Lately a group of Israeli intellectuals has called upon the hospitalized Palestinian prisoner Samer Issawi to end his eight-month-long hunger strike. Ira Glunts posted on their appeal yesterday.
What follows are three Israeli responses. First, Ofer Neiman pointed out in an email that the Haaretz report on the appeal cites nothing that these Israeli intellectuals are willing to give Issawi in return for his stopping his hunger strike. They merely cite signs that negotiations could soon begin between Israelis and Palestinian leaders as a reason for him to end his protest. Neiman continues:
Israeli luminaries, such as Gaza and Lebanon onslaught supporters Amos Oz and A.B Yehoshua call on Samer Issawi to end his hunger strike. They could have preempted it by leading a civil disobedience campaign against Israel’s apartheid. Why should he listen to them? What can they give him (his people) in return?…
Saturday, a few activists tried to visit Issawi at the Kaplan hospital (in Rehovot, south of Tel Aviv). One of them is literary editor and translator Ilana Hammerman, who unlike MOST Israeli intellectuals, calls for civil disobedience against the Israeli government, and practices it by various means, including driving Palestinian children from the West Bank, who are not allowed to enter Israel, to fun days at the beach. Another intellectual connection: Her response to the hypocritical Spanish writer Antonio Munioz Molina, who has tried to defend his acceptance of the Jerusalem Literature Prize. She’s the opposite of Amos Oz.
And this from an activist whose pen name is Yoav Haifawi, at Free Haifa: “Zionist Intellectuals offer a Pizza to Samer Issawi.” Haifawi riffs off an incident in which the Prime Minister’s wife offered pizza to student activists on hunger strike against rising tuition:
Some of those who claim to be “Israeli intellectuals” have proven today that their arrogance and insensitivity far exceed those of Mrs. Netanyahu…
No, they did not wake up when Samer was arrested without any cause, as they didn’t protest at the imprisonment without trial of thousands of other Palestinians, including political activists, journalists and intellectuals. They didn’t even raise their voices while Samer was on a hunger strike for 200 days, as the continuing disregard to his cry for freedom puts his life under imminent danger.
What caused their response was Samer’s heartbreaking letter from his bed in the hospital, published in Haaretz by the courageous journalist Gideon Levy. Samer writes in his letter:
“… I’ve chosen to write to you: intellectuals, academics, writers, lawyers, journalists and activists in civilian Israeli society…
“Israelis, I’m looking for an educated one among you who has passed the stage of the shadows and mirrors game. I want him to look at me as I lose my consciousness. Let him wipe the gunpowder from his pen, the shooting sounds from his mind, and see my face’s features etched in his eyes. I will see him and he will see me. I will see how tense he is about the future and he will see me, a ghost clinging to his side and not leaving.
“Perhaps you will be asked to write a romantic story about me. You will testify I was a creature of whom nothing remained but a skeleton, breathing and choking from hunger, losing consciousness now and then. And after your cold silence, my story will be an achievement to add to your resume. When your students will grow up they will believe the Palestinian died of hunger … Then you can celebrate your cultural, moral supremacy with a death ritual.”
They did not rush to defend Samer Issawi, to demand his freedom, to save his life. They cried out to expel his living ghost, which knocks on their doors, breaking the peace of the occupation and satiety.
They did not, God Forbid, turn to the authorities to request for Samer’s release. They did not even care to ask what crimes he did that caused the State of Israel to chase him on their behalf, in the name of the public whose conscience and morality they purport to represent, to his expected and approaching death.
They requested Samer to stop the hunger strike unconditionally, to agree to be confined for many years in prison for no reason, in violation of the prisoners’ swap, when the only accusation against him is that he went out of the “restricted zone” drawn for him in his city Jerusalem.
Even the Pizza that they offer Samer is a used, worn and cold Pizza from the kitchen of Mrs. Netanyahu’s husband.
They write about: “New encouraging signs that the negotiations between the sides will resume,” adding that these measures may secure Samer’s release alongside other Palestinians imprisoned in Israel.
Probably they don’t really live in Israel. Please remind me, Gentlemen, when did Israel release Palestinian prisoners due to negotiations and not in a prisoners’ exchange?
Of course, the Zionist morality is never far from self interests and the “current affairs” of give and take. As they do not oppose the occupation unconditionally, they are not demanding the unconditional release of any prisoners, even if there is no reason for their arrests. Why, what happened? How will Israel achieve its goals if it will not trade in occupied territories, in the freedom of thousands of prisoners languishing in its prison and in the lives of millions of residents humiliated every day while crossing military checkpoints and groaning in the big prison called occupation?
The Zionist intellectuals have a whopping bargain to offer Samer and the Palestinians, really the deal of the Century: Give up the right of return of millions of Palestinian refugees; Forget about the land that was robbed by the settlers through military decrees, faked papers and extortion; Recognize Israel as a Jewish state and give your consent to the status of your Palestinian brethren as second-class citizens. Only then would the Zionist intellectuals recommend to the government to bring the negotiations to a blessed conclusion and slightly loosen the shackles on Samer’s corpse.
At this stage of his hunger strike, pizza would most likely kill him. I don’t know if there is anything sinister behind this but anyone who has read their Holocaust history would know that when the allies first entered the concentration camps, the liberators’ natural response was to feed the inmates but this was disastrous as it often killed the inmates who had survived imprisonment.
The attitude of these people is better explained by Philip Zimbardo in his book “The Lucifer Effect: Understanding How Good People Turn Evil”
http://www.lucifereffect.com/index.html
What Issawi accomplished with this letter is to shame and disturb the depraved into removing their masks. These hasbara charlatans that measure every word in their calculating Zionist narrative are the marie antoinettes of Zionism: let the starved for freedom and compassion eat cake and let the dying choke on pizza while they, the privileged Zionist intelligentsia, gorge on their superiority and entitlement. These intellectual guardians of Zionism are the height of depravity because they endure the oppressed victim they robbed while they rationalize the injustice they help to sow. Pure evil.