war, concentration camp survivors, and survivors of some religious cults.

    (my note: also explicitly children in warzones, let alone decades long warzones, read further thru article) lots of good references in this article


Leave a Reply