‘This is our village!’ – a report from Nabi Saleh

The following is a shocking video from Nabi Saleh, a Palestinian village of 500 residents located north of Ramallah. The village has been engaged in growing demonstrations during the past few weeks to protest the illegal seizure of valuable agricultural land by the Hallamish (Neve Tzuf) settlement. Settlers have also recently uprooted of hundreds of the village’s olive trees.You can find more on the recent protests in Nabi Saleh at Ibn Ezra.

About Adam Horowitz

Adam Horowitz is Co-Editor of Mondoweiss.net.
Posted in Israel/Palestine

{ 44 comments... read them below or add one }

  1. Cliff says:

    Can’t stand these stories. So upsetting to see blatant colonization going on amidst all the hasbara.

    • Shafiq says:

      I wonder how the Hasbara-niks are going to attempt to justify this blatant theft.

      On a related note, the Jewish society at my university is holding a talk next week about ‘Why a boycott against Israel is an absurd idea’, with Ishmael Khalidi as their guest of honour. It just happens to coincide with a week of Gaza memorial events held by the Palestine Solidarity Group – very late I know, but what can you do if you have exams?

      I was wondering if anyone has any material on the difficulties faced by Palestinian academics as a result of the occupation. I remember someone posting a piece but forgot to save it. Any help will be greatly appreciated.

      • Cliff says:

        So I looked up Ishmael Khalidi. He’s a Bedouin. Served in the Israeli Border Police and the IDF too (I think).

        Seems like a PR dream for Israel.

        link to gogalil.com

        “The Western democratic world has a lot to learn from Israel about democracy,” says Khaldi. “Yes, we make mistakes, but who doesn’t make mistakes? As a shepherd I learned to give in. A shepherd is ultimately responsible for bringing the goats in from the pasture, and he must give his all and give in. That’s the way it is in diplomacy, too: If we’ve failed once and haven’t managed to explain that Israel is a normal country, we have to try again and again and again until this changes. And it will change.”

        Folksy! And it gets even better!

        I, Ishmael Khaldi, am Israeli. I served with the IDF, with the Israeli police, and with the Israeli Defense Ministry. In the last year, I have lost two Bedouin friends on army duty (God bless their memory) defending the State of Israel. My friends and family feel that we have a common destiny with the Jewish people in Israel: our grandparents created this land with Jewish immigrants who arrived during the 1920s, ’30s and ’40s to build a democracy.

        Because of this connection to the State of Israel, I cannot stand on the sidelines during Israel’s time of need. I feel that I must speak up and
        be heard.

        I recently returned from a two-month campus speaking tour North America, mostly organized by Hasbara Fellowships. This was the fourth tour I had done over the past year. I’ve traveled the United States coast to coast (of course, being a Bedouin nomad, I mainly took Greyhound!) and flew for a ten day tour across Canada.

        The tour was certainly miraculous – a Bedouin shepherd who had never been to any major city before, all of sudden found himself in downtown Manhattan! It proved to be one of the most adventurous, challenging and enriching experiences of my life.

        Gee whiz. I guess we had it wrong about Israel. According to this Bedouin, everything’s fine. I wonder what details he could provide about Jewish-Bedouin relations. Not individuals, but the whole history.

        I wonder if he focuses on generalized statements about minority rights (in a favorable context) and then switches to personal experience (favorable context).

        If one were to counter him, with reports and statistics from minority rights groups and just historical analysis – what would he say?

        The rhetoric he uses is standard amongst Zionists: ‘the State of Israel’ [the Land of Israel], or the lame brotherly-love bit he does about Jewish-Arab [Zionist-Arab] cooperation.

        So the Zionist group on your campus trots out this poodle so they can further indoctrinate themselves?

        Isn’t he superfluous within the context of Israeli PR? At this point, who would be so idiotic and gullible to fall for this circus act?

        • He’s an uncle tom. The Israelis have been using him as PR for quite some time. The only issue they have with him is that he is easily debunked.

          Zionuts think if they can find one or two “Arabs” who praise Israel, then all the other millions of “Arabs” must be lieng.

          Thus Palestinian anger towards Israelis is merely “anti-semitism.”

        • I have a friend who was in the army and was stationed in the M.E. One time they had a very badly injured Bedouin in their helicopter and they were trying to get him to an Israeli hospital. The hospital kept asking over the radio communication what type of person the injured man was. When the hospital found out he was a Bedouin they said “then you can’t bring him here.” The Bedouin man died.

        • Cliff says:

          What happened to all that Jewish-Bedouin co-dreaming of a Jewish State?

          I wonder who the Zionists are trying to indoctrinate these days. You have to be dumb as hell to believe their PR.

      • annie says:

        shafig, check out the adam’s post on this blog preceding this one

        The excerpt below tells one of those stories. Terry Boullata is the principal of an elementary school in Abu Dis, a neighborhood in East Jerusalem that has been bisected by the Wall. The excerpt discusses how the Wall has impacted the school Boullata runs, and how it divides and disrupts the Palestinian families that end up in its path.

  2. Oscar says:

    Stunning piece of raw video. Amazing to watch teenaged IDF thugs smacking and kicking the civilian Palestinian women amidst the tear gas. Our $3 billion is US taxpayer dollars, hard at work to perpetuate Middle East apartheid.

  3. Citizen says:

    What, the US A supporting Jewish rascism?

    • RoHa says:

      There is no such thing as Jewish racism, and anyone who says there is such a thing is, ipso facto, an anti-Semite or a self-hater.

      Or both.

      And don’t argue. If you do, it proves that you are an anti-Semite or a self hater.

      You probably are, anyway.

  4. Avi says:

    Despicable.

    So when is Dennis Ross and the HACKS and LIARS in Washington going to tell that serial killer Netanyahu to “stop using violence”, like they often say to the Palestinians? Any time soon?

  5. annie says:

    ma’an today: they arrested another peace activist abducted

    spokesman for the Palestine Solidarity Project Mohammad Awad identified those detained as Hussein Ibrahim, 17, Issa Mohammad Issa Awad, 21, and Muhanad Khaled Abu Awad, 20.

    i just recieved the following in my inbox

    This morning at 03:20 AM the Israeli Army came into the home of Khaled Abu Awwad the General Manager of the Palestinian Parents Circle – Families Forum, they woke up all family members by throwing a bomb at their door screaming that if they won’t go out of the house in one minute they will bomb their home and car. Khaled’s wife Jalila and their children were in the house, the three oldest boy’s Mohannad, Moayad and Shadi were taken to an Army Jeep and his oldest son Mohannad blind folded and chained. In the meanwhile his wife, his older daughters Worood and Sana and the three small children had to stand outside the house in the freezing cold of the Hebron mountains. The soldiers were screaming entering the house alone with a dog, leaving the house after 30 minutes and taking with them Mohannad. When the family were allowed to enter their home they found everything upside done, dirty with mud and dogs urine.

    I know Mohannad already for 7 years and in the past 2 years we were working very close in Al-Tariq, he is a powerful leader who promotes democracy, non violence and peace. The soldiers who took him try to stop him in his mission to end the circle of violence in peaceful ways. He has chosen this very hard path although two of his uncle’s were murdered and his twin brother Moayad injured massively by the Israeli Army. We pray to God that he won’t be beaten or humiliated even more by the soldiers and that he will return safe to us.

  6. tommy says:

    American drones used to kill Pakistani civilians should be diverted to Nabi Saleh to protect the villagers of Nabi Saleh.

  7. aparisian says:

    Strange the Hasbara folks disappeared! Witty, Yonira and co Where the hell are you?

  8. JGlatzer says:

    It makes me so sad to see this violation of people’s humanity and victimizing them on their own land. These are the types of video I watch and then wonder how anyone cannot understand Palestinian suffering and can think Israel is a lovely democracy that needs the occupation for “security”.

  9. Mooser says:

    Has Mondoweiss noted the $11 million payments Israel is paying the UN for damages to the UN building in Gaza?

    • Avi says:

      Fear makes Israel adhere to common decency, never mind international law, fear of a lawsuit after targeting and destroying more than three UN schools in Gaza and a warehouse full of UN humanitarian aid. But, don’t worry, Tel Aviv will find away to make the UN pay that sum back, one way or another. Heck, they don’t even have to try hard, just accuse the UN of being anti-Semitic and it’s as good as a done deal.

      /Cynicism off

      • Mooser says:

        Avi, I haven’t had time to peruse the articles on this payment, but I believe the one I read said that this payment represents something new for Israel, and an admission of responsibility which may be critical for others seeking accountability from Israel for its actions. So even tho amount is not huge, and the payment goes to the UN, not the Gazans, this may be significant, and that’s why I brought it up.
        The payment may be the beginning in a more positive trend in getting accountability from Israel.
        I took a quick search on Mondoweiss to see if it was posted, didn’t see it, and thought I would mention it.
        I hope it’s the start of increased accountability for the Israeli regime.

        • VR says:

          “Results 1 – 20 of about 3,490,000 for Israel pay damages Gaza. (0.26 seconds).” Mooser, that is some pretty cheap PR, you cannot buy good PR for that amount of money these days.

        • LeaNder says:

          It’s not cheap PR, but rather quite “in line” with Phil’s focus. Watch out for little signs of change.

          Yes, it is not huge, but as Mooser says it is a start. We have all been watching the immense destruction both in Lebanon and Gaza for quite some time now. … An important part of the larger tale, predominance of air force attacks to save the live of soldiers on the ground. After all they are fathers, sons, daughters, neighbors, and dead soldiers are a sensitive issue in Israel. In effect you bomb countries back a couple of decades and then point fingers at them: Look they are so unable to build up structures, institutions, a functioning economy …

          Lebanon 2006 redux

          I was asked what will happen if the 2006 Lebanon War gets a re-run:

          “The IDF Air Force will once again attempt to justify air power advocates’ belief that countries can be bombed into surrender. That means that they will bomb the length and breadth of the country against infrastructure targets.

          Consider the larger context. Consider the not yet quite restored image of the IDF, in this context this indeed may be important.

        • LeaNder says:

          in this context this indeed may be important.

          wiggle space for saner minds in Israel.

          And to close the circle.

          Concerning the occupied territories. Doesn’t war always work to distract attention, keep the world’s public mind on the central “iron wall line”: Israel is surrounded by a sea of enemies. In this context war and PR go hand in hand.

        • VR says:

          LeaNder, I will believe it when we start to see this happening multiple times for the past massacres, and when it starts to show compassion for humanity. This is nothing but a PR ploy as far as I am concerned, you can think the beast is changing if you like, but I will not with the attended escalation of who is in power, and the 90 plus percent of Israelis who put them there. When they pay reparations for the two Qana’s, than we might have some real change taking place, until than it is PR, just like a Palestinian child is taken to an Israeli hospital with the cameras rolling

          <a href="link to tyros.leb.net
          1

          <a href="link to tyros.leb.net
          2

          In the meantime the money is paid to the UN, and this to show that Israel is supposed to be some responsible member of the international community. If not anything else it is a mere side bet and token just in case things heat up when Israel is asked for their report, which will be filled with the “bad apple” line in regard to some of its soldiers.

        • Citizen says:

          Originally Israel denied it did anything wrong and called the UN report biased (a la Goldstone report treatment). For some reason the full very damning 194 page report was never published, just a cleaned-up summary.

          link to guardian.co.uk

          That one-time 11 million seems absurdly low compensation considering the damage and death suffered.

        • Citizen says:

          The after the UN report came out last May, an Israeli spokesman calculated
          the damages @ 11 million–so it took 8 months for Israel to pay the UN 10.5 million for damage to UN buildings during the Gaza Turkey Shoot?

          link to theaustralian.com.au

        • Citizen says:

          Yes, Mooser’s right–this is the first time anyone is getting compensation for suffering or damage during the Gaza Turkey Shoot. Israel is not admitting
          any criminal responsibility, is recognizing some collateral damage–trying to soften up the UN and any follow up there to the Goldstone Report:
          link to online.wsj.com

        • Citizen says:

          Israel has said it has already found a few bad apple soldiers from its own investigation based on the Goldstone Report (which it dismisses as biased).

          On another note; isn’t it interesting how Obama talks as if Hamas and Israel
          are equally powerful, and as if we do not do all we can to kill off popylarly elected Hamas while we simultaneously send constant blank welfare checks to Israel? Were Obama and crew really as ignorant as Obama claims here during the timeline leading up to his Cairo speech? Was, is Mitchell? Rahm?
          link to time.com

        • Mooser says:

          “LeaNder, I will believe it when we start to see this happening multiple times for the past massacres, and when it starts to show compassion for humanity”.

          Although the Israelis could change any day they decide to do so, no one is depending on their compassion, that is not why the payment is significant. It’s significant because it is a judgement against Israel, and Israel has decided to pay it. It could be a precedent.

          If you are waiting for Israel to change, I wish you excellent health and longevity. On the other hand, if some of the rest of the world, for a change puts real pressure on Israel (if only in the world’s self-interest) Israel will have to change, quick, they are strictly a dependency.
          In any case, I wish you health and longevity. What could it hurt?

        • Citizen says:

          Actually, Goldstone does the same thing by not even giving an introductory general context to his report, that is, by saying absolutely nothing about the 43 year Israeli occupation. We won’t even mention the whole history of the area from 1880 to 1967. It’s like a history channel show parsing Custer’s Last Stand, Wounded Knee, or The Alamo–without any historical context. Imagine if not only the Goldstone Report, but it’s historical cotext, was dumped in the laps of America’s couch potatoes–lots of Americans have no jobs; they’d have the time to watch….

        • Citizen says:

          Maybe it was paid off so the UN wouldn’t mind slacking off on fully pursuing
          the Goldstone Report? Who at the UN decided to not even publish the full
          UN report, but simply give out a whitewashed summary?

        • Citizen says:

          Actually, Goldstone does the same thing by not even giving an introductory general context to his report, that is, by saying absolutely nothing about the 43 year Israeli occupation. We won’t even mention the whole history of the area from 1880 to 1967. It’s like a history channel show parsing Custer’s Last Stand, Wounded Knee, or The Alamo–without any historical context. Imagine if not only the Goldstone Report, but it’s historical cotext, was dumped in the laps of America’s couch potatoes–lots of Americans have no jobs; they’d have the time to watch….

  10. Shafiq says:

    Thanks everyone for the links, much appreciated!

  11. JSC says:

    It’s one thing to read about this sort of thing, but to actually watch it happen just hits you on a visceral level. It’s infuriating that my tax dollars support this.

  12. JSC says:

    The Israelis allowed this to be filmed by several people and just don’t care. Don’t they at least care about their image enough to keep this sort of thing under wraps?

  13. Pingback: Gaza Digest | PINKtank

Leave a Reply