Exile and the Prophetic: Gaza City is right around the corner from the Warsaw Ghetto

Israel/Palestine
on 6 Comments

This post is part of Marc H. Ellis’s “Exile and the Prophetic” feature for Mondoweiss. To read the entire series visit the archive page.

The irony of it all, Gaza becomes a trial run, as a disposable, superfluous population on the other side of Jewish power. Well, it has been this way for years. Did I miss the afterthoughts of Israel’s Operation Cast Lead or just bury them in my subconscious?

That the Palestinians are highly symbolic on all sides and candidates for collateral damage whenever the need arises is another supreme irony when looked at through the lens of Jewish history.

Perhaps I couldn’t believe my eyes when I read the post-Gaza reflections in 2009. Or perhaps I was too caught up in flurry of ‘This is the end of Israel’s transgressions. The international community won’t allow it,’ missives to notice the rational calculation behind the emotion. I never believed it was the end and took a hit for saying so.

I’ve also noticed there isn’t much of ‘this is the end’ right now. Is that because many feel Iran is right around the corner?

On the analysts theme that Israel lost the latest Gaza go-round, what with Mohamed Morsi emerging as the go-to man, I’m an agnostic. The recent flare-up regarding Morsi’s assumptions of power is already dominating the news cycle. Momentum is important but is often interrupted.

It’s so interesting how the politically savvy don’t seem to get the Israel/Palestine situation. They’re constantly thinking Israel’s collapse is imminent or the international community is riding to the rescue or a leader of another country is in the ascendancy. There are endless scenarios, the latest being the Arab Spring. None of these have panned out over the long run.

The reality is that Israel isn’t collapsing, isn’t being disciplined and won’t give one more inch than it is forced to.

Meanwhile, the distance traveled from Eastern Europe to Palestine seems a lot longer to outsiders than to Palestinians who experience it. Though the actually distance is almost 1600 miles and soon to be seventy years, I’m beginning to think Gaza City is right around the corner from the Warsaw Ghetto.

For Gaza City to be right around the corner from the Warsaw Ghetto is to travel down memory lane. As we travel, it might dawn on Jews that when we observe Palestinian history we’re also viewing our own.

Rather than a comparison, I can’t shake this image. Call it a time machine inversion, but it’s scary when you think about it. A vulnerable population surrounded by others who force you to stay put – under their control. Periodically the same population can be used as symbolic fodder for whatever you want to achieve for yourself. Tell me, in historical terms what populations fit that bill?

You see, the Jews of Europe were considered superfluous by the countries they lived in. They could be herded together in ghettos and later expelled. Jews could be forced into certain occupations during certain time periods and denied that same occupation at another time. Jews could be protected by the powers that be. In turn, that power could be withdrawn.

In general the wellbeing of Jews was dependent on others. The state could bring Jews to their country and, at times, protect them. The same state could render Jews stateless and thus expose them to the violence of the mob. Again it is interesting to think of Palestinians in this regard.

The last time Jews were rendered stateless was during the Nazi period. Jews were systematically deprived of every right and protection of the German state. This was done legally and bureaucratically. The other side of this coin was terror. Jews were hassled on the streets and ultimately disappeared into vast prison camps we know as concentration camps. Some of these concentration camps morphed into death camps.

As with all occupations, Israel uses advanced social organization, bureaucracy and terror to keep the Palestinian population under control. Israel has rendered Palestinians stateless. It uses the vulnerability of statelessness to keep Palestinians vulnerable.

With Palestinians vulnerable, Israel has constructed a vast prison system to house disaffected Palestinians. Over the years some estimate that over 600,000 Palestinians have spent time in Israeli prisons. Today almost 5,000 Palestinians are jailed by Israel.

These are official prison sites. If we count the Palestinians under Israeli occupation and periodically subject to search, seizure, military raids, targeted assassinations, bombings and closure – if we expand our understanding of prison from a specific physical location to larger geographic areas where populations are under surveillance and control – then Israel’s prison system holds millions.

How far is it between the Warsaw Ghetto and Gaza City? Eastern Europe and occupied Palestine?

My response: Quite far. Not far enough.

About Marc H. Ellis

Marc H. Ellis is retired Director and Professor of Jewish Studies at Baylor University and author of Future of the Prophetic: Israel's Ancient Wisdom Re-Presented.

Other posts by .


Posted In:

6 Responses

  1. pabelmont
    November 27, 2012, 12:34 pm

    “I’ve also noticed there isn’t much of ‘this is the end’ right now. Is that because many feel Iran is right around the corner?” No. “this is the end” is whistling in the dark, but today after so much, no-one feels like whistling any more.

    Sure Israel can do worse. And probably will, because like all of us it is a creature of habit. And the nations (and media and pundits on all sides) must have noticed that the nations are also creatures of habit and there is s strong habit not to cross swords with the USA (or with Israel).

    So, is “this” the end? Hardly. Why expect the tiger to change his stripes, the leopard to change his spots?

  2. yourstruly
    November 27, 2012, 1:03 pm

    how far is it between the warsaw ghetto and gaza?
    no distance at all, what with -

    gaza and the warsaw ghetto
    same place
    different time
    while the world stands by
    genocide*
    live

    *initially slow motion in gaza, not so now

  3. Eva Smagacz
    November 27, 2012, 1:25 pm

    Anybody with a heart and knowledge of Jewish fate in Europe is shocked by the historical parallels between Gaza and Warsaw Ghetto. To not see it you need to be either totally ignorant of history, or utterly convinced that Jewish ( or Arab, for that matter) suffering is superior by the definition due to supremacy of the race that is being maltreated. ( Sort off Rudogen’s “The Gazans have a deep culture of resistance and aspiration to martyrdom, they’re used to it from Cast Lead and other conflicts, and they have such limited lives than in many ways they have less to lose. And I’ve been surprised that when I talk to people who just lost a relative, or who are gathering belongings from a bombed-out house, they seem a bit ho-hum”)!.

    Of course, to get to similarities between Gaza and Warsaw ghetto, you need to examine the desintegration of universal humanist values of both societies – Germany in 1930′s and Jewish Israelis since 1940′s. If we can learn anything about debasement of victors and societal upper-handers, we need to discuss the similarities between two societies. Otherwise we will just wring our hands and speak, again, about the human capacity to committ evil, as if it was something baffling, and not a predictable trajectory in a hospitable environment.

  4. DICKERSON3870
    November 27, 2012, 10:16 pm

    ● RE: “Israel has rendered Palestinians stateless. It uses the vulnerability of statelessness to keep Palestinians vulnerable.” ~ Marc Ellis

    ● MY COMMENT: Israel enhances the “vulnerability” of the stateless Palestinians through the use of ‘maintained uncertainty’ and ‘learned helplessness’.

    ● FROM ALISTAIR CROOKE, London Review of Books, 03/03/11:

    [EXCERPTS] . . . It was [Ariel] Sharon who pioneered the philosophy of ‘maintained uncertainty’ that repeatedly extended and then limited the space in which Palestinians could operate by means of an unpredictable combination of changing and selectively enforced regulations, and the dissection of space by settlements, roads Palestinians were not allowed to use and continually shifting borders. All of this was intended to induce in the Palestinians a sense of permanent temporariness. . .
    . . . It suits Israel to have a ‘state’ without borders so that it can keep negotiating about borders, and count on the resulting uncertainty to maintain acquiescence. . .

    SOURCE – link to lrb.co.uk

    ● FROM WIKIPEDIA [Learned helplessness]:

    [EXCERPT] Learned helplessness is the condition of a human or animal that has learned to behave helplessly, failing to respond even though there are opportunities for it to help itself by avoiding unpleasant circumstances or by gaining positive rewards. Learned helplessness theory is the view that clinical depression and related mental illnesses may result from a perceived absence of control over the outcome of a situation.[1] Organisms which have been ineffective and less sensitive in determining the consequences of their behavior are defined as having acquired learned helplessness.[2]
    The American psychologist Martin Seligman’s foundational experiments and theory of learned helplessness began at the University of Pennsylvania in 1967, as an extension of his interest in depression. Quite by accident, Seligman and colleagues discovered that the conditioning of dogs led to outcomes that opposed the predictions of B.F. Skinner’s behaviorism, then a leading psychological theory.[3][4]

    Experiment
    Summary
    In the learned helplessness experiment an animal is repeatedly hurt by an adverse stimulus which it cannot escape.
    Eventually the animal will stop trying to avoid the pain and behave as if it is utterly helpless to change the situation.
    Finally, when opportunities to escape are presented, this learned helplessness prevents any action. The only coping mechanism the animal uses is to be stoical and put up with the discomfort, not expending energy getting worked up about the adverse stimulus. . .

    SOURCE – link to en.wikipedia.org

  5. MSeveral
    November 28, 2012, 12:15 pm

    I find Mr. Ellis’s linking the Holocaust to Gaza utterly offensive. Simultaneously he is minimizing the horror of the Holocaust while displaying his ignorance of what happened during the war. The Warsaw ghetto, like the numerous other ghettos the Nazis set up in Eastern Europe were temporary holding bins prior to sending its occupants to the extermination centers, of which Auschwitz was the major one. Mr. Ellis’s suggestion that Gaza is a temporary holding place prior to the Israelis exterminating its residents, is as I said at the beginning, offensive while displaying his ignorance.

Leave a Reply