Media Analysis

Netanyahu gives hero’s embrace to US Jew who spied on the U.S.

The news today is that Jonathan Pollard, the former Navy intelligence analyst who spent 30 years in prison for spying for Israel, flew to that country and got a hero’s reception in the middle of the night at the airport by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Netanyahu went to the steps at the plane and handing Pollard, who is Jewish, an Israeli I.D. card, said, “You’re home.”

The amazement is that Netanyahu participated in this staged drama, putting up video on his twitter account of Pollard and his wife kissing the ground as the PM met them. Whatever domestic political value the drama had, the Prime Minister is sticking his thumb in the eye of the American security establishment, which despised Pollard, who spent 30 years in prison here for his crimes.

American Israel supporters regularly tell us that it is in the U.S. national interest to support Israel right or wrong and give the country $4 billion in aid a year. Rep. Ted Deutch said it last week,

“Some of my colleagues want to shift the conversation on Israel and talk about withholding aid and punitive measures. It’s up to all of us to explain why it’s not in our interest to do that. . . I don’t think it’s in our interest to start putting restrictions on aid that might impact Israel’s ability to protect innocent civilians.”

Actually US interests and Israeli ones depart all the time from one another, and Netanyahu just underlined the fact, embracing a guy whom seven secretaries of Defense said they didn’t want freed because he had committed such serious offenses.

Americans died because of Pollard’s crimes, according to prosecutor Joseph DiGenova (in the Los Angeles Times):

DiGenova said that U.S. intelligence authorities suspect that some of the material obtained from Pollard was bartered to the Soviet Union in return for the release of Soviet Jews to Israel, and that U.S. intelligence “assets” in the Soviet Union were compromised and possibly killed as a result.

Pollard was freed from prison five years ago but lived under travel restrictions. Trump lifted those restrictions a few weeks ago, and today we learn that Pollard was flown to Israel on a plane owned by Sheldon Adelson, the biggest Republican donor, whose only issue is Israel.

Adelson has said that he wishes he had served in the Israeli army not the American army.

And Trump has fulfilled every pro-Israel Ask on Adelson’s wishlist in exchange for 100s of millions of campaign contributions — from killing the Iran deal to legalizing illegal Israel settlements to defunding Palestinian refugees to moving the Embassy to Jerusalem. The only thing Trump hasn’t delivered is a war with Iran, but he’s got a few weeks to go. . .

“One of, if not THE, biggest American political donors gave a VERY expensive ride to a man convicted of espionage against the United States. This seems like a big deal,” says Eli Clifton.

No, it’s just the ongoing scandal in plain sight: the Israel lobby using money to sway U.S. Middle East policy, against the best interests of the American people.

Netanyahu once said the U.S. is “something that can be easily moved,” and he appears to know what he is talking about. As Susan Abulhawa commented today, “Chelsea Manning, Edward Snowden, and Julian Assange are locked up and/or in fear for their lives, while this criminal gets a free pass to go colonize in my homeland.”

At least the New York Times article on Pollard’s trip highlights Netanyahu’s bizarre middle of the night ceremony and Adelson’s airplane and openly mentions the “dual loyalty suspicion” that Pollard’s advocacy created. “[O]thers faulted [Pollard] for having created enormous problems for Jews in the United States government who felt that their loyalties had been suddenly called into question.”

This was not a small or casual case. Pollard stole suitcases-full of documents, per the National Public Radio report. From our earlier coverage:

The reason that Pollard was kept in prison for so long is that American authorities knew that he had taken a vast amount of US intelligence, including a top secret manual detailing methods for the collection of intelligence around the world. Former Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld is adamant that Pollard shouldn’t be freed; he publishes a letter he wrote to his boss George W. Bush in 2001, in which he was joined by seven former Defense Secretaries opposing Pollard’s release.

Here is an excerpt of a 1999 piece by Seymour Hersh in the New Yorker, detailing the allegations that the material ended up in Soviet hands, as a trade for Soviet emigres to Israel:

A number of officials strongly suspect that the Israelis repackaged much of Pollard’s material and provided it to the Soviet Union in exchange for continued Soviet permission for Jews to emigrate to Israel. Other officials go further, and say there was reason to believe that secret information was exchanged for Jews working in highly sensitive positions in the Soviet Union. A significant percentage of Pollard’s documents, including some that described the techniques the American Navy used to track Soviet submarines around the world, was of practical importance only to the Soviet Union. One longtime C.I.A. officer who worked as a station chief in the Middle East said he understood that “certain elements in the Israeli military had used it” — Pollard’s material — “to trade for people they wanted to get out,” including Jewish scientists working in missile technology and on nuclear issues.

9 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Finally Trump was able to repay Casino man Adelson for the over $25 million he donated towards his failed campaign, and also help Jared’s good buddy Bibi get some credit before the next elections. First it was Jerusalem, then it was the Golan Heights, and now this. We should be thankful Trump will be gone before the next Israeli election, or he might have gifted him all the Palestinian territories, although it is still a possibility the West Bank might be annexed as a parting gift.

Israel got their favorite spy to betray the country he lived, worked, and benefitted from, and American leaders refused to release the traitor, despite pleas from Israel. They made claims he was dying of some illness, but what do you know, we could all see a fit and healthy man being given a hero’s welcome, by none other that the crooked PM of Israel, and the traitor was even able to bend over and kiss the ground he spied on his country for. With friends like Israel, we don’t need to look for enemies.

So we are sending them billions of dollars for this? Really?

I thought I’d go over to the Fox News website to see if this news is there. And it is, halfway down the main page, at a link with the label: Convicted spy who sold US military secrets arrives in Israel, granted citizenship. In the 9 hours since the article was posted, there have been 44 comments. Some are pro-Pollard, but the dominant sentiment seems to be that he deserved to be executed. However, no commenter has said anything about Sheldon Adelson, even though a photo caption there does say that Pollard flew to Israel on “a private plane provided by American casino magnate Sheldon Adelson“.

Here’s an article on Pollard from the Washington Report on Middle East Affairs – I think it’s interesting because the authors are Gideon Levy and Anshel Pfeffer, two Israeli jouralists.

Pfeffers piece is titled “Israel Still Owes American Jews an Apology for the Jonathan Pollard Affair”, Levy’s is titled “One Is a Free Hero, the Other, a Hostage”, referring to Mordechai Vanunu:
https://www.wrmea.org/2021-january-february/jonathan-pollard-is-no-hero-he-betrayed-his-country-for-cash.html

Pollard is neither a hero nor is he a nationalist. He’s a spy, an American Jew who betrayed his country, doing damage to both his community and Israel….The defense establishment in the United States did indeed treat him cruelly; but Israel has no right to complain. Its treatment of another man, a man with arguably more values than Pollard, Mordechai Vanunu, is much crueler. And yet—a torch has already been lit on Mount Herzl on Independence Day for the former, while the torture of the other hasn’t ended to this very day, and hardly anyone says anything in protest.

Then we had Rosen and Weissman get off the accountability hook for classified intelligence meddling Franklin paid a price. https://fas.org/sgp/jud/aipac/index.html

No one did any time for outing Plame. U.S. operatives around the world lives were allegedly jeopardized by her outing, (Fleisher, Rove, Libby etc)

So Israel gets their spy Pollard…when will Mordechai Vanunu ever be released from Israeli bondage?

Thanks for the good summary.
One thing, though: you quote “the ‘dual loyalty suspicion’ that Pollard’s advocacy created” without commenting on it.

Huge damage to one country (or defending its perpetrator) on behalf of another one is anything but “dual” loyalty. It’s exclusive loyalty to one of them. That must be underlined because it’s the key point in denouncing these people.