Saudi Arabia’s silence may be a good thing

Helena Cobban makes a notable observation:

Yemen, Jordan, Algeria, and other Arab countries have also been seeing some significant popular unrest... However, one other player in the Middle East is currently notable because it is "the dog that isn't barking" (pardon the metaphor, which is derived from Sherlock Holmes.) This is Saudi Arabia, which throughout these past 41 years-- and most particularly since the killing (assassination?) of King Faisal in 1975-- has been a central bulwark of U.S. policy both within the Middle East and far beyond.

In Lebanon, it was the Saudi monarch's stalwart support of Saad Hariri, and his equally stalwart opposition to the government in Damascus, that sustained (financially and in other ways) the whole anti-Syria, anti-Hizbullah, and "March 14" phenomenon from 2004 until the Doha summit in 2008. And this time around, when Hariri desperately sought the support of King Abdullah in New York, instead of giving him what he sought, Abdullah checked out of playing any continuing active role in the negotiations over Lebanon. So when I say Saudi Arabia is the "dog that isn't barking" this is not a comment on the absence of popular protest in Saudi Arabia (which may or may not be happening; but it isn't being reported at this point.) It's a comment on the fact that Saudi diplomacy is playing no discernible role these days in trying to prop up the pro-U.S. order of which it has for so long been a key pillar.

About Annie Robbins

Annie Robbins is Writer at Large for Mondoweiss, a mother, a human rights activist and a ceramic artist. She lives in the SF bay area.
Posted in Israel/Palestine

{ 9 comments... read them below or add one }

  1. Avi says:

    One thing is certain, should the US-backed Mubarak regime fall, Israel will not be able to count on a US-led attack against Iran. Saudi Arabia and Egypt both play a pivotal role in that anti-Iran coalition. As Falls Wichita, So Falls Wichita Falls.

    • RoHa says:

      “Saudi diplomacy is playing no discernible role these days in trying to prop up the pro-U.S. order of which it has for so long been a key pillar.”

      (But Israel is America’s only ally in the Middle East.)

      • annie says:

        But Israel is America’s only ally in the Middle East.

        that is how it now appears. unless there is some backyard plan for US/SA to stay out of it and let the egyptian regime fall. unless there’s some payback going on we don’t know about. unless this is somebodies way of getting around congress.

        i don’t know what to think but right now, no news (from saudi arabia) seems like good news to me.

      • annie says:

        hey roha, helena’s got a killer post up about the muslim brotherhood. in it she mentions

        Saudi Arabia’s diplomacy has always had an episodic, slightly elusive quality. But at some stages it has played a significant role: in supporting the US war against the Soviets in Afghanistan; in brokering the Taef Agreement for Lebanon in 1989; in spearheading the Arab Peace Peace Plan offer to Israel, of 2002…

        Well, that last one got speedily broken off at the knees by the imperium, didn’t it?

        And now, where are the Saudis? Can the monarch not be persuaded to intervene (somehow!) and deploy some of his billions to try to “save” the Mubarak or Hashemite regimes?

        No, for a number of reasons. First, since the king and crown prince have both suddenly run up against the limits of medical and organ-replacement technology, the princes are all in the middle of their own succession struggle. Second, quite a lot of them– probably, the majority– are so alienated from Washington by its clear Zionist tilt over recent years that they would not be inclined to help even if there were no succession struggle to attend to. Third– what plan is it they would be supposed to be supporting, anyway?? There is no discernible plan.

        it appears the plan for a number of years been to prop up israel, at the expense of all our other opportunities for alliances there.

  2. annie says:

    I’m noticing helena’s link is not opening. here it is again. her whole post is really good.

  3. Potsherd2 says:

    Yemen is heating up, and SA can’t afford to ignore Yemen.

  4. Potsherd2 says:

    Heh – look at today’s home page at Arab News: all about the flooding in Jeddah. The Egyptian “protests” have equal billing with the snowstorm in NY

Leave a Reply