Having a settler for neighbor in Hebron

Israel/Palestine
on 11 Comments

The Jabari family lives in the Hebron neighborhood of Wadi Al Hussein, between the illegal Israeli settlements of Kiryat Arba and the Giva Ha’avot. Since 2001, the family has been fighting a legal battle to regain control of their land after settlers illegally built a “Synagogue Tent” on it. “Problems started very early but increased after the second intifada. Settlers tried to convince my father to sell the house. My father said no, they threatened him. They said this is Israeli land, not Palestinian. But this is my father’s land, for many generations”, Ayat, one of the Jabari daughters says.

On four occasions since 2008, Israeli courts have ordered the tent to be removed, but after each time the settlers have rebuilt it. The family’s case is still going through the court system.

“When we first came here they [the settlers] stabbed my little brother in the stomach, then hit another of my brothers on his eyes. Another time they pushed my father from the hill and he broke his shoulder. Every day, every night they throw stones at us”, Ayat says. She explains the settlers want the land so they can connect up the different settlements in the city center with those on the outskirts.

The story of the Jabari’s family, sadly, is representative of that of many vulnerable Palestinian families in Hebron living close to Israeli settlements, civilian communities established on Palestinian land occupied by Israel since the 1967 Six-Day War. Settlements are illegal in international law, as set in Article 49 of the Fourth Geneva Convention, which prohibits an occupying power from deporting or transferring parts of its own civilian population into the territory it occupies.

Hebron is the only Palestinian city in the West Bank, besides East Jerusalem, that has settlements in its city center. Between 500 and 800 settlers live in Hebron 2 (H2), the Israeli controlled center of Hebron, in a number of separate settlements and outposts. Kiryat Arba, the largest of the settlements on the outskirts of Hebron, has a population of approximately 8,000 settlers. It was established in 1968, and was the first Israeli settlement in the West Bank. Several hundred Israeli soldiers are posted in Hebron, allegedly to protect Israeli settlers living there against possible attacks by Palestinians.

Kiryat Arba buildings overlooking Palestinian houses in Wadi Al Hussein (Photo: EAPPI/Sabrina Tucci)

Kiryat Arba buildings overlooking Palestinian houses in Wadi Al Hussein (Photo: EAPPI/Sabrina Tucci)

Palestinians living close to settlers face serious challenges in accessing basic health, water and sanitation services as well as in accessing work, education and worship. Many streets are closed to Palestinian motorists and are accessible only by pedestrians, forcing residents to carry provisions such as food, water and cooking-gas canisters by hand and pushcart. Ambulances are often unable to reach households due to street closures, and some schools can be reached only on foot. Children and teachers are required to go through daily searches at checkpoints. Whilst these measures are justified by the Israeli authorities as necessary to protect the settlers residing in the city, they hinder not only the urban development of Hebron, but also the ability of Palestinian residents to live a normal life.

“Nobody can drive on Prayers’ Road (the main road going through Ayat’s neighbourhood and connecting Kiryat Arba with the old city of Hebron) or in any other part of Wadi Al Hussein”, explains Ayat. “From 2002 to 2005 people could not even walk here. This street is closed, we people cannot walk freely or drive. Every day children go to school walking up the hill, but this is dangerous in winter because of the snow and the rain. There is no pavement there. But walking on the main street is even more dangerous. Here we have four checkpoints and people need to go through them every day. We are surrounded by three settlements”.

In addition to access and movement restrictions imposed by the Israeli authorities, Palestinians in H2 also face harassment at the hands of Israeli settlers, including property damage and confiscation, physical attacks, verbal abuse, and the intimidation of children on their way to school.

“Today people do not walk here because they are afraid of the settlers,” admits Ayat. “Sometimes when settlers see women with hijabs they try to take these away. People from other parts of Hebron are afraid to come here. Internationals are afraid too. We do not have any visitors, and friends coming here. Before the checkpoints they used to visit us. We live in a jail, I am sad for my family, the children cannot walk on the street, my family does not know what is outside. I imagine Palestine in a jail. Life here in H2 is different from that in the rest of Hebron but in reality we are all in jail. Put me in your suitcase when you leave?”.

Asphalted pathway leading to Kiryat Arba next to an unpaved pathway leading to Palestinian houses in Wadi Al Hussein (Photo: EAPPI/Sabrina Tucci)

Asphalted pathway leading to Kiryat Arba next to an unpaved pathway leading to Palestinian houses in Wadi Al Hussein (Photo: EAPPI/Sabrina Tucci)

In 2014 the United Nations Special Rapporteur on human rights in Palestine, Richard Falk, stressed that settlements in H2 have led to severe restrictions and an atmosphere of tension that negatively affects all Palestinians. The lack of resources to carry out comprehensive investigations and the obligation for Palestinians to file complaints and testify at police stations inside Israeli settlements, also deter victims of violence from lodging complains against settlers. According to the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, the large majority of complaints about settler violence filed in recent years have been closed by the Israeli authorities without indictment. The United Nations has called on Israel to respect and implement the humanitarian needs and human rights of Palestinians in Hebron, including their right to freedom of movement and their right to be free from discrimination. It also calls on the authorities to ensure that those responsible for violence and intimidation are held accountable under Israeli law.

“Why nobody does anything to help here?”, asks Ayat. “We are human beings, this is why I stay. What else can I do? I hope to do something, to give life back to this area but it is not easy… it is so quiet here, can you hear?”. I nod, as I hear the silence in the neighborhood from her house.

Sabrina Tucci is currently in Hebron for a placement as a human rights monitor as part of the Ecumenical Accompaniment Programme in Palestine and Israel (www.quaker.org.uk/eappi).

About Sabrina Tucci

Sabrina Tucci is a human rights professional with over 8 years’ professional experience in national and international human rights organizations and is employed at the International Secretariat of Amnesty International where she specializes on the death penalty.

Other posts by .


Posted In:

11 Responses

  1. Henry Norr
    February 23, 2016, 6:44 pm

    Many thanks to Ms. Tucci for her report and for her courage in being in Hebron. For two months in 2006 I lived in H2 as part of a now defunct program called the Tel Rumeida Project, which brought internationals to Tel Rumeida, an ancient Palestinian neighborhood adjacent to the Old City, in an effort to deter or, failing that, to document attacks against the Palestinians.

    I’d visited there before that, and I’d spent months in various other parts of the West Bank and Gaza, so I thought I knew what I was getting into. But in the event I found it totally crazy-making. The place was swarming with international observers – our group, Ms. Tucci’s (EAPPI), slews of retired EU civil servants working for an official Oslo-era mechanism called TIPH – Temporary International Presence in Hebron, visiting observers from OCHA and other UN entities, and more. And yet for all our efforts the people in our neighborhood were under constant attack: on the street settlers would routinely throw things at them, spit on them, assault them, grab the shopping bags of women, steal from their yards, occasionally invade their homes, and so on. The IDF soldiers stationed every few hundred feet would just look on, frankly admitting, when asked, that they were there to protect the settlers and no one else.

    All this is easily documented, and in fact has been over and over. And yet it goes on decade after decade. I left asking myself the same question Ms. Tucci’s source Ayat did: ““Why nobody does anything to help here?” But I’m afraid we all know the answer….

  2. Henry Norr
    February 23, 2016, 6:48 pm

    Another new report on conditions in Hebron, by women from JVP and OdePink, is at

    http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/2016/02/23/a-day-of-unrest-in-hebron/#more-59264

  3. Marnie
    February 24, 2016, 1:37 am

    I despise the settler scum. Long live the Palestinian people!

  4. Tchoupitoulas
    February 24, 2016, 10:14 am

    “When we first came here they [the settlers] stabbed my little brother in the stomach…” and then,

    “But this is my father’s land, for many generations”, Ayat, one of the Jabari daughters says.”

    Which is it, please? Or did I not read carefully enough? Are the Jabaris relatively new arrivals to the area? Or has the family been there for generations? Thanks

    • oldgeezer
      February 24, 2016, 11:38 am

      @tchoupitoulas

      I would suspect the first we should be a they but regardless the two things are not mutually exclusive. The speaker clearly means the land has been in her fathers family for many generations as basic biology would preclude many generations issuing from her father and her being around to make the statement. It is quite feasible that the land was in the family, even in the possession of her father and they moved to live on it. It is not a prerequisite to always live on land you own.

      I doubt the answer is that complex but the statements arent contradictory to begin with.

      • Tchoupitoulas
        February 26, 2016, 8:59 am

        Thanks for your response.

    • talknic
      February 25, 2016, 11:07 pm

      @ Tchoupitoulas

      “Which is it, please? Or did I not read carefully enough? Are the Jabaris relatively new arrivals to the area? Or has the family been there for generations? Thanks”

      It’s not uncommon for people to own more than one parcel of land. Maybe part of the family lived elsewhere and other parts of the family farmed this particular piece of land.

      Too hard to understand? You think it’s a problem ? For a real problem, let’s take ‘returning Jews’ who’ve NEVER lived in the region, who cannot name a single ancestor who lived in the region or who owned any real estate in the region … for example

      From Haaretz Seven Chinese people with Jewish roots landed at Ben-Gurion Airport on Tuesday to start a new life in Israel, becoming the largest such group to ever arrive here.

      • Tchoupitoulas
        February 26, 2016, 9:00 am

        And thank you for your response, Talknic. The snark however, was unnecessary.

Leave a Reply