Activism

Palestinian liberation is the grammar of our freedom – On the moral bankruptcy of the University

The Inter-University Coalition on Palestine is mobilizing students and workers at hundreds of universities worldwide who refuse to accept the rules of the colonial university. We demand a Free Palestine. This is the horizon of our collective freedom. 

Editor’s Note: The following open letter was initiated by the recently formed “Inter-University Coalition on Palestine,” which currently has signatories from over 200 universities worldwide. To add your university and join the coalition for future organizing, sign here.

We write as workers and students of the university to reiterate our conviction that the struggle for Palestinian liberation is our collective cause. The occupation of Palestine is a frontline in the endurance of colonialism and its myriad sites: seas, borders, camps, and settlements. The occupation of Palestine has embodied global anticolonial solidarity since at least the early twentieth century. Such solidarity and mobilization further deepened with the outbreak of anticolonial struggles in the mid-twentieth century and continued to strengthen since the 1970s. Today, we continue in their footsteps.

Calls for Palestinian liberation grow louder in the face of air strikes and televised mass murder. But the occupation of Palestine is no punctuated experience; it structures everyday life. It shows us that the Nakba of 1948 is a constantly unfolding event. It is an ongoing system of apartheid that undergirds Israel’s existence as an ethno-national state. This colonial history is not a primordial rivalry between Arabs and Jews, nor is it a conflict between two equal powers. Settler colonialism in Palestine is a century-long process, as well as an instrument of British and later American imperialism.

Israel’s siege of Gaza only reasserts the country’s colonial power over Palestine. The siege is a tightening chokehold on the Palestinian struggle against years of blockade, fragmentation, controlled resources, restricted mobility, and, increasingly, starvation.

We refuse to participate in a discursive war that renders some lives more grieveable than others. Our stratified vocabulary of mourning and victimhood forecloses the critical recognition that lying beyond the border walls and fences, there is a shared humanity. Wrapped in the rhetoric of mainstream media and politicians is the claim that people who risk everything to overthrow the chains of racialized oppression do not deserve to live. The echoes of the decolonizing war in Algeria, the anti-apartheid movement in South Africa, and the ongoing struggle for Black liberation ring loudly. The same racialized logic that rendered these movements the work of primitive, violent savages now demands we condemn Palestinians as uncivilized and barbaric. We refuse the status quo that these constructions uphold.

Pro-Palestinian speech is met with McCarthyite backlash on university campuses. Institutions of higher education have abdicated their responsibility to protect the lives and well-being of Arab, Black, Brown, Indigenous, and Muslim students. University administrations’ calls for “diversity,” “equity,” and “inclusion” conspicuously disregard the long-suppressed Palestinian claim to life. Our institutions produce vacuous statements while far-right organizations – bankrolled by donors with endowed university centers – harass, threaten, and actively harm marginalized students. Death threats and doxxing against students and faculty who speak out against the occupation of Palestine and systemic violence have become the norm.

Across the Global North, the classroom is compromised by capitalist capture, which constrains the liberatory potential of our thought. Behind the veneer of neutrality lies the dollar. Our university endowments – growing in value thanks to investments in a racialized prison industrial complex that stretches from Israel to the United States – are bloated by the eager affirmation of white supremacy. The university derives dividends from bloodshed via weapons and oil investments that produce the Middle East as a fractured geography of war. Today, the university is one of capitalism’s most productive agents. Our universities are not financially bankrupt; they are morally so.

The apartheid wall, the border fence, the prison bar, and the police cordon are conjoined sites of struggle fragmented in appearance only. Liberalism’s limited vocabulary has thinned our perceptions of the possible, suturing the future to the ruins of procedural democracy. We recognize these systems at work in our own lives, in our poisoned politics, and in the fragmented solidarity that renders us all complicit today. 

Neutrality cannot be the condition for participation in the university. Dissent is pedagogy. Knowledge is politics. In the interstices of the university, we insist on different relations of learning and struggle that remember and reenact the classroom as a space for protest.

Palestinian liberation is the grammar of our collective freedom. Palestinians offer us a language that can force the locks and break the chains of domination that structure our world. To accept the existence of an ethnostate predicated on dispossession and genocide would be to foreclose the very possibility of justice. 

Demands within a system where liberation is neither a category of thought nor action cannot meet our moment. Palestinian liberation is a practice of refusal. We cannot seek justice from a system committed to the permanent deferral of redistribution. We cannot imagine yielding to a status quo wherein condemning genocide is relegated to political positioning. What is needed now goes beyond all previous policy prescriptions. Talks of ceasefire and humanitarian aid, peace processes, and multi-national dialogues have only resulted in the continual theft of Palestinian land. 

We take our cues and lead from Palestinian voices within the university, beginning with the echoes of Birzeit University’s Union of Professors and Employees

We in occupied Palestine — and all Palestinians — have no illusions in the poetic dreams of the triumph of the pen over the sword because the sword has cut too deeply into our flesh at the hands of an enemy who has been granted by the hypocritical international community and the destiny of imperial history to claim a monopoly on both the sword (that which acts to kill) and the pen (that which narrates the acts of killing). As intellectuals and academics working in occupied Palestine, we have to use our words, however futile they may feel in such critical times. We also have faith in the bold souls of our people, our resistance and the triumph of freedom, and in our inalienable rights. We recognize and proclaim that at this critical and urgent historical juncture, we shall overcome – justice shall overcome. We are not your passive victims; we have been murdered, maimed, and displaced by a setter state driven by an ideology of insane hatred and bloody violence, but we will not be silenced. Our resistance shows us the path forward, and we remain steadfast, and we shall triumph.

We join our colleagues in their resistance. We recognize that decolonization is a material practice. We call for the land back. We are mobilizing a coalition of students and workers at institutions of higher learning who refuse to accept the rules of the colonial university. We demand a Free Palestine. This is the horizon of our collective freedom. 

Our call is open to all students and workers in higher institutions across the globe to sign. If you support the letter and would like to add your institution to the above list, please fill out the details here. Your personal information will not be displayed or shared, and you can sign the letter anonymously. 

Signed by students and workers at:

  1. Alexandria University, Egypt
  2. Aligarh Muslim University, India
  3. Aljamea-tus-Saifiyah, Pakistan
  4. Ambedkar University Delhi, India
  5. The American University in Cairo, Egypt
  6. American University of Beirut, Lebanon
  7. The Autonomous University of Barcelona, Spain
  8. Azim Premji University, India
  9. Bard College, USA 
  10. Baruch College, USA
  11. Berlin University of the Arts, Germany
  12. Birla Institute of Technology and Science, Pilani – Hyderabad Campus, India
  13. Birmingham City University, England
  14. Boğaziçi University, Turkey
  15. Boston University, USA
  16. Brac University, Bangladesh
  17. Brandeis University, USA
  18. Brigham Young University, USA 
  19. Brooklyn College, USA
  20. Brown University, USA
  21. Butler University, USA
  22. Cà Foscari University of Venice, Italy
  23. California Institute of the Arts, USA
  24. Carnegie Mellon University, USA
  25. Central European University, Austria
  26. Christ University, India
  27. City University New York, USA
  28. City, University of London, England
  29. Christ University, India  
  30. The Claremont Colleges, USA
  31. Clark University, USA
  32. College of Wooster, USA
  33. Columbia University, USA
  34. Concordia University, USA
  35. Dartmouth College, USA
  36. Delft University of Technology, Netherlands
  37. De Montfort University, England
  38. DePaul University, USA
  39. Drexel University, USA
  40. Duke University, USA
  41. Elmhurst University, USA
  42. Emory University, USA
  43. Erasmus University Rotterdam, Netherlands
  44. European University Institute, Italy 
  45. ETH Zurich, Switzerland
  46. Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
  47. Fielding Graduate University, USA
  48. Film and Television Institute of India, India
  49. Forum Transregionale Studien, Germany 
  50. Fulbright University Vietnam, Vietnam
  51. Georg August University of Göttingen, Germany 
  52. Georgia Institute of Technology, USA
  53. George Washington University, USA 
  54. Guilford College, USA
  55. Hamad Bin Khalifa University, Qatar
  56. Harran University, Turkey
  57. Harvard University, USA
  58. Hertie School, Germany
  59. Hitotsubashi University, Japan 
  60. Hochschule Geisenheim University, Germany
  61. Humboldt Universität zu Berlin, Germany
  62. Hunter College, USA
  63. Indiana University, USA
  64. Institute Paul Bocuse, France
  65. Istanbul University, Turkey
  66. Jadavpur University, India
  67. Jamia Millia Islamia, India
  68. Jawaharlal Nehru University, India 
  69. Johns Hopkins University, USA
  70. Karachi University, Pakistan 
  71. Karel de Grote University College, Netherlands
  72. Kent State University, USA 
  73. King’s College London, England
  74. Kyoto University, Japan
  75. London School of Economics and Political Science, England
  76. Manipal Academy of Higher Education, India
  77. Maryland Institute College of Art, USA
  78. Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts, USA
  79. Massachusetts Institute of Technology, USA
  80. McGill University, Canada 
  81. McMaster University, Canada 
  82. Middle East Technical University, Turkey
  83. Middlebury College, USA
  84. Mount Holyoke College, USA
  85. Moore College of Art & Design, USA
  86. National Institute for Oriental Languages and Civilizations, France
  87. New Mexico State University, USA 
  88. New York University, USA 
  89. The New School for Social Research, USA
  90. Northeastern University, USA 
  91. Northwestern University, USA
  92. The Ohio State University, USA
  93. Oklahoma State University, USA
  94. Passaic County Community College, USA
  95. Paris Dauphine University, France
  96. The Pennsylvania State University, USA
  97. Pepperdine University, USA
  98. Pontifical Catholic University of Chile, Chile
  99. Pratt Institute, USA
  100. Princeton University, USA
  101. Queen’s University, Canada
  102. Rama Devi Women’s University, India
  103. Ram Manohar Lohiya National Law University, India
  104. Rhode Island School of Design, USA
  105. Royal College of Art, England
  106. Royal Holloway, University of London, England
  107. Rutgers University, USA
  108. Rutgers University-New Brunswick, USA
  109. San Francisco State University, USA
  110. Sarah Lawrence College, USA
  111. School of Oriental and African Studies, England
  112. Sciences Po, France
  113. Shahjalal University of Science & Technology, Bangladesh
  114. Sorbonne-Université, France
  115. Stanford University, USA
  116. Stony Brook University, USA
  117. Syracuse University, USA 
  118. Tata Institute of Social Sciences, India
  119. Technical University Berlin, Germany
  120. Temple University, USA
  121. Tehran University, Iran 
  122. Temple University, USA
  123. Tilburg University, Netherlands
  124. Thomas Jefferson University, USA
  125. Tulane University, USA 
  126. University College Dublin, Ireland
  127. University College London, England
  128. Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
  129. Università per Stranieri di Siena, Italy
  130. University of Amsterdam, Netherlands
  131. University of Antwerp, Belgium
  132. University of Arizona, USA
  133. University of the Arts, USA
  134. University of Bath, England 
  135. University of Bayreuth, Germany  
  136. University of Birmingham, England 
  137. University of Bologna, Italy
  138. University of British Columbia, Canada
  139. University of Bristol, England
  140. University of California –Berkeley, USA
  141. University of California – Irvine, USA
  142. University of California – Los Angeles, USA
  143. University of California – San Diego, USA
  144. University of California – Santa Barbara, USA
  145. University of California – Santa Cruz, USA
  146. University of Cambridge, England
  147. University of Chicago, USA
  148. University of Delaware, USA
  149. University of Delhi, India
  150. University of Denver, USA
  151. University of Dhaka, Bangladesh
  152. University of East Anglia, England
  153. University of Edinburgh, Scotland
  154. University of Gothenburg, Sweden
  155. University of Göttingen, Germany
  156. University of Graz, Austria
  157. University of Hartford, USA
  158. University of Hawaii, USA
  159. University of Houston, USA
  160. University of Illinois – Chicago, USA
  161. University of Leicester, England
  162. University of London, England
  163. University of Manchester, England
  164. University of Maryland, USA
  165. University of Massachusetts – Amherst, USA
  166. University of Massachusetts – Boston, USA
  167. University of Melbourne, Australia
  168. University of Michigan, USA
  169. University of North Carolina – Chapel Hill, USA
  170. University of North Carolina – Charlotte, USA
  171. University of Oregon, USA
  172. University of Oslo, Norway
  173. University of Oxford, England
  174. University of Pennsylvania, USA
  175. University of Pittsburgh, USA
  176. University of Potsdam, Germany
  177. University of Quebec in Montréal, Canada
  178. University of Rajshahi, Bangladesh
  179. University of San Diego, USA
  180. University for Foreigners of Siena, Italy
  181. University of Siena, Italy 
  182. University of São Paulo, Brazil
  183. University of South Florida, USA
  184. University of Southern California, USA 
  185. University of Southampton, England
  186. University of Texas at Austin, USA
  187. University of the South Pacific
  188. University of Tokyo, Japan
  189. University of Toronto, Canada
  190. University of Toronto Scarborough, Canada
  191. University of Virginia, USA
  192. University of Waterloo, Canada
  193. University of Zürich, Switzerland
  194. Utrecht University, Netherlands
  195. Vanderbilt University, USA
  196. Waseda University, Japan
  197. Washington State University, USA
  198. Wayne State University, USA
  199. Wellesley College, USA
  200. Wesleyan University, USA 
  201. West Virginia University, USA
  202. Widener University, USA
  203. William & Mary, USA
  204. Yale University, USA
  205. Yeditepe University, Turkey
  206. York University, Canada 

To add your university and join the coalition for future organizing, sign here.