The breathtaking arrogance of Alan Dershowitz’s ‘advice’ to Black Lives Matter

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

The Boston Globe recently ran an article by Alan Dershowitz that was full of imperatives for the membership of Black Lives Matter, telling them what they “must” do to make things right with supporters of Israel and to avoid being cast into the “dustbin of history along with other discredited bigoted groups.” Key among his demands is that BLM rescind its characterization of Israel as an apartheid state that subjects Palestinians to an ongoing  act of genocide.  “Until and unless Black Lives Matter removes this blood libel from its platform and renounces it, no decent person — black, white, or of any other racial or ethnic background — should have anything to do with it,” Dershowitz said.

Well I’ve got news for Mr. Dershowitz.

Those of us that support Black Lives Matter are not particularly interested in anything that he—a serial bully, and heedless flinger of hurtful and grotesquely exaggerated epithets, sycophant to the rich and powerful and arch-apologist for Israel’s long and constant history of ethnic cleansing—says to us.

Indeed, many us of find the pose he adopts, the all-too-familiar one of the Zionist—which is to say a person beholden to an ideology that grants civil rights on the basis of a person’s bloodlines—telling us what we can and cannot say about this or that subject, and which terms we can use in what historical contexts,  to be not only offensive, but borderline comical.

The days of profligately abusing loaded terms like “anti-semitism” and “blood libel” to try and control the parameters of thinkable thought on Israel are, thankfully, coming to a close. Unlike previous generations, younger people fully understand the mechanics of this long-running and all-too-successful thought control gambit and will not put up with it any more.

Not that I think any of this will stop the famously self-involved Mr. Dershowitz from writing such breathtakingly arrogant pieces in the future, nor his enablers at the Globe and other major media outlets from publishing them.

History is full of figures and organizations that were unable to recognize that the ideas and methods that catapulted them to notoriety and power in one phase of their existence had become largely, if not yet loudly, discredited in their later years.

It seems that Mr. Dershowitz and the Globe are determined to add to this long and unfortunate list of tragically blinkered thinkers and social institutions.

39 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

“Those of us that support Black Lives Matter are not particularly interested in anything that he—a serial bully, and heedless flinger of hurtful and grotesquely exaggerated epithets, sycophant to the rich and powerful and arch-apologist for Israel’s long and constant history of ethnic cleansing—says to us. ” Be honest, Thomas.… Read more »

The Dersh: … In a recently issued “platform,” more than 60 groups that form the core of the Black Lives Matter movement went out of their way to single out one foreign nation to accuse of genocide and apartheid. … … The platform accuses the US of being “complicit in… Read more »

The reaction of all the usual suspects in attacking Black Lives Matter and the coverage it has garnered demonstrates the sheer narcissism and egocentrism of the “excuse JSIL of every crime” crowd. Someone needs to tell these ego maniacs* that not everything is about them and their petty little concerns.… Read more »

It should be pointed out that all the people, including the Dersh, who dumped on BLM for their “language” have NOTHING to say about Israel’s oncoming human rights abuses. For the Hasbara Brigade talking about Isreal’s crimes is worse than the crimes themselves. Shorter Dersh: “When a white man speaks… Read more »

“Those of us that support Black Lives Matter are not particularly interested in anything that he—a serial bully, and heedless flinger of hurtful and grotesquely exaggerated epithets, sycophant to the rich and powerful and arch-apologist for Israel’s long and constant history of ethnic cleansing—says to us.” Good. Alan Dershowitz has… Read more »