We’ve been covering the case of a Florida politician, Evelyn Garcia, who resigned from the Democratic National Committee, after emails emerged in which she bewailed the treatment of Palestinians under occupation by Israel. Garcia was elected to the DNC in 2008 and is now running for state office.
Several of Garcia’s emails were written a year ago to Dan Liftman, a legislative aide in the office of Alcee Hastings, a Democratic congressman from Ft. Lauderdale, FL. In one of his exchanges with Garcia, Liftman writes:
“What Palestinians? As yet there is no Palestine. Not officially.”
Hold on there. A right wing Republican, Newt Gingrich, got in trouble earlier this year for calling the Palestinians an “invented people.” Even Mitt Romney condemned the remark as “incendiary.” But here’s a Democrat saying the same thing!
I called Liftman in Hastings’s Ft. Lauderdale office and asked him if he was speaking for Hastings when he said, There are no Palestinians. He said:
“It absolutely does not reflect the congressman’s views and it never will. I was writing in a moment of pique and I was speaking for myself. It has nothing to do with the Congressman. I got a little angry when I read something like what Evelyn sent me. ‘Concentration camps, crimes against humanity.’ But this has nothing to do with the Congressman.”
I called then emailed Hastings’s press secretary. I have yet to hear from her.
Liftman said he has apologized for his “invective.” I pointed out that Garcia’s comments have cost her a job. Liftman said that those comments were “horrible” and that Garcia herself had called them “ugly and insensitive,” but there was no need for him to resign over his statements about Palestinians.
“No. Of course not. I’ve already been chastised for speaking out,” he said.
When asked who had chastised him, Liftman said, “This has gone too far” and declined to say.
Though he is Jewish and very strongly pro-Israel, he said he has friends on all sides of the issue, including Muslims. (By the way, Hastings’s district is mostly African-American; constructed for the purpose of sending an African-American to Congress.) Liftman also said he was not the source of the leaked emails.
Oh and to repeat the takeaway: you can be a liberal Democrat in the United States today and hold these essentially racist views. No one is busting you for having these views, really. And the Democratic Party is trying to paper over the differences between Israel lobby types like Josh Block and critics of Israel in the party’s base. That process won’t last; the contradictions are too great.
when is racism not an important issue? when the racism, no matter how extreme, is directed toward Palestinians. if this were directed against any other people, this man would be talking about his *former* boss, and he’d be on the street looking for work, never to work in mainstream politics again. and that’s the way it should be. but the same should also also apply here. Shameful, but the Democratic Party was, and is, and shall forever be, the party of virulent anti-Palestinian racism. It varies by degrees, and there a very few exceptions to the rule, but Liftman is much closer to the Democratic Party official mainstream as any of us that work for, and not against, human rights.
That’s one of many reasons why there is a Green Party.
Honestly, ideologues who say there are no Palestinians are no different to Saudi men who say there are no women.
Alcee Hastings’s district is heavily African-American. It was drawn up precisely to be a minority majority district. Does he need this kind of aide?
Does he need this kind of aide?
does mark kirk need richard goldberg?
makes me curious if every congressperson’s office is staffed with an ideolog lobby gatekeeper. he should be fired for making such a racist statement. he uses the excuse he was piqued at the time, but that doesn’t rationalize why he would take his anger out on palestinians…. if he was piqued at garcia. he used a well worn racist hasbara talking point. why? and why are there no repercussions?
kudos to phil for interviewing liftman.
Of course, insulting Palestinians and offending them is not so bad because in the political stock market Palestinians are valued as trading low all the time, but their cousins are valued as high, though their same cousins should also remember that some decades ago they were valued in a low way and people didn’t pay attention to their suffering. When we don’t pay attention to each others suffering we cause more human suffering to others. I don’t see why Garcia had to resign. She opposed the occupation while Litman opposed the existence of the said people under occupation. He said something worse in a way, but nothing happened to him.
It goes without saying that Liftman won’t be forced to resign, as was Evelyn Garcia.
Whenever someone says something like “there are no Palestinians,” I’m always tempted to ask: “So, those folks I saw walking around on the street in Ramallah, Hebron, and Nablus, were they robots or holograms?”
Evelyn Garcia is receiving a ton of hate mail. I emailed her and then posted on her website a message of support. You should too. Here is her email address
http://www.evelyngarciacampaign.com
Here is the Palm Beach County Democratic Party’s website. You might think of sending an email to Mark Alan Siegel asking him to stop with the bullying and remind him this is America.
geofgray: That is her website, to send her a message of support which I just did, the link is:
link to evelyngarciacampaign.com
“But here’s a Democrat saying the same thing! ”
Why wouldn’t a Democrat say the same thing as a Republican?
As far as I can tell, the only differences between Democrats and Republicans are the names and the fact that the Republicans have a few more swivel-eyed, foam-flecked loonies.
Good for you. Phil. Keep calling.
RE: “…you can be a liberal Democrat in the United States today and hold these essentially racist views. No one is busting you for having these views, really. And the Democratic Party is trying to paper over the differences between Israel lobby types like Josh Block and critics of Israel in the party’s base.” ~ Weiss
SEE: “Repressive Democracy: How Not to Waste Your Vote in November”, by Andrew Levine, Counterpunch, 6/20/12
ENTIRE COMMENTARY – link to counterpunch.org
P.S. No more battered
spousevoter syndrome for me!• Jill Stein for President - link to jillstein.org
Screw the self-important, gatekeeper intermediary. Now that we know the who and what about this, Garcia should just contact Hastings directly and hash it out. So he loses a staffer. There’s more.
The problem is that Garcia backtracked too soon. She can’t resolve this in her favor because she gave up/in.
That may be the definition of a politician, but it’s also the definition of the generic problem. Stand up for yourself, Ms. Garcia.
If the Florida DNC was compelled to make public statements about Garcia’s private exchange last year and the remove her from the DNC for voicing a known truth, would the DNC feel compelled to speak to the racist and inhumane statements in that exchange by Liftman?
If enough people write the Florida DNC or his boss?