Israel likely killed Iranian scientist to kill US/global diplomatic effort to resolve nuclear issue — Lobe

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr
netanyahu 2
Escalation of Iran tensions serves
only Netanyahu gov’t and Iranian hardliners

A brilliant post by Jim Lobe. Read the whole thing at the link. Some excerpts:

I haven’t read all the commentary — or nearly all the commentary — on the assassination of the Iranian chemist today, but I have the distinct impression that whoever targeted him had a much broader agenda than simply killing yet another scientist working on Iran’s nuclear program. I think the prospect of renewed negotiations between the P5+1 and Iran was the bigger target.

My sense of the last week or so was that the mostly verbal confrontation between Iran and the U.S., particularly regarding the Strait of Hormuz, was spinning out of control much more rapidly than anyone had expected and that the possibility of a conflict had suddenly become very real in ways the Obama administration certainly never intended. (See Anne-Marie Slaughter’s CNN column, “Saving Face and Peace in the Gulf,” as an example of “this is getting really dangerous all of a sudden”. Until last fall, of course, she was Clinton’s director of policy planning and a very influential figure in the administration.) So there seemed to be a real effort to dial things back, expressed not only in repeated statements by senior administration officials, including Clinton, emphasizing Washington’s readiness to negotiate, but also, if the always well-informed Laura Rozen is to be believed, a lot of diplomatic — some of it, I’m sure, behind the scenes — manoeuvring to get the P5+1 process back into gear, with Turkey serving as the convenor/mediator.

Under these circumstances, the timing of today’s assassination was particularly remarkable. Among other things, it makes me believe that the U.S., which condemned the attack and categorically denied any role in it (See Clinton’s statement in her press conference with the Qatari Prime Minister here), was not in fact involved….

If there was indeed an Israeli hand behind it, the assassination was not just an effort to set back the Iran’s nuclear program and induce fear among other scientists working on it. I think it was also a provocation designed to 1) blow up prospects for progress in any p5+1 negotiations that might convene over the next month or so; 2) strengthen hard-line factions in Tehran that oppose negotiations; and 3) possibly provoke retaliation that will further escalate tensions, if not armed conflict. Of course, all three of these overlap and reinforce each other…

If it was Israel, I imagine that the administration, as well as key EU countries (although probably not Sarkozy), would be very angry about the timing of this attack precisely because it will strengthen hard-liners in Tehran and thus make it more difficult for Iran’s leadership to enter into serious negotiations with the P5+1. Indeed, given the extreme sensitivity of the moment and what I think is a strong desire on the part of virtually all parties to avoid war, at least at this time, the only actors who could possibly see this as serving their strategic interests are the hawkish political leadership in Israel and hard-line factions in Tehran. Assuming for the sake of argument that Israel was behind it, it will be very interesting to see if signs of renewed tensions between the administration and Netanyahu over Iran surface in the coming days.

UPDATE: I see Thursday’s New York Times appears to agree with the thrust of my last paragraph:

The statements by the United States appeared to reflect serious concern about the growing number of lethal attacks, which some experts believe could backfire by undercutting future negotiations and prompting Iran to redouble what the West suspects is a quest for a nuclear capacity.

P.S. Here is Washington Post publishing the view that the killing has endangered an American life:

TEHRAN — The assassination Wednesday of an Iranian nuclear scientist in northern Tehran increases the peril for an Iranian American who was sentenced to death Monday, analysts said. Iranian officials quickly blamed the scientist’s killing on the United States, ratcheting up tensions between the two countries and making it less likely that Amir Mirzaei Hekmati, a 28-year-old former U.S. Marine arrested in August and accused of spying for the CIA, will be released anytime soon. “Unfortunately, the greater the escalation is, the greater the likelihood that the perceived costs of executing him decline,” said Trita Parsi, president of the National Iranian American Council and author of a new book about the Obama administration’s dealings with Iran.

42 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Well, this being an election year, and given recent claptrap from presidential candidates like Santorum, don’t expect the fallout from this to present itself in the public domain. In other words, US officials may feel betrayed by Israel’s actions, but they won’t openly voice their displeasure. That’s a given.

So, CNN and the NY Times say the Obama administration is worried or whatever, and Jim Lobe plays along. So, after three years of talking about “no options off the table” – increasing the severity of sanctions, support for anti-regime groups and forces, involvement in previous assasinations, lying about alleged Iranian terror plots in the US, and continuing the policy of provocation and encirclement of Iran- its now 2012 and the Obama Administration is running… Read more »

You pay for what you get. All that money shelled out to Israel seems not to have bought any kind of leash normally worn by US lackeys.

I wonder if the people who actually carried out the hit were members of the MKE organization that the neocons so love.

Whatever. Imagine if an Israeli scientist was murdered. Where would Obama or indeed any US POTUS be on the issue? In fact, imagine if Israel was standing in Iran’s shoes right now. US would be absolutely vicious, scrambling to protect Israel from economic sanctions, let alone threats of war. Meanwhile, since here in the US celebrity culture those people are idolized and followed, here’s Angela Jolie & her hubby on the I-P situation–not to be… Read more »