Israeli Defense Minister urges ban against poet for calling Ahed Tamimi a hero

Israel/Palestine
on 14 Comments

Poet and author Yehonatan Geffen is an iconic popular figure in Israeli culture since the 1970’s. I grew up as a toddler on his children’s books, and he has a lot to say to adults today. He is tongue-in-cheek and doesn’t mince his words. The kind of guy who calls out Netanyahu for being a racist.

On Monday, he posted a poem on his Instagram which infuriated Defense Minister Avigdor Lieberman so much that Lieberman called for the army radio to ban him and his work completely, also urging all media outlets to do the same. 

Let’s have a look at Geffen’s poem. I’ve seen some slightly imprecise translations in Israeli media, including Haaretz, so I’m providing mine, containing just about every word he wrote:

A beautiful 17-year-old girl did a terrible thing

And when a proud Israeli officer

Once again invaded her home

She slapped him

She was born into it and in that slap

Were contained 50 years of occupation and humiliations.

And on the day the story of the struggle is told,

You, Ahed Tamimi,

With red hair,

Like David who slapped Goliath,

Will be mentioned in the same line  

As Joan of Arc, Hannah Szenes and Anne Frank.

It is the last line that had apparently infuriated Lieberman most. Apparently not so much the mentioning of Joan of Arc, but more the mentioning of Hannah Szenes (a Palestinian Jew who volunteered to parachute in WW2 Europe in order to save Jews), and Anne Frank:

“The State of Israel should not give a platform to a drunk who compared a girl who was murdered in the Holocaust and a heroine who battled the Nazi regime, to Ahed Tamimi, the bimbo who attacked a soldier”, Lieberman said.

Culture Minister Culture and Sports Minister Miri Regev also attacked Geffen, and said, with a somewhat bizarre twist:

“Yehonatan Geffen’s outrageous reference to Ahed Tamimi as comparable to Hannah Szenes, Anne Frank and King David is surely part of Geffen’s delusions.”

Where did King David come from? Part of Regev’s delusions perhaps?

Regev exploited the opportunity in order to call Ahed Tamimi a “terrorist” (as I’ve noted earlier, Israel is seeking to make Ahed a terrorist), saying:

“The ghastly comparison between the heroes of our people’s Holocaust and terrorist Tamimi, on the same week the world marks International Holocaust Remembrance Day, is crossing a red line by someone seeking to rewrite history”.

So now Ahed Tamimi is a ‘terrorist-bimbo’, and Geffen is a ‘drunk’ holocaust-revisionist, according to Lieberman and Regev.

But there has to be a limit to cultural censorship in the ‘only democracy’, and even though Lieberman is Defense Minister, there are rules guaranteeing autonomy to the army radio. Thus state attorney Avichai Mandelblit issued an official opinion, by which “the legal authority to determine the content of the station’s broadcasts is only in the hands of its professional officials.” Nonetheless, sidestepping his legal function, Mandelblit joined the chorus of incitement against Geffen (and Tamimi): “The aforementioned opinion should not be taken to legitimize in any manner the content of the outrageous statements made,” he added.

Now, we have to ask Mandelblit: who asked you to hand out opinions about art? Are you now the arbiter of what should or should not be considered ‘outrageous’ poetry? What is the purpose of this irrelevant addition?

The purpose of that addition is incitement. It is the same as when Netanyahu’s Foreign Ministry threw Jewish philanthropist George Soros under the bus, when the latter was being attacked by Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban last year. Orban, who had recently praised the Nazi-collaborator Hungarian leader Miklos Horthy, ran a massive ad campaign against Jewish Hungarian-born billionaire George Soros, with anti-Semitic undertones serving an anti-immigrant agenda. At first, Israel’s ambassador to Hungary, Yossi Amrani, condemned the billboard campaign, saying it invoked “sad memories but also sows hatred and fear.” But a day later, the Foreign Ministry in Jerusalem under Netanyahu issued a “clarification,” which states that while Israel deplores anti-Semitism and supports Jewish communities in confronting this hatred, criticism of Soros was legitimate:

“In no way was the statement meant to delegitimize criticism of George Soros, who continuously undermines Israel’s democratically elected governments by funding organizations that defame the Jewish state and seek to deny it the right to defend itself,” the Foreign Ministry stated.  

So Mandelblit is ostensibly playing politically correct, but in fact signaling his approval for this cultural censorship of Geffen, in a most shameful way.  

Anyhow, Defense Minister Lieberman is not even pretending to accept Mandelblit’s official position (which is legally binding) – Lieberman said he is “rejecting Mandelblit’s opinion out of hand.”

Lieberman is suggesting that Geffen’s expressions are simply an existential danger – to all soldiers, whom it is his duty to protect:

“My role as defense minister is to shield all soldiers—both regular and reserve—who cannot retort to politicians and public figures”, he said. 

Lieberman posed that he was simply, and exclusively, guided by common sense:

“My only guide is the law of common sense, which stands above any bureaucratic instruction”, he said.

The suggestion is that Mandelblit has simply lost it.

“With all due respect and admiration, which I do have towards the attorney general”, Lieberman added, “in this instance I reject his position out of hand. He would have been better served denouncing Geffen, who’s desecrating both Jewish history and IDF soldiers. Army Radio is first and foremost a military station, and will not provide a platform for tongue-lashings by some Israel basher or other against our soldiers.”

But the attorney general had in fact denounced Geffen.

And all the furor against Geffen is of course because he showed some understanding for Palstinian pride, dignity and heroism. That makes him an “Israel basher.” Culture Minister Regev added mockingly that he was “a poet determined to liberate Palestine.” It can hardly get any worse in Israeli jargon. Lieberman suggested that “the proper stage for Geffen’s nonsense are broadcasts of Hezbollah’s Al-Manar network.”

And attorney general Mandelblit opines that Geffen’s statements are “outrageous.”

Because, in Israel, you are not allowed to show understanding for Palestinian humanity.  

About Jonathan Ofir

Israeli musician, conductor and blogger / writer based in Denmark.

Other posts by .


Posted In:

14 Responses

  1. eljay
    January 24, 2018, 10:22 am

    … Let’s have a look at Geffen’s poem. …

    I’m not fond of most poetry, but I like this poem. It’s lean but evocative.

    … It is the last line that had apparently infuriated Lieberman most. …

    “The State of Israel should not give a platform to a drunk who compared a girl who was murdered in the Holocaust and a heroine who battled the Nazi regime, to Ahed Tamimi, the bimbo who attacked a soldier”, Lieberman said

    It’s sad to see a supremacist lose his shit over a poem about a girl slapping one of his supremacist military goons. Captain Israel is embarrassed by Mr. Lieberman’s behaviour.

    • Misterioso
      January 25, 2018, 11:05 am

      @eljay

      The Zio-racists are running scared. They are losing all important youth around the world, including increasing numbers of Jews.

      This is not 1948 or 1967. The ugly truth of Zionism is easy to discover.

  2. Annie Robbins
    January 24, 2018, 12:23 pm

    i’m shocked no one suggested imprisoning geffen, he could share a cell with Dareen Tatour. another example of the apartheid system.

    Where did King David come from? Part of Regev’s delusions perhaps?

    hmm, i assumed it came from the reference to david and goliath in the poem.

    You, Ahed Tamimi,

    With red hair,

    Like David who slapped Goliath,

    last but not least, thanks jonathan for another excellent article! although i personally think it drifted off course a bit throwing in the part about the hungarian prime minister and soros as it kind of broke up the flow of the article for me, i’m sure it added to your point, so — thank you! btw israeli officials remind me more and more of characters from animal farm.

    • eljay
      January 24, 2018, 12:33 pm

      || Annie Robbins: i’m shocked no one suggested imprisoning geffen … ||

      Maybe he’ll “learn the hard way” that his behaviour was deemed to be unacceptable and a “price [will] be collected on another occasion, in the dark, without witnesses and cameras”.

  3. Ronald Johnson
    January 24, 2018, 1:50 pm

    “Animal Farm”. There have been questions of which actual people are represented in George Orwell’s allegory. Allegories are like that; transmissible in time and place. “Pilgrim’s Progress” had “Mr. Smooth-it-away”. It could be a tossup between the Democrats and the Republicans today, each feeding class conflict to the Electorate, both parties with many “smooth it aways” in attendance.

    Apropos of the times of the writing, there is a school of thought that Orwell had a role for the Communist leaders of the Soviet Union in “Animal Farm”.

    • RoHa
      January 24, 2018, 6:21 pm

      It was obvious at the time that Animal Farm was an allegory of the Soviet Union, with the pigs as the leaders and Boxer as Stakhanov.

      But, as you say, such allegories can be used for other circumstances.

  4. Noodles
    January 24, 2018, 6:13 pm

    Soros is hardly a philanthropist.

    His efforts have turned the Ukraine into a failed state. Soros has been funding Ukrainian politicians since 2008, he helped fund the coup against the democratically elected Yanukovych, and he is the mastermind behind military strikes against Dunbass. See “Confidential Document: Soros’s Plan for Ukraine” by Eric Zuesse. The civil war that followed the coup killed 10,000 people and forced at least 1.5 million Ukrainians to become refugees. This is a greater number of refugees than those exiled by the Nakba and a worse death toll than operations Blast Dead and Protective Shield combined. Leaked documents by Soros show that he regarded the Ukraine as a stepping stone for regime change in Russia. WW3 here we come.

    The Soros funded the Global Center for the Responsibility to Protect (RSP), the doctrine that led to the Libyan coup. Libya is now a failed state where impoverished Libyans are openly sold as slaves.

    Soros may fund formerly respected groups in America and Israel, but in view of the bloodshed he has caused it is reasonable to question his motives. If Israel “threw Soros under the bus”, I say even a stopped watch is right twice a day.

  5. Marnie
    January 25, 2018, 12:00 am

    It is absolutely chilling these arch criminals – lieberman and regev specifically – are calling Ahed Tamimi a terrorist, at the same time the criminal ‘state’ of israel is pursuing the death penalty for ‘terrorists’. This young woman is already a global face of strength and resistance against tyranny and now these fools would enshrine her forever as a martyr and saint! Zionists are so INCREDIBLY STUPID.

    It’s also funny to me that none of these rat bastards dare travel outside of israel as they could find themselves placed under arrest – ;^) – conversely, were Ahed allowed to travel – anywhere – she would be given a hero’s welcome.

    • Cazador
      January 25, 2018, 9:34 am

      Marnie,

      «conversely, were Ahed allowed to travel – anywhere – she would be given a hero’s welcome»

      I would really love to believe that, but I have a huge impression that the USA would not welcome her as a hero, considering how AIPAC controls the US rulers of all kinds, parties and States. I could already hear and read the most awful comments against the brave young girl Ahed Tamimi.

      Of course, Marnie, that being said, I totally wish that you’ll be right, absolutely right. The young and beautiful Ahed Tamimi deserves such a glorious treatment!

      • Marnie
        January 25, 2018, 11:40 am

        The u.s. isn’t the be all and end all – there’s more enlightened countries where she’d be welcome.

  6. Citizen
    January 25, 2018, 10:47 am

    Ahed will turn age 17, the day of her next imminent hearing. You can send her a short note of your support, give her hope, here: https://actionnetwork.org/forms/send-ahed-a-personal-birthday-message-of-support-before-her-trial-begins?source=twitter&

  7. Vera Gottlieb
    January 25, 2018, 2:42 pm

    Still allergic to truth.

  8. amigo
    January 27, 2018, 2:25 pm

    “Polish lawmakers approved a bill on Friday that makes it a crime, punishable by up to three years in prison, to use statements suggesting Poland bears responsibility for crimes against humanity committed by Nazi Germany.” j post.

    The Polish gov objects to the use of the term , “Polish Death Camps”.

    http://www.jpost.com/International/Poland-moves-to-make-use-of-phrase-Polish-death-camps-criminal-offense-539950

    And in typical zionist fashion , Israel,s leaders rush to condemn the Polish Gov which They accuse of trying to whitewash the crimes of Polish citizens against Jews.

    More Zionist chutzpah from the nation where a majority of it,s citizens have been involved in crimes against Palestinians.

    I was unable to find this story on more mainstream Media so wer,e stuck with J,Post until a more honest source becomes available.

Leave a Reply