Piotr: Gilad, I think that you at occasion make anti-Semitic rants.
G: You are entitled to think, whether you can substantiate is obviously another matter.
Piotr: I do not recall the details, but once you discuss opinions of a Jewish Marxist on some Palestinian issue. Which you found disturbingly incorrect and you attributed the errors to the obstinate Jewishness of the writer.
G: Don’t you think that it is slightly outrageous to come with such a vague statement and yet to associate me with a racism.
I guess that this is the piece you are referring to
If you find ‘antisemitism’ there, i will be happy to discuss it
Piotr: According to your own synopsis, this guy was reducing the isssue to class warfare and imperialism. Correct or wrong, this is a standard Marxist perspective, rather than “Jewish Marxism”. Unless Jewishness of Marxism goes all the way back to Karl Marx. In any case, standard Marxism is a universalist doctrine, and so very far from tribalism.
G: If you read my paper , you will be able to stop guessing…