Culture

not always clear to those who…

[The Holocaust] was not a planned process, but a series of measures linked to one another. . . .
If the linearity and coherence of the process seems clear in hindsight,
they were not always clear at the time to its victims,
but also and above all
not always clear to those who conceived and implemented them.

Enzo Traverso, “Auschwitz, Marx and the twentieth century” in Critique of Modern Barbarism: Essays on fascism, anti-Semitism and the use of history. p. 26

As the Israeli school system
and the Israeli Defense Force
train nice Jewish boys and girls
to be innovators, to staff the most ethical military in the world,
and indeed perfect functionaries
who see only the appropriate evils,
their vision of our common Jewish tradition
and hard-won insights and beliefs
negates the wisdom of a millennium of Talmudic scholars,
sees social justice and empathy for others
as effeminate filthy ghetto culture
as Herzl once proclaimed.

I can hear their justifications now,
“I was just following orders,”
perhaps even the “Forgive me, Lord,
for I knew not what I did,”
of their political backers in Biden’s America,
as they passed laws negating Palestinians’ nationality,
approved bills of lading for cattle cars
bound for Gaza,
counter-signed instructions to turn all water away
and ban food from crossing Gaza’s border.
Perhaps telling the kids that it was the Palestinians’ own fault,
they just lacked the culture
to make arid deserts bloom.

And somewhere, some teen-age malcontent whispering
“Is the answer to the test question
‘Never Again’?
or is it ‘Ever Again? and Again? and Again’”

4 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

focusing on how it was “not always clear to those who conceived and implemented”
is a conversation of evasion and excuse. none of what is happening is happening because nobody clearly conceived of it. let’s talk about the people whose fault it is. i just watched a conversation with ben rhodes and peter beinart. rhodes said “‘i always wish the other side of this debate would be honest. just say ‘we don’t believe there should be a palestinian state’… that’s the position of the israeli gov, that’s the position of the republican party.. they’re more honest about it’”

“Biden’s America” is no different than Trump’s in regard to israel palestine or iran. they’re just less honest about it. anyone who can’t see what’s happening after 70 years is lying brainwashed or stupid. “not always clear” is not a reasonable go to option in the days of apartheid, it’s an excuse.

How Zionist Jews view Palestinians:

Europal Forum

And

d1iZpdB1EulQ.jpg (1125×1516) (europalforum.org.uk)