Cornell partnership with military-linked Israeli school greeted by protests on first day of class

Cornell-Technion protest About 25 activists gathered outside the offices of Google, where the Cornell partnership with an Israeli university with deep ties to the IDF is housed for now (Photo: Alex Kane)

Palestine solidarity activists greeted the first day of classes for students attending Cornell NYC Tech with leafleting, signs and petitions against the school, a massive collaboration between Ivy League Cornell University and Technion-Israel Institute of Technology. About 25 demonstrators braved the biting cold to send a message to Cornell and the city: that they should cut off their links with Technion due to their involvement in making Israeli weaponry used on Palestinian civilians.

The action was called by New Yorkers Against the Cornell-Technion Partnership (NYACT), a new group formed to organize against the collaboration between Google, which is providing free space to the school until the real campus is built, the city of New York, Cornell and Technion. Activists from a variety of groups involved in Palestine solidarity in the city, including Brooklyn for Peace and Adalah-NY, also showed up to voice their displeasure at the partnership. And many activists noted that the first day of classes for a partnership that includes a university with deep ties to the Israeli military was held on Martin Luther King day.

The protesters gathered at 8th Ave and 15th street in Manhattan, right outside the offices of Google, where the students went to attend classes. But only eight students are enrolled this semester, according to the New York Times, which perhaps answers the question that activists had yesterday: where were the students?

Regardless, even if the activists didn’t manage to reach out to students attending the school, they did manage to pass out leaflets to New Yorkers and obtained signatures on a petition against the partnership. The petition demands that the city end their role in the partnership, which includes $100 million in taxpayer funds and real estate space on Roosevelt Island, where the campus is slated to built by 2017.

“Technion is heavily involved with aspects of Israeli state policy. They work hand in hand with the weapons industries in Israel,” said Anna Calcutt, an activist with NYACT. “They’re the worst of the worst–and are particularly repulsive.”

Calcutt was passing out leaflets that spoke to her point: Technion helps to produce weapons and surveillance equipment for the Israeli army, including drones; academics from the school have formulated plans for the Israeli Jewish takeover of the Galilee; the institution works closely with Rafael Advanced Systems and Elbit Systems, two companies that provide the Israeli military with crucial equipment to maintain the occupation; and Technion gives special treatment to Israeli soldiers while discriminating against Palestinian students.

“For decades, the Technion has provided the brains Israel required to create the elaborate mechanism of control under-girding its occupation of Palestine,” noted journalist Max Blumenthal back when the partnership was first announced. “Through its partnership with Israel’s burgeoning arms industry, Technion’s creations have been imported to armed forces around the world. In the words of Israeli researcher Shir Hever, the Technion ‘has all but enlisted itself in the military.’”

A few members of Cornell’s Students for Justice in Palestine group also demonstrated at the protest. “I feel obligated to protest when my university does something like this,” noted Paul Flaig, a Cornell student. “It is a flashpoint issue because it is in the U.S. and Technion’s ties to the Israeli occupation are clear.”

The Cornell-Technion partnership grew out of the Bloomberg administration’s plans to build a new, high-tech graduate school for applied sciences. While a number of schools put in bids to get their hands on Bloomberg’s prize, it was the partnership, forged in secret, between Cornell and Technion that did the trick. The Cornell-Technion partnership’s bid to win the Bloomberg administration’s contest was buoyed by a $350 million gift from Cornell alumnus Charles Feeney, a philanthropist.

It also doesn’t hurt to have members of the New York City Council behind the deal. In February 2012, about a dozen Democratic Party members of the council went on a delegation to Israel organized by the Jewish Community Relations Council. The Jewish Week reported that “the 10-day trip [included] a visit to the Technion, the science institute that will partner with Cornell University to create a new applied sciences campus on Roosevelt Island.”

That the Cornell-Technion partnership is cemented is a “blow” to supporters of Palestinian rights in the U.S., as Max Ajl, an SJP member at Cornell and a sometime contributor to this site, put it to Mondoweiss in an interview when the partnership was first announced. “It should almost be a wake-up call for some people. This is a huge institutional partnership and it’s with a primary target of BDS, a weapons producer, and clearly the Cornell administration is totally comfortable with making a partnership with an Israeli educational institution that produces the weapons to kill people,” said Ajl, a PhD student at Cornell and a contributing editor to Jacobin magazine. “What does that say about where we are? It says we have a ways to go here in America.”

There are also local issues that activists have raised to try to gin up opposition to the deal. When the campus is built on Roosevelt Island, a quiet space of land between Queens and Manhattan only accessible by tram, it will displace a hospital. Activists with NYACT have gone to meetings about the plans for the campus on Roosevelt Island to try and educate residents about the problematic nature of the partnership. And while activists acknowledge that it is pretty much a done deal, they plan to continue to organize against the school.

“We want to stop this, though it may be impossible. But it is a good public education opportunity,” said Terri Ginsberg, a member of NYACT (and also a contributor to this site).

Another local issue is that academics at Cornell have complained that it the deal was made out of public view, with no transparency. At an event on the partnership at Cornell in March 2012, “panelists challenged the University’s decision-making process, claiming its partnership with the Technion was cemented before administrators sought input from the faculty,” the Cornell student newspaper reported. “There was no debate in the deliberative bodies of the faculty before those decisions were made,” Prof. Eric Cheyfitz said at the panel.

Despite the fact that Technion is likely here to stay, activists plan to forge ahead in their opposition, noting that the full campus won’t be built for another four years. A press release from NYACT announced that “NYACT and supporters will host a regular leafleting vigil every other Tuesday starting January 29th, from 5-7pm, at the Google offices.”
 

About Alex Kane

Alex Kane is an assistant editor for Mondoweiss and the World editor for AlterNet. Follow him on Twitter @alexbkane.
Posted in Activism, BDS, Israel/Palestine, US Politics | Tagged

{ 6 comments... read them below or add one }

  1. hophmi says:

    “They’re the worst of the worst–and are particularly repulsive.”

    Some of the repulsive things done at Technion:

    link to en.wikipedia.org

    link to technioncancer.co.il

    link to www1.technion.ac.il

    link to www1.technion.ac.il

    etc., etc.

  2. Les says:

    Cornell-Technion, another member of the military-industrial-academic complex.

  3. Anna Calcutt says:

    The Technion is complicit in crimes committed by Israel on many levels, including its development of weapons used during the 2008/9 assault on Gaza, and its close ties with Elbit Systems which provides key components of the Separation Wall in the West Bank which is a violation of international law. For more information please see our fully referenced document (link to nyact.net), based on previous articles by Tadamon! in Montréal, the Alternative Information Center, and the British Committee for Universities for Palestine (BRICUP).

    Only the first building of the Roosevelt Island campus is scheduled to be complete by 2017, the entire campus won’t be finished till 2037. This means that the residents of Roosevelt Island will live next door to a building site for over twenty years. Transportation on and off the island consists of an aerial tram from Manhattan, the F-train subway from Manhattan/Queens, and one roadway from Queens. These means of transport are already stretched to their limit and so the new development will likely have a huge effect on movement on/off Roosevelt Island.

    • hophmi says:

      So I assume you’ll be boycotting any American university involved in weapons development, like, say, MIT. Oh no . . . that would mean boycotting Chomsky.

      • Anna Calcutt says:

        Boycott is a tactic, not an end unto itself, to be used where it is deemed to be effective. In the US other tactics are more useful. By boycotting an Israeli institute we are not discouraging anyone from standing up against US academies which are likewise complicit.

  4. It should also be mentioned that the Cornell-Technion Partnership came into being at the contemporary moment of massive global economic instability and restructuring. As I have written elsewhere:

    “[C]ooperation [by U.S. universities with Israeli institutions] conveniently dovetails with Israel’s desperate drive to prove the necessity of its devastating domestic policies, as it becomes further isolated economically and politically on account of growing international condemnation of its harsh treatment of Palestinians and of its self-serving manipulation of US foreign policy, all in the wake of the Arab uprisings and increasing petrodollar instability, which have challenged the sustainability of US and Israeli regional hegemony. The pro-Zionist promotion of collaborative US-Israeli projects is indeed but one manifestation of hasbara. Another is a largely neoconservative effort to ensure that US dominance in the Middle East — especially over diminishing oil reserves — retains a strong Israeli component. While scholars as diverse as Cheryl Rubenberg, James Petras, and John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt have argued that alliance with Israel is essentially unnecessary to US national interests, neocons and their followers are dubbing Israel the techno-scientific ‘Start Up Nation’ with the aim not only of making Israel more attractive to potential investors but of realigning and reintegrating the Israeli national interest with that of the 21st century United States as envisioned by the neocon purveyors of the Project for the New American Century. ”

    We should also be concerned that Cornell NYC Tech has been hedging questions about the kind of research its students and faculty will be conducting on the new campus, since its spokespersons have merely stated–repeatedly–that it will host only a “dry lab” mainly for “robotics” research and “communications development,” not a “wet lab” for biological research (see: link to electronicintifada.net). Considering that weapons and surveillance technology development take place in dry labs, Cornell NYC Tech’s insistence that it will “only” be doing dry lab research should give us much pause and lead us to ask: WHAT’S THE BIG SECRET, CORNELL??