@ echinococcus July 16, 2017, 2:48 pm
"Thank you for demonstrating the contradiction in Talknic’s continuous argument to recognize squatting rights to the Zionist invaders"
You're delusional. The Zionist state was recognized by the International Comity of Nations. It's simply a fact. Has nothing to do with me or what I'd like to see or what I think is wrong or right. The person reading the weather report isn't responsible for the weather
@ Nathan July 16, 2017, 3:20 am
"according to the Partition Plan a Jew residing in the proposed Arab State can become a citizen in the proposed Jewish state."
That's right and by which they are then prohibited from permanently residing in the Arab State as citizens of the Jewish State without an appropriate Arab State permission. It's NORMAL. The same as Australian immigration law and probably every other State on the planet except in the diseased mind of a ZioFool
" In other words, ... ... ... "
No thanks. The actual words are the only words applicable.
"You take the position that only the borders of the Partition Plan are legitimate."
No. What I have done is point out the fact that they are the borders proclaimed by Israel in its plea for recognition and recognized as Israeli by a majority of the International Community of Nations, legitimate or not and the fact that no country has ever recognized any territories Israel has acquired by war since proclaiming those borders
" but you don’t accept the very legitimacy of the Partition Plan"
It was completely against the UN Charter. Never the less, Israel now exists. Legitimate or not. As such it should be held responsible to it's legal obligations, held to the laws it claimed it would uphold in order to be recognized, withdraw, pay reparations
" Should one understand your position to be that at first Israel should withdraw to the Partition Plan borders, and then afterwards you propose fighting the legitimacy of the Jewish state even in the borders that you “agree” to?"
The Palestinian have the right to pursue their full legal rights. Israel has no valid legal claim to any territories outside of those borders by which it was recognized.
"Obviously, it’s silly to think that such a ploy would succeed"
What ploy? It's simply one of the many legal options open to the Palestinians. I doubt it will ever come to pass for the simple reason that the Palestinians have stated they'd give/cede 78% of their rightfull territories to Israel for peace.
"The important issue is the intellectual sneakiness"
Uh huh. Stating the facts against the Hasbara is like holy water to Nosferatu
"Just state your opinion that the Jewish state shouldn’t exist. That’s your ideology, and there’s no need to pretend that it’s an issue of international law."
But it does exist! I should deny reality because of what you think my ideology should be? No thanks
"Finally, why are you such a rude person? It shouldn’t be such a difficult task to tell someone that you disagree (“chewing gum”) while at the same time maintaining the basic rules of politeness (“walking in a straight line”). "
Why be polite to anyone who supports liars, cheats and the slaughter of innocents by the Zionist Colonization program?
"Good luck facing the challenge of normal human relations"
Zionism has no place in normal human relations.