How about a cold water dash of reality for Rosenberg? There’s nothing that’s a given or sacred about the existence of any political/juridical entity we call a state. These organizations are the works of man, and as such all are temporal and doomed to decline and decay and obsolescence and termination. Just ask the Roman Empire type, if you can find any around.
And there’s lots of former Soviet Union types around. Ask them what happened to the state which once counted them as citizens.
And one day, hard to believe, ther will no longer be a USA.
There’s nothing special about the continued and perpetual existence of Israel – either as a “Jewish” state or a non-secterial run-of-the mill liberal democratic parliamentary democracy. It will one day too pass from the scene, and the Rosenberg’s of the world ought to reconcile themselves to that fact. BDS may hasten that goal, either by design or chance. I shrug my shoulders and say “so what?” Because as an american citizen, and as a Catholic in recovery, there’s nothing about the state of israel which command either my interest or my respect.
Rosenberg and his ilk are the King Canutes of our age – they hold up their hands and bid the tide not to come in, but the tide comes in.