I have spent over 12 months spred over eight years on the ground in Jerusalem, West Bank and Gaza, so naturally I salute the author’s review of the facts. However, my support for the Right of Return is not absolute: it depends on its parameters…How many returnees? How many generations qualify? According to what time schedule? To what lands/what land swaps? With what compensation to the returnee? With what–if any–linkage to other issues? So yes, let’s go for it, mindful of the complexity of the issue.