Video shows undercover Israeli police abducting a Palestinian minor while playing soccer

I will never get used to this. I hear about these arrests but this is the first time I can recall watching an abduction of a minor with all the hallmarks of a hostile kidnapping.

B'tselem

According to Jaber's testimony to B'Tselem, the undercover policemen forced him to lie on the floor of the vehicle and blindfolded him with a piece of cloth. He cried, out of fear and helplessness. While the vehicle was moving, the boy said, the undercover forces questioned him while slapping his face. Jaber was interrogated on suspicion of stone-throwing without having his parents present, nor was he given an opportunity to consult with a lawyer. He told B'Tselem that after he refused to sign a document written in Hebrew, the interrogators punched him and hit him with a club. He maintained his refusal and was released at the entrance to the Ma’ale Zeitim settlement, in Ras al-‘Amud, approximately an hour after he was taken. Members of his family had asked police representatives where he would be released and were waiting for him at the spot. Jaber's father took him to the emergency room at Hadassah Hospital, Mt. Scopus, where he was found to be suffering from external bruising. Jaber told B'Tselem that since the incident, he has been waking up at night from nightmares.

About Annie Robbins

Annie Robbins is Writer at Large for Mondoweiss, a mother, a human rights activist and a ceramic artist. She lives in the SF bay area.
Posted in Israel/Palestine

{ 91 comments... read them below or add one }

  1. annie says:

    i’m counting at least 2 vehicles and 8 adults involved in this operation, not including the driver of the van.

    don’t these people have anything better to do? doesn’t the state have something better to do?

  2. iamuglow says:

    Abused and mistreated for not being born Jewish.

  3. Dan Crowther says:

    Is this “Never Again” in action?

    Id spit on these people. Just disgusting.

  4. I don’t understand why you guys have a problem with this. After all, the kid was playing hockey, wasn’t he?

  5. Look, you guys don’t know what this kid did earlier, and you certainly don’t know what he was gonna do later.

    (Ok, Dimatok, don’t try to tell me I’ve never done anything for you. Now you can go to lunch, and needn’t be bothered with posting on this thread. I’ve got it covered for you.)

  6. eljay says:

    So…are these the big, brave, regular-forces IDF thugs or just the nancy reservists?

    Regardless, you gotta admire the big-balls swagger of their operation (“Jump Boy”? “Smash ‘n’ Grab”? “Live #AND# Let Live”?). Nothing says “Only democracy in the Middle East” like a van-load of soldiers accosting and abducting a kid alleged to have thrown stones.

    Damn you, Hamas!!!

    • libra says:

      eljay: “So…are these the big, brave, regular-forces IDF thugs or just the nancy reservists?”

      Well, I was expecting one of the military vehicles to stop but it turned out to be the unmarked white van. It was a similar, spotlessly white vehicle that was involved in the arrest of the young American Lucas Koerner, so I suspect some arm of state security.

      But given these sinister white vans and the white-shirted young Zionist extremists, the clear message in Israel is that when it comes to street violence and intimidation, white is indeed the new black.

  7. iamuglow says:

    Annie,

    You should juxtapose this video with some of the endless ones on You tube of settler children throwing rocks at internationals. They almost always show the soldigers doing almost nothing and treating those kids with velvet gloves…

    The difference is, those kids had the fortune of being born Jewish in a state where that means everything.

    • annie says:

      why thank you very much dim, so loverly to be watching videos from the idf station. plus, one of the perks is reading the excellent accompanying explanations.

      The IDF in coordination with the Civil Administration and the Israeli Police have prepared for the annual olive harvest in the West Bank region. The harvest began in early October and is expected to last through December.

      Seen here are soldiers from the “Kfir” Brigade guarding the Palestinians during near the Itamar Community. The soldiers are there to maintain order and ensure the Palestinians have a safe and successful harvest.

      As part of the preparations, Civil Administration officials met with their Palestinian counterparts, representatives from various villages in the region, and Palestinian olive oil manufacturers in order to coordinate the schedule for this harvest. In addition, Israeli security forces conducted security assessments and authorized the plan for the harvest, during which they provide round-the-clock security.

      The IDF and the Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories (COGAT) respect this mission with high importance and value, understand the cultural and economic significance of the olive harvest to the Palestinian people of the region, and will operate accordingly so as to allow for the harvest to occur.

      • dimadok says:

        By the way this is the same brigade who killed two men two days ago in Calandia, during the night raid. Kinda ironic isn’t it? It brings my point of the embedded ambiguity of the whole situation.

        • annie says:

          do you mean in Qalandiyah? in what way do you mean ironic? could you elaborate?

        • dimadok says:

          Imagine the every day conflict which goes in minds of the soldiers.
          I brought this example to underline my previous posts about IDF soldiers (and myself) as not a blood-thirsty thugs, but as a soldiers with moral dilemmas and highly complicated environment of operation. Same goes for their commanders.

        • DC Red says:

          Really? That’s the best you can come up with? ‘It’s complicated’?

          But then, when I think about it – oftentimes when I see kids playing on the street I have to make split-second decisions about whether or not to kidnap and torture them while blindfolded. It’s a tough moral choice we all have to make each day.

          Sorry Dim, but only an absolute lunatic would ever even consider this, much less consider it a ‘difficult’ decision.

        • Mndwss says:

          If it walks like SS and quacks like SS……

          What is ironic?

          This brigade should be in prison. And their supporters (you) should join them.

        • Shingo says:

           Imagine the every day conflict which goes in minds of the soldiers.

          So now you’re yelling us they’re hallucinating and having paranoid episodes too.

          Do you think it wise that they be carrying guns?

        • GringoDingo says:

          Highly complicated yet surprisingly easy to solve in just one single step:

          1- Stop occupying Palestinian land.

          There, problem solved.

        • Shingo says:

           Sorry Dim, but only an absolute lunatic would ever even consider this, much less consider it a ‘difficult’ decision.

          Agreed. 

          In fact, if this were a video of Hamas, Dim, eee and Hop would be screeching about how the white van illustrated how Hamas hide among the civilian population and the absence of uniforms showed their failure to adhere to the rules of war.

        • ToivoS says:

          So Dim good to hear that you experience moral dilemma. I think most normal humans have that experience when performing immoral acts on behalf of a state or social group.

          So what are you going to do about it?

        • Mooser says:

          “highly complicated environment”

          The old shoot-and-kvetch! Dimmy, that crock-o-crap won’t sell here.

        • MRW says:

          but as a soldiers with moral dilemmas and highly complicated environment of operation. Same goes for their commanders.

          American military who have had to interface with them call them undisciplined, badly trained, and substandard.

          “highly complicated environment of operation?” A 50-square mile area is a highly complicated environment? The IDF have never been tested in anything except regional battles at sea level. They go home to their mamas at night. They’ve never fought in mountainous regions far from home (of course not, they don’t help anyone but themselves) at high altitudes or real battle situations. They’re a glorified police force.

        • RobertB says:

          dimadok…

          Its NOT “complicated” for your IDF killer to kill/murder Palestinian boys & girls, and for that matter, any Arab/Palestinian regardless of their age and/or gender.

          Your IDF don’t spend one hour in prison…for killing an Arab…NEVER!

          If you & your IDF had any morals, they would not be murdering women, children, unarmed civilians…

          Israel/zionism’s agenda is to keep oppressing the Palestinians & keep restricting their movements…so they can leave their land/country.

          Just think about all those Palestinian families & their children what they have to go through because of your IDF & its oppressive occupation. Think about their fears for their lives & their children.

          No Palestinian is safe from your IDF killers!

        • Shingo says:

          but as a soldiers with moral dilemmas and highly complicated environment of operation.

          It’s only complicated because these nancy boys with guns and ski masks aka “soldiers” are aiding and abetting on going crimes, occupation, land theft,. ethnic cleasing and home demolition.

          The life of a thief is always complicated.

        • eGuard says:

          Beware the advocate who says “it’s complicated”. Fire him. He’s too expensive, and will never get you free.

        • dimadok says:

          Why then US forces come to train with us? Perhaps we know more than you see- you know actual fighting and urban warfare. Tank battles and air combat. Come visit us someday you’ll see.

        • Shingo says:

          Perhaps we know more than you see- you know actual fighting and urban warfare.

          Shooting children throwing rocks is not urban warfare? Come to think of it, that wuodl explain why ten years later, US forces are still bogged down in Iraq and Afghanistan

          Tank battles and air combat.

          You call dropping 500lb bombs on Gaza air combat?

          Who have you had tank battles with? Oh yeah, that’s how the fried remains of Merkava’s ended up in Southern Lebanon.

        • pjdude says:

          Israel doesn’t know jack about real combot as they have never faced an equal opponent in their history. they are just real good at beating up on those weaker than themselves.

        • Woody Tanaka says:

          “Perhaps we know more than you see- you know actual fighting and urban warfare.”

          Yeah, I’m sure if the US needs tips on beating up old women, stealing farmer’s lands, kidnapping unarmed innocent teens and burning up babies with white phosphorus, you cockroaches would be on the Pentagon’s speed-dial.

        • Shingo says:

          Israel doesn’t know jack about real combot as they have never faced an equal opponent in their history.

          Well they kinda did when they faced a few thousand fighters with a tiny fraction of the arms Israel had, and still got their asses kicked.

        • pjdude says:

          um that was losing to an inferior opponent not an equal one.

        • annie says:

          urban warfare dimadok? we don’t have to visit israel to see urban warfare, one only has to scroll to the top of the page to watch the video.

        • Rag says:

          The ‘dilemma’ is quite simple, the Nürnberg trials did away with that – no person can hide under ‘I just followed orders’. International laws supersedes given orders at all times. International law education should be given during basic military training – if it’s not you need to seek that information yourself.

        • Taxi says:

          “Come visit us someday you’ll see”.

          You want us to come and have a look at your village-pillage and your spoils of war?

          Especially all that young human loot you’ve ‘acquired’?

          Thanks for the invite Vlad the Impaler!

    • annie says:

      speaking of how helpful to farmers the idf can be, it reminded me of an article i read just this morning

      IDF prevents Israeli activists from escorting Palestinians to their lands in West Bank
      Women from human rights group Yesh Din barred from entering West Bank settlement of Ofra while escorting villagers to their lands in Silwad; villagers’ access to lands blocked by the settlement.

      The IDF prevented the women from human rights group Yesh Din from entering the West Bank settlement of Ofra on their way to Silwad. The women were escorting five villagers who had been permitted to enter their lands for the first time in about 10 years, during which time the settlement had blocked access to them.

      But the region’s IDF brigade commander, Col. Saar Tzur, issued a one-day order declaring the Palestinian lands a “closed military zone,” prohibiting the activists from entering with the farmers. A group of soldiers waited for the Silwad villagers yesterday, following prior arrangement with Yesh Din, to escort them to their lands. The entrance to the lands from the village itself − rather than through the settlement − had been fenced off. The farmers, among whom was the village council head Nail Hamad, were afraid to enter the settlement or be near it without Israeli escorts to help them with the authorities.

      A study by human rights group B’Tselem in 2008 shows at least 58 percent of Ofra was built on private Palestinian land, mainly registered to Ein Yabrud and Silwad in the land registry.

      This means that even according to Israel’s criteria, Ofra is not a legal settlement, with no jurisdiction and no legal building permits, B’Tselem says.

    • Shingo says:

      Here some video for ya’ll:

      Yeah right. The IDF protecting the Palestinians picing olives from attacks by settlers they are there to serve.

    • eGuard says:

      Thank you for showing that Israel is not always like that. That’s showing a moral dilemma indeed.

      I myself, I never hit my wife on Mondays. Never!

  8. radii says:

    I don’t know if this is the MONSTER at work or at play … what a sick society zionist israel has turned out to be

  9. lysias says:

    Looks like NATO has learned from the Israeli attack on last year’s Freedom Flotilla: Moon of Alabama: Libya: NATO Pirates Take Ship At High Sea:

    According to the Petrolium Economists (currently VERY slow load) some Libyan rebels pirated an oil tanker with the help of “western” special forces:

    Libyan rebel forces last night boarded a fuel tanker belonging to Muammar Gaddafi’s regime, seized it and are sailing the vessel laden with gasoline to Benghazi.

    The ship was boarded by Libyan nationals acting without the National Transitional Council’s (NTC) knowledge, said a source familiar with the operation. A European government provided logistical support for the action, which is believed to have involved special forces boarding the ship from the air.

    [...]

    Nato began interdicting seaborne supplies of fuel to the regime in May, leaving the Cartagena and its cargo stranded in the Mediterranean. It was originally chartered to land the fuel in Tripoli.In recent weeks, it has been anchored off Malta and then Algeria. It recently returned to Malta to pick up more bunker fuel. It was boarded by special forces while sitting offshore Malta.

    [...]

    At 17:00 UK time on 3 August, the Cartagena was said to be sailing towards Benghazi. Ship-tracking services could not locate the vessel, suggesting its transponder had been shut off.

    The Cartagena was at high sea and pirating it has certainly nothing to do with “protecting civilians” in Libya. My best guess is that the French did this. I am curious with what excuse NATO will come up for committing piracy on the open sea.

    The U.S. is currently trying to get Russia and China to agree to some UNSC statement on Syria. They are reluctant to do so as the UNSC resolutions on Libya were thoroughly abused by the “west”. This will make them even more reluctant to agree on anything similar with regards to Syria or any other country.

  10. Kate says:

    When I was in the West Bank the IDF’s idea of ‘protecting’ the Palestinians from the settlers carrying guns and knives was to evict us – Palestinians and Internationals – from the Palestinian olive grove where we were trying to pick. The idea of evicting the settlers instead seems never to have occurred to them. In fact some of the soldiers were walking around arm in arm with some of the the settlers.

  11. Les says:

    I wonder if Bahrain is importing its legal advisors from Israel.

    “The official Bahraini government explanation of the destruction of at least 35 Shia mosques and religious sites is that they had been constructed without building permission.”

    link to counterpunch.com

  12. Cliff says:

    Brave, moral IDF. A battalion of soldiers needed to kidnap one kid playing soccer.

    Occupying army gets rocks thrown at them by kids. Poor poor IDF.

    Fascist thugs.

  13. I wanna file a missin’ persons report…..

    Description; 4’3″, Male, balding. Approx. 220 lbs.

    Clothing; Frayed plaid bathrobe, red/white. Slippers.

    Known haunts; Sofa and computer desk. Also known to frequent the refrigerator.

    Known aliases: Dim, Dimadozen, Diminudik.

    Last seen; August 3rd, attempting to apply lipstick to one very fat pig.

  14. Shingo says:

    The DOD made an estimate that ine Hezbollah fighter was equivalient to 4 or 5 IDF fighters. Based on this pathetic performance, I’d say the DOD was being generous to the IDF.

  15. dimadok says:

    What a pile of filth, verbal insults and self-righteous evil I have discovered here! I should send it to my friends – so they can see the “civilized” faces here.

    • annie says:

      look on the bright side. i was over at abumuqawama (coin intel site) once on a sat morning and they were in some kind of guy mood thing and one of them started telling stories about the sex lives of certain arab leaders. it was all full of a variety of animals and children (of course!). naturally i interrupted them and informed them everyone might not share their sense of humor.

      • dimadok says:

        I have a quite broad sense of humor and I always enjoy pushing the limits, you know dark humor and Jews go long way, but here it is beyond the borders. However it still comparable to the insults I heard during my IDF service and before that from the same Antisemitic speakers. You see- every time they call me names or make jokes about people in Israel, it makes me happy. And you know why- because my country is still there, my friends are there, life goes on. It’s when the barking stops- then I start being worried. Otherwise be my guest and bring all semantics that you have picked.

        • Shingo says:

          And you know why- because my country is still there, my friends are there, life goes on.

          If you would dare to pull your head out of your ass for long enough, you might have figured out by now that no one has a problem with your country being there, or your friends.

          What we have a problem with is you occupying land, stealing it, and driving the indigenous people from it.

        • Woody Tanaka says:

          “I have a quite broad sense of humor and I always enjoy pushing the limits,… but here it is beyond the borders.”

          Yeah, I’m sure a Wehrmacht officer in Chicago in 1940 probably would have heard things “beyond the borders” from the Polish-Americans there. You scum only have yourselves to blame. Sow the wind, reap the whirlwind.

        • Chaos4700 says:

          you know dark humor and Jews go long way

          So why would that be anti-Semitism if I said that? Oh right, that’s what you say whenever I post anything.

        • RobertB says:

          “I have a quite broad sense of humor and I always enjoy pushing the limits”

          ~~~~~
          Dima,

          You probably kick Palestinian women & children at the IDF roadblocks/checkpoints & then start laughing …because of your “broad sense of humor”

    • Shingo says:

      What a pile of filth, verbal insults and self-righteous evil I have discovered here!

      He says, while flushing the toilet, where his own faeces is then dumped into Gaza.

      I should send it to my friends – so they can see the “civilized” faces here.

      Yeah, maybe you can introduce them to faces that don’t support mass murder, ethnic cleansing, occupation, land theft and the torture of children.

      I’m sure your friends would be equally disgusted.

    • Woody Tanaka says:

      And you should see what we called you that didn’t get past the mods…

    • “What a pile of filth, verbal insults and self-righteous evil I have discovered here!”

      Yeah, well not all of us get to pass our time figuring out excuses for beating the shit out of adolescents and teenagers. So, uh, what the hell, we gotta make up for it somehow.

    • Chaos4700 says:

      Tell your friends they’re in our videos! I’m sure they’ll get a kick out of that too.

    • You should try JSS News for some fine Jewish comments (in French though) … How do you describe something that goes way beyond a “pile of filth, verbal insults and self-righteous evil” ?

    • RobertB says:

      “What a pile of filth, verbal insults and self-righteous evil I have discovered here! I should send it to my friends – so they can see the “civilized” faces here.”

      ~~~~~~~~

      Dima

      Killing & murdering little Palestinian boys & girls, women, grandmothers, unarmed civilians by your IDF killers is by far the worst EVIL !

    • eljay says:

      >> WHAT THE HELL IS THIS????

      It looks like someone has pulled a Mondoweiss thread off a feed and incorporated it into his own site. If you scroll to the bottom of the page, you’ll see the acknowledgement “via mondoweiss.net”, which includes a link back to the original Mondoweiss thread.

      “Someone”, according to the main page of his site, is “New Orleans writer, filmmaker and educator, Kalamu ya Salaam … co-director of Students at the Center, a writing program in the New Orleans public schools [and] moderator of neo•griot, an information blog for black writers and supporters of our literature worldwide”.

      Seems harmless enough.

      • Damn. Not enough drama.

        Cancha juice it up a little eljay? Make a controversy or conspiracy theory out of it or something?

        I kinda figured it was some sorta sinister Mossad black op, designed to tie this website into the upcoming War On Circumcision.

        • annie says:

          the person who posted it is also named seham, and she’s participating in the comment section. maybe we should call in sherlock holmes and see if he can figure this one out.

        • eljay says:

          >> Cancha juice it up a little eljay? Make a controversy or conspiracy theory out of it or something?
          >> I kinda figured it was some sorta sinister Mossad black op, designed to tie this website into the upcoming War On Circumcision.

          Looks like you’re doing just fine with the conspiracy theory angle… ;-)

          If it was up to me, I’d pin the blame “dissent” and Hamas because, y’know, it’s always their fault. :-)

      • Chaos4700 says:

        Okay, so maybe I’m way too vain but… yay! My valiant efforts to depants eee for making a mockery of American history has been crossposted! :D

        What can I say. Artists crave attention, you know.

  16. NickJOCW says:

    All humans, and many other species, are naturally provoked to affection by their own and other young. This cannot be simple inhumanity; it looks more like a deliberate policy to keep the tinder dry so that it can be ignited at a convenient time. Like next month?

  17. CigarGod says:

    The people watching the boys in uniform picking people off German streets also justified/rationalized those actions.

Leave a Reply