Dear Neil Young,
We are Palestinian farmers and agricultural workers in the besieged Gaza Strip.
As you have stood many times for farmers and agricultural workers around the world, you would have doubtless found yourself meeting some of the most dignified, hard working and family oriented people. You will know that life cultivating the land is not easy. For Palestinians in the Gaza Strip, you would have to see to believe what the Israeli Occupation Forces, many for whom you plan to perform in July this year, have done to our farming livelihoods, families and communities. Try and imagine continuing our lives as farmers while:
· Getting shot at each day while planting or harvesting our crops with live ammunition by armed Israeli soldiers behind a fence with F16 machine guns
· Having our crops and land overturned and destroyed by enormous American made bulldozers protected by jeeps, tanks and snipers of the Israeli army
· Having our farmhouse crushed or demolished losing our possessions, farming equipment, livestock and water-wells.
· Having huge areas of farmland bombed, with crop growth stunted by contamination from banned chemical weapons such as white phosphorous
· Having replacement equipment, rebuilding of houses, restocking of crops made impossible by a medieval Israeli blockade of our border preventing materials and equipment from reaching the population, such as saplings, pesticides and fertilizers, plastic sheets for greenhouses and hoses for irrigation.
This is our daily life in the Gaza Strip. We ask for the simple right to live and work as farmers do anywhere in the world, instead of having the work and livelihoods we love destroyed by an occupying army no Western government or international institution will stand up to.
With Willie Nelson and John Mellencamp you organized the first Farm Aid concert to raise awareness about the loss of family farms and to raise funds to keep farm families on their land. We share our solidarity with you and the entire world’s farming community. We also wish that you respond to the call of Palestinian farmers to not tolerate the Israeli occupation and siege that has suffocated our people and left our farming communities devastated.
The United Nations Office for the Coordination of humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) has documented the brutal edge of Israeli policy that punishes and denies access to our own farms, seriously affecting the lives of 113,000 people, or 7.5 percent of our total population. Regular shootings make farming in the “buffer zone” next to the border “high risk”, where 35% of the most arable Palestinian land is situated. There are frequent incursions by Israeli bulldozers accompanied by Jeeps and Tanks, leveling the best land and destroying our property. The value of agricultural and other property destroyed from 2005 to 2010 is estimated at least USD 308 million. 90 percent of this cost is represented by fruit trees, greenhouses, chicken and sheep farms and water wells. Due to the blockade the lost agricultural output in this “buffer zone” totals 75,000 tons per year, representing lost income of more than US$50 million. More importantly for us farmers, our culture, self-determination and attachment to the land has been taken away from us. [1] The Israeli military has demolished over 150 water wells in the restricted areas since 2005 and routinely destroy any crop taller than 80cm, forcing farmers to grow basic crops such as barley or wheat. [2]
In Israel’s 2008-09 Cast Lead attacks on Gaza that killed 1400 Palestinians in 3 weeks, including over 330 children, a total of 46% of agricultural land in the Gaza Strip was assessed to be inaccessible or out of production. Residue from phosphorous and artillery shells seriously impact the quality of the food that farmers are able to produce and have impacts on health. [3] After the recent November 2012 Israeli onslaught on Gaza, the Ministry of Agriculture in Gaza estimated that the agricultural sector incurred losses totaling US$21 million.
The generating capacity and reliability of the Gaza power plant was massively impaired over the past eight years by the destruction of six transformers by an Israeli airstrike in 2006 and the restrictions of the seven year Israeli blockade have significantly restricted the import of spare parts, equipment, and fuel. Recently we have suffered day after day with access to only 6 hours of electricity. For farmers, as well as the other impediments, this means at least 140,000 dunums of land planted with fruits and vegetables are at risk of drought due to inability to use 85 percent of the agricultural wells operated with electricity. Reduced production and incomes for Palestinian farmers have left 80% of Palestinians in Gaza dependent on food aid. [4]
Says Mustapha Arafat, a farmer from Zeitoun, Gaza City:
“The daily aggression suffered by us the Palestinian farmers every day must be highlighted to the world, so people can understand the reality of the attacks and the suffering that has continued throughout the recent ‘ceasefire’. The boycotts of Israeli companies in agriculture are so important as the Israeli occupation has destroyed our farming production and denied us the possibility of exporting our own products. International pressure on Israel from people of conscience is the only way our own economy will be allowed to develop and for us to live normal lives.”
Thomas Jefferson, author of the US Declaration of Independence said “Cultivators of the earth are the most valuable citizens. They are the most vigorous, the most independent, the most virtuous, and they are tied to their country and wedded to its liberty and interests by the most lasting bands”
In “Last of His Kind,” the words of your song resonate with farmers across Palestine:
“Don’t say much for the future
When a family can’t survive.
I’d hate to say the farmer
Was the last of his kind.” [5]
We are tied to our land, but we are being forced off it, watching rich land eaten away by erosion that the Israeli army who at gunpoint does not allow us to cultivate, and kills us if we do. We ask you to show solidarity with the farmers and their families of Gaza, by refusing to perform for the regime that is doing everything to destroy our means, our livelihoods and our communities.
Union of Agricultural Work Committees Association
Besieged Gaza
References
1 http://www.ochaopt.org/documents/ocha_opt_special_focus_2010_08_19_english.pdf
2 Al Mezan Center for Human Rights, Israel Reduces Wheat Supply to the Gaza Strip: Food Security in Gaza at Greater Risk as Israeli Siege Continues, (2010)
3 http://al-shabaka.org/sites/default/files/Abdelnour_et_al_PolicyBrief_Eng_July_2012.pdf
5 http://www.releaselyrics.com/468a/neil-young-last-of-his-kind/
Thanks Annie for this.
There is an on-line petition to Neil Young launched by CJPME (Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East) at –
I hope it works but I somehow doubt it.
His state of mind is not sanguine; and if you look closely at Neil’s eyes, you’ll see he’s suffering from something the Japanese call ‘Sanpaku’, which in English translates into ‘three whites’, in reference to the white surrounding the iris of the eye. The norm is two whites on either side of iris. Sanpaku on a person indicates a critical imbalance of physical health and/or mental judgement – as if the eye is rolling up and backwards, exiting consciousness, slipping away from life and towards death.
Never sign a contract with a person suffering from Sanpaku. Their energetics attract accidents, illness and tragedies. Oriental medicine has volumes of literature on this very subject.
This is yet another example of how capitalism co-ops dissent. Back in the 60s before they were rich and successful, Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young gave voice to an anti-establishment, anti-war generation. Neil Young’s “Ohio” still retains the power to move. Somewhere along the way, fueled to an extent by drugs and fame, they inevitably made peace with the system which had rewarded them so well, although they still thought of themselves as rebels. After 9/11, Neil Young supported the war on terror only to later do an about face and call for Bush’s impeachment when he finally figured out he had been duped. David Crosby and Graham Nash showed some awareness by serenading the occupy movement in Zucotti Park but then performed for Obama at the White House. Perhaps they were channeling Bono. I still love their music, but let us be honest, they have morphed into cocaine liberals. Success will do that to you. Fortunately, I have been spared that fate.
Do the words “fucking idiotic” mean anything to you? Neil Young is going to cancel his sold out concerts in a place where he will be received with open and loving arms because a few 2 bit terror-loving busybodies are pressuring him to cancel because they hate the existence of Jews? I don’t think so.
There is irony here too, because there’s been more danger, damage and hardship inflicted upon their own people with missiles that have fallen short and into Gaza than the Israelis could ever do.
Neil wrote the most incisive couple of lines in the history of rock and roll —
We’ve got a thousand points of light for the homeless man
We’ve got a kinder, gentler machine gun hand
–in response to George Bush I, and was the only white superstar who publicly opposed George Bush II’s “war on terror.” (Living with War album, 2006)
I hope he finds the guts and compassion to do the right thing here, too.