Elie Wiesel’s statements about Israel’s 2008-09 attack on Gaza don’t add up.
On September 29, Wiesel appeared alongside Sheldon Adelson, Rwandan President Paul Kagame and Shmuley Boteach to talk genocide and about how the “strong” can protect the “weak” in the context of the chemical weapons attack in Syria in August. “Israel is part of our lives. It is truly part of mine,” Wiesel said on stage.
At the conclusion of the bizarre event, Max Blumenthal and I asked the world’s most famous Holocaust survivor an obvious, though unasked, question: who would protect the people of Gaza from Israel?
His first answer (minute 6:20 in the video above) was that “all human beings should be protected everywhere.” When I pressed him about the 300 children killed in Gaza during Operation Cast Lead and whether he supported the assault, his response was: “I don’t know anything about it.” Blumenthal and I each tried one more time, and Wiesel again said he didn’t know anything about Cast Lead.
But Wiesel knows about Israel’s 2008-09 attack on Gaza. In September 2009, Wiesel, Alan Dershowitz, Elliott Abrams and others signed an NGO Monitor letter that criticized Human Rights Watch’s reporting on the “recent Gaza conflict.” In February 2010, Wiesel told Haaretz that the Goldstone report, which documented human rights violations committed by the Israeli army during its assault on Gaza, was “a crime against the Jewish people.”
Richard Goldstone and his team personally confirmed the deaths of 47 children in Gaza during Operation Cast Lead.
But Wiesel says he doesn’t know anything about the killing of children in Gaza. How seriously can we take his pronouncements on Israeli policy or international affairs if he’s not aware of these basic facts?
(H/T Max Blumenthal.)
Of all the things he could say I didn’t expect ‘Ich habe es nicht gewusst’…
Wiesel always drones on about the importance of memory.
And history.
He means, of course, the memory of the Holocaust. He does NOT mean the memory of the Nakba.
What about Operation Cast Lead? He claims that he knows nothing about it. He has a short memory. Short and highly selective.
As a young man, Wiesel was a member of Menachem Begin’s terrorist Irgun. Wiesel did not (as far as I know) shoot anybody. He was a journalist. That was his contribution to the Israeli cause. So he wasn’t, personally, a terrorist. Instead he was a propagandist for Israel, whose leaders (e.g. Begin) were definitely terrorists.
Some things don’t change. Elie Weisel is still an Israeli propagandist.
Perhaps I can help you with that hump.
What hump?
I hear him saying in the voice of Sgt. Schultz from Hogan’s Heroes, “I know nothing! NOTHING!”
What a clown this guy is.
Just like Berliners (not the doughnut) knew nothing about Oranienburg and Munichers knew nothing about Dachau.