Gunter Grass, by Marcus Brandt in the Guardian
The Gunter Grass poem was published in Germany. Our translation is by Norbert Jost. It is already stirring big controversy. Guardian headline: “Nobel Prize-winning author Günter Grass uses poem to say a nuclear-armed Israel is a threat to world peace.” Tom Segev says Grass is “pathetic” and is guilty about his Nazi past.
Why am i silent, conceal already too long a time,
What is apparent and has been simulated
in exercises, at the end of which we the survivors
may at best be footnotes.
It is the alleged entitlement for a first strike,
which could extinguish the Iranian people,
– subjugated by a big mouth and
directed to organized jubilations-
because one assumes
the making of a nuclear bomb.
Alas, why do i restrain myself
to name the name of the other country,
where since years – although kept secret –
a growing nuclear potential (is) available,
albeit beyond control, because inaccessible
for any examination?
The general silence of this fact,
which my silence has subordinated itself to,
i feel to be a burdensome lie
and as coercion, which promises punishment,
soon as it is not complied with;
the verdict “antisemitism” is ready at hand.
However, now, that my country,
which is confronted with its very own crimes
which are unique without comparison,
again and again and made to answer for,
is about to deliver, routinely and businesslike,
even though with a nimble tongue declared as reparation,
is to supply Israel another submarine, the speciality of which
is to deliver all-destructive warheads
to where the existence
of a single nuclear bomb is unproven,
only “proven” by the strength of fear,
I say, what must be said.
But why did i remain silent so far?
Because I was of the opinion, that where i am from,
which is stained with a never removable stain,
forbids me, to dare confronting Israel,
the country I am attached to and want to remain so,
with this fact as an outright spoken truth.
Why do I speak now only,
aged and with the last ink:
The nuclear power Israel endangers
the world’s peace, ever so delicate anyhow ?
Because it must be said,
what already tomorrow could be too late;
also because we – as Germans burdened enough –
could become suppliers of a crime,
which can be foreseen, and why our complicity
could not be made undone by any of the usual evasions.
And admitted: i do not remain silent anymore,
because i am weary of the hypocrisy of the West;
moreover, it is hoped,
may many free themselves of the bondage of silence,
demand from the originators of the discernible danger
the renunciation of all violence and
simultaneously insist,
that an unhindered and permanent control
of Israeli nuclear potential
and of Iranian nuclear facilities
through an international entity
will be permitted by the governments of both countries.
Only this way, everybody, Israelis and Palestinians,
even more, all human beings, who live as enemies
next to each other in this region, occupied by madness,
can be helped – ultimately us, too.
It’s thoughtful of you to put this on your site.
Here’s a little more information.
http://www.commondreams.org/headline/2012/04/04-1
There has never been a dearth of prominent public figures in Germany who criticise Israel. Grass himself has done so more than once. Since his Nazi past was unveiled a few years back, however, after he’d covered it for more than 60 years, his moral weight was rather diminished.
“may many free themselves of the bondage of silence,” : ALWAYS.
Good for Gunter! And he admits that his and others silence has been complicity. Last President to demand Israel open up to inspections was Kennedy. Since then we have heard Former President Carter, Brzezinski , Norman Finkelstein bring this outrageous double standard up. Many letters at the IAEA’s website form leaders in that world addressing the fear that many nations in that region live with due to Israel’s undeclared and un inspected nuclear, biological and chemical weapons.
I have heard hundreds of non Jews talk about and talk to their Reps for decades about this massive double standard.
Mordechai Vanunu. What a brave man!
Nice one Phil.
Nuclear weapons play a big time role in the conflict (not only I/P but I/ME)
Its a little more than disconcerting that Israel has a nuclear arsenal, for obvious reasons. No shame in stating that fact.
http://articles.latimes.com/2002/apr/07/opinion/op-perlmutter
Masada was not an example to follow–it hurt the Romans not a whit, but Sampson in Gaza? With an H-bomb? What would serve the Jew-hating world better in repayment for thousands of years of massacres but a Nuclear Winter. Or invite all those tut-tutting European statesmen and peace activists to join us in the ovens?
—David Perlmutter