People keep sending me this British short about checkpoints and the Palestinian experience reimagined. When people keep sending you something, that means it’s important.
-
-
- Israel demolishes homes in Hebron, Jerusalem and the Jordan Valley 0
- The antiwar movement must rise again. Now 14
- Halper vows to rebuild Palestinian home destroyed five times by … 3
- New additions to the Mondoweiss comments policy 127
- Israel’s latest threat — the silver screen 3
- The agenda behind the anti-Muslim film screened to NYPD: protecting … 5
- Bad career move by Tilda Swinton 22
- Good career move by Susan Rice 6
-
- Today in Pittsburgh, Jesse Lieberfeld, 17, will deliver a hammer … 1270
- Breaking: Israeli bulldozer, soldiers destroy entire Bedouin community near Anata … 687
- Report: Israel to give US only 12-hour warning before attacking … 383
- Publisher of the ‘Atlanta Jewish Times’ suggests Mossad should assassinate … 383
- Video: Settlers claim olive oil as ‘Israeli’ 278
- EU diplomats propose boycotts, divestment, and sanctions against Israeli colonialism 256
- Arab-American high school student video targets US backing for killings … 216
- Settlers assault Palestinians in Hebron. Palestinian fire fighters save settlers … 170
-
- A regular commenter on this site seeks a more temperate … 506
- Publisher of the ‘Atlanta Jewish Times’ suggests Mossad should assassinate … 375
- Today in Pittsburgh, Jesse Lieberfeld, 17, will deliver a hammer … 238
- Israel is at the heart of Jewish identity, Gorenberg says 134
- Report: Israel to give US only 12-hour warning before attacking … 134
- ‘Israel Firster’ gets at an inconvenient truth 120
- Obama begins push for Jewish support in 2012 by touting … 91
- Video: Atlanta Jewish Times publisher’s tearful anti-apology 81
-
Recent Comments
click link to see last 100 comments- The antiwar movement must rise again. Now (14)
- Bruce: @kma I didn’t name those people because I necessarily thought any of them would take up my suggestion. I...
- jayn0t: The anti-war left disappeared with the election of Obama. This shows leftism is bankrupt. But Bruce...
- Bruce: @ToivoS I asked Phil to change the title of my posting, as like you I do not believe this should be a movement...
- New additions to the Mondoweiss comments policy (128)
- anonymouscomments: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v =ufG-s1yOxXQ&list=PLF9CB52 4399DAB564&index=20&...
- kalithea: I disagree. The Nakba is literally “the catastrophe”; a painful, history/life-altering tragic...
- ToivoS: Tree says I sincerely hope that … Gilad Atzmon has not been banned here. That should be new rule (3).
- Halper vows to rebuild Palestinian home destroyed five times by Israeli soldiers (3)
- mudder: A truly haunting photo.
- mudder: Blessed are you who are poor Blessed are you who weep. Malak has no place where she may lay her head.
- Annie Robbins: look at the all knowing expression in her face. to see this happen to your home at such a young age.
- Bad career move by Tilda Swinton (22)
- chauncey: megadittos…what dupes we’ve been of this Hollywood disinfo. You watch Reel Bad Arabs, and you...
- The antiwar movement must rise again. Now (14)
Our Writers
- Philip Weiss
- Adam Horowitz
- Today in Palestine
- Alex Kane
- Joseph Glatzer
- Matthew Taylor
- Scott McConnell
- Boulos
Blogroll
I’ve seen this, but it doesn’t convey anything of the real experience.
Crowd 500 people in there and hold them for hours with no access to a bathroom and you’ll have taken a small step in that direction.
If you bombard people with many images of suffering you may loose them, rather than win them.
People support causes based on emotions initially, and only later, and often to the lesser degree, on logic and legality, rationality and common sense.
So a good video is like a punch in the stomach to an unsuspecting audience: it should create righteous anger, which hopefully will be follow by enquiry into the facts. And frankly, anyone who will spend any time goggling “Israeli checkpoints”, will never advocate for Israel with a clear conscience.
There is a point when discomfort of seeing somebody’s stark suffering is so great, that we turn away.
Telling you that 16 members of my family died in Auschwitz – Oswiecim doesn’t have as much impact that saying that my 17 year old great aunt, whose picture in satin and pearls reminds me of Gloria Vanderbilt, died of hunger after being punished by having food rations withheld for some unknown misdemeanour against the camp’s rules (she didn’t die in starvation bunker – this was on man’s side of the camp, I believe).
We evolved to feel empathy to individuals, not crowds – this is why the video above works so well on uninitiated.
We evolved to feel empathy to individuals, not crowds – this is why the video above works so well on uninitiated.
Well said, couldn’t agree more.
If this is the new wave of Palestinian advocacy, then I’m all for it.
Pingback: Viral film forces us to imagine life for Palestinians | Antony Loewenstein
“When people keep sending you something, that means it’s important. ”
It really doesn’t.
Actually that depends on who sends it to you. For those among us who have a circle of friends consisting of intelligent, politically aware people, it arguably does mean something.
I hope Phil will realize that those emails he’s been getting, the ones urging him to do something about his tiny penis, are equally important.
Speaking from your own vast experience in that department, one assumes?
Why would he? (Provided, first of all, that he does not have a spam filter.) He was talking about something sent by people, after all.
I’m one of those who sent the link to Phil. I agree with potsherd that “it doesn’t convey anything of the real experience”, but I thought it was noteworthy that modish Brits were making such videos in the first place, and winning some sort of award for it. And I think that such elaborate efforts, however imperfect, deserve the encouragement needed to go even further.