News

Supporting Iraq war was, and apparently still is, a good career move

I’m told that last year in a panel at Columbia Journalism School, a writer for The New Yorker said that only one member of the magazine’s staff who dealt with foreign policy opposed the Iraq war. Wow. Why did this leading magazine that told people how to think about Vietnam flub this one so bad?

There is no introspective spirit in this New Yorker piece by George Packer about why we went to war with Iraq. Apparently, Peter Beinart and Packer himself did so because of Republicans, and a spirit that fairies implanted in the American establishment:

Reagan’s rhetorical call for an end to the Soviet Empire prompted second-generation neoconservatives, such as Robert Kagan, William Kristol, and Elliott Abrams, to imagine that democracy could be delivered to the whole world by F-22s…

President George H. W. Bush’s invasion of Panama, in December of 1989, now seems hardly more consequential than Reagan’s splendid little war in Grenada. But, as Beinart reminds us, Panama became a dress rehearsal for the ideological battle over Iraq, and a key transition from the hubris of toughness to the hubris of dominance.

But Beinart and Packer are liberal Democrats. What did they believe that made them so wrong? Packer gives us class-day bromides:
"Beinart’s fundamental message is to avoid hubris and cultivate wisdom."
Got that? I bet those two isms that scare me so much, careerism and Zionism, had something to do with it. Beinart has said recently that he would sacrifice his liberal values in Israel for his Zionism. What else would it make him do? Why did Tom Friedman say he wanted the U.S. to smash something in the Arab world to answer suicide bombers in Tel Aviv? Why did Ken Pollack, leading the New York Times forward to the hustings, dismiss the Palestinian issue as meaningless to the Arab street?
P.S. The piece misspells the word "overweening," putting an a in it. Hard times at the New Yorker.
24 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments