Activism

Syrian and Palestinian refugees can be helped by better representation on TV and in film

As Syrians go West, they are met with the anxiety of many who may have only met them before through negative media portrayal.

The first wave of Arab and Muslim immigration to the U.S. and Europe was via slavery. The first recorded Arabic speaker to come to North America was called Zammouri, which in Arabic means someone from Al-Zammour, Morocco. Zammouri arrived in America in the 1500s, and he came as a slave to the Spanish.

Despite centuries in the U.S., Arabs and Muslims are outsiders in most of our cultural landscape, including film and TV. American media is loaded with ‘star attachments,’ known celebrity actors which make investments more secure in the eyes of film financiers. There are very few ‘star’ Arab and Muslim American actors. That is indicative of the problem point blank. Arab and Muslim Americans don’t have the representation for Arab or Muslim centered work to be readily viable.

The fear of Arab refugees has been heightened over the part to the past fifteen years of ominous media representations. There has been both a fascination and disgust for Arabs and Muslims in the mainstream media since 9/11. In the U.S., they have been characterized as the pernicious threat in television programs and as villains in feature films.  This scapegoating by the media is parallel to legal action taken against the community.

Since the attack on the World Trade Center, there has been an American focus on taking and disempowering Arab/Muslim lives for the safety of the U.S. In addition to wars abroad, domestically the U.S. ban on “Providing material support or resources to designated foreign terrorist organizations” expanded in the Patriot Act, sought to indict anyone associated with terrorists. This has led to the arrests and detention of Arab and Muslim Americans who have not killed or caused any Americans harm. One of the most tragic cases is that of graduate student, Pakistani-American Syed Fahad Hashmi. The young man housed an acquaintance donating socks and ponchos to Al Qaeda. While Hashmi had never interacted with Al Qaeda, his house guest had, and this has led to Hashmi’s years of imprisonment. Arab Americans and Muslim Americans, in addition to those in Canada and Europe, have become subject to such harassment and arrests.

I am a filmmaker of Syrian descent. It’s my project as a filmmaker to intervene with complex, positive, alternative images, especially of women, and from the beginning, I have found the discrimination against Arab and Muslim subjects to be crippling to the making of the work. I entered film school in September 2001. After my first year of film school, I decided to go to Palestine/Israel to make a documentary. I received a letter from the administration that while I would be traveling through Palestine Territories to make the film, I must “withdraw” from the University because of the “exceptional danger.” I sought the power to create empathy and mutual understanding, by making Arab cinema. In order to do so, I had to leave the protection of my university.

Over time, Arab cinema has developed from narrative films seeking to define national identity, such as “The Battle of Algiers” to a concern for our individual identities, including our physical domain, such as “Wadjda.” This is in correlation with the current fetishization of the body of the Arab: with the media focus on child Syrian brides, ISIS’ rape survivors, and most recently the corpse of the dearly departed Aylan Kurdi.

Today’s events in Syria and the refugee crisis invoke the importance of films led by Arab and Muslim people, playing to American and European audiences. More Arab and Muslim led work screening in the West will be a sign of our integration. As we enter the media, in a humanized way,  in our own truths, so we are equalized in society. Arab and Muslim-centered films present people from walks of life viewers might not be familiar with, in our own words via our own ideas. These films are a necessity to the civil rights movement, for Arab and Muslim Americans. Even as an American society, if we do this with Arab and Muslim Americans, we do it before the rest of the world. Arab and Muslim American led films can help European and American people and governments to be welcoming and generous to Syrian immigrants.

At this time, I am making an expansion of my short film that was an official selection of the Sundance Film Festival, “Marjoun and the Flying Headscarf.” That short, in 2006, was one of the first pieces of Arab American-led narrative work. Even though the short premiered with much support surrounding it, the climate was so hostile to Arab and Muslim Americans, that I felt it was not time to release an Arab American centered feature film. Instead, I dove into making my first feature “Habibi,” set in the Gaza Strip. As time has gone by, nearly ten years since that short screened at Sundance, I am faced with my responsibility as a maker to present an Arab American feature film–if anything because the climate has not improved, only changed. I am crowdfunding this feature, and relying on grants. That’s how we made “Habibi” and that’s how we make “Marjoun.” When there’s no opportunity, we turn to our community to create one for ourselves.

Our screens are a reflection of our society. We need an honoring of Syrian and Palestinian life as equal as our own as Americans and Europeans. Supporting media by Arabs and Muslims about Arabs and Muslims is one way that we can instigate the process of healing and hope.

If you would like to be a part of our journey with “Marjoun,” please see the link below.

Visit the ‘Marjoun and the Flying Headscarf’ campaign here: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/2034575596/marjoun-and-the-flying-headscarf

31 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

That’s only true from an American perspective, where day to day contact with Arabs in general and Arab muslims in particular is very sparse.

In Europe there is a lot of contact. People may not live along side each other but if you live in a major city, you can’t really avoid day to day contact. The problem isn’t that they haven’t been exposed to enough people, the problem is that they have and that they don’t like what they see.

Just take a look at this:

http://hessenschau.de/gesellschaft/missstaende-in-fluechtlingslager-ein-interview,interview_grothe_giessen-100.html

Yes, german link but Google translate does the job. A lot of girls are at risk of forced prostitution and rape, often from men who have medieval views on women’s rights. These are women who have fled the region and are now subject to the cultural norms of extremists who are in large part responsible for making the Middle East such a toxic place for women and sexual minorities. You think people don’t notice these things?

And then there’s this from the BBC:

http://www.bbc.com/news/health-34335853

Yeah, this is less about religion, FGM rates in some Christian countries is very high, but it is about a cultural practice that is barbaric and which is absolutely imported.

You can dismiss these things as irrational fears etc, but the reality is, they can’t be ignored anymore. Most people are fleeing genuine persecution and also in some cases in search of a better life. But what happens with the 2nd generation if they grow up with the attitudes of their homeland? We already know the answer to that question. Look at Bradford. Look at Bethnal Green.

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/08/18/world/europe/jihad-and-girl-power-how-isis-lured-3-london-teenagers.html

The real story isn’t the 3 girls. It’s the increasing reactionary development of the community at large, the advance of Islamists.

These issues can’t be wished away, or waved away. There is a critical mass which cannot be erased or invisibilised.

RE: “The fear of Arab refugees has been heightened over the part to the past fifteen years of ominous media representations. There has been both a fascination and disgust for Arabs and Muslims in the mainstream media since 9/11. In the U.S., they have been characterized as the pernicious threat in television programs and as villains in feature films.” ~ Susan Youssef

MY COMMENT: Not to mention scary school mascots!

SEE: “California high school drops controversial Arab mascot” | by Philip J. Victor & Nadeem Muaddi | america.aljazeera.com | September 12, 2014

[EXCERPT] A California high school that faced mounting pressure to change its team name, mascot and other imagery and traditions that many Arab-Americans deemed offensive has agreed to a compromise, school officials announced on Friday.

The Coachella Valley High School Arabs will now be known as the Mighty Arabs, after the school district’s board of trustees voted 5-0 on Tuesday to amend the school’s team name. They also agreed to change CVHS’ Arab mascot to look less barbaric and more distinguished. . .

ENTIRE ARTICLE – http://america.aljazeera.com/articles/2014/9/12/arab-mascot-coachella.html

Follow the link everybody and you will see Marjoun and the Flying Headscarf only has 67 more hours to go on the kickstarter campaign and the goal is $100,000 and it’s already at $91,191 !!!!

that’s amazing. i so hope you make it susan.

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/2034575596/marjoun-and-the-flying-headscarf?ref=hero_thanks

There was an episode of the Good Wife which featured a Palestinian student involved in a murder. As I recall the protagonist, Alicia, argues that the murder was not terrorism because the student invinces no interest in “nationist” issues.

And therein lies the problem, the inability of American television to present Arabs or Muslims as regular people who care about issues effecting their communities. I have yet to see a sympathetic portrayal of Palestinians that also articulated their feelings about Israel and Zionism. “Good” Arabs are always either victims (of other Arabs or Muslims) or working as asests for the “good” guys. I don’t know how you change that.

I commend Krauss for pointing to some of the difficulties Europe has with mass Muslim immigration, rather than pretending they don’t exist. The degree of them, discussion of which articles overstate or minimize them, can be a topic for debate, no? I’ve been reading this useful blog by an American law prof in Germany: http://andrewhammel.typepad.com/german_joys/

which seems to provide a more realistic window than does the mainstream American press (much as mondoweiss does).

Here is a recent post:
Here’s a selection of my short summaries of the stories on the “Refugee Crisis” live-blog of the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, Germany’s leading center-right broadsheet, with my comments:

13:19: Migrants end hunger strike in Nuremburg, migrants in Griebo near Wittenberg begin hunger strike, demanding to be housed in apartments instead of a multifunction hall

13:07: Psychology professor Jürgen Hoyer says it’s no surprise so much violence in refugee shelters, many people of different backgrounds packed together

This is why Germany will start seizing private commercial and residential property in a desperate rush to get migrants into apartments where the risk of violence is lower.

12:41: Federal government estimates 30% of those claiming to be Syrian when they arrive in Germany are lying.

12:28: Middle East Director of UNHCR says 8,000 people coming to Europe each day, no sign of decrease, and that these are ‘tip of the iceberg.’

As I’ve mentioned before in comments, I see no reason why migrant stream will reduce during winter, because (1) 80% of the journey will be in countries with mild winters; (2) by the time they get to the cold places there will be volunteers and trains: (3) migrants know they have a rapidly-closing time window, it’s now or never.

12:16 Poll of 213 Dutch local governments reveals 80% have no place for migrants, 25% anticipate resistance from local citizens esp. based on fear of competition for subsidized housing, only 17% say they have sufficient resources to integrate refugees.

12:11 On German national TV, Interior Minister Thomas de Maiziere said opening Germany’s borders (Merkel’s decision) led to situation going ‘out of control’

This is pretty amazing. Last night on a political talk-show watched by millions of Germans, the Interior Minister of Germany said the migrant situation was ‘out of control’. The Interior Minister. And blamed it on a decision by Merkel, his close political ally & friend (though he didn’t name her). You know what Germans don’t like? Things that are out of control.

11:56: Knife-fight among 20 young men in shelter in Chemnitz, 2 young Tunisian men and 2 young Albanian men in hospital.

With thousands of new (presumably) genuine Syrian war refugees arriving every day, what are Tunisians and Albanians still doing here taking up precious shelter space and participating in gang knife-fights?

11:55: In an 1800-person shelted in Leipzig conference center there was a mass confrontation between 100-200 Syrians and Afghans, required ‘mass intervention’ of police to bring situation under control.

How long before the first murder in a migrant shelter? Weeks would be my guess. Rapes are already commonplace in some shelters, although nobody seems to care about that.

11:51: In Finland, gang dressed as KKK members pelt incoming migrant bus with stones and fireworks.

11:22 Sticks and metal rods converted to weapons found in Donaueschingen shelter after 400 refugees protested against planned relocation.

10:54: Majority of Germany continues to believe migrants can be accommodated, but majority shrank over last 2 weeks from 62 to 57 percent. Number who say it can’t be done rose from 35 to 40%.

I think we’re going to see that trend continue.