US aid to PA withheld over statehood bid, Hamas, and ‘failure to recognize Israel’s right to exist as Jewish State’

Tanya Reinhart RIP , 2002

http://dissidentvoice.org/Articles/ReinhartPenalColonies.htm

While the external fence is presently being built, Israel’s current military operation is set to be the final step in the implementation of IDF plans for reestablishing full military rule (which was abolished in large parts of the West Bank during the Oslo process). Though Israel describes everything it does as a spontaneous reaction to terror, the plan was fully spelled out in the Israeli media already back in March 2001, soon after Sharon entered office. Alex Fishman, military and strategic analyst of Yediot Aharonot, explained at the time that since Oslo, “the IDF regarded the occupied territories as if they were one territorial cell”, and this placed some constraints on the IDF and enabled a certain amount of freedom for the PA and the Palestinian population. The new plan is a return to the concept of the military administration during the pre-Oslo years: the occupied territories will be divided into tens of isolated “territorial cells,” each of which will be assigned a special military force, “and the local commander will have freedom to use his discretion” as to when and who to shoot. (Yediot Ahronot, weekend supplement, March 9, 2001)

The first stage of this plan, the destruction of the institutions of the Palestinian Authority, was completed in the previous �Operation Defensive Shield� in April of this year. In practice, from that time on, the towns and villages of the West Bank have been completely sealed. Even exit by foot, which was possible up to that point, became blocked, and movement between the “territorial cells” now requires formal permits from the Israeli military authorities. Soldiers and snipers prevent any “unauthorized” walking to agricultural fields, to places of work and study, or for medical treatment.

However, unlike the pre-Oslo period of Israeli military rule, the army makes it clear that there is no intention to construct any civil administration that will take care of the basic daily needs of the two million Palestinians, such as food supplies, health services, garbage and sewage. For these tasks, some form of a Palestinian Authority will be maintained, though in practice it will not be allowed to function.

As a �military source� told Ha’aretz: �Internal conclusions of the security echelons, following operation �Defensive Shield’, assessed that the functioning of the civil branches of the Palestinian Authority had reached an unprecedented nadir, mainly due to the destruction the IDF operation left behind in Ramallah (including the systematic destruction of computers and databases)… Combined with the severe restrictions on movement, the Palestinian population is becoming, as the military source defined it, ‘poor, dependent, unemployed, rather hungry, and extreme’… The financial reserves of the Palestinian authority are reaching the bottom… In a future not far off, the majority of Palestinians will only be able to maintain a reasonable life through the help of international aid.� (Amos Har’el, Ha’aretz, Hebrew edition, June 23, 2002)

Thus, the West Bank is being driven to the level of poverty of the Gaza strip.

The EU, the largest PA donor, is under constant pressure from Israel to cut its aid, which is used, inter alia to pay the salaries of teachers and health workers. The tactics are always the same: Israel provides some documents presumably linking the PA to terror. Any aid to the PA is, therefore, aid to terror. (2)

Since September 11, Sharon has been constructing an analogy between the occupied territories and Afghanistan (with the PA as Al Qaeda). He keeps declaring that the solution to Palestinian terror, and the required �reforms,� should be along the lines set in Afghanistan. The analogy is frighteningly revealing: As it established the �reforms� in Afghanistan, the US forced starvation upon millions of people. This is how Noam Chomsky described it: �On Sept. 16, the New York Times reported that �Washington has also demanded [from Pakistan] a cutoff of fuel supplies…and the elimination of truck convoys that provide much of the food and other supplies to Afghanistan’s civilian population.� Astonishingly, that report elicited no detectable reaction in the West, a grim reminder of the nature of the Western civilization that leaders and elite commentators claim to uphold. In the following days, those demands were implemented… �The country was on a lifeline,� one evacuated aid worker reports, �and we just cut the line� (NY Times Magazine, September 30). According to the world’s leading newspaper, then, Washington demanded that Pakistan ensures the death of enormous numbers of Afghans, millions of them already on the brink of starvation, by cutting off the limited sustenance that was keeping them alive. (Interview with Michael Albert, reprinted in Noam Chomsky, 9-11, Seven Stories, 2002).

Arundhati Roy summarized this at the time: “Witness the infinite justice of the new century. Civilians starving to death while they’re waiting to be killed” (�The Algebra of Infinite Justice,� The Guardian, UK, Sept. 29, 2001).

The new stage of Israel’s �separation� can no longer be compared to the Apartheid of South Africa. As Ronnie Kasrils, South Africa’s Minister of Water Affairs, said in an Interview with Al-Ahram Weekly, “the South African apartheid regime never engaged in the sort of repression Israel is inflicting on the Palestinians” (Issue of March 28-April 3, 2002). We are witnessing the daily invisible killing of the sick and wounded being deprived of medical care, the weak who cannot survive in the new poverty conditions, and those who are bound to reach starvation.

Nevertheless, the public debate in Israel revolves around questions of efficiency: Is it possible to stop terror with such methods. Let us suppose even that it is. Is it allowed? Is this what we (Israelis) want to be?

One people stole the �Lamb of its poor neighbor� (5): Gaza and the West Bank are 22% of the land of Israel/Palestine, where the Palestinians lived in the past. On this small piece of land, three million people live, with hopes, needs and dreams, just like ours. Since Oslo, they have been lured with promises that we are about to evacuate the settlements and give them back their land, at the very same time that we have been imprisoning them in Gaza, stealing more of their land in the West Bank, and leaving them no hope whatsoever. The Palestinian people are fighting for their freedom. The crimes of Palestinian terror do not remove our culpability for our own crimes