Trending Topics:

Honor Mandela by viewing Palestine with the same moral clarity as apartheid South Africa

ActivismIsrael/Palestine
on 7 Comments

This post by UCLA graduate student Rahim Kurwa originally appeared on his Tumblr.

In today’s edition of the Daily Bruin you can read wonderful interviews with Professors at UCLA who were a part of the 1970s and 1980s struggle against apartheid in South Africa. Apartheid is the term coined by whites in that country to refer to a political system in which whites systematically dominated the native black population – using a comprehensive set of separate laws to keep the black population unfree and unequal. The paper also includes a warm essay by Eitan Arom reflecting on the University of California’s relationship to Mandela, how he and Winnie Mandela were seen as inspirational figures, how the anti-apartheid movement helped UCLA discover its “moral center,” and how the fight for South African liberation awakened a sense of internationalism among UCLA students.

Arom’s essay includes a prayer that “we can only hope to see with the same moral clarity as [Mandela] did, or at least for leaders like him to open our eyes when we don’t.”

Today, however, we have an opportunity to put the lessons of Mandela and South Africa into practice by looking at the question of Palestine with the same moral clarity.

In 1974 there were pass laws that restricted where blacks could travel within their country. Students protested Polaroid, the company that supplied the film to create the pass-books that repressed millions on the basis of their skin color. Today, Hewlett Packard operates an analogous system in the Occupied Palestinian Territories, providing the biometric identification systems used to restrict the freedom of movement of Palestinians in their own country.

In 1974, there was a network of blacks-only areas, known as “bantustans,” outside of which blacks were not allowed to go. These bantustans were turned into independent black mini-states, cut off from each other and denied access to the resources of the South African state. Today, the West Bank is carved up into much the same network of isolated islands, cut off from water resources, fertile lands, and each other. Those islands are surrounded by a system of segregated roadsand a network of checkpoints and walls (that we are invested in) that attempt to make their isolation permanent. Comparing the Palestinian territories in the West Bank to the bantustans from South Africa’s past, South Africa’s International Relations Minister Maite Nkoana-Mashabane said ”the last time I saw a map of Palestine, I couldn’t go to sleep…It is just dots, smaller than those of the homelands, and that broke my heart.”

Bantustans in South Africaimage

The West Bank’s Palestinian areas:

image

In 1974, blacks in South Africa were systematically denied the right to education, the right to vote, the right to a fair judicial process. Today Palestinians yearn for the same basic equalities.

In 1974, the University of California was invested in many American corporations that did business with and propped up the apartheid system. These companies were happy to sell the apartheid government whatever it wanted, at a steep price, and the University of California invested in those companies because it knew it could get a high return on its investment.

Students at the University of California, led by figures such as Tim Ngubeni, Sam Law, Pedro Nogueira, and hundreds of other women and men whose names have fallen from the historical record, recognized their complicity in this oppressive system. They understood that it was their obligation to stop the University of California from investing in American companies that supported apartheid. From approximately 1974 to 1986, they organized to force the UC Regents to divest from South Africa. It required no small measure of moral clarity to work day after day to achieve something that was not promised, and for a long time never seemed likely to happen.

As we mark the death of Nelson Mandela and think about his legacy here at UCLA, we must recognize that 1974 and 2014 are not so different. Today we are investing in a very similar kind of apartheid. A new set of corporations are providing the goods and services that are required in order to deny Palestinians the same basic freedoms that blacks in South Africa were denied for so long. And a new set of students are joining thedivestment movement across the state. If Mandela’s legacy lives on, it must be in our constant effort to understand our relationship to systems of oppression. It must be in our struggle for divestment from oppressive systems like the prison industrial complex in our own country and the apartheid system operating in Palestine today.

It should come as no surprise that there is a long history of South African solidarity with the Palestinian people, who like black South Africans are jailed, beaten, and killed while struggling for their own freedom. Nelson Mandela expressed his solidarity with the Palestinian struggle in simple but compelling terms. Today, Desmond Tutu actively supports the divestment campaigns of SJPs at the University of California, and Ahmed Kathrada, who spent 26 years in prison alongside Mandela, works to freePalestinian prisoners subjected to conditions he, Mandela, and many others once faced.

In the same interview in which she compared the situation in Palestine to her country’s own past, Nkoana-Mashabane declared that “the struggle of the people of Palestine is our struggle.” Today we must join her in solidarity with the Palestinian people, or else bury the legacy of Nelson Mandela.

Rahim Kurwa
About Rahim Kurwa

Rahim Kurwa is an active member of Students for Justice in Palestine and is currently a graduate student in the Sociology Department at the University of California, Los Angeles.

Other posts by .


Posted In:

7 Responses

  1. Mike_Konrad
    Mike_Konrad
    December 9, 2013, 4:26 pm

    South Africa and Israel are NOT equivalents.

    The left has taken a few similarities but out of context.

    • Woody Tanaka
      Woody Tanaka
      December 9, 2013, 4:55 pm

      Of course people like Desmond Tutu will tell you that the situation in Palestine is worth. But what the hell does he know about Apartheid, right Mike_Konrad??

    • seafoid
      seafoid
      December 9, 2013, 5:01 pm

      Both apartheids are and were evil but the Israelis speak Hebrew. However the Afrikaners and the Disneylanders both pronounce the r in the German style. GGGGGGGGHHHHHHHHH

    • Shingo
      Shingo
      December 9, 2013, 5:11 pm

      South Africa and Israel are NOT equivalents.

      They are more that equivalents, they are mirror images. Sharon was even a big fan of the bantustans.

  2. Keith
    Keith
    December 9, 2013, 4:36 pm

    Those who hold up South Africa as a model for Palestine would be well advised to consider the actual consequences of the end of Apartheid and the concurrent introduction of neoliberalism.

    “South Africa’s democratization was profoundly compromised by an intra-elite economic deal that, for most people, worsened poverty, unemployment, inequality and ecological degradation, while also exacerbating many racial, gender and geographical differences.” (Patrick Bond)
    http://www.counterpunch.org/2013/12/06/the-mandela-years-in-power/

    The outlook for the Palestinians appears to me to be quite grim. Perhaps a South African solution is the best they can hope for. In any event, they will not be well served by embracing the mythology while ignoring the reality. The creation of useful mythology is, after all, an integral part of the doctrinal system and of social control. Mandela the myth diverts our gaze from unpleasant truths.

    • bilal a
      bilal a
      December 9, 2013, 4:48 pm

      If Mandella’s South African One State solution comes to Israel, expect middle class Israelis and Arabs to be crushed under massive tax burdens,epidemic violent crime, and Neo Liberal IMF austerity, while a corrupt new elite prosper behind armed watchtower walls in their gated communities. The saintly Mandella let this happen as a form of reconciliation while his wife was necklacing the opposition.

      By Peter Beinart
      Don’t Sanitize Nelson Mandela: He’s Honored Now, But Was Hated Then
      http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/12/05/don-t-sanitize-nelson-mandela-he-s-honored-now-but-was-hated-then.html

      Its also important to realize that Israelis will have the 2nd passports to leave
      while the Arabs will be left in the western preferred model , a secular ANC/Mubarak /as Sisi ‘Lord of the Flies’ dystopia.

    • Citizen
      Citizen
      December 10, 2013, 9:40 am

      banking and corporations= inevitable class apartheid.

Leave a Reply