Trending Topics:

‘The struggle for Palestinian liberation has become a mainstream global civil rights movement of our time’: CUNY panel discusses the BDS movement

on 11 Comments
Top row (l-r): Sherry Wolf, Ashley Dawson Bottom row (l-r): Christopher Stone, Bill Mullen, Radhika Sainath. (Photo: Öykü Tekten)

Top row (l-r): Sherry Wolf, Ashley Dawson
Bottom row (l-r): Christopher Stone, Bill Mullen, Radhika Sainath. (Photo: Öykü Tekten)

“The struggle for Palestinian liberation has become a mainstream global civil rights movement of our time,” said Bill Mullen, Professor of American Studies and English at Purdue University. “No one who believes in global justice can now stand on the sideline”.

Mullen was addressing over fifty students, academics and activists for the panel “BDS and Academic Freedom” at The Graduate Center, City University of New York (CUNY) last Wednesday evening. The panel discussed boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) and academic freedom both within CUNY and in universities throughout the U.S.

In addition, panelists also included Radhika Sainath, a staff attorney at Palestine Solidarity Legal Support, as she examined historical cases related to academic freedom and recent anti-boycott bills which infringe on the first amendment. Speaking on the neoliberal restructuring of higher education was Palestinian solidarity activist Sherry Wolf, member of Adalah-NY and editor of the International Socialist Review. Ashley Dawson, professor of English at The Graduate Center and College of Staten Island (CUNY), spoke about the intellectual roots of academic freedom and his own experience with censorship as editor of the American Association of University Journal of Academic Freedom. Moderating the panel was Christopher Stone, Professor of Arabic at Hunter College and faculty member of The Graduate Center (CUNY).

This discussion is just one of the many ongoing conversations and debates occurring across the nation in academia, as students groups such Students for Justice in Palestine push for their universities to divest and boycott Israeli academic partnerships. In one of the biggest resolutions of 2013, American Studies Association (ASA) members voted to academically boycott Israeli institutions, not individuals. Panelists were quick to clarify that the boycott concerns the ASA itself and is not a specific mandate for universities to follow.  An original statement from the ASA defines their boycott as:

limited to a refusal on the part of the ASA in its official capacities to enter into formal collaborations with Israeli academic institutions, or with scholars who are expressly serving as representatives or ambassadors of those institutions (such as deans, rectors, presidents and others), or on behalf of the Israeli government, until Israel ceases to violate human rights and international law.

In the last few weeks, academic freedom was challenged at Columbia College Chicago. Adjunct faculty member Iyman Chehade’s course on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict was cancelled after showing the joint Israeli-Palestinian award-winning film 5 Broken Cameras. The American Association of University Professors (AAUP) issued a statement of support, which “concluded that Professor Chehade’s academic freedom was violated as a result”. Chehade’s class was later reinstated. Mullen, member of the advisory board for the US Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel (USACBI) noted: “policing curriculum means the university campus is as much as ever a crucial front in a battle for real economic and political justice”.

Panelists at The Graduate Center spoke on increasing attempts to control discussions on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and how faculty members throughout the country are steadily offered non-tenured positions, resulting in an ever-increasing self-censorship. With a largely non-tenured faculty body—a process that Wolf calls the “‘adjunctification’ of higher ed”—students and researchers alike are limited on their public support for the BDS movement and other Palestinian solidarity movements. Panelist Ashley Dawson spoke about his experience as editor of Journal of Academic Freedom, which, ironically, was accused of being too biased on the issue of academic boycotts in an issue last fall. The Journal came under attack for publishing too many articles that supported the boycott of Israeli institutions. In his defense, Dawson stated that the call for papers simply did not receive as many submissions other than those related to the academic boycott of Israel. According to that issue’s introduction, some of the questions Dawson sought to answer are, for example: “how is the expansion of US higher education around the world and the increasing international integration of academia affecting academic freedom?” and “In what ways, conversely, is the globalization of higher education transforming academia within the United States, shifting and impinging upon traditional notions of academic freedom?” Owing to disputes such as these, anti-boycott bills recently passed by many cities throughout the country are and should be of great concern to academics throughout the country, as pointed out by panelist Radhika Sanaith.

One of the main worries of such self-censorship means that “our scholars and our intellectuals, our teachers, our researchers are being denied their right to express unconventional views, go down untrodden paths, pursue controversial hypotheses” expressed Wolf. In her discussion on mobilization, tenure and its centrality to academic freedom, Wolf cited the “1940 Statement of Principles on Academic Freedom and Tenure” as issued by the AAUP which speaks at lengths on the relationship between academic freedom and tenure:

The purpose of this statement is to promote public understanding and support of academic freedom and tenure and agreement upon procedures to ensure them in colleges and universities… Academic freedom is essential to these purposes and applies to both teaching and research. Freedom in research is fundamental to the advancement of truth. Academic freedom in its teaching aspect is fundamental for the protection of the rights of the teacher in teaching and of the student to freedom in learning…

Tenure is a means to certain ends; specifically: (1) freedom of teaching and research and of extramural activities, and (2) a sufficient degree of economic security to make the profession attractive to men and women of ability. Freedom and economic security, hence, tenure, are indispensable to the success of an institution in fulfilling its obligations to its students and to society.

In quoting Omar Barghouti, co founder of the BDS movement, Mullen noted that the BDS movement has reached “a tipping point” and added that students in Loyola University Chicago, University of Michigan, UCLA, University of New Mexico, National University of Ireland, Kings College London and York University have also recently pursued boycott resolutions.

Towards the end of the conversation, Christopher Stone stated that in regards to the American Studies Association’s (ASA) recent support for the BDS movement “so many of the negative responses… were framed totally in concern for the academic freedom of Israeli academics…[while] there are other parties for whose academic freedom we should be concerned.”

In December 2013, former president of The Graduate Center and now-interim chancellor of CUNY William B. Kelly issued a statement denouncing ASA’s decision to boycott:

The free exchange of ideas is at the heart of the academic enterprise. Any effort to impede that flow is antithetical to the values that universities hold most dear. The City University of New York is proud of its many international collaborations and is committed to extending and deepening those relations. We take this opportunity to reaffirm our long association with Israeli scholars and universities…the need for global cooperation has never been more urgent, and we repudiate any effort to foreclose productive dialogue.

The BDS conversation at CUNY and universities nationwide will only continue to grow and divide academics and scholars alike. Based on the strength and increasing support for BDS nationwide, several BDS supporters affiliated with The Graduate Center, specifically the Doctoral Students’ Council, are considering a resolution in support of the BDS movement. As pointed out by Bill Mullen: “the battle for Palestine is quickly becoming this generation’s Vietnam”.

Jenn Nina

Jenn Nina resides in New York City and received her M.A. in Middle Eastern Studies from The Graduate Center, City University of New York in 2013. Her writings can be found on her blog, Middle Journal.

Other posts by .

Posted In:

11 Responses

  1. pabelmont on April 8, 2014, 10:27 am

    “There are other parties for whose academic freedom we should be concerned.”

    Yes. Palestinians, whose academic freedom is greatly reduced by occupation (for those living under occupation), exile (for those outside MP), and Israeli racism (for those living inside green-line Israel).

    And, yes, American academic freedom, which has been so violently attacked by Zionist power in recent years, both as to denial of tenure for professors, and as to suppression of student pro-Palestine work.

  2. seafoid on April 8, 2014, 10:43 am

    “The struggle for Palestinian liberation has become a mainstream global civil rights movement of our time”

    Sah. Absolutely.

    2 factors kept Israel going for so long :

    1. The Shoah and the shameless of milking of as well as the allied “Jews wouldn’t do that”

    2 The otherness of the Palestinians

    But all the broken promises added up in the end.
    And the latest generation of Palestinians have changed the narrative .

  3. Kay24 on April 8, 2014, 1:32 pm

    If BDS is to succeed, it will take the academia, in all American institutions, to make that fire burn. It will not come from the congress, leaders, zionist media, or even Hollywood – they are steeped in loyalty to a devious nation, that has control over how they act and think. It is heartening to know that our Institutions are beginning to wake up, and will soon catch up their counterparts in other nations.

  4. anthonybellchambers on April 8, 2014, 4:07 pm

    This Israeli government is ABSOLUTELY DETERMINED to undermine the UN and the international pressure for the establishment of a Palestinian state for the 5 million true indigenous people of the region. That is why the BDS movement is so vital.

    And in this context, When will the international community and, in particular, the EU, take action to abrogate the EU-Israel trade agreement that allows Mr Netanyahu free access to the European single market that enables him to take such atrocious liberties with international law, justice, freedom and the rights of man?

  5. BrianEsker on April 8, 2014, 7:24 pm

    Sorry. BDS will never get past being known as a crank-filled terror cult that attracts racist morons. It’s the fraud, racism and terrorism. You can’t paper those over or fool everybody indefinitely with the wolf in sheeps’ clothing passive aggressive warfare crap.
    Normal, sane, people…just won’t buy it. They know it’s all a pack of lies.

    • James North on April 9, 2014, 9:07 am

      BrianEsker is trying to earn a bonus for venom from Hasbara Central.

      • gamal on April 9, 2014, 10:32 am

        “BrianEsker is trying to earn a bonus for venom” really?

        I read it as cry for help

        “Normal, sane, people” that, clinches, it, ,,

        “just wont buy it” is witty, given the subject matter, though sadly reflective of his loss of confidence and

        “They know its all a pack of lies” is affecting, sometimes the straight road is the hardest to navigate.

    • justicewillprevail on April 9, 2014, 9:26 am

      Tssk, applying the traits of zionism to BDS is a classic example of guilt transference.

    • amigo on April 9, 2014, 9:49 am

      To quote Kerry mr esker!!!


    • eljay on April 9, 2014, 9:59 am

      >> … a crank-filled terror cult that attracts racist morons. It’s the fraud, racism and terrorism.

      An excellent description of Zio-supremacism by one of its own.

    • American on April 9, 2014, 10:32 am

      BrianEsker says:

      ”Sorry. BDS will never get past being known as a crank-filled terror cult that attracts racist morons. It’s the fraud, racism and terrorism. You can’t paper those over or fool everybody indefinitely”>>>>>

      LOL,…no you cant fool everyone indefinitely. BDS and condemnation of Israel growing, growing, growing in every nook and cranny around the world…its everywhere.

      Former foreign minister Bob Carr says ‘pro-Israel lobby’ influenced government policy
      Updated 27 minutes ago
      Former foreign minister Bob Carr has hit out at what he calls the “pro-Israel lobby in Melbourne”, saying it wielded “extraordinary influence” on Australia’s policy during his time in Julia Gillard’s cabinet.
      Speaking to ABC’s 7.30 program, Mr Carr said “extreme right wing” pro-Israel lobbyists had an “unhealthy” influence on Australia’s policy towards Israel and the Occupied Territories.
      Mr Carr details his time as foreign minister, and his criticism of the pro-Israel lobby, in his new book, Diary of a Foreign Minister.
      “I found it very frustrating that we couldn’t issue, for example, a routine expression of concern about the spread of Israeli settlements on the West Bank – great blocks of housing for Israeli citizens going up on land that everyone regards as part of the future Palestinian state if there is to be a two-state solution,” he said.
      “The important point about a diary of a foreign minister is you shine light on areas of government that are otherwise in darkness, and the influence of lobby groups is one of those areas.”

      Milwaukee based People’s Books Co-op boycotts Israel
      Fight Back! Newspaper-Apr 7, 2014
      The People’s Books Co-op board voted in favor of “instituting a consumer, cultural and academic boycott of the Israeli state due to significant..

      Ryerson University student union votes to join BDS
      The Times of Israel-Apr 8, 2014
      The student union of Ryerson University in Toronto voted to join the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement aimed at Israel, at least the …
      A Montreal Restaurateur’s Anti-Israel Rant
      Monday, April 7, 2014, by Ian Harrison

      Richard Holder (Holder, Brasserie Bernard, Bar Waverly) has made his views on Israel known on Facebook over the past two weeks.
      “The bully state of israel must end one day, as must much of the world’s silence on this subsidized massacre,” the prominent Montreal restaurateur wrote on April 5, above a link to a blog article about the death of a Jordanian judge of Palestinian origin.
      This came one day after Holder wrote, “netanyaho: murderer” in a show of apparent solidarity with the Facebook group I Acknowledge Apartheid Exists.

      Moroccan group publishes blacklist of ‘Zionist infiltrators’
      Individuals are listed for visiting and cooperating with Israel, says Moroccan Observatory against Normalization with Israel.
      An anti-Israel organization in Morocco has published a list of people and institutions it accuses of collaborating with the Jewish state.
      The Moroccan Observatory against Normalization with Israel published the list last
      They were listed for visiting Israel or working to further cooperation with it, according to the report, which named some of the individuals listed as “symbols of the Zionist infiltration into Morocco.”
      The observatory is described as an umbrella body representing groups and individuals who are working to end commerce and international ties between Israel and Morocco, one of the Arab world’s friendliest countries to Israel. Its spokespeople have said they seek to “put a price on collaboration with Israel.”

Leave a Reply