‘Politico’ quietly revises a political anecdote, saving face for ‘J Street’

What is J Street up against? The American Jewish establishment, which is calcified and backward and ethnocentric. Politico’s Alex Isenstadt reported the other day that U.S. House candidate Doug Pike had lost support among Jews in the Philadelphia suburbs because he liked J Street. Emphasis mine:


Doug Pike, a Democratic House candidate in the heavily Jewish Philadelphia suburbs, discovered the perils of alienating part of that Democratic constituency when he lost the endorsement of state Rep. Josh Shapiro, who complained about Pike’s support for J Street, the liberal-leaning Israel policy organization.

Now that story has been revised to save J Street political embarrassment, and make the anecdote flimsy. It reads:

Doug Pike, a Democratic House candidate in the heavily Jewish Philadelphia suburbs, discovered the perils of alienating part of that Democratic constituency when he lost the endorsement of state Rep. Josh Shapiro, who voiced concerns about Pike’s positions on Israel.

I hope the second version is true, but somehow I doubt it. J Street has come under incredible pressure inside Jewish power politics. It’s why the group sandbagged Goldstone all last year, and why a J Street rep said nice things to Alan Dershowitz outside AIPAC even as Dershowitz was trying to excommunicate him.

 
I wish J Street well, they’re trying to reform the Israel lobby cosa nostra. But maybe they ought to take more of a stand against the Israel lobby. Maybe they ought to be the change, not just pray for it.
 
Update: Some good news for J Street. They raised $54,000 in 24 hours lately by summoning Jews to back them up on Obama’s side of the settlements issue.

About Philip Weiss

Philip Weiss is Founder and Co-Editor of Mondoweiss.net.
Posted in Beyondoweiss, Israel Lobby, Israel/Palestine, US Politics

{ 17 comments... read them below or add one }

  1. potsherd says:

    I’ve read that Pike is returning J Street’s campaign contribution and asking them to take his name off their list of endorsed candidates.

  2. annie says:

    silverstein has a post up. ‘profile in craven cowardice’. ha!

    I’m glad to report that J Street’s supporters responded by raising $30,000 in new money in response to Pike’s reversal. Let that be a lesson to those who are mesmerized by the siren song of Aipac dough.

    But I’m pleased to report that there is an even better Democratic candidate running in his district: Dr. Manan Trivedi. Trivedi is an Indian-American medical doctor, Iraq war veteran and Lt. Commander in the U.S. Navy……….

  3. Citizen says:

    Is Pike the guy who did the analysis on our Vietnam expedition in its final throes? The guy who asked, when somebody was questioning his street creds, Would you trust a lay person over a dentist to do a root canal on you?

    It took the South Africa BDS campaign over 20 years to have results, yet in only 5 years after the Palestinian call for BDS, it has swept the globe in a big way. (Take that, Richard Witty and other hasbara clones suffering from lost of memory to dimish the BDS movement as it slowly takes effect.)

    The BDS National Committee (BNC) is calling on you to unite in your different capacities and struggles for a Global BDS Day of Action on March 30, 2010 in solidarity with the Palestinian people and for boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) against Israel. Israel’s oppression of the Palestinian people cannot be tolerated any longer and we will accordingly adopted diverse forms of BDS against Israel until it ends its oppression of the Palestinian people and fully complies with international law.

    Join the Global BDS Day of Action on March 30 2010! Activists from around the world will mark this day, so find an action in your area or register your own. You can do so easily online.

  4. RE: “as Jeff Blankfort points out, there are 18 members of Congress, 12 senators and six House members, on TIP’s board…”
    MY COMMENT: Including one of senators, S-A-X-B-Y! Praise the Lord!

  5. Colin Murray says:

    ot:

    Israel’s Provocation at al-Aqsa, Rabbi plans ‘miracle’ at the Western Wall

    Israeli officials rejected this week a Jerusalem court’s proposal to shelve the plan after the judge accepted that the plaza’s expansion would violate the “status quo” arrangement covering the Old City’s holy places. Islamic authorities agreed to the arrangement after Israel occupied East Jerusalem in 1967.

    “I was asked by the government to inspect the damage two days after it occurred and I found maybe a dozen stones had been dislodged,” he said. “The ramp could have been repaired in less than a week but instead they decided to demolish it.”

    Judge Arad, Mr Ben Dov said, had been “shocked” when she saw the photographs.

  6. Protect Obama from AIPAC on Israeli Settlement Expansion
    AIPAC lobbyists are demanding that Congress pressure Obama back down from his opposition to Israeli settlement expansion. Urge your representatives in Congress to support President Obama’s opposition to Israeli settlement expansion.
    TO SEND E-MAILlink to justforeignpolicy.org

  7. radii says:

    the zio-army just doesn’t get it – cracking the whip on their own to keep everyone spewing the same propaganda line and conforming to the official position is so yesterday – it just makes them look all the more desperate

  8. One question Helen Thomas asked Obama but he wouldn’t answer:

    “White House Press Corps longest-serving member, HELEN THOMAS, says Obama lost credibility when he dodged her question on Israeli nukes.

    link to youtube.com

  9. Pingback: A WOODIE FOR SANDRA DEE | Hot Daily Gossip

Leave a Reply