The borders of the Palestinian ‘state’ come into focus

An article this week in The Jerusalem Post suggested that "when the construction freeze in Judea and Samaria ends on September 26", Israeli PM Netanyahu intends to build mainly in the so-called settlement blocs "Israel will likely keep under an agreement with the Palestinians".

Further down, the piece notes:

Deputy Prime Minister Dan Meridor, who is also in the septet [inner security cabinet], first came out in favor of resuming building only in the blocs in a June 15 speech in Efrat.

Sources close to Netanyahu said shortly afterward that he might make such a decision because it could satisfy both Likud and Labor. They noted that Netanyahu had made a point of planting trees on Tu Bishvat in three “consensus” areas: Ariel, Ma’aleh Adumim and Gush Etzion.

So, according to Netanyahu, the 'consensus' areas - in other words, illegal colonies that are assumed to remain under full Israeli control - include Ariel, Ma'aleh Adumim and Gush Etzion. The following map (from the Applied Research Institute of Jerusalem) points out these three blocs, as well as Qiryat Arba in Hebron, and Modi'in Illit.

Some key settlement blocs
Some key settlement blocs

Defining what constitutes a 'bloc' is difficult, as there are differing interpretations. Here is another map from ARIJ, highlighting a greater number of blocs.

14 settlement blocs
14 settlement blocs

We already know that Netanyahu intends to keep the Jordan Valley in Israeli hands. Along with the 'consensus' colonies, the borders of the Palestinian enclaves continue to get clearer.

About Ben White

Ben White is author of 'Israeli Apartheid: A Beginner's Guide' and 'Palestinians in Israel: Segregation, discrimination and democracy'. Follow him on twitter at @benabyad and on his website www.benwhite.org.uk.
Posted in Israel/Palestine

{ 32 comments... read them below or add one }

  1. Chaos4700 says:

    The quest for lebensraum continues.

  2. Diane Mason says:

    The borders that Netanyahu intends for “Palestine” are the same as every other Israeli PM has had in mind for the last 20 years i.e. the Allon Plan with minor variations:

    link to lawrenceofcyberia.blogs.com

    • eljay says:

      >> The borders that Netanyahu intends for “Palestine” are the same as every other Israeli PM has had in mind for the last 20 years i.e. the Allon Plan with minor variations:

      Examining those maps only makes RW’s incredible hypocrisy even more galling. “No reason to reject it because it’s ‘not perfect’!” He wouldn’t be quite so generous were the Israelis in the situation the Palestinians are currently in.

      At least he knows how to “Remember the Holocaust!”

  3. tree says:

    Good point, Diane. And your link is to a very cogent posting of yours. Highly recommended for anyone seeking to understand the Israeli “negotiating” position over the decades.

    • Sumud says:

      Agreed tree ~ I wish I had time to read through all the LoC archives. Thanks Diane, I’m a big fan.

      • Keith says:

        DIANE- I agree completely with you, tree and Sumud. Put aside the smoke, mirrors and hasbra, the facts on the ground tell a tale of Zionist plans and objectives consistently applied. This would be common knowledge if the corporate media had even a shred of integrity.

      • MHughes976 says:

        Very good stuff. Of course when talk turns to generosity we should remind people that the Palestinians have never been offered one square inch of territory where they would have true sovereignty with control of borders, which is the same as saying that every square inch of Palestine is claimed for Israeli control and sovereignty. This, after all, is what the Bible is said to require.

  4. Sumud says:

    West Bank aquifers.

    Under no circumstance should Israel receive a single square inch of land beyond the June 4 1967 line. Israel must not be rewarded for putting Palestinians in the Occupied Territories through hell for the last 43 years.

    The world already turned a blind eye once to Israel’s land-grabbing, permitting it to swallow fully half of the Palestinian partition in 1947/8/9. No more.

  5. Government is the most successful form of banditry

  6. Jim Haygood says:

    Edit: ‘the temporary borders of the Palestinian enclaves continue to get clearer.’

    The Swiss-cheese West Bank is not a viable territory. If the two-staters prevail, this interim arrangement won’t last more than a few years.

    Try to find the borders of the former Bophuthatswana out in the South African veld now. It lasted 17 years before its arbitrarily-imposed apartheid borders were swept away into history’s dustbin.

    Gerrymandering Palestine is an exercise in futility.

  7. Chu says:

    yikes,

    the crime spree killer was boarded on a plane to Israel.

    link to nytimes.com

    A suspect in the killings of five people and the stabbings of 15 others in three states was arrested at the airport here as he tried to board a plane to Israel, the authorities said Thursday morning.

    The suspect was identified as Elias Abuelazam, 33, and investigators said they believed he was responsible for a spree of attacks in Michigan, Ohio and Virginia that began in May. Mr. Abuelazam was arrested on Wednesday night and was being held on unrelated charges, the police in Leesburg, Va., said in a statement.

  8. Tuyzentfloot says:

    The way it’s evolving it looks like all palestinans are ending up in areas A and B. There are about 4 percent left in area C and they are having a very hard time, standard of life is worse than in Gaza. (here is an article about standard of life in Area C: link to english.aljazeera.net
    ) . The positive news about economical development in the west bank then gets a new twist: can economical development be used as a tool to help concentrate the population in a smaller area? It’s not clear to me what the ideas are about what to do with the gaps between areas A+B and the Allon plan. Also there is the little triangle for which a way has to be found to transfer it out of Israel.

  9. David44 says:

    Ben:

    You’re missing something very important here. Even if one leaves aside the illegality of Israeli settlements in any part of the West Bank, Netanyahu’s (and the Jerusalem Post’s) claim that there is “consensus” on incorporating Ariel or Maale Adumim into Israel in a two-state settlement is – bluntly – a lie by any account. President Bush PREVENTED Israel from extending the security barrier around Ariel, precisely because the US did NOT accept that Ariel would end up in Israel, given its location – see e.g. link to npr.org
    .

    And if even President Bush didn’t accept that, I think we can safely say that no Palestinian negotiator has ever done so either. Netanyahu is trying to extend the concept of “consensus blocs” from border areas (like Gush Etzion, where – rightly or wrongly – a lot of people on all sides assume that it will end up in Israel via land-swaps) to smuggle in places way inside the West Bank that no one outside the Israeli far right thinks can ever be in Israel under a two-state settlement.

  10. Eva Smagacz says:

    Several tv networks say he is ARAB-Israeli lest people were to form a mistaken opinion that Jewish Israelis are capable of violence.

  11. Avi says:

    Ever since Oslo 1993, the idea has been to outsource the occupation to a contractor. In this case, the contractor turned out to be the Palestinian Authority headed by Abbas.

  12. Sumud says:

    The exact point made by Rashid Khalidi in his excellent talk from 2007 on internal Palestinian politics.

    The PA is little more than an administrative arm of the Israeli occupation, designed to give the false impression that Palestinians have a degree of autonomy (“Look! They have a President and a PM”) over their lives. Khalidi also points to the brouhaha about Hamas recognising Israel – participating in the PA elections in 2005/06 was in fact de-facto recognition of Israel.

    ‘Rashid Khalidi – Palestine: 40 Years of Occupation, 60 Years of Dispossession’
    link to video.google.com

  13. radii says:

    re; israeli serial stabber: serial killers are defined from the neck up – for their sickness

    re; borders – if israel wants to give up land of an equal area in israel proper to compensate for the settlement areas they plan to keep in Palestinian territory then maybe there could be a deal … but the chances of that happening are slim to none

  14. Lexikon says:

    To all of you,

    Where can I get access to physical maps and resource maps of Israel/WB ? I’ve been trying for quite some time this morning and I always end up hitting water.

    Aquifers, farmable land, etc.

Leave a Reply